Lecture 7-1: Explosive Growth
목차 27
- Lecture 1-1: The Korean Anomaly
- Lecture 1-2: The Lens of World Christianity
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Sources Fairly
- Lecture 2-1: Books from Beijing
- Lecture 2-2: The Ancestral Rites and the Persecutions
- Lecture 2-3: The Martyrs and Their Memory
- Lecture 4-1: What Happened
- Lecture 4-2: Practices Born of Revival
- Lecture 4-3: What Did the Revival Do?
- Lecture 5-1: Churches and the Nation
- Lecture 5-2: The Shrine Crisis
- Lecture 5-3: Remembering Collaboration and Resistance
- Lecture 6-1: The Church of the North
- Lecture 6-2: The Korean War
- Lecture 6-3: Anticommunism and the Church in North Korea Today
- Lecture 7-1: Explosive Growth
- Lecture 7-2: A Church That Keeps Dividing
- Lecture 7-3: The Churches and Democratization
- Lecture 8-1: Korea as a Sending Church
- Lecture 8-2: The Immigrant Church
- Lecture 8-3: Korea in Global Christian Networks
Between the end of the Korean War and the 1990s, South Korean Christianity grew at a pace that surprised observers inside and outside the country. Protestant churches multiplied in the new cities; mass rallies filled the largest open space in Seoul; a Pentecostal congregation that began in a tent in 1958 became, by most accounts, the largest single congregation in the world. The Catholic Church, smaller and slower at first, grew fastest of all in the 1980s.
This lecture describes that growth and then asks the harder question: why? Sociologists, historians and theologians have offered many answers — the upheaval of rapid urbanization, the shape of Confucian authority, the inheritance of shamanism's hope for blessing in this life, the church as a door into modern life. Each explains something. None, this lecture will argue, explains everything, and some explain the Catholic growth poorly or not at all.
이 26분으로 얻는 것
- Describe the scale of church growth in South Korea between 1953 and the 1990s, citing census figures with their years and noting how church-reported figures differ.
- Explain the history and methods of the Yoido Full Gospel Church, including its cell groups and its teaching of the "threefold blessing".
- Evaluate at least four explanations of Korean church growth, stating what each explains and what it misses.
- Compare Protestant and Catholic growth in the period and explain why a theory built only on one of them is incomplete.
All who believed were together, and had all things in common. They sold their possessions and goods, and distributed them to all, according as anyone had need. Day by day, continuing steadfastly with one accord in the temple, and breaking bread at home, they took their food with gladness and singleness of heart, praising God, and having favor with all the people. The Lord added to the assembly day by day those who were being saved. — Acts 2:44-47
World English Bible
Beloved, I pray that you may prosper in all things and be healthy, even as your soul prospers. — 3 John 2
WEB
These two passages belong together in this lecture because Korean churches in these decades drew heavily on both. The picture in Acts — large gatherings "in the temple" alongside meals "at home" — is very close to the pattern of the Korean megachurch, where a huge Sunday congregation was held together by small weekly meetings in members' homes. The verse from 3 John became the foundation of one of the most influential Korean sermons of the century: David Yonggi Cho's teaching of a threefold blessing of the soul, of circumstances and of the body. Whether that reading does justice to a greeting in a short letter is a question interpreters in Korea and elsewhere have argued about; the lecture below explains why it was heard so eagerly.
1. A country on the move
The single largest fact behind this lecture is not religious at all. In 1953 most South Koreans lived in villages and worked the land. By 1990 roughly three-quarters lived in cities. Seoul, a city of perhaps one and a half million in the mid-1950s (sources differ on the exact figure), passed ten million around 1990. Industrialization under the military governments of Park Chung-hee and Chun Doo-hwan drew young men and women from the countryside into factories, building sites and offices, often alone and far from their families and their home villages.
This matters for church history because in the Korean countryside a person's life was held within a thick web of lineage, village and ancestral ritual. The move to the city tore much of that web. Newcomers needed a place to belong, a way to find work and a spouse, help when they were sick, and a moral order that did not depend on the village elders. A church could provide all of these. The Protestant churches, which needed only a rented room and a pastor to begin, were especially quick to appear where the migrants settled.
2. The numbers, and how to read them
Figures for this period must be read carefully, because there are two kinds.
- Government census figures. The Korean census began asking about religion in 1985. It recorded about 6.5 million Protestants (about 16% of the population) in 1985 and about 8.8 million (about 19.7%) in 1995; about 1.9 million Catholics (about 4.6%) in 1985 and about 2.9 million (about 6.6%) in 1995.
