Lecture 5-1: Rome and Judea
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What "Second Temple Judaism" Means
- Lecture 1-2: The Sources We Have
- Lecture 1-3: Reading Sources Against Each Other
- Lecture 1-4: What Stones and Inscriptions Say
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Two Sources on One Event
- Lecture 2-1: The Persian and Hellenistic Ages
- Lecture 2-2: The Maccabean Revolt and the Hasmoneans
- Lecture 2-3: Rome Arrives; the House of Herod
- Lecture 2-4: Herod's Kingdom: Power, Building and Fear
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Chronicle
- Lecture 3-1: The Temple, the Priests and the Festivals
- Lecture 3-2: Synagogue, Torah and Daily Practice
- Lecture 3-3: Jews in the Diaspora
- Lecture 3-4: Galilee and Judea: Villages, Work and Language
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Letter and a House Rule
- Lecture 4-1: Groups: What the Sources Say, What the Textbooks Add
- Lecture 4-2: Hopes: Messiah, Resurrection and the Age to Come
- Lecture 4-3: Torah and Covenant: How Jews Understood the Law
- Lecture 4-4: Scripture in Many Hands
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Reading Groups
- Lecture 5-1: Rome and Judea
- Lecture 5-2: Cities, Households and Patronage
- Lecture 5-3: The Market of Religions and Philosophies
- Lecture 5-4: Associations, House Gatherings and the First Churches' Setting
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: An Inscription and a Letter
Two objects can open this lecture. One is a small silver coin. The other is a broken block of stone.
The coin is a denarius. In the Gospels, someone holds one up and Jesus asks whose face is on it. The stone was found at Caesarea, the Roman governor's port city on the coast. It carries part of a Latin dedication, and one line of it names Pontius Pilate. A coin and a stone are not the whole story of Rome in Judea. But both show what week 5 is about: the New Testament was written in a world where Rome was the ruling power, and where the ruler's name and image were part of everyday life.
Earlier weeks followed Temple and dynasty, synagogue and home, groups and hopes. This week moves outward to the Roman and Greek world that surrounded all of them. Lecture 2-3 told how Rome arrived and how the family of Herod ruled for a time. This lecture asks a different question: how did Roman rule actually work for people in Judea, and how did Jews answer it? Reading the Gospels well needs both. The New Testament overview in BT501E gives the broad outline of Roman rule. This lecture goes a step further and reads what the sources say, source by source, about one governor and one policy.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Describe how a Roman governor ruled a province such as Judea, and name two ways he depended on local leaders.
- Say what the coin and the stone from Caesarea can show about Pilate, and what they cannot.
- Compare how the Gospels, Josephus and Philo present Pilate, and name the lean of each.
- Explain what the emperor cult was, and why it was a harder question for Jews than for most of their neighbours.
- Describe three kinds of Jewish response to Rome (armed, non-violent, cooperative) without saying that "the Jews" chose one.
Is it lawful for us to pay taxes to Caesar, or not?” But he perceived their craftiness, and said to them, “Why do you test me? Show me a denarius. Whose image and inscription are on it?” They answered, “Caesar’s.” He said to them, “Then give to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” — Luke 20:22-25
World English Bible
At this, Pilate was seeking to release him, but the Jews cried out, saying, “If you release this man, you aren’t Caesar’s friend! Everyone who makes himself a king speaks against Caesar!” — John 19:12
WEB
The first passage is about money and the image on it. The second is about a governor under pressure. Between them they show Rome as a presence in the ordinary life of the Gospel stories, not as a distant background.
1. How a governor ruled
Rome ruled many peoples across a large area. It did not do this by placing an official in every village. It did it by a small number of officials, a limited number of soldiers, and a great deal of reliance on local leaders. Judea fits this pattern.
After the end of the rule of Herod's son over Judea, early in the first century AD, Rome sent its own governor. The title changed over time. Pilate's stone gives his title as prefect; later governors are often called procurators by other writers. The word matters less than the job: the governor was the emperor's man on the spot, responsible for keeping order, collecting what Rome was owed, and judging the most serious cases. His base was Caesarea on the coast. He came up to Jerusalem when crowds gathered for the pilgrim festivals, because crowds were the moment when order was most likely to break.
What did the governor need from local people? Mainly three things.
Local leaders to do the daily work. Roman officials were few. Towns and villages managed their own affairs, and the large families of Jerusalem, with the priestly houses at the centre, had a part in carrying out what Rome required. The governor could appoint and remove the high priest, which means that the most important religious office was tied to Roman favour. That fact explains some of the tensions in the Gospel accounts and in Josephus.
Taxes. Rome collected tribute from the province, and there were also duties on goods and tolls on roads and at harbours. Those who collected them are the "tax collectors" of the Gospels. The Temple tax of lecture 3-1 was a separate matter, a Jewish payment to the Temple, not a Roman one. That is why the question in Luke 20 is a sharp one: "Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar?" was a question that could split an audience.
