FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT618E Second Temple Judaism and the World of the New Testament

Lecture 2-4: Herod's Kingdom: Power, Building and Fear

Contents 31
BT618E Second Temple Judaism and the World of the New Testament
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Meeting the World of the New Testament Through Its Sources
  1. Introduction: Meeting the World of the New Testament Through Its Sources
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Learning to Read the Sources
  1. Lecture 1-1: What "Second Temple Judaism" Means
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Sources We Have
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading Sources Against Each Other
  4. Lecture 1-4: What Stones and Inscriptions Say
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Two Sources on One Event
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The History of Temple and Dynasty
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Persian and Hellenistic Ages
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Maccabean Revolt and the Hasmoneans
  3. Lecture 2-3: Rome Arrives; the House of Herod
  4. Lecture 2-4: Herod's Kingdom: Power, Building and Fear
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Chronicle
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Temple, Synagogue and Daily Life
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Temple, the Priests and the Festivals
  2. Lecture 3-2: Synagogue, Torah and Daily Practice
  3. Lecture 3-3: Jews in the Diaspora
  4. Lecture 3-4: Galilee and Judea: Villages, Work and Language
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Letter and a House Rule
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Groups, Hopes and Torah
  1. Lecture 4-1: Groups: What the Sources Say, What the Textbooks Add
  2. Lecture 4-2: Hopes: Messiah, Resurrection and the Age to Come
  3. Lecture 4-3: Torah and Covenant: How Jews Understood the Law
  4. Lecture 4-4: Scripture in Many Hands
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Reading Groups
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Rome and the Greek World
  1. Lecture 5-1: Rome and Judea
  2. Lecture 5-2: Cities, Households and Patronage
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Market of Religions and Philosophies
  4. Lecture 5-4: Associations, House Gatherings and the First Churches' Setting
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: An Inscription and a Letter
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Returning to the New Testament
  1. Lecture 6-1: The First Believers Were Jews
  2. Lecture 6-2: Reading the New Testament's Portraits of Jews Honestly
  3. Lecture 6-3: Using Background Well
  4. Lecture 6-4: Many Worlds, One Text
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Background Note

Jump to the key points ↓

22 min

Some rulers are remembered for one thing. Herod the Great is remembered for three, and they do not fit easily together. He was a builder who gave Jerusalem its largest Temple, ports, palaces and fortresses. He was a ruler who held power by pleasing Rome and by watching his own family for signs of treachery. And in the Gospel of Matthew he is a frightened king who orders the killing of children in Bethlehem.

Which of these is the real Herod? The honest answer is that each source gives us a part, and each part is shaped by the writer's purpose. A reader who takes only the Temple builder will miss the fear. A reader who takes only the child-killer will miss the builder, and may forget that Matthew was telling a story about Jesus and not writing a biography of Herod.

This lecture uses Herod to practise what the whole course teaches: reading a source by asking who wrote it, for whom and why. We look at what Josephus says of Herod and what lean he has. We look at how Herod used buildings and fear. We read Matthew 2 with care for what it says and for what we may and may not add from other sources. And we end with a small example of separating what a text says from what a source adds and what is only conjecture.

What these 22 minutes give you

  • Describe what Josephus says about Herod's rule and explain why his account has more than one layer.
  • Explain how Herod's building projects served several audiences at once.
  • State what Matthew 2 says about Herod and what Matthew is doing with the story.
  • Explain why the silence of Josephus about the killing of the children neither proves nor disproves the story.
  • Separate, for one verse, what the text says, what a source adds, and what is conjecture.

Then Herod, when he saw that he was mocked by the wise men, was exceedingly angry, and sent out, and killed all the male children who were in Bethlehem and in all the surrounding countryside, from two years old and under, according to the exact time which he had learned from the wise men." — Matthew 2:16

World English Bible

The verse is short and hard. It is the end of a story that begins with visitors from the east asking for a newborn king. Read it as Matthew's account of a king who feared a rival, and keep Matthew's reader in mind: a community that knew the stories of Israel and the Law and that already knew what a ruler's fear can do.

1. The man behind the sources

Almost everything we know about Herod as a ruler comes from Josephus, a Jewish writer of the first century AD who wrote in Rome under the protection of the Roman emperors. He wrote about Herod in two books, one that tells the war of the Jews with Rome and one that is a long history of the Jewish people. The accounts are not identical. They were written at different times, with different emphasis.

Josephus did not know Herod. He was born decades after Herod's death. For Herod's reign he used earlier writings. Most scholars hold that one of them was a history written by a man who had been at Herod's court and who had a reason to praise him. That gives Josephus's account at least two layers: a layer that looks like a court history, admiring of the king's skill, building and generosity; and a layer that tells of the king's cruelty and the sorrow of his last years, in a tone of tragic judgement. Josephus put the two together. He tells us what a king can build and what a king can destroy.

