FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT734E Diaspora and Migrant Ministry: Immigrant Congregations, Generations and the Welcoming Church

Lecture 3-4: Identity and Belonging

Contents 31
PT734E Diaspora and Migrant Ministry: Immigrant Congregations, Generations and the Welcoming Church
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Neighbours Who Have Moved
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Neighbours Who Have Moved, and What This Course Does Not Teach
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Strangers and Pilgrims: A Biblical and Theological Foundation
  1. Lecture 1-1: A People Who Move
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Law of the Stranger and the Words of Jesus
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Scattered Church and the Language of Pilgrims
  4. Lecture 1-4: Believers Who Disagree
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Where My Family and My Congregation Came From
Chapter 2 · Week 2: The Immigrant Congregation: Haven, Closed Door and Leadership
  1. Lecture 2-1: One Door, Several Rooms: What the Immigrant Congregation Does
  2. Lecture 2-2: Haven and Closed Door
  3. Lecture 2-3: Leaders, Money, Buildings and Succession
  4. Lecture 2-4: One People or Many? Ethnic, Language-Based and Intercultural Congregations
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Walk Through the Door
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Generations: Different Windows, One Household
  1. Lecture 3-1: First, One-and-a-Half and Second Generation: What Each Carries
  2. Lecture 3-2: Language and the Language of Faith
  3. Lecture 3-3: When Generations Quarrel
  4. Lecture 3-4: Identity and Belonging
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Listening Across a Generation
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Handing On the Faith Across Languages
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Home as the First Place
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Congregation: Language, Structures and Leaders
  3. Lecture 4-3: Those Who Leave and Those Who Return
  4. Lecture 4-4: Across Traditions: Sacraments, Catechesis and the Rhythm of the Year
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Telling How I Came to Believe
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The Welcoming Church and the Vulnerable Neighbour
  1. Lecture 5-1: Two Congregations, One Building, and the Road Toward One Family
  2. Lecture 5-2: The First Year: How a Congregation Receives a Newcomer
  3. Lecture 5-3: Insecure Status and Exploited Work: The Church's Ethical Stance
  4. Lecture 5-4: Strain at Home, Loneliness and Distress
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Newcomer's First Week
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Many Roads: Refugees, Workers, Students, Return and Shared Mission
  1. Lecture 6-1: Refugees and People Seeking Asylum: Accompaniment
  2. Lecture 6-2: Workers, Students, Domestic Workers and Internal Migrants
  3. Lecture 6-3: Return, and Ties Across Borders
  4. Lecture 6-4: Migrants and the Mission of the Church, Without Using People
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Covenant of Welcome

Jump to the key points ↓

27 min

"Where are you from?" is one of the oldest questions people ask each other. It can be a friendly door. It can also, for a young person whose family has moved, be a small test that is taken many times and never quite passed.

This lecture is about belonging: how a young person (and, in other ways, a parent) holds more than one place in the heart, what makes that a gift and what makes it a weight, and what a congregation can do. It starts from a plain rule that the rest of the lecture keeps: the church does not decide a person's identity for them. It can offer a place, a name, a listening ear and the company of God's people. It cannot hand someone a finished answer to "who am I?", and it should not try.

The lecture also deals, briefly and carefully, with things that hurt: discrimination, the loneliness of not fitting, and the young person who does not match the congregation's picture of an ideal child. It describes warning signs as what a friend might notice, and it always points beyond itself to those whose work it is to help.

What these 27 minutes give you

  • Explain why a question like "Where are you from?" can be friendly or hurtful depending on how it is asked and heard, and suggest other questions.
  • Describe, without romance and without despair, what it can mean to live between two worlds, including the gift and the cost.
  • Say what a congregation should do when a young person reports discrimination or exclusion.
  • Describe a young person of mixed origin, or one who does not fit the congregation's picture, and say what the church owes that person.
  • Read Genesis 41:50-52, Philippians 3:20, Galatians 3:28 and Esther 2:7-10 honestly.

