FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT734E Diaspora and Migrant Ministry: Immigrant Congregations, Generations and the Welcoming Church

Lecture 5-3: Insecure Status and Exploited Work: The Church's Ethical Stance

Contents 31
PT734E Diaspora and Migrant Ministry: Immigrant Congregations, Generations and the Welcoming Church
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Neighbours Who Have Moved
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Neighbours Who Have Moved, and What This Course Does Not Teach
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Strangers and Pilgrims: A Biblical and Theological Foundation
  1. Lecture 1-1: A People Who Move
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Law of the Stranger and the Words of Jesus
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Scattered Church and the Language of Pilgrims
  4. Lecture 1-4: Believers Who Disagree
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Where My Family and My Congregation Came From
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Immigrant Congregation: Haven, Closed Door and Leadership
  1. Lecture 2-1: One Door, Several Rooms: What the Immigrant Congregation Does
  2. Lecture 2-2: Haven and Closed Door
  3. Lecture 2-3: Leaders, Money, Buildings and Succession
  4. Lecture 2-4: One People or Many? Ethnic, Language-Based and Intercultural Congregations
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Walk Through the Door
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Generations: Different Windows, One Household
  1. Lecture 3-1: First, One-and-a-Half and Second Generation: What Each Carries
  2. Lecture 3-2: Language and the Language of Faith
  3. Lecture 3-3: When Generations Quarrel
  4. Lecture 3-4: Identity and Belonging
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Listening Across a Generation
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Handing On the Faith Across Languages
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Home as the First Place
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Congregation: Language, Structures and Leaders
  3. Lecture 4-3: Those Who Leave and Those Who Return
  4. Lecture 4-4: Across Traditions: Sacraments, Catechesis and the Rhythm of the Year
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Telling How I Came to Believe
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The Welcoming Church and the Vulnerable Neighbour
  1. Lecture 5-1: Two Congregations, One Building, and the Road Toward One Family
  2. Lecture 5-2: The First Year: How a Congregation Receives a Newcomer
  3. Lecture 5-3: Insecure Status and Exploited Work: The Church's Ethical Stance
  4. Lecture 5-4: Strain at Home, Loneliness and Distress
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Newcomer's First Week
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Many Roads: Refugees, Workers, Students, Return and Shared Mission
  1. Lecture 6-1: Refugees and People Seeking Asylum: Accompaniment
  2. Lecture 6-2: Workers, Students, Domestic Workers and Internal Migrants
  3. Lecture 6-3: Return, and Ties Across Borders
  4. Lecture 6-4: Migrants and the Mission of the Church, Without Using People
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Covenant of Welcome

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

This lecture gives no legal advice. It is about what a congregation owes to a neighbour whose right to stay in a place is uncertain, or whose work is unsafe, unpaid or unfairly paid. Rules about status, visas, asylum, work and wages differ from country to country and change, and they have serious consequences for the person concerned. Anyone facing such a question should consult a qualified immigration or employment adviser, a lawyer, or an accredited organisation in that place. The lecture will not say what any law is, will not name any category of permission, and will never show anyone how to avoid the law, hide from it or evade enforcement.

What the lecture can say is something else, and it matters a great deal. A congregation does not need to be an expert in law to know how to treat a person. The church's part is to connect, keep confidence, protect dignity, refuse to exploit, and learn the local rules in advance. Its claim is: a neighbour whose position is insecure is owed dignity, silence about their affairs, honest dealing and a road to qualified help, and no believer may take part in their abuse.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Say plainly what this lecture is not (legal advice) and list the five parts of the church's own task: connect, keep confidence, protect dignity, refuse to exploit, learn local rules in advance.
  • Describe how a congregation can fail a person with insecure status through gossip, curiosity or unpaid labour, and how to avoid it.
  • Name the ways in which unpaid or underpaid work can enter a congregation's own life, including unpaid "volunteer" labour and a leader's private business.
  • Explain how emergency material help can be given with dignity.
  • State fairly the disagreement among believers about how far a congregation should go between respect for law and loyalty to a neighbour, and what the course asks at minimum.