- Church-reported figures. Denominations and councils count their own members, and in the 1980s and 1990s their combined totals were often far higher than the census — some claimed well over ten million Protestants. Double-counting of people who changed churches, generous counting of occasional attenders, and the pride of rival denominations all played a part.
For the decades before 1985 we depend mostly on church reports and scholarly estimates. Most historians agree on the shape even where they disagree on the numbers: Protestant growth was steep through the 1960s and 1970s, peaked in rate during the 1970s and 1980s, and was slowing by the 1990s. Chapter 9 of this course takes up what happened after that.
3. The rallies
Mass evangelism was one of the visible signs of growth, and it was also a cause of it. Two events stand out.
In May and June 1973, the American evangelist Billy Graham held a crusade in Seoul. Its evening meetings were held on the vast open plaza on Yeouido (Yoido) island in the Han River, and the final meeting was reported to have drawn over a million people — among the largest crowds Graham ever addressed. His interpreter, the Korean Baptist pastor Billy Kim (Kim Jang-hwan), became famous in Korea for matching Graham's energy phrase by phrase. The crusade was organized by a broad committee of Korean Protestant churches, and it gave Korean evangelicals a sense that their movement could fill the capital's greatest public space.
In August 1974, the Korean branch of Campus Crusade for Christ, led by Kim Joon-gon (Kim Chun-gon), held Explo '74 on the same plaza — a week of evangelism training for a very large number of registered participants, with evening meetings whose attendance organizers reported in the hundreds of thousands to more than a million. Further mass gatherings followed later in the 1970s and in 1980.
Crowd figures for events like these come from the organizers and the press of the time, and they are hard to check. What is not in doubt is that the rallies reached people who were not already in churches, gave ordinary Christians training in personal evangelism, and fixed in Korean Protestant memory the image of a nation on the verge of conversion.
Rallies and the state
The rallies also had a political setting. They were held on a plaza the Park government had built, during a period of emergency rule, and the government allowed and in some ways assisted them. Some critics at the time and since have argued that the regime welcomed a Christianity focused on personal conversion because it did not criticize the state; organizers and participants have generally replied that they were simply preaching the gospel where they could. Lecture 7-3 returns to this argument.
4. Yoido Full Gospel Church
No single congregation symbolizes this period more than the one that grew up on the same island.
In 1958, a young Pentecostal preacher, Cho Yonggi (David Yonggi Cho, 1936-2021), and an older woman evangelist, Choi Ja-sil (1915-1989), began holding services in a tent in a poor district on the western edge of Seoul. Cho had been converted as a teenager while seriously ill with tuberculosis; he had trained at a small Assemblies of God Bible school in Seoul, where he met Choi, who later became his mother-in-law. Choi's own story — a widow who had lost her livelihood, contemplated suicide, and found faith — matched the stories of many of the people who came to the tent.
The congregation moved into central Seoul in the early 1960s and then, in 1973, to a large new building on Yeouido, beside the plaza of the rallies. By the early 1990s the church itself was reporting a membership in the hundreds of thousands — figures around 700,000 were widely repeated — making it, by its own count and in most reference works, the largest single congregation in the world. As with all church-reported figures, these are best treated as approximate.
Three features explain much of its shape.
Cell groups. Cho later wrote that in the mid-1960s he collapsed from exhaustion while trying to minister to his growing congregation alone. His response was to divide the congregation into small home groups, each led by a lay member, most of them women — which was controversial in a church culture where leadership was male. These cell groups (guyeok, "district", groups) met weekly in homes to pray, study, share needs and invite neighbours. Care that one pastor could not give was given by hundreds of lay leaders. Other Korean churches, Presbyterian and Methodist as well as Pentecostal, adopted versions of the model, and it travelled far beyond Korea through Cho's books and conferences.
The "threefold blessing" and the "fivefold gospel". Cho summarized his message as a fivefold gospel (, the fullness of the Holy Spirit, divine healing, blessing, and the ) and a threefold blessing drawn from 3 John 2: the soul's salvation, prosperity in one's circumstances, and bodily health. To people who had known war, hunger and disease, a gospel that promised God's care for body and livelihood as well as soul was not an abstraction. Supporters saw in it a recovery of the New Testament's concern for the whole person; critics, in Korea and abroad, argued that it tied faith too closely to material success and risked baptizing the aspirations of an industrializing society. Both readings have serious defenders, and the same sermon could be heard either way.