To Joseph were born two sons before the year of famine came, whom Asenath, the daughter of Potiphera priest of On, bore to him." — Genesis 41:50

World English Bible

Joseph called the name of the firstborn Manasseh, “For”, he said, “God has made me forget all my toil, and all my father’s house.”" — Genesis 41:51

WEB

The name of the second, he called Ephraim: “For God has made me fruitful in the land of my affliction.”" — Genesis 41:52

WEB

For our citizenship is in heaven, from where we also wait for a Savior, the Lord Jesus Christ;" — Philippians 3:20

WEB

There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." — Galatians 3:28

WEB

He brought up Hadassah, that is, Esther, his uncle’s daughter; for she had neither father nor mother. The maiden was fair and beautiful; and when her father and mother were dead, Mordecai took her for his own daughter." — Esther 2:7

WEB

So, when the king’s commandment and his decree was heard, and when many maidens were gathered together to the citadel of Susa, to the custody of Hegai, Esther was taken into the king’s house, to the custody of Hegai, keeper of the women." — Esther 2:8

WEB

The maiden pleased him, and she obtained kindness from him. He quickly gave her cosmetics and her portions of food, and the seven choice maidens who were to be given her out of the king’s house. He moved her and her maidens to the best place in the women’s house." — Esther 2:9

WEB

Esther had not made known her people nor her relatives, because Mordecai had instructed her that she should not make it known." — Esther 2:10

WEB

Joseph's sons are born in Egypt and given names that hold loss and fruitfulness at once. Paul tells a church in a Roman colony that its citizenship is in heaven. In Galatians, the old dividing lines do not decide who belongs to Christ. In Esther, a young woman is told by her guardian to keep her people secret. These texts do not give a formula for identity. They show that the people of God have always asked what it is to belong to more than one place.

1. "Where are you from?" asked twice

(An invented case.) Tamsin is seventeen. She was born in Dunmere to parents who moved there. When someone new at school asks, "Where are you from?", she answers, "Dunmere." Sometimes that is the end of it. Sometimes the person says, "No, where are you from?" and she knows what is being asked. It is often a friendly question. The person is curious. But she has answered it, and the second asking tells her that her answer was not accepted. It says, however kindly, that she is a visitor in her own city.

Then Tamsin visits her grandmother in a small town, her parents' place of origin. A neighbour asks her the same question. "Dunmere," she says. "Ah," says the neighbour, "the one from abroad." In Dunmere she is asked where she is really from. In her grandmother's town she is the one from abroad. She is not being attacked in either place. And both answers say that she belongs somewhere else.

Here is the point. The question itself is not forbidden. People ask it out of interest, and some young people like telling the story. What matters is the second asking, and the listening afterwards. A person who has told you where they are from has answered. If you want to know more, you can ask something else, and let them choose the door: "Which places matter to you?" "What do you cook at home?" "What did you do last week that you liked?"

A better question

Try asking questions that do not require the other person to prove where they belong. "Tell me about the places that matter to you" invites a story. "Where are you really from?" asks for a defence. The first lets the other person decide how much to say.

2. Between two worlds: gift and cost

Some young people who have grown up in two worlds describe a gift. They can see a thing from two sides. They can speak two languages, in the full sense, and move between two sets of customs. They can sometimes sit with people others cannot reach. The scholar Stuart Hall wrote about identity in the diaspora as something that is always being made and never finished, rather than something a person has once and for all. That can be a freeing thing to read.

Other young people, or the same ones on other days, describe a cost. It is tiring to switch between two ways of being many times in a single day: one at the dinner table, another at school, a third at church. It is lonely to feel that no group quite has you. It is painful to be the one who explains each world to the other.

Both descriptions are fair, and neither is the truth about everyone. A congregation should not tell a young person that living between two worlds is a gift, in a tone that suggests they ought to feel grateful. Nor should it tell them it is a burden, in a tone that suggests they ought to feel pitiable. It can ask: "What is it like for you?" and then wait.

Joseph offers a picture in Genesis, and we should read it without gloss. His two sons are born in Egypt, to an Egyptian mother, to a father who had been taken there against his will and who has risen high. He gives them names that hold two things at once:

"Joseph called the name of the firstborn Manasseh, “For”, he said, “God has made me forget all my toil, and all my father’s house.”" — Genesis 41:51 (WEB)

"The name of the second, he called Ephraim: “For God has made me fruitful in the land of my affliction.”" — Genesis 41:52 (WEB)

The names are the father's words, and they show a man holding loss and fruitfulness together. We cannot know whether Manasseh and Ephraim felt that way about their own lives. The book later counts them among the tribes of Israel, so they were received into the family's story. For our purpose the point is smaller: from the beginning of the Bible, a person can hold a place of affliction and a place of fruitfulness in the same breath. That does not make migration easy. It shows that the Bible does not demand a single, simple answer.

