Lecture 10-1: Gutiérrez, Cone, and the Theology of Liberation
목차 40
- Lecture 1-1: The Turn to the Reasoning Subject
- Lecture 1-2: Kant's Critique and the Limits of Reason
- Lecture 1-3: Hegel and the Historicizing of Doctrine
- Lecture 2-1: Schleiermacher and the Feeling of Absolute Dependence
- Lecture 2-2: Ritschl, Harnack, and the Essence of Christianity
- Lecture 2-3: Troeltsch and the Crisis of Historicism
- Lecture 3-1: The Collapse of Liberal Optimism and Barth's Break with His Teachers
- Lecture 3-2: Barth's Mature Theology of the Word
- Lecture 3-3: The Barth-Brunner Controversy over Natural Theology
- Lecture 4-1: Kierkegaard, Heidegger, and the Turn to Existence
- Lecture 4-2: Bultmann and the Program of Demythologization
- Lecture 4-3: Tillich's Correlation and the Hermeneutical Turn
- Lecture 5-1: Reinhold Niebuhr and the Recovery of Sin as Political Realism
- Lecture 5-2: H. Richard Niebuhr's Christ and Culture, and Its Limits
- Lecture 5-3: The Wider Legacy of Christian Realism
- Lecture 6-1: Dietrich Bonhoeffer's Prison Writings
- Lecture 6-2: Harvey Cox's The Secular City and the Debate It Provoked
- Lecture 6-3: The "Death of God" Theology of the 1960s
- Lecture 7-1: Process Philosophy's Foundations — Whitehead and Hartshorne
- Lecture 7-2: Process Theology Proper — Cobb, Griffin, and the Problem of Evil
- Lecture 7-3: Open Theism within Evangelicalism
- Lecture 8-1: Jürgen Moltmann — Hope and the Crucified God
- Lecture 8-2: Wolfhart Pannenberg — Revelation as Universal History
- Lecture 8-3: The Second Vatican Council and Catholic Renewal
- Lecture 8-4: Karl Rahner and Hans Urs von Balthasar — Two Catholic Responses to Modernity
- Lecture 9-1: Rahner's Complaint and the Rule That Answered It
- Lecture 9-2: Zizioulas and the Orthodox Recovery of Personhood
- Lecture 9-3: Social Trinitarianism and the Tritheism Question
- Lecture 10-1: Gutiérrez, Cone, and the Theology of Liberation
- Lecture 10-2: The Global South and the Method of Contextual Theology
- Lecture 10-3: Pentecostal Theology's Academic Emergence and Amos Yong's Pneumatology
- Lecture 11-1: Postmodern Philosophy's Challenge to Enlightenment Reason
- Lecture 11-2: George Lindbeck and the Cultural-Linguistic Model
- Lecture 11-3: Hauerwas's Narrative Ethics and Milbank's Radical Orthodoxy
- Lecture 11-4: The Religious Pluralism Debate
- Lecture 12-1: The New Evangelical Mind — Carl F. H. Henry, J. I. Packer, and the Turn Toward Engagement
- Lecture 12-2: Reformed Epistemology — Plantinga, Wolterstorff, and the Rationality of Belief
- Lecture 12-3: Analytic Theology and Vanhoozer's Doctrine as Drama
- Lecture 12-4: The Contemporary Frontier and Course Synthesis
In 1968, the Latin American Catholic bishops met at Medellín, Colombia, for a conference that applied the Second Vatican Council's teaching (studied in chapter 8) to the specific reality of a continent marked by extreme poverty, sharp inequality between a small landowning class and a vast rural and urban poor, and, in several countries, military dictatorships willing to use violence against anyone organizing the poor politically. Out of that conference and the theological reflection surrounding it came the phrase that would define Latin American liberation theology's central claim: God has a "preferential option for the poor." Gustavo Gutiérrez, a Peruvian Catholic priest working in the slums of Lima, gave that claim its most influential systematic statement in A Theology of Liberation (1971), arguing that authentic salvation cannot be separated from concrete historical liberation - from hunger, from exploitation, from political powerlessness - even though it is not reducible to those things either.