Josephus has his own lean as well. He wrote as a Jew who had served in the war against Rome, been captured, and then lived on Roman support. He wished to show Romans that the Jewish people were serious and well governed in the past, and he wished to show Jews that rebels and bad rulers had brought disaster. A king who ruled well and fell by family quarrels fits that picture. We must not take it as a neutral record.

With that in mind, we can look at what he says.

2. Power: how Herod held his kingdom

Josephus describes a king who ruled with the support of Rome and who was always afraid of losing it. Herod's family was not of the old priestly or royal houses, and the Hasmonean family that had held the throne before him still had living members. According to Josephus, Herod removed Hasmonean rivals over time. The most painful case was within his own household. He married Mariamne, a woman of the Hasmonean house, and Josephus tells that he later had her put to death on suspicion of treachery. He also had sons executed after accusations of plotting against him. Josephus tells these stories at length, as the sorrow of a powerful man who destroyed those closest to him.

We should take care here. These stories come mostly from Josephus, and he tells them in a way that fits his view of Herod as a man who ended in tragedy. We cannot test each charge. But the main outline, that Herod was ruthless to those he saw as threats and that his own family was in danger from him, fits with what the Gospels say of his fear.

Herod also used force and structure. He kept fortresses. He had a strong army and foreign soldiers. He controlled who held the high priesthood. And he sought the favour of the Roman emperors with gifts and with named buildings.

Josephus also reports acts of care. In a time of famine, he says, Herod used his own resources to bring grain, and he reduced taxes on at least one occasion. Josephus does not tell these as signs of gentleness; they appear as acts of a ruler who knew that hungry people rebel. A king can act from fear and from generosity in the same year.

3. Building: one king, several audiences

Herod's buildings are the part of his rule that stand today. They are also the part where evidence from the ground and the written sources meet.

In the south and east of his realm he built or strengthened fortress-palaces on hills, including one that bears his name and another on a high plateau by the Dead Sea. In Jerusalem he built a palace and a fortress beside the Temple, which he named for a Roman friend. On the coast he built a harbour city, and he named it for the emperor. Josephus describes this harbour with pride, and excavations on the coast have found the remains of the harbour works, which is a good example of the ground bearing out the page. In Samaria he refounded an older city with a new name that also honoured the emperor. In several cities with non-Jewish populations he built temples and public buildings, and in Jerusalem he began the vast rebuilding of the Temple described in lecture 2-3.

Now ask: who was this for? A careful historian does not give one answer. The buildings made Herod safe, because fortresses protected him. They pleased Rome, because they carried Roman names and showed his loyalty. They employed many people and brought pilgrims and trade. They raised his standing among the Jews, for the Temple was the work of a king who cared for their God, or so it could be said. And they served his pride. All of these can be true at once.

Notice something that students often miss. The same man who built a Temple for the God of Israel also built temples for other gods in other cities, in lands where most people were not Jewish. To a Roman, that would look like a wise king serving all his subjects. To many Jews, it would look like a king who could not be fully trusted with the sacred. Both were possible reactions, and we do not have a record of how each person felt.

4. Fear: the last years

Josephus describes Herod's last years as ones of illness and suspicion. In that account the king, near death, is a man who saw plots everywhere, and the court was a dangerous place. The sources date his death to the year we now count as 4 BC. After his death, according to Josephus, there was disorder in the land, and Rome had to send soldiers.

The word "fear" in the lecture's title is meant in three ways. A king who came to power by Roman gift feared losing the gift. A king from outside the old houses feared the people who had a better claim. And his people feared him. These three fears together explain a good deal about the age. They do not excuse cruelty, and they do not make every charge against Herod true.

5. Matthew and the king

Now to Matthew. The Gospel of Matthew tells that after the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem, visitors came to Jerusalem from the east, asking where the newborn king of the Jews was. They had seen his star. "When King Herod heard it, he was troubled, and all Jerusalem with him" (Matthew 2:3), the text says. Herod asked the chief priests and scribes where the Christ was to be born, and they told him Bethlehem. He sent the visitors there, asking them to return with word. They were warned in a dream not to go back. Herod, seeing that he had been tricked, "sent out, and killed all the male children who were in Bethlehem and in all the surrounding countryside, from two years old and under" (Matthew 2:16). Joseph, warned in a dream, had already taken the child and his mother to Egypt.

First, a note about reading "all Jerusalem with him". The sentence does not say that the people of Jerusalem opposed Jesus. It places the city's fear beside the king's. A city that knows a king's temper is troubled when he is troubled. A student who reads the verse as the people's rejection has added something the text does not say. Lecture 6-2 comes back to why this matters.

Second, what Matthew is doing. This Gospel is written for readers who know Israel's Scriptures. In its first chapters it shows Jesus as a descendant of David and of Abraham, a child under threat from a hostile king, rescued by going down into Egypt and brought back. Many readers, of different traditions, hear in this an echo of the story of Moses, in which a king threatens the children of Israel and a child is saved. Matthew's own text links the events to Scripture. That is the lean of the account: it is told so that a reader will see who Jesus is. It is not told as a list of events for an archive.