Order. The main aim was quiet. A Roman governor was judged by whether his province was calm and its payments came in. A riot at a festival was a mark against him. This helps us read a scene such as John 19, which we come to below.
2. Roman policy toward Jews
Rome did not, as a rule, try to end Jewish practice. In general, Jews were allowed to keep their ancestral customs: to keep the sabbath, to send the Temple tax to Jerusalem, to meet in their own assemblies. Josephus, a Jewish author who wrote under Roman protection, preserves a number of Roman letters and decrees giving such rights to Jewish communities. Historians debate the details of some of these documents, but the general picture, that Rome usually respected ancestral custom in matters of religion, is widely accepted.
There was a limit. Rome expected the ruler to be honoured, and Jews could not honour him in the usual way. The Temple compromise was that sacrifices were offered in the Temple on behalf of the emperor, not to him. This counted as loyalty on both sides: the Jews showed respect, and Rome allowed them not to worship. According to Josephus, the ending of this offering in the year AD 66 was one of the signs that a revolt had begun. We will leave the revolt itself for lecture 6-1.
3. The emperor cult
The emperor cult is the name modern writers give to the honours paid to the emperor, and sometimes to his family, as more than human. It took many forms: statues, festivals, priests, temples, coins, and oaths. It was not one thing everywhere. In many cities of the east, it was the city itself, not Rome, that voted the honours. A city that wanted the emperor's favour had every reason to build him a temple. The ruler's image appeared on coins and public buildings, so a person could not go through a market day without meeting it.
Readers differ about how much it mattered to ordinary people. Some hold that it was a civic ceremony, more like a flag and an anthem than a creed. Others hold that it carried real religious weight for many people. Both can be true in different places. What matters here is that for Jews, the question was sharper. The first commandment forbids other gods and the images made of them. A coin with the emperor's head and a title, or a standard carrying his image, was not a neutral object.
That is the background to the coin in Luke 20. The text says what is on the coin: an image and an inscription, and that they are Caesar's. It also says the questioners were spies sent to trap him, "so as to deliver him up to the power and authority of the governor" (Luke 20:20). Jesus does not answer yes or no. What the text says: the coin carries Caesar's image; give to Caesar what is Caesar's and to God what is God's. What the source adds: a Roman coin bore the ruler's portrait and a title, which is why the question of "whose image" was not idle. Conjecture: how much, in Jesus' answer, is a comment on the limits of Caesar's claim. Readers have taken it in more than one way, and this course does not need to choose.
4. Pilate, as three sources show him
Pilate is the Roman most often named in the New Testament. He is also a good test for the skills of week 1, because we meet him in several sources, each with its own lean.
The stone. The stone from Caesarea was found in the nineteen-sixties, reused in a later building. It is broken, and the Latin is partly missing. The surviving lines name the emperor Tiberius and Pilate with his title as prefect of Judea. It shows that Pilate was real, that he held that title, and that he put his name to a building or a dedication in the port city. What it cannot do is tell us anything about the trial of Jesus, or about his character. A name on a stone is a name on a stone. A common mistake with inscriptions is to treat them as "proof" of a whole story. Lecture 1-4 warned against that habit.
Josephus. Josephus tells of two incidents. In one, soldiers brought military standards bearing the emperor's image into Jerusalem, and crowds went down to Caesarea to protest for days until Pilate gave way. In another, he used money from the Temple treasury for a water supply, and the people's protest ended in violence. Josephus writes as a Jew who, after the failed revolt, wrote under Roman protection. He has reasons to show Roman governors as sometimes harsh and sometimes wise, and to show most Jews as peaceful. His Pilate is a man who misjudges the people.
Philo. Philo of Alexandria, a Jewish philosopher, tells of a time when Pilate set up shields with an inscription in Jerusalem, and the leading men protested to the emperor. Philo includes the story in a work about a later and much worse emperor, to show how Rome could threaten Jewish customs. His Pilate is harsh, greedy and cruel. Philo is arguing a case, and his picture of Pilate serves the argument.
The Gospels. In the Gospels, Pilate hears the case against Jesus. He seems to find no reason for execution, and he gives way under pressure. In John 19:12 the pressure is put in political terms: "you aren't Caesar's friend". The Gospels write for believers, to tell why Jesus was crucified and by whom. They do not aim to give a full biography of Pilate.
Put the four together and a careful reader does not choose one and discard the others. Josephus and Philo show a governor who clashed with the people over images and money. The Gospels show a governor who gives way when his own position is threatened. These may be the same man, because a hard official can also be an anxious one. But we cannot say more than the sources allow.
What John 19:12 says, adds and leaves open
What the text says: Pilate was seeking to release Jesus; a cry went up that releasing him would mean Pilate was not Caesar's friend, and that anyone who makes himself a king speaks against Caesar.
