무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

STEL2E Modern Theology

Lecture 9-3: Social Trinitarianism and the Tritheism Question

목차 40
STEL2E Modern Theology
제 0 장 · Introduction: What Is Modern Theology, and Why Study It?
  1. Introduction: What Is Modern Theology, and Why Study It?
제 1 장 · Chapter 1: The Enlightenment Challenge
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Turn to the Reasoning Subject
  2. Lecture 1-2: Kant's Critique and the Limits of Reason
  3. Lecture 1-3: Hegel and the Historicizing of Doctrine
제 2 장 · Chapter 2: Nineteenth-Century Liberal Theology
  1. Lecture 2-1: Schleiermacher and the Feeling of Absolute Dependence
  2. Lecture 2-2: Ritschl, Harnack, and the Essence of Christianity
  3. Lecture 2-3: Troeltsch and the Crisis of Historicism
제 3 장 · Chapter 3: Neo-Orthodoxy — Barth and Brunner
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Collapse of Liberal Optimism and Barth's Break with His Teachers
  2. Lecture 3-2: Barth's Mature Theology of the Word
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Barth-Brunner Controversy over Natural Theology
제 4 장 · Chapter 4: Existentialist and Hermeneutical Theology
  1. Lecture 4-1: Kierkegaard, Heidegger, and the Turn to Existence
  2. Lecture 4-2: Bultmann and the Program of Demythologization
  3. Lecture 4-3: Tillich's Correlation and the Hermeneutical Turn
제 5 장 · Chapter 5: Christian Realism and Public Theology
  1. Lecture 5-1: Reinhold Niebuhr and the Recovery of Sin as Political Realism
  2. Lecture 5-2: H. Richard Niebuhr's Christ and Culture, and Its Limits
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Wider Legacy of Christian Realism
제 6 장 · Chapter 6: Secularization and Bonhoeffer's Legacy
  1. Lecture 6-1: Dietrich Bonhoeffer's Prison Writings
  2. Lecture 6-2: Harvey Cox's The Secular City and the Debate It Provoked
  3. Lecture 6-3: The "Death of God" Theology of the 1960s
제 7 장 · Chapter 7: Rethinking God — Process and Open Theism
  1. Lecture 7-1: Process Philosophy's Foundations — Whitehead and Hartshorne
  2. Lecture 7-2: Process Theology Proper — Cobb, Griffin, and the Problem of Evil
  3. Lecture 7-3: Open Theism within Evangelicalism
제 8 장 · Chapter 8: Hope, the Cross, and Catholic Renewal
  1. Lecture 8-1: Jürgen Moltmann — Hope and the Crucified God
  2. Lecture 8-2: Wolfhart Pannenberg — Revelation as Universal History
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Second Vatican Council and Catholic Renewal
  4. Lecture 8-4: Karl Rahner and Hans Urs von Balthasar — Two Catholic Responses to Modernity
제 9 장 · Chapter 9: The Trinitarian Renaissance
  1. Lecture 9-1: Rahner's Complaint and the Rule That Answered It
  2. Lecture 9-2: Zizioulas and the Orthodox Recovery of Personhood
  3. Lecture 9-3: Social Trinitarianism and the Tritheism Question
제 10 장 · Chapter 10: Liberation, Black, and Global Theologies
  1. Lecture 10-1: Gutiérrez, Cone, and the Theology of Liberation
  2. Lecture 10-2: The Global South and the Method of Contextual Theology
  3. Lecture 10-3: Pentecostal Theology's Academic Emergence and Amos Yong's Pneumatology
제 11 장 · Chapter 11: Postmodernism, Postliberalism, and Pluralism
  1. Lecture 11-1: Postmodern Philosophy's Challenge to Enlightenment Reason
  2. Lecture 11-2: George Lindbeck and the Cultural-Linguistic Model
  3. Lecture 11-3: Hauerwas's Narrative Ethics and Milbank's Radical Orthodoxy
  4. Lecture 11-4: The Religious Pluralism Debate
제 12 장 · Chapter 12: Evangelical Theology and the Contemporary Frontier
  1. Lecture 12-1: The New Evangelical Mind — Carl F. H. Henry, J. I. Packer, and the Turn Toward Engagement
  2. Lecture 12-2: Reformed Epistemology — Plantinga, Wolterstorff, and the Rationality of Belief
  3. Lecture 12-3: Analytic Theology and Vanhoozer's Doctrine as Drama
  4. Lecture 12-4: The Contemporary Frontier and Course Synthesis

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

21분

The two previous lectures traced independent recoveries of a Trinity treated, for centuries, as practically inert: Rahner's methodological rule connecting God's saving action to God's eternal being, and Zizioulas's Orthodox argument that relationship constitutes being itself, rooted in the Cappadocian Fathers. This lecture follows one specific, influential extension of that recovered doctrine — and the sharp, unresolved dispute it provoked.