You shall not wrong an alien, neither shall you oppress him, for you were aliens in the land of Egypt." — Exodus 22:21

World English Bible

You shall not take advantage of any widow or fatherless child." — Exodus 22:22

WEB

If you take advantage of them at all, and they cry at all to me, I will surely hear their cry;" — Exodus 22:23

WEB

and my wrath will grow hot, and I will kill you with the sword; and your wives shall be widows, and your children fatherless." — Exodus 22:24

WEB

You shall not oppress a hired servant who is poor and needy, whether he is one of your brothers, or one of the foreigners who are in your land within your gates." — Deuteronomy 24:14

WEB

In his day you shall give him his hire, neither shall the sun go down on it; for he is poor, and sets his heart on it; lest he cry against you to Yahweh, and it be sin to you." — Deuteronomy 24:15

WEB

Behold, the wages of the laborers who mowed your fields, which you have kept back by fraud, cry out, and the cries of those who reaped have entered into the ears of the Lord of Armies." — James 5:4

WEB

He who oppresses the poor shows contempt for his Maker, but he who is kind to the needy honors him." — Proverbs 14:31

WEB

These passages come from different settings. The first two are from the law given to Israel, and they speak to a society with its own courts and its own household economy. James writes to a church some of whose members may have held land and hired labour. Proverbs gathers wisdom. None of them is about a modern visa or a modern labour contract, and none should be read as a ruling on a modern law. What they have in common is a refusal to let anyone who has power over another person's livelihood use that power to take advantage, and a belief that God hears those who have no one else.

1. What the passages are about, and what they are not

Exodus 22 names three groups the law protects: the alien, the widow and the fatherless child. It gives the reason in the same sentence: "you were aliens in the land of Egypt." The law is strong in its language, and says that God hears the cry. Deuteronomy 24 turns to the hired worker who is poor and needy, "whether he is one of your brothers, or one of the foreigners who are in your land", and says that his wage is to be paid on the day it is earned. James repeats the matter for the church: wages kept back "by fraud" cry out. Proverbs sums it up: to oppress someone who is poor is to show contempt for his Maker.

We have to be honest about what these texts do not do. They are laws and sayings for a particular society, written long ago. They do not tell a modern church what the law of a modern country should be, and they do not tell a congregation how to answer a legal question. They tell us how God regards the treatment of a person who is vulnerable, and especially how God regards the withholding of pay. It is reasonable to read them as a strong witness that such things matter to God, and as a warning to anyone, including a member of a church, who is in a position to take advantage.

2. The five parts of the church's own task

Because the church is not an immigration office or a court or a labour tribunal, it helps to say exactly what it can do.

Connect. The church can help a person reach those whose work it is: a qualified immigration adviser or lawyer, an accredited organisation that supports people in such situations, a workers' or labour organisation, a legal aid office, a trusted community office. A good connection is a person's own choice, made with information, and may include going along to the first appointment if asked. The church may not know who is reliable in that place, so it should find out in advance and keep an updated list. Unqualified helpers, including well-meaning members and some people who offer help for a fee, can make a person's position worse. It is the church's job to ask who is accredited and recognised in the place, not to guess.

Keep confidence. What a person says about their status, work, fears or family is theirs. A congregation that has learned something of a person's situation tells nobody: not the pastor's friends, not the prayer group, not the other leaders unless the person has agreed, not the person's own family or employer. A confidence is not a secret to be used as currency, and it is not material for sympathy in a sermon. The one exception is where someone is in danger of serious harm or a child is at risk, and then the church's safeguarding rule applies (lecture 5-4).

Protect dignity. A person whose status is uncertain is not a label, a "problem" or "one of those". The congregation does not use such words in conversation, from the pulpit or in the kitchen. It does not ask a person to prove anything in order to be welcomed. It does not make a person the subject of a prayer request in public without leave.

Refuse to exploit. A congregation does not take advantage of anyone's insecurity: not by asking for unpaid work that it would not ask of others, not by offering low pay to a member who cannot refuse, not by making help depend on silence. This is discussed below.

Learn the local rules in advance. A congregation that wants to be useful does well to learn, from a qualified source, how matters work in its own place: whom to call, what a person's rights to a fair wage and a safe workplace are, and what the congregation's own obligations are. The rules differ everywhere. The congregation does not need to master them. It needs to know where to send someone and what not to say.

What the church does not do

A church does not give legal advice, does not tell a person what to say to an official, does not help a person avoid, hide from or evade the law, does not guess at the person's category or chances, and does not promise an outcome. These belong to qualified advisers. The church's work is to stand beside the person and help them reach one.

3. Dignity in the congregation's own life

Some of the greatest risks of exploitation are not in the world outside but inside the congregation itself.