What the source adds: A governor's place depended on the emperor's trust, and a charge of disloyalty could be dangerous to him. This makes the phrase "Caesar's friend" understandable as a political pressure.
What is conjecture: exactly how Pilate weighed this, and how much of his decision came from fear for his position. The text does not tell us what he felt.
A note of care. "The Jews cried out" in John 19:12 is a phrase from inside a dispute in the first century. It is not a verdict on a whole people. Later in church history these words were used to blame all Jews of every age and to harm them. Lecture 6-2 returns to this. For now it is enough to note that the verse describes a crowd at one trial, and that Pilate, the Roman governor, is the one who gave the sentence.
5. How people answered Rome
The sources show Jews answering Roman rule in at least three ways. They are not three parties with neat labels. A single person could move from one to another, and many people are not heard from at all.
Armed resistance. Josephus tells of leaders who gathered followers, of bands in the countryside, and of the great revolt that began in AD 66. He has his own lean: he blames a few violent leaders for leading a people astray, and he was himself a commander in the early months of the war. Other accounts would tell the story differently.
Non-violent protest. In the story of the standards, the crowd did not take up weapons. Josephus tells that they came to Caesarea, stayed for days, and, when the governor threatened them, offered their necks. They appealed to the governor and, at times, to the emperor. Delegations, petitions and long public demonstrations are a recurring form of Jewish response in these sources.
Cooperation. The high priestly families, the Herodian rulers and many who held local office worked with Rome. Some did so for their own advantage, some because they thought that order was better than war. A modern reader should not decide in advance that cooperation was shameful or that resistance was always right.
There were other responses, too: withdrawal from public life, waiting for God to act, and quiet getting on with ordinary life. The lesson of the lecture is that "the Jews" did not have one answer to Rome. To say "the Jews hated Rome" or "the Jews welcomed Rome" is the kind of universal claim we cannot defend.
6. What this means for reading the New Testament
Keep the habit of week 1: ask who is speaking. The Gospels' Pilate, Josephus's Pilate and Philo's Pilate are three different writers with three different purposes. A coin and a stone give us a few firm facts, and the writers give us the interpretation. When a New Testament passage mentions taxes, soldiers, governors or Caesar, the Roman setting helps us hear it. It does not tell us what the passage means. That is the work of the text, and of the book courses.
Diagram 1. Roman rule in Judea: what Rome used and how people answered
Diagram 2. A small table: reading a Roman object
| Object | What it can show | What it cannot show |
|---|---|---|
| A coin with the emperor's head | The ruler's image and title were in daily use | What any one person felt about it |
| The Caesarea stone | Pilate was real and held the title of prefect | The trial of Jesus, or Pilate's character |
| A decree kept by Josephus | Rome often allowed Jews their customs | That every governor kept to it every time |
In short
- Rome ruled Judea through a governor at Caesarea with few soldiers, relying on local leaders, taxes and the aim of quiet.
- The governor could appoint the high priest, so Roman favour and the Temple's leadership were tied together.
- Rome in general let Jews keep ancestral customs; sacrifice was offered for the emperor in the Temple, not to him.
- The emperor cult took many forms and varied by place; it was a sharper question for Jews than for most neighbours.
- The Caesarea stone shows Pilate was real and a prefect; Josephus, Philo and the Gospels each present him with a lean.
- Jews answered Rome in armed, non-violent and cooperative ways; "the Jews" had no single answer.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Prefect or procurator | The Roman governor of Judea; Pilate's stone names him as prefect. |
| Emperor cult | Honours paid to the emperor in many forms, varying by place; a sharper question for Jews. |
| The Caesarea stone | Shows Pilate was real and held his title; it cannot show the trial or his character. |
| Three responses | Armed, non-violent and cooperative; no single answer from "the Jews". |
One sentence to remember A coin and a stone give us a few firm facts about Rome in Judea; the writers give us the interpretations, each with a lean.
This week's action Choose one sentence in a Gospel that mentions taxes, soldiers or Caesar, and write down what the text says, what a source adds and what is only a guess.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Rome ruled with few officials and relied on local leaders. What are the advantages for the ruler of such a system, and what dangers for the local leaders?
- The lecture says the coin and stone can show certain things and not others. Can you think of an object in your own place that is often used as "proof" of more than it shows?
- Josephus and Philo both lean in their own direction when they write about Pilate. What do you think each wished his readers to conclude?
- In the Gospel of John, "the Jews cried out" describes a crowd in one scene. Why is it important not to turn such a phrase into a verdict on a people?
- The lecture names three kinds of response to Rome. What might make a person choose one rather than another? What does "the Jews did not have one answer" protect us from?
- When a ruler's image is on the money, what kind of daily questions does this raise for a person of faith? You may answer for a different place or time.