3. Believing the young person who reports exclusion

(An invented case.) Marek is fifteen. He tells his youth leader that a classmate has been him names about his family's origin, and that a teacher has laughed. The youth leader, who is kind, says, "I'm sure they didn't mean it that way," and moves on. Marek does not mention it again.

Nothing the youth leader said was cruel. But what Marek heard was: you may have misunderstood. A young person who reports exclusion or insult is often braver than we know, and a quick explanation can shut the door on the next time.

What helps is simple. Listen to the whole account. Believe the young person, in the sense of taking the account seriously and not looking for the gentle reading that lets everyone off. Do not make him prove it on the spot. Do not demand that he forgive. Say plainly that what happened is not right if it was not right. Then ask what he would like to happen, and find out who can help: a school, a workplace, a community organisation, or whoever has responsibility in that place. Where the matter involves a legal question or a formal complaint, this lecture gives no advice; a qualified adviser or an accredited organisation should be consulted, and the person should check locally for the rules that apply.

The exclusion may also be in the church itself. A congregation may be a place where a young person of mixed origin is asked, again and again, which side they are on; where a newcomer to the youth group is assumed to need help with the language when he does not; where a family is not asked to serve because "they might prefer to keep to themselves". The church is not outside the question. A congregation that wants to believe the young person has to be willing to hear that it might be part of the story.

4. A visit "home"

(An invented case.) Dalia, sixteen, has been told for years about the town of Tarn Hollow, where her parents grew up. For her first visit, her parents are excited. She has been given a list of relatives to greet.

It does not go as expected. She finds herself unable to follow the older relatives' jokes. She is noticed everywhere and called "the visitor". She feels, to her surprise, a flash of recognition when she smells a particular bread, and then loses it. Her father sees that his daughter is treated as a foreigner in the place where he grew up, and it hurts him more than he expected. Her mother notices that the town is no longer the town she remembered, and begins to wonder what exactly she has been telling her daughter about.

Everyone in that picture is affected. Nobody in it did anything wrong. The young person has learned that "home" is not one place. The parents have learned the same thing from the other direction.

A visit may also not be possible, for reasons of cost, of safety, of family circumstance or of paperwork, and some young people have never seen the place their parents speak of, and some do not wish to. This lecture does not advise on any of those matters. What a congregation can do is to listen to the young person without assuming that the visit is a happy thing, or that the absence of a visit is a sad one.

5. Mixed origin

(An invented case.) Ines, nineteen, has a mother from one place and a father from another, and a grandmother in each. At a cultural evening her congregation held, she was asked to wear the costume of one side and to say a few words about it. A few weeks later at a similar evening she was asked to do the same for the other. Everyone was kind. She had been, twice, the representative of a side. What she wanted was to be asked what she liked.

A young person of mixed origin may be asked to choose, or to explain, or to stand for both. Some find it a happy thing to belong to two families' stories. Some find it a constant question. The only fair thing for a congregation to do is not to fix the answer in advance.

6. The young person who does not fit the picture

Every congregation has a picture of an ideal young person, held without anyone saying so. In one it is the child who is first in the class, plays the instrument and serves at the door. In another it is the one who knows the old songs and the old language. In another it is the one who speaks the local language most smoothly and can lead the youth group.

(An invented case.) Joren, sixteen, is none of these. He is quiet. He does not like singing in front of others. He is better with engines than with books. He sits at the back, and the adults say he is "no trouble". Nobody has asked him what he thinks of God. He has a few things to say, and he is waiting to be invited.

There are young people who fit no picture for reasons that are much harder. They may be struggling with their schooling, with how they are treated, with their family, with doubts about faith, with questions about who they are that their tradition answers in a particular way, or with a health condition. Each tradition has its own teaching on some of these matters and this course does not settle any of them. What it asks is that no young person be made a stranger in their own church, and that each be received as a person and as one of God's people before being measured against anyone's picture.

7. What the Bible can and cannot say

Philippians 3:20. "Our citizenship is in heaven." Some scholars point out that Philippi was a Roman colony, a city that took pride in Roman citizenship, so Paul's words may have sounded in a special way to its Christians. The verse speaks of what believers belong to ultimately. It does not say that earthly belonging does not matter, and it must not be said to a young person as a way of closing the question: "Your real home is heaven, so you need not mind that you do not fit here." The language of strangers and exiles is a picture of all believers, and it should never cover over the real pain of someone who is not accepted where they live. This course says so wherever the picture comes up.