At almost exactly the same historical moment, and for entirely independent reasons rooted in a different history and struggle, James H. Cone, an African American theologian teaching in New York, was making a structurally similar but distinct argument from within the American context of Jim Crow segregation's long aftermath and the Black Power movement's challenge to the nonviolent civil rights strategy associated with Martin Luther King Jr. In Black Theology and Black Power (1969) and then more systematically in A Black Theology of Liberation (1970) and God of the Oppressed (1975), Cone argued that God is not a neutral, colorless observer of American racial injustice but is actively and specifically identified with Black experience and Black liberation from White oppression, and that any theology claiming otherwise had baptized White supremacy rather than the gospel.
This lecture presents both theologians' arguments in a form their own defenders would recognize as fair, and then states - honestly and without softening either side - the real theological criticism each received: for Gutiérrez, chiefly from the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith; for Cone, chiefly from other Black and womanist theologians who thought his early work, for all its power, had not gone far enough.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- State Gutiérrez's concept of "integral liberation" and the "preferential option for the poor" in terms he himself would recognize as an accurate summary of *A Theology of Liberation*.
- Explain the historical setting - Vatican II, the Medellín conference, and Latin America's specific social and political conditions - that produced Gutiérrez's argument.
- State Cone's central claim about God's identification with Black experience, including what he meant and did not mean by describing God and Christ as "Black."
- Summarize the Vatican's 1984 and 1986 instructions on liberation theology accurately enough to explain what they affirmed as well as what they criticized.
- Describe at least one specific criticism of Cone's early theology from a womanist theologian, and explain what that criticism adds rather than simply subtracts from Cone's project.
The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me to heal the broken hearted, to proclaim release to the captives, recovering of sight to the blind, to deliver those who are crushed,
and to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord.
Yahweh said, "I have surely seen the affliction of my people who are in Egypt, and have heard their cry because of their taskmasters, for I know their sorrows.
I have come down to deliver them out of the hand of the Egyptians, and to bring them up out of that land to a good and large land, to a land flowing with milk and honey; to the place of the Canaanite, the Hittite, the Amorite, the Perizzite, the Hivite, and the Jebusite.
Luke 4:18 (World English Bible)
Luke 4:19 (WEB)
This is Jesus's inaugural sermon in the Nazareth synagogue, quoting Isaiah, and both Gutiérrez and Cone treat it as programmatic rather than merely descriptive - not one text among many that happens to mention the poor, but Jesus's own announced agenda at the outset of his public ministry. Gutiérrez reads "good news to the poor" and "release to the captives" as naming concrete social and economic realities, not only spiritual ones: a gospel that changes nothing about hunger or bondage while promising something to the soul is not, on this reading, the gospel Jesus announced in his own words. Cone reads the same text as establishing that Jesus's ministry began by aligning himself with the oppressed and against the systems that oppressed them, which for Cone is the interpretive key to reading the rest of the Gospels rightly.
Exodus 3:7 (WEB)
Exodus 3:8 (WEB)
The exodus narrative functions for both theologians as the Bible's founding paradigm of God's character: God is not a detached deity who merely permits or tolerates the exodus generation's suffering but a God who "sees," "hears," "knows," and then acts to deliver a specific, historically identifiable people from a specific, historically identifiable oppressor. Gutiérrez treats the exodus as establishing that liberation from concrete bondage is not a secondary theme in Scripture's account of God's saving action but one of its central, recurring shapes, continued and fulfilled rather than replaced in Christ. Cone treats the exodus, read alongside the prophets, as establishing the same principle applied directly to American slavery and its aftermath: the God of the exodus is, on his reading, necessarily on the side of the enslaved and not the enslaver, and any American theology that had not drawn that conclusion for itself had failed to read its own Scripture honestly.