A number of theologians working in the last third of the twentieth century, particularly the English Reformed theologian Colin Gunton and the American Catholic theologian Catherine Mowry LaCugna, argued that the recovered emphasis on relationship within the Godhead should not stay confined to abstract doctrine about God's inner life. If the economic Trinity genuinely discloses who God eternally is — Rahner's claim from 9-1 — and if divine persons are constituted by mutual, self-giving relationship rather than by a prior, self-contained substance — Zizioulas's claim from 9-2 — then, these theologians argued, the Trinity's own inner life of relationship offers a genuine, theologically grounded model for human community: family, church, and even wider social and political life. This position has come to be called social trinitarianism. It drew, almost immediately, one of the sharpest criticisms leveled against any position in this chapter: that treating the three divine persons as something like a model human community risks describing three separate centers of consciousness cooperating closely together — which sounds, to its critics, much closer to three gods than to the one God confessed at Nicaea. This lecture states both sides of that dispute as their proponents would state them, and it does not resolve it, because contemporary systematic theology has not resolved it either.

이 21분으로 얻는 것

  • Explain the constructive argument of social trinitarianism, associated with Colin Gunton and Catherine Mowry LaCugna, including how it builds on the economic-Trinity emphasis from 9-1 and the relational ontology from 9-2.
  • State at least one specific way social trinitarians proposed the Trinity as a model for human community, life, or society, and explain what theological warrant they gave for making that move rather than treating it as mere analogy or illustration.
  • State the tritheism criticism of social trinitarianism precisely — what specifically about "three centers of consciousness in loving relationship" risks sounding like three gods rather than one — and identify at least one theologian associated with pressing this criticism.
  • Explain why this course presents the dispute as live and unresolved rather than declaring a winner, and state what kind of further theological or philosophical work would be needed to resolve it.
  • Connect this chapter's three lectures into a single overall account of the "Trinitarian renaissance" without treating any one of the three as the chapter's single center.

Social trinitarians drew heavily on New Testament texts describing unity and love within the Godhead, and specifically on passages where Jesus prays that the unity between himself and the Father should become, in some sense, a pattern for the unity of his followers.

Romans 8:31-32 states: "What then shall we say about these things? If God is for us, who can be against us? He who didn't spare his own Son, but delivered him up for us all, how would he not also with him freely give us all things?" (World English Bible) Social trinitarians read this passage as displaying, within the economy of salvation, a relationship of mutual self-giving between the Father and the Son — the Father giving up the Son, for the sake of others — that they took as revealing something about the eternal character of divine relationship itself, a character they then proposed extending, by analogy, to describe what genuinely Christian human community should look like: self-giving rather than self-protective.

John 17:22-23 makes the connection to human community explicit within the text itself, in Jesus's own prayer: "The glory which you have given me, I have given to them; that they may be one, even as we are one; I in them, and you in me, that they may be perfected into one; that the world may know that you sent me, and loved them, even as you loved me." (WEB) This passage is the single most important piece of textual evidence social trinitarians cite for their position, because Jesus himself draws the analogy — "that they may be one, even as we are one" — rather than the analogy being imposed on the text by later theologians. Critics of social trinitarianism do not generally dispute that this verse draws some analogy between divine and human unity; the dispute, examined below, concerns how far that analogy can be pressed before it distorts what "unity" means for God specifically.

1. The constructive claim: from economic disclosure to social model

Colin Gunton, whose work on personhood already appeared in the previous lecture through his debt to Zizioulas, argued across a series of works, including The Promise of Trinitarian Theology (1991), that Western theology's long practical neglect of the — the same neglect Rahner named in 9-1 — had left Western culture more generally without theological resources to resist a corrosive, atomizing individualism: a picture of the human person as a self-contained unit whose relationships to others are optional and secondary rather than constitutive. Gunton proposed that a properly recovered Trinitarian doctrine, read through the relational ontology examined in 9-2, supplied exactly the theological resource modern individualism lacked: a vision of personal being, modeled ultimately on the being of God, in which relationship to others is not an addition to an already-complete self but part of what it means to be a self at all.

Catherine Mowry LaCugna pressed a related but distinct argument in God for Us: The Trinity and Christian Life (1991), building directly and explicitly on Rahner's Rule from 9-1. If the — God's saving action in history, disclosed as an action of mutual self-giving love among Father, Son, and Spirit — genuinely discloses who God eternally is, LaCugna argued, then the practical, communal shape of Christian life (koinonia, communion, mutual self-giving within the church and, by extension, within wider human society) is not a separate ethical topic loosely inspired by Trinitarian doctrine but a direct outworking of what the doctrine itself actually claims about the structure of reality. For LaCugna, "the Trinity is a practical doctrine with radical consequences for Christian life," precisely because, on her Rahnerian premises, there is no gap between the doctrine of God and the doctrine of how redeemed human life ought to be lived — both describe, at different levels, the same underlying pattern of persons constituted by mutual communion.