Prayer and the Holy Spirit. The church's retreat centre, a "prayer mountain" (gidowon) outside Seoul opened in the 1970s under Choi Ja-sil, drew people for fasting and prayer. Speaking in tongues, prayer for healing and emotional worship connected the congregation to the worldwide Pentecostal movement — and, in the eyes of some observers, to older Korean religious patterns, as the next section explains.
Yoido was the largest, but not the only very large church. By the 1990s Seoul had a number of Presbyterian and Methodist congregations counted in the tens of thousands. Many of them were founded or led by the northern refugee pastors of Chapter 6 of this course, or by their students.
5. Catholic growth
Catholic growth in this period is sometimes left out of the story, which distorts it.
The Catholic Church in Korea emerged from the war small and poor, dependent on foreign missionary orders for priests and money. After the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965) the was celebrated in Korean rather than Latin, lay organizations multiplied, and the church took up a new public voice on social questions (Lecture 7-3). In 1969 Archbishop Stephen Kim Sou-hwan (Kim Su-hwan, 1922-2009) of Seoul became Korea's first cardinal.
The Catholic Church grew steadily in the 1960s and 1970s and fastest in the 1980s and 1990s. The visit of Pope John Paul II in 1984, the bicentenary of the church's founding, and his canonization in Seoul of 103 Korean martyrs (Chapter 2 of this course) drew national attention. By the census figures above, the Catholic share of the population rose by about half in the ten years between 1985 and 1995. Historians have commonly linked this to the church's reputation for moral seriousness and its public role in the democratization movement, as well as to its unity at a time when Protestant bodies were visibly divided — though these links are argued rather than proven.
The Catholic case is important for any explanation of growth. The Catholic Church in Korea had no prosperity preaching, no Pentecostal healing services on the Yoido scale, and a centralized structure rather than the entrepreneurial church-planting of Protestants. Yet it grew. A theory that explains Korean church growth only by features peculiar to Protestantism has left half the data out.
6. Why? Four explanations, weighed
Scholars have offered many explanations. Here are four of the most discussed.
1. Dislocation and community. The migrant from the countryside lost village and kin; the church gave a new family, with "brothers" and "sisters", mutual aid, and help finding work. This explanation, familiar from the sociology of religion in many industrializing societies, fits the timing well: growth tracked urbanization. It explains less well why Korea's urbanization produced more Christians than, say, Taiwan's or Japan's, and why Buddhism, which also has urban temples and lay associations, did not benefit as much in the same decades.
2. Confucian patterns of authority. Korean society was shaped by Confucian teaching on hierarchy, loyalty and learning. A church with a strong senior pastor, an ordered eldership, disciplined Bible study and a high value on education fitted those patterns. This helps explain the style of Korean churches — including their reverence for the pastor and their emphasis on study. As an explanation of growth it is weaker: Confucian values were at least as strong in the nineteenth century, when the Catholic Church was persecuted precisely for offending them (Chapter 2 of this course).
Shamanism and growth
3. Shamanism and "this-worldly blessing". Korean shamanism (mugyo), the oldest layer of Korean religion, is concerned with the spirits, healing, and prosperity in this life. Some scholars — among them the Korean theologian Boo-Woong Yoo and, from outside, the American theologian Harvey Cox in Fire from Heaven (1995) — argued that Korean Pentecostalism in particular grew because it took up these hopes: prayer for healing, casting out spirits, the promise of blessing. Sociologist Andrew Eungi Kim has argued along related lines about Protestantism more broadly. Korean Pentecostal leaders have generally rejected this reading, arguing that healing and blessing are biblical and that similarity is not borrowing. The explanation fits Pentecostal practice better than it fits, say, Catholic or Reformed Presbyterian practice — and it risks describing Korean Christians as shamanists in disguise, which is not how they understand themselves.
4. The church as a modernizing institution. From the 1880s on, Protestant (and Catholic) churches had been associated in Korea with schools, hospitals, the Korean alphabet, and the modern world (Chapter 3 of this course). In the decades after 1953, with the United States as South Korea's main ally, Christianity carried a strong association with modernity, education and America. Joining a church could feel like joining the future. This helps explain growth among the educated middle class. It fits the Protestant case well, and it helps explain the Catholic case too — but it also predicts that growth would slow once South Korea was fully modern, which is roughly what happened.
Other factors are regularly added: the anticommunism the churches shared with the state after the war (Chapter 6 of this course), which made Christianity respectable; the energy of northern refugee Christians; the organized evangelism of the rallies; the disciplines of dawn prayer and Bible study inherited from the revival (Chapter 4 of this course); and — for believers — the work of God, which a history course can record as a conviction but cannot measure.