1. Gutiérrez and the shape of "integral liberation"
Gustavo Gutiérrez was ordained a Catholic priest in 1959 and spent most of his working life as a parish priest and theological teacher in Rímac, a poor district of Lima, Peru, an experience that shaped A Theology of Liberation as directly as Reinhold Niebuhr's Detroit pastorate shaped Moral Man and Immoral Society (chapter 5). Gutiérrez's book, published in Spanish in 1971 and building on themes he had already presented at a 1968 conference in Chimbote, Peru, argued that 's proper starting point is not abstract doctrine applied downward to social questions but praxis - committed action alongside the poor, reflected on theologically afterward - which is why Gutiérrez famously described theology itself as "critical reflection on praxis in the light of the Word of God" rather than primarily a body of settled propositions.
Gutiérrez distinguished three interwoven but distinct levels of liberation, careful never to collapse them into one another. The first is liberation from unjust social, economic, and political structures - concrete poverty, exploitation, and powerlessness, the kind of liberation an economist or a sociologist could in principle measure. The second is a deeper, more properly theological liberation: liberation of the human person's own self-understanding and agency, the transformation "from being an object to being a subject" in history rather than a passive recipient of decisions others make. The third, and for Gutiérrez the most fundamental, is liberation from sin itself, understood in its full traditional theological sense as the deepest root of all injustice and division, including division from God - and it is this third level that keeps his account, on his own explicit statement, from being reducible to a purely political or economic program. Gutiérrez insisted these three levels cannot be neatly separated in practice, since sin has genuine social and structural consequences and not only private ones, but he also insisted - a point his critics sometimes missed - that liberation theology does not simply identify the kingdom of God with any one political or economic system, including socialism.
The Medellín bishops' conference in 1968, and later the 1979 Puebla conference, gave Gutiérrez's language an official standing within Latin American Catholicism that it would not otherwise have had: Puebla explicitly adopted the phrase "preferential option for the poor" into the documents of an official episcopal gathering, meaning Gutiérrez's central claim was not simply one theologian's argument but a phrase a substantial part of the Latin American Catholic hierarchy had itself endorsed, even as individual bishops and priests continued to disagree sharply about what practical commitments the phrase required.
2. Cone and the theology of Black Power
James H. Cone was raised in Bearden, Arkansas, under Jim Crow segregation, earned a doctorate in systematic theology at Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary and Northwestern University studying primarily European theologians - including, by his own later account, a heavy diet of Barth - and then, watching the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. in 1968 and the rise of the Black Power movement's more confrontational rhetoric, concluded that the White academic theology he had been trained in had almost nothing to say to the actual crisis facing Black America. Black Theology and Black Power (1969) was written, by Cone's own account, in a matter of weeks, in a kind of theological urgency; A Black Theology of Liberation (1970) developed the argument more systematically, and God of the Oppressed (1975) restated and refined it after a decade of criticism from multiple directions.
Cone's central and most provocative claim was that God, in Christ, is "Black." This requires careful statement, because it is easy to caricature in either direction. Cone did not mean this primarily as a claim about Jesus of Nazareth's literal first-century ethnicity, though he did think White American theology's imaginative habit of picturing a blue-eyed, blond Jesus was itself a theological problem worth naming. He meant "Black" primarily as a theological symbol: God, in every age, identifies with the particular oppressed group of that age, takes their side against their oppressors, and in twentieth-century America that oppressed group is the Black community suffering under segregation and its aftermath, so that to say "God is Black" is to say, concretely and specifically, that God is against White supremacy and for Black liberation, not a claim that other racial or ethnic groups are outside God's love. By the same logic, Cone used "White" and "Whiteness" as theological symbols for the oppressor's structural position, a usage many readers - including some sympathetic ones - found rhetorically severe, and Cone himself later softened some of his earliest and most polemical formulations without abandoning the underlying argument.