Gossip and curiosity. In a small congregation, news travels fast. "I heard that his papers are not in order." "Have you noticed she has been working nights?" Such remarks may be passed on with concern, and they do real harm: they can lead to shame, to loss of work, to a person's absence from worship. A congregation that wants to be safe for a neighbour with an uncertain position cultivates a habit of not asking, not repeating and not guessing.

Volunteering that is really unpaid labour. A congregation depends on volunteers, and people give time gladly. It becomes a different matter when a person who cannot easily refuse is asked for long hours without rest or pay, when the "volunteering" is tied to help the person receives, or when the work is for something that is really the leader's own benefit. A useful check: would we ask this of a member who was secure and had other options? Is the person free to say no without losing anything? Is anyone being paid for this elsewhere? Where the answer is troubling, the congregation should change its practice.

A leader's private business. A pastor, priest or lay leader may also own a shop, a cleaning company, a building firm or a farm. Church members may work for the leader, sometimes with good terms and sometimes not. There is nothing wrong in a leader's having a business, and some leaders do so out of necessity (lecture 2-3). But where the people who work for the business are also the people who depend on the leader for their place in the congregation, there is a risk that the leader's authority over worship slides into authority over wages. A leader should ask whether anyone who works for him or her is paid a fair wage, on time, with the same terms as anyone else, and whether anyone feels unable to leave. The congregation should have a way for such a question to be raised that does not depend on the leader's goodwill.

(An invented case.) In a town called Embra Cross, a church member named Cecil owns a small cleaning business and employs three people from his own congregation. One of them, a woman named Ruth, found that her pay had been delayed three times in a row. She did not wish to complain: Cecil was a and had helped her family to settle. She mentioned it to a friend in the women's group, who did not repeat it but said, "Is there somebody outside the church you trust to ask about wages?" Ruth contacted a workers' advice office that she had heard about. The advice office explained how it worked in that place. In the end Cecil, who was embarrassed more than hard-hearted, and had never thought of it as exploitation, changed the way he paid. The congregation later drew up a simple rule: any member who employs another should be willing to say how the wage is set and paid, and a person who works for a member may raise a concern with someone other than the employer.

The case does not show a villain. It shows a gap in a congregation's structure which let a good man do a poor thing without noticing.

4. Material help with dignity

A person with an uncertain position may also be short of food, clothing, rent or fares. A congregation often gives what it can: a meal, groceries, a coat, a place to sleep for a night. Giving is good. The question is how.

Ask what would help. A person's needs are not always those we imagine.

Give without questions that the help does not require. A food parcel does not require an account of a person's status. Asking a person to explain themselves in order to be fed makes help a kind of examination.

Give discreetly. An envelope, a bag left at a door, a card that can be used in a shop: these let a person take help without being seen to take it. The names of those who receive help are not announced, and the congregation does not hold a collection "for" a named person without that person's consent.

Give without conditions that the help does not carry. Help does not depend on attendance, on gratitude or on silence.

Know the local help. A food bank, a shelter, a day centre or an agency may be able to do things the congregation cannot. The congregation connects the person with them, and does not hold on to the person so as to be the only giver.

Give a person something to give. A person who is receiving help may also be able to cook, mend, teach or watch the children of another. The congregation can ask (lecture 5-2).

5. Where readers will not agree

Between the law and a neighbour

Believers have thought long and hard about what a congregation should do when a neighbour's legal position is uncertain, and they do not agree.

Some hold that obeying the law of one's country is part of loving one's neighbour, because law protects the weak as well as the strong, keeps order in which all can live, and gives everyone, including newcomers, a place to stand. On this view a congregation should be honest with officials, should not work against the law, and should help a person by connecting them to lawful routes and by supporting them, in love, through whatever follows. Some Christian writers who press the importance of law and order in public life, such as Wayne Grudem in his work on politics and the Bible, hold a view of this kind. The of the Catholic Church likewise says that political authorities may, for the sake of the common good, regulate migration, while also saying that more prosperous nations are bound to welcome foreigners as far as they are able.

Others hold that the call to protect a person in danger may sometimes come before the demands of a law that the church judges to be unjust or too harsh, and they point to the long Christian tradition of giving sanctuary and to the biblical commands about the alien. On this view a congregation may choose to give sanctuary, or to stand openly beside a person, accepting the cost. Writers such as M. Daniel Carroll R. and Luke Bretherton have written about the Bible and migration in ways that give a strong place to hospitality and the protection of the vulnerable, though they differ from one another and from other writers on how that works out.