2. What "model" means, and what work it is doing

It is worth being precise about the specific theological claim social trinitarians were making, since an unfair caricature of this position is easy to construct. Gunton and LaCugna were not simply observing, as almost any Christian theologian across every tradition surveyed in this course would agree, that Christians ought to love one another because God is loving — a general point about imitating divine character that carries no particular weight for Trinitarian doctrine as distinct from any other doctrine of God. Their claim was more specific: that the particular structure of divine unity-in-diversity — three fully personal, fully equal, mutually indwelling persons constituting one God through relationship rather than through hierarchy or uniformity — offers a specific, theologically grounded corrective to human social and political structures organized around domination, hierarchy, or the suppression of difference in the name of unity. Some theologians working in this stream, particularly in political and feminist theology, drew directly on this structure to criticize forms of church governance or political authority organized around a single dominant will, arguing that a genuinely Trinitarian vision of authority should instead reflect mutual, non-hierarchical relationship among equals.

3. The tritheism criticism, stated precisely

The criticism social trinitarianism drew is not a vague accusation of heresy; it is a specific logical concern about what "three persons in loving relationship" can coherently mean once "person" has been given the fuller, more robust sense Zizioulas's relational ontology and the social trinitarians' own appeal to it seem to require. Classical Trinitarian orthodoxy, from the Cappadocians through the Western tradition alike, insisted that Father, Son, and Spirit share a single divine will, a single divine mind, and a single divine act of knowing and loving — the three persons are not three separate loci of consciousness who happen to agree perfectly and cooperate closely, the way three exceptionally well-coordinated human persons might, but one God who exists, acts, and knows as three persons rather than as three beings.

Critics of social trinitarianism — a position associated in the secondary literature with theologians including Karen Kilby, whose 2000 essay " and Projection" is among the most cited statements of the concern — have argued that describing the divine persons as something close to three distinct "centers of consciousness" in mutually loving relationship, in order to make the Trinity intelligible as a model for human community, risks quietly abandoning the single-will, single-mind unity classical orthodoxy actually confessed and replacing it, in substance if not in formal statement, with three closely allied but genuinely distinct minds and wills — which is a description of three gods cooperating in unusually close harmony, not one God existing as three persons. Kilby's specific and additional charge is that the whole social-trinitarian project tends to move in the wrong direction methodologically: rather than deriving a doctrine of human community from a prior, independently secured doctrine of the Trinity, social trinitarians risk projecting an already-favored ideal of human community — mutual, non-hierarchical, egalitarian relationship — onto the Godhead, and then claiming that ideal back as though it had been derived from revelation about God rather than read into it.

4. The defense, stated fairly

Social trinitarians and their defenders have not conceded the point. LaCugna and Gunton both explicitly affirmed the classical doctrine of one divine will and one divine substance, and argued that speaking of the divine persons as fully, robustly personal — rather than as mere internal relations within an otherwise undifferentiated single subject, a criticism social trinitarians level in turn at some older Western accounts they judge to lean toward modalism, treating Father, Son, and Spirit as little more than three names or modes of one underlying divine subject — does not by itself require abandoning that single will and substance. On this defense, the language of "persons in relationship" can be held together with the classical affirmation of one divine mind and will without contradiction, if "person" is understood, as Zizioulas himself intended it, as constituted by relation to the other persons specifically, rather than as an independent center of consciousness that merely happens to relate to others afterward — the very distinction between "person" and "individual" examined in 9-2. Whether this defense fully answers Kilby's charge, or whether the more vivid and socially applicable language social trinitarians actually use in constructive and pastoral contexts inevitably drifts back toward something closer to three cooperating individuals regardless of the careful qualifications made in technical passages, is exactly the point on which contemporary systematic theologians remain divided.

Tritheism debate

This is a point where readers will not agree. Social trinitarianism's defenders, including LaCugna and Gunton, hold that a properly qualified relational account of divine personhood illuminates both the doctrine of the Trinity and the shape Christian community should take, without collapsing into tritheism. Critics, including Karen Kilby, hold that the position's own rhetorical and pastoral usefulness depends on treating the divine persons in ways that, however carefully qualified in principle, function in practice much closer to three distinct minds than classical Trinitarian orthodoxy permits. This course states both positions as their own proponents would state them and does not declare a winner.