Two readings of Blackness
This is a point where readers will not agree. Cone's use of "Blackness" and "Whiteness" as theological categories, rather than only sociological ones, remains genuinely contested. Defenders, including Cone himself in his later writing, argue the symbolic language was a deliberate and necessary provocation aimed at forcing White American theology to notice its own unexamined social location - the assumption that a supposedly neutral, universal theology was in fact a theology comfortable with racial injustice as long as it was not named. Critics, including some who were otherwise sympathetic to Cone's core argument about God's solidarity with the oppressed, worried that language framing an entire racial category as theologically synonymous with sin risked its own form of the reduction Cone was diagnosing in others - substituting one totalizing racial category for another rather than dismantling the logic of racial totalization itself. This course states both readings and does not resolve the dispute.
3. Rome's response: criticism and clarification
The Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, under Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, issued two documents addressing liberation theology within two years of each other, and reading only one gives a distorted picture of the church's actual response. The 1984 Instruction on Certain Aspects of the "Theology of Liberation" was sharply critical, focused specifically on liberation theologians (Gutiérrez was not named, though the document was widely read as addressing his school of thought) who, in the Congregation's judgment, had uncritically adopted Marxist categories of class struggle as an analytical tool, risking a reduction of the gospel to a political and economic program and an instrumentalization of the church itself as an agent of revolutionary struggle rather than a bearer of the gospel to every class. The 1986 follow-up, Instruction on Christian Freedom and Liberation, struck a markedly more constructive tone, affirming that "liberation" is a legitimate and even central biblical and theological theme, explicitly endorsing a preferential option for the poor as a genuine implication of the gospel, and distinguishing an authentic theology of liberation, rooted in Scripture and tradition, from the specific Marxist-analytical errors the 1984 document had targeted.
Gutiérrez himself was investigated but never formally condemned or silenced, and his relationship with the institutional church, though genuinely strained for a period, was substantially repaired over the following decades; he later joined the Dominican order and, in 2004, co-authored a book with Cardinal Gerhard Müller - who would go on to head the same Congregation that had investigated liberation theology in the 1980s - a fact liberation theology's harsher critics sometimes leave out and its uncritical defenders sometimes leave out as well. The fairest historical summary is that the Vatican's engagement with liberation theology was neither wholesale condemnation nor wholesale endorsement, but a genuine internal Catholic argument about method - how far a legitimate concern for the poor could draw on Marxist social analysis without compromising the gospel's own content - that ended closer to qualified affirmation than rejection.
4. Womanist theology's challenge to Cone
The most searching criticism of Cone's early work came not from White theology but from within the Black theological tradition itself, in the form of womanist theology - a term coined by the novelist Alice Walker and adopted by Black women theologians including Jacquelyn Grant, Delores Williams, and Kelly Brown Douglas. Their central argument was that Cone's early Black theology, for all its power in naming racial oppression, had written as though "the Black experience" were a single, unified thing best represented by Black men's experience specifically, leaving the distinct experience of Black women - who faced racism and sexism together, and in Delores Williams's influential argument, often faced a distinct history of sexual exploitation and forced surrogate labor going back to slavery itself - theologically underexamined.
Williams's Sisters in the Wilderness (1993) is the clearest single statement of this challenge: rather than centering the exodus, as Cone had, Williams centered the story of Hagar (Genesis 16 and 21), the enslaved Egyptian woman used, exploited, and then cast out by Sarah and Abraham, arguing that Hagar's story - not primarily a liberation into a promised land but survival and God's provision in the wilderness after being used and discarded by her own oppressed community's own family - spoke more directly to many Black women's actual historical experience than the exodus paradigm did on its own. Jacquelyn Grant's White Women's Christ and Black Women's Jesus (1989) pressed a related but distinct point, arguing that both White feminist theology and Black male liberation theology had, in different ways, failed to take Black women's specific standpoint as a genuine theological starting point rather than a subset of someone else's category.
