Lecture 6-1: Revising in Layers
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
- Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
- Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
- Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
- Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
- Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
- Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
- Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
- Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
- Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
- Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
- Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
- Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
- Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
- Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
- Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
- Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
- Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
- Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
A first draft is not a failure. It is the first time your thinking sits on a page where you can look at it. Until you have a draft, you do not know how far your reading has brought you. After the draft, you do.
Most students stop too early, or revise in the wrong way. Some hand in the first draft after a spell-check. Others read the draft again and again, changing a word here and a comma there, and never ask whether the paragraph should be there at all. Both are understandable. Both leave the real work undone.
This lecture gives one method: revise from the large to the small. First the thesis, then the structure, then the paragraphs, then the sentences, and only then the proof-reading. Each pass has one question. The order matters because a large change makes a small one pointless. There is no use polishing a sentence in a paragraph you will delete.
The method belongs to the central claim of the course. Revising is where you check that you have said only as much as you can support. It is also where you find out that some things you wrote were never supported at all.
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Name the five layers of revision in order and give the question that belongs to each.
- Explain why proof-reading comes last.
- Make a reverse outline of a draft and use it to find a missing, repeated or misplaced part.
- Decide what to cut, and decide what to add when a draft is short.
- Plan a revision in at least three separate readings, with some time away from the draft.
Who can discern his errors? Forgive me from hidden errors." — Psalm 19:12
World English Bible
Where there is no counsel, plans fail; but in a multitude of counselors they are established." — Proverbs 15:22
WEB
The psalmist asks a plain question: who can see his own mistakes? The answer the psalm expects is that no one can see them all. That is a good starting point for a writer. The faults in your own draft are the hardest for you to see, because you know what you meant. Proverbs adds the remedy: plans fail without counsel, and they stand when many give it. Lecture 6-2 deals with other readers. This lecture deals with what you can do alone before they read.
1. Why a draft is not finished
A draft shows the state of your thinking on the day you wrote it. Often the thinking was clearer at the end of the draft than at the beginning. That is normal. You began by guessing where the argument would go, and you found out as you wrote. So the opening paragraphs may promise a paper that the closing paragraphs no longer match.
Revision is the work of making the whole paper match the thinking you have reached. It is not decoration, and it is not only correction. It is a second round of thought, done with the page in front of you.
This is also why the length of the revision should not be measured in hours spent on grammar. A student who changes the thesis after the first draft and rebuilds two sections has done more revising than a student who corrected fifty commas.
2. Five layers, from large to small
Think of the draft as a building. You would not paint a room that you are about to take down. In the same way:
- Thesis. Does the paper answer the question it asked?
- Structure. Are the parts in the right order, and does each part do a job?
- Paragraphs. Does each paragraph make one claim and support it?
- Sentences. Is each sentence clear, and does it say what you mean?
- Proof-reading. Are spelling, punctuation, names, numbers, quotations and notes correct?
The diagram at the end of this lecture shows the five layers and the question for each.
Proof-read last. Layers one to four can delete whole paragraphs. If you correct the spelling of a paragraph and later cut it, that time is lost. Proof-reading is also the pass that gives the paper its final look, so it needs to be done on the final words.
3. One question per reading
Do not try to check everything in one reading. A reader who looks for five things at once usually finds the easiest one. Choose one question and read the whole draft with only that question in mind.
This is slower than it sounds, but it is more reliable. After a reading for structure, you know much more about the structure than you would after a general read. And the later readings are faster, because the large problems are gone.
4. Layer one: the thesis
Put the draft away, or turn the page over, and write in one or two sentences what the paper actually argues. Do not look at your introduction. Then compare what you wrote with your stated thesis (lecture 1-2).
Three things can happen.
- The two match. Good. Go on to the structure.
- The paper argues something narrower than the thesis. Your thesis promised more than you showed. Narrow the thesis; do not hope the reader will not notice (see lecture 6-4).
- The paper argues something different from the thesis, often something better. Your thinking moved while you wrote. Rewrite the thesis and the introduction to match, and then check whether the body still serves it.
Here is a short example. (an invented example)
Stated thesis: "Paul's teaching on the Lord's Supper in 1 Corinthians 11 shows what the early churches believed about the ."
What the draft really argues: "In 1 Corinthians 11, Paul treats the way the Corinthians eat together as part of the meaning of the meal."
Revised thesis: "In 1 Corinthians 11, Paul ties the meaning of the meal to how the Corinthians treat one another at the table."
The first thesis promised to speak for all the early churches. The draft only read one chapter. The revised thesis claims what the draft can show.
5. Layer two: the structure
The best tool for this layer is a reverse outline. Make it after the draft, not before. Read the draft paragraph by paragraph and write one line for each, saying what that paragraph does. Not what it is about; what it does. Then read your list.
A reverse outline for a short draft might look like this. (an invented example)
| Paragraph | What it does |
|---|---|
| 1 | Asks the question and gives the thesis |
| 2