5. The chapter, drawn together

Read across all three lectures, this chapter has followed a single doctrine recovered from practical inertness by two independent routes — Rahner's methodological rule connecting economy and eternity, and Zizioulas's Orthodox ontology of relational personhood — and then followed one consequence of that recovery, social trinitarianism, into a live dispute about how far a relational account of God can be extended to describe human community without endangering the very oneness of God the doctrine exists to protect. The next chapter turns to theologies written from specific communities and locations, several of which will draw directly on the Trinity's relational and communal themes examined here; readers should carry the unresolved tritheism question forward rather than treating the social model of the Trinity as settled ground other arguments can simply build on.

Social Trinitarianism and the Tritheism Question Gunton and LaCugna, against Kilby's critique The constructive claim The Trinity's own relational structure — persons constituted by mutual communion, not hierarchy — models human community The tritheism criticism "Three centers of consciousness" risks abandoning one divine will and mind — sounding like three gods in close cooperation, not one unresolved Kilby's added charge: does the model derive a vision of community from God — or project a favored ideal onto God? Builds on both earlier lectures 9-1 Rahner: the economic Trinity discloses the immanent Trinity 9-2 Zizioulas: persons are constituted by relationship, not prior substance

6. Further Reading

  • Colin E. Gunton, The Promise of Trinitarian Theology, 2nd ed. (T&T Clark, 1997) — Gunton's fullest statement of the constructive argument covered in this lecture.
  • Catherine Mowry LaCugna, God for Us: The Trinity and Christian Life (HarperSanFrancisco, 1991) — LaCugna's development of Rahner's Rule into a practical, communal doctrine of the Trinity.
  • Karen Kilby, "Perichoresis and Projection: Problems with Social Doctrines of the Trinity," New Blackfriars 81.957 (2000) — the primary scholarly source for the tritheism and projection criticism presented in this lecture.
  • Stephen R. Holmes, The Quest for the Trinity: The Doctrine of God in Scripture, History and Modernity (InterVarsity Press, 2012) — a broader critical history arguing that much twentieth-century Trinitarian theology, social trinitarianism included, departed further from classical sources than it acknowledged.
  • Miroslav Volf, After Our Likeness: The Church as the Image of the Trinity (Eerdmans, 1998) — an influential constructive application of Trinitarian relational theology to ecclesiology, engaging both Zizioulas and the social-trinitarian tradition directly.

핵심 요약

  • Social trinitarianism, associated with Colin Gunton and Catherine Mowry LaCugna, says the relationship within the Trinity offers a theological model for human community: family, church and wider society.
  • Gunton argued that a recovered Trinity answers modern individualism. LaCugna built on Rahner's Rule to say the Trinity is a practical doctrine whose shape is mutual self-giving communion.
  • Their claim was about the specific structure of divine unity in diversity, equal persons without hierarchy. Some political and feminist theologians used it to criticize domination in church and state.
  • Critics such as Karen Kilby say it risks describing three centers of consciousness, close to three gods. She also says it may project an ideal of community onto God.
  • Gunton and LaCugna affirmed one divine will and substance. John 17:22-23 draws the analogy itself. The lecture does not declare a winner.

Topic: Social trinitarianism, which uses the Trinity's relational life as a model for human community, and the tritheism and projection objections to it.

Remember: Social trinitarians say the Trinity is not only a doctrine about God but a pattern for communion, grounded in Rahner's Rule and Zizioulas's relational ontology.

Caution: The dispute is live. Defenders affirm one will and one substance, but critics say the position's vivid language works in practice like three minds. The lecture asks readers to carry the question forward.

One line to carry into ministry: When you use the Trinity as a model for the church or family, say how far the analogy goes, and do not read your own ideal into God.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • State the social-trinitarian argument, drawing explicitly on both Rahner's Rule (9-1) and Zizioulas's relational ontology (9-2), in a form its own defenders would recognize as fair. Then state Kilby's tritheism criticism in a form its own proponents would recognize as fair. Which premises, if any, do both sides actually share?
  • LaCugna and Gunton both explicitly affirmed the classical doctrine of one divine will and substance. Does this affirmation, on its own, answer Kilby's criticism, or does Kilby's criticism concern something beyond what a theologian formally affirms — such as how the position functions rhetorically and pastorally? Explain your reasoning.
  • John 17:22-23 has Jesus himself draw an analogy between divine and human unity ("that they may be one, even as we are one"). Does the fact that this analogy originates in the text itself, rather than being imposed by later theologians, settle the dispute over how far the analogy can be legitimately extended? Why or why not?
  • This lecture states that the tritheism dispute is presented as unresolved rather than settled. What kind of further argument, evidence, or clarification — theological, philosophical, or exegetical — would actually be capable of resolving it, in your judgment? Is it possible that this is a genuine and permanent tension internal to Trinitarian doctrine itself rather than a problem any single further argument could settle?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.