Third, the silence of Josephus. Josephus, who tells of Herod's cruelty at length, does not mention the killing of the children of Bethlehem. What follows from this?

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some readers, including many Christians who hold the Gospel as Scripture, hold that the event happened, and they point out that Bethlehem was a village, that Herod's cruelties were many, and that Josephus did not write everything. Some historians hold that the event is a way of telling who Jesus is, shaped by the story of Moses, and they point to the silence of Josephus and of other writers. Others take a middle view: that Matthew has a real memory of Herod's temper and has told the story to bring out its meaning, while the exact events are beyond recovery. Each side has real arguments. Silence is a weak argument in either direction, because a writer may leave out what he does not know or does not wish to tell, and because a single incident in a village may not have reached him at all. What this course requires is less than any one side requires: that you can state what Matthew says, say what Josephus does and does not show, and keep silence from being treated as proof.

6. A worked example: Matthew 2:16 in three columns

Here is a small exercise in the method of this course. For one verse, set apart what the text says, what a source adds, and what is conjecture.

What the text says What another source adds What is conjecture
Herod saw that he had been mocked by the visitors and was very angry. He sent and killed the male children in Bethlehem and the countryside nearby, two years old and under, according to the time he had learned from them. Josephus portrays Herod as a king who struck hard at those he took for rivals, including members of his own family. How many children; how Herod's soldiers carried it out; why Josephus does not mention it; whether Matthew wrote of the event to the letter or in the shape of an older story.

The three columns do different jobs. The first stays on the verse. The second gives a picture that fits the verse without proving it. The third lists what we do not know and should not pretend to. If the second column were turned into the first, we would be using Josephus to say what Matthew means. If the third were turned into the second, we would be building a story on a guess.

7. Back to the principle

Herod's power came by Rome's gift, and he used the Temple to hold it. He rebuilt it, and the rebuilding made him known and made the Temple both greater and more dependent on him. His fear shaped how the people saw him and how Matthew tells the story of Jesus' birth. When power changed hands, from the Hasmoneans to a Roman king to Roman governors, the Temple's meaning changed too. The next lecture asks you to practise reading a source that favours one side.


Diagram 1. Two sources on one king

Two Sources on One King Josephus and the Gospel of Matthew on Herod Josephus Matthew Who and when A Jewish author writing in Rome, long after Herod, using earlier writings Who and when A Gospel written for readers who knew Israel's Scriptures, in a later generation Purpose To tell the Jewish story to Romans and to explain how rulers and rebels led to ruin Purpose To show who Jesus is, as king and as the child saved from a hostile ruler Herod appears as Builder, skilled ruler, then suspicious king who destroyed his own family Herod appears as A frightened king who asks about a rival and acts against the children of Bethlehem Leaves out or leans away from The killing in Bethlehem; much of ordinary village life under Herod Leaves out or leans away from The buildings, the Temple and the rest of Herod's reign Neither source is a full portrait. Each answers its own question.

Diagram 2. Three columns for one verse

Column Question it answers Danger if it slips
What the text says What are the words and the scene? Adding to the text without noticing
What a source adds What does another source suggest that fits? Using the other source to say what the text means
What is conjecture What do we not know? Building a story on a guess

In short

  • Almost all we know of Herod's rule comes from Josephus, who wrote long after, in Rome, with earlier writings and a purpose.
  • Herod held power by Rome's support, by fortresses and soldiers, and by control of the Temple, and he acted from both fear and generosity.
  • His buildings served Rome, the Jews, his own safety and his pride; the same king built temples for other gods in other cities.
  • Matthew shows a frightened king and a child saved, told so that readers see who Jesus is.
  • The silence of Josephus about Bethlehem neither proves nor disproves the story; readers differ on how to weigh it.
  • Keep three columns apart: what the text says, what a source adds, and what is conjecture.
Front Back
Josephus on Herod A Jewish author in Rome, writing long after, using earlier writings; builder and tyrant both appear.
Herod's buildings Fortresses, a harbour city, palaces and the Temple; they served Rome, the Jews, his safety and his pride.
Matthew 2 A frightened king and a child saved, told for readers who knew Israel's Scriptures.
Three columns What the text says; what a source adds; what is conjecture.

One sentence to remember Each source gives one face of Herod, and neither gives the whole man.

This week's action Take a verse you know well and write down what it says, one thing another source could add, and one thing no one can know.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why does this lecture say that Josephus's account of Herod has more than one layer? What does that do to how we should use it?
  • Herod's buildings served several audiences at once. Name two, and say how each might have seen the Temple rebuilding.
  • The lecture says "a king can act from fear and from generosity in the same year". Is that more convincing than a simple picture of a good or bad king? Why?
  • What does Matthew 2:3 say about the city of Jerusalem, and what does it not say? Why does the difference matter?
  • Why is the silence of Josephus a weak argument both for and against the story of Bethlehem? What would count as stronger evidence?
  • Choose another verse from a Gospel and fill in the three columns. Which column was hardest to fill?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.