Galatians 3:28. "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." The verse says that the dividing lines of the ancient world do not decide who belongs to Christ. Readers have argued for centuries about how much it asks of a church's structures and how it sits with the rest of Paul's letters. For this lecture it says one thing safely: a young person's origin is not a reason to hold them at a distance from the body of Christ. It does not say that differences of language, history or custom do not exist, or that a church should pretend not to see them. A person is one in Christ and also a person with a particular story.

Esther 2:7-10. Esther is a young woman in a foreign court. Mordecai, who has brought her up, tells her not to make known her people or her family, and she does not. The text does not say whether he was wise. It does not tell us what it cost her. We should notice that she was "taken" to the king's house, and that she did not choose the place she found herself. Later in the book she speaks openly as one of her people, and acts. The point is not that hiding is wrong or that speaking out is always right. It is that a young person between two worlds may be advised by those who love her to keep part of herself quiet, and that this advice is given out of care, and has a price.

8. Warning signs a friend might notice

None of this is a diagnosis. These are things a friend might see. A young person who used to come and now does not. Someone who sits alone at the edge of every group, who says "I'm fine" in the same tone every time, who has stopped doing what they enjoyed, who seems tired all the time, or whose eating or sleeping has changed. A person who speaks of being a burden, or of not belonging anywhere.

What a friend can do is small and human. Say what you have noticed, kindly and without accusation. Ask how they are, and stay for the answer. Offer company. Suggest that a trusted adult, a doctor or a counsellor might help, and offer to go with them. This lecture is not mental-health advice, and a church is not a clinic. If a young person speaks of harming themselves or of not wanting to live, take it seriously: stay with them, do not leave them alone, tell a trusted adult or the proper authority at once, and if the danger is immediate, call the local emergency number or a local crisis line. Check locally for the lines that exist in your place.

9. One thing the church has done well

(An invented case.) In the city of Corvane, a Catholic parish was troubled that its welcome card asked every newcomer, "Where are you from?" and that the answers were then used to put people in groups. The youth team replaced the question with a wall in the parish hall. Every young person who came was invited to pin a small paper tag to a large map, at any place that mattered to them: a birthplace, a grandmother's town, a holiday, a street. Nobody was required to pin anything. After some months the map held more places than anyone had expected. The priest said later that the wall let the young people tell their own stories, and that the adults learned them by walking past it.


Diagram 1. One question, three hearings

One question, three hearings "Where are you from?" asked twice What the asker may mean Curiosity. Interest. A wish to be friendly. What the hearer may hear "Your answer was not enough." "You are a visitor here." A better question "Which places matter to you?" Let the person choose the door. What a congregation can do Believe a young person who reports exclusion. Do not explain it away. The church offers a place and a listening ear; it does not decide identity. Signs a friend might notice Stops coming. Sits apart. "I am fine" in the same tone. Tired all the time. Stay, ask, offer company, refer on. Any talk of self-harm is urgent: emergency number.

In short

  • "Where are you from?" asked twice tells a young person their answer was not accepted; invite stories with other questions.
  • Living between two worlds can be a gift and a weight; do not tell a young person which to feel.
  • Believe a young person who reports exclusion: listen, do not explain it away, and find who can help. No legal advice here.
  • A young person of mixed origin or one who does not fit the picture is a person and one of God's people; the church does not decide identity.
  • Warning signs of loneliness are what a friend notices; stay with the person, refer on, and treat any talk of self-harm as urgent.
Front Back
Topic Identity and belonging: "Where are you from?", between two worlds, exclusion, visits "home", mixed origin and not fitting the picture.
Remember The church offers a place and a listening ear, not a finished identity. The gift and the weight of two worlds are both real.
Caution Do not explain away a report of exclusion. Do not use "citizenship in heaven" to close a lonely person's question. Danger of self-harm means stay and call for help.
One line to carry into ministry Ask "which places matter to you?" and then listen.
Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • When have you been asked "Where are you from?" or asked it of someone else? What did you hear, and what did you mean?
  • Which questions would you ask instead? Write three.
  • The lecture says the gift and the cost of living between two worlds are both fair. What would you say to a young person who describes only one of them?
  • What did Marek's youth leader do kindly, and what did Marek hear? What could the leader say next time?
  • Dalia's visit hurt her parents as well as her. Why?
  • What is the congregation's picture of an ideal young person in a place you know? Who does not fit it?
  • Why is "your real home is in heaven" the wrong thing to say to someone who is lonely, and what might you say instead?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.