Cone himself, to his credit and by his own later account, took this criticism seriously rather than dismissing it; his later writing, and his prominent role in mentoring a generation of womanist theologians at Union Theological Seminary, reflects a genuine engagement with the challenge rather than a closed door. The right way to state this dispute, in a history-of-doctrine course, is not "Cone was wrong and womanist theology corrected him," which flattens a real and ongoing internal conversation into a simple verdict, but rather that womanist theology represents Black theology's own tradition pressing its founding claim - that theology must begin from the standpoint of the actually oppressed rather than an abstract universal subject - further and more consistently than Cone's earliest work had yet done.
6. Further Reading
- Gustavo Gutiérrez, A Theology of Liberation: History, Politics, and Salvation, rev. ed. (Orbis Books, 1988).
- James H. Cone, A Black Theology of Liberation, 40th anniversary ed. (Orbis Books, 2010).
- James H. Cone, God of the Oppressed, rev. ed. (Orbis Books, 1997).
- Delores S. Williams, Sisters in the Wilderness: The Challenge of Womanist God-Talk (Orbis Books, 1993).
- Jacquelyn Grant, White Women's Christ and Black Women's Jesus: Feminist Christology and Womanist Response (Scholars Press, 1989).
- Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Instruction on Certain Aspects of the "Theology of Liberation" (1984) and Instruction on Christian Freedom and Liberation (1986).
핵심 요약
- After Vatican II and the 1968 Medellín conference, Gustavo Gutiérrez wrote A Theology of Liberation (1971). He argued that salvation cannot be separated from concrete liberation, though it is not reduced to it.
- Gutiérrez described three levels of liberation: from unjust structures, from being an object to being a subject in history, and from sin. He did not identify the kingdom of God with any political system.
- Luke 4:18 and Exodus 3:7-8 are key texts. Both Gutiérrez and Cone read them as showing a God who sees, hears and acts for a specific oppressed people.
- James Cone said God in Christ is "Black," meaning a theological symbol of God's solidarity with the oppressed, not a claim about Jesus's ethnicity. Readers dispute his use of "Blackness" and "Whiteness" as theological categories.
- The Vatican's 1984 instruction criticized Marxist categories, while its 1986 instruction affirmed liberation and the option for the poor. Womanist theologians, including Delores Williams with Hagar's story, pressed Cone's own starting point further.
Topic: Liberation theology in Gutiérrez and Cone, the Vatican's two responses, and the womanist challenge to Cone's early work.
Remember: Both theologians begin from the standpoint of the oppressed and read God's character from the exodus. Gutiérrez held that liberation from sin is the deepest level and keeps it from being only political.
Caution: Do not cite only one Vatican document, since 1984 criticized and 1986 affirmed. Womanist theology is not simply a correction of Cone but his tradition's own logic pressed further.
One line to carry into ministry: Read the exodus and Luke 4:18 with those who suffer, and keep concrete help for the poor together with the gospel's call about sin.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- State Gutiérrez's three levels of liberation in your own words. Why did he insist they cannot be collapsed into one another, and what would be lost theologically if they were?
- Exodus 3:7-8 says God "has come down to deliver" a specific, named people from a specific, named oppressor. How do Gutiérrez and Cone each use this specificity in their arguments, and what would be lost if either theologian instead appealed only to a general divine concern for "the poor" or "the oppressed" without any particular historical referent?
- Explain, carefully and in language Cone himself would recognize as accurate, what he meant and did not mean by saying God and Christ are "Black." Why does the distinction matter for evaluating the claim fairly?
- Compare the Vatican's 1984 and 1986 instructions. Why does citing only one of the two documents produce a misleading account of the institutional Catholic response to liberation theology?
- Delores Williams centered Hagar's story rather than the exodus. What did she think the exodus paradigm, taken alone, left out of the account of Black women's experience specifically - and how is this a form of the same "start from the actually oppressed" logic Cone himself used against White theology?