7. Weighing them
Each explanation describes something real, and each fails on its own. Dislocation explains timing but not scale. Confucian culture explains style but not timing. Shamanism explains some Pentecostal practice but not Catholic or Presbyterian growth. Modernity explains the appeal to the educated but not the Pentecostal tent churches of the poor. The most careful accounts — for example the survey by Kirsteen Kim and Sebastian Kim, or Timothy S. Lee's study of evangelicalism — combine several factors and still leave room for Korean choices that no structural theory predicts.
It is also worth being suspicious of the question itself. "Why did Korean Christianity grow?" invites an answer in which Korea is a machine and religion its output. The people who joined churches in these decades had reasons of their own — a healing, a friend's invitation, an answered prayer, a sermon, a lonely room in a new city — and those reasons do not add up to a single theory. A useful rule of thumb: an explanation that is too elegant is often one the historian has imposed.
5. Going to the Sources
Source: David Yonggi Cho (with Harold Hostetler), Successful Home Cell Groups (Plainfield, New Jersey: Logos International, 1981). The opening chapters tell, in Cho's own voice, how the cell-group system began. The book is still in copyright, so what follows is a paraphrase, not a quotation.
Paraphrased: Cho recounts that in the mid-1960s, as his congregation grew, he tried to do all the preaching, visiting, counselling and praying for the sick himself. One Sunday, while assisting at a baptism and then preaching, he collapsed from exhaustion, and he was left weak for a long period afterwards. Lying ill, he read again in the Bible how Moses was told by his father-in-law Jethro to share the burden of judging the people with others (Exodus 18), and how the first Christians met in homes (Acts 2 and 5). He decided to divide the church into home groups led by lay people. When his male deacons were unwilling, he turned to the women of the church, whom he trained and appointed as leaders — a step he describes as a breach of custom in Korea at the time, and one that some in his congregation resisted.
- Cho's account connects a new method to a personal crisis and to a fresh reading of Scripture. What does a founder gain by telling the story this way? What might such an account leave out — for example, the influence of other churches' small-group models, or the role of Choi Ja-sil?
- The source says that women led most of the early cells. How does that fit, or not fit, with what you know about women's leadership in Korean churches (see Chapter 9 of this course)?
- The book was written for a Western Christian audience in 1981, when Cho was already internationally known. How might that audience have shaped what he chose to emphasize?
핵심 요약
- Between 1953 and the 1990s, South Korea moved from villages to cities, and churches grew fast. Census figures (from 1985) differ from the larger church-reported figures, which include double-counting.
- Mass rallies, including Billy Graham's 1973 crusade and Explo '74, reached people outside churches. Crowd figures come from organizers, and the government allowed the rallies, which critics say suited a faith focused on personal conversion.
- Yoido Full Gospel Church, begun in a tent in 1958 by Cho Yonggi and Choi Ja-sil, grew through lay-led cell groups and the "threefold blessing" drawn from 3 John 2. Supporters and critics read that teaching differently.
- Catholic growth, fastest in the 1980s and 1990s, had no prosperity preaching, so a theory built only on Protestants leaves out half the data.
- Four explanations are weighed: dislocation, Confucian authority, shamanism and this-worldly blessing, and modernity. Each explains something and misses something. The lecture says an elegant single explanation is often imposed by the historian.
Topic: This lecture describes South Korean church growth from 1953 to the 1990s and weighs several explanations of why it happened.
Remember: No single explanation covers Protestant and Catholic growth. Count with care, and note whether a number comes from the census or from a church.
Caution: The lecture does not say Korean Christians are shamanists in disguise, and it does not settle whether the threefold blessing is faithful to 3 John 2. Both readings have serious defenders.
One line to carry into ministry: Offer newcomers real community and care, and judge growth by more than numbers or one favourite theory.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Of the four explanations of growth in this lecture, which do you find most persuasive, and what evidence would change your mind?
- If you have belonged to a cell group or small group in a Korean church (or any church), what did it give you that a Sunday service did not? What did it ask of you?
- The threefold blessing of 3 John 2 has been heard as good news for the whole person and as a promise of material success. How would you preach that verse to a congregation of new migrants in a city — and would your sermon be different to a congregation of the comfortable?
- A historian can count members, but cannot measure a conversion. How should a Christian reader hold together the sociological explanations in this lecture and the conviction that God was at work?