Some readers will find themselves persuaded by one of these views at one moment and by another at another, depending on the case. The course takes no side. It does not tell a congregation that either view is the Christian one. It asks, at minimum, two things: that no person be left without help, and that no believer take part in abuse. It also asks that a congregation that is considering anything beyond the ordinary should first learn, from a qualified adviser and from its denomination or diocese, what the rules in its own place are and what the consequences could be for the person and for others. A choice made out of love can bring serious harm to the person it was meant to protect if it is made without knowing.

6. What a congregation has done well

Some congregations have done well in this area, and it is worth saying how.

(An invented case.) A parish in a city called Tamsin Ridge set up a small hardship fund run by two members who had agreed in writing to keep every request in confidence. Neither is on the parish council, and neither takes part in any discussion of a person's circumstances elsewhere. They give food vouchers and help with fares without asking about status. They keep a list, reviewed each year with the help of a local workers' advice centre, of agencies which have a good reputation in that place. They tell each person: "We do not give legal advice. We can help you find someone who does, and we can go with you if you wish." The priest preaches now and then on the dignity of work and the justice of wages, in general terms and without pointing at anyone. One member of the parish who had worried that the fund would encourage gossip said later that it had done the opposite: the habit of confidence had spread.

This is the pattern: a small structure, a clear rule of confidence, a list of qualified help, and no questions the help does not need.

7. Between the church and the person

A congregation is not the only body in a person's life, and it should not try to be. The person has their own mind. They may choose a path that the congregation would not have chosen. They may decline help. They may leave. A church that has done these five things (connect, keep confidence, protect dignity, refuse to exploit, learn the local rules) has done what is its own to do. For workers who live in another person's home, who move for a contract or who are in a country of which they are not citizens, lecture 6-2 goes further, and lecture 6-1 speaks of those who seek protection.


Diagram 1. What the church can do, and who does the rest

The Church and the Insecure Neighbour This is not legal advice The church's own task 1. Connect to qualified advisers and accredited bodies 2. Keep confidence no gossip, no repeating, no guessing 3. Protect dignity no labels, no proof asked, no public prayer without leave 4. Refuse to exploit no unpaid labour, no private business advantage 5. Learn the local rules in advance whom to call, what not to say Not the church's to do Give legal advice Guess a person's category or chances Tell a person what to say to an official Show anyone how to avoid, hide from or evade the law Promise an outcome Spread a person's affairs Qualified advisers, accredited bodies and workers' organisations do these things. The course asks at minimum No person is left without help. No believer takes part in abuse. The course takes no side on how far a congregation goes between law and loyalty.

In short

  • This lecture gives no legal advice; the church's task is to connect, keep confidence, protect dignity, refuse to exploit and learn the local rules in advance.
  • Scripture speaks strongly against taking advantage of the alien, the poor and the hired worker, and especially against withholding wages, in settings other than ours.
  • Danger can lie inside a congregation: gossip, "volunteering" that is really unpaid labour, and a leader's private business.
  • Material help is given discreetly, without questions it does not need, without conditions, and with a road to qualified agencies.
  • Believers disagree about law and loyalty; the course takes no side and asks that no person be left without help and no believer take part in abuse.
Front Back
Topic The church's ethical stance toward a neighbour whose status is uncertain or whose work is unsafe or unpaid; not legal advice.
Remember Connect, keep confidence, protect dignity, refuse to exploit, learn local rules in advance; help is given discreetly and without conditions.
Caution Never teach anyone to avoid, hide from or evade the law; guard against gossip and unpaid labour inside the congregation.
One line to carry into ministry Keep what you are told, never use a person's insecurity for the church's gain, and walk with them to someone qualified.
Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • The lecture begins by saying what it is not. Why might it matter that a congregation says plainly "we do not give legal advice"? What could go wrong if a well-meaning member did?
  • Which of the five parts (connect, keep confidence, protect dignity, refuse to exploit, learn the local rules in advance) would be hardest for a congregation you know? What would help?
  • Where might "volunteering" in a congregation come close to unpaid labour? Ask the check questions about a task you know.
  • In the case of Ruth and Cecil, what did the friend do well? What gap in the congregation's life did the later rule close?
  • State the two views about law and loyalty as fairly as you can. Which part of the view you hold less would you want to keep in mind?
  • How can a congregation give material help in a way that does not turn a person into an exhibit or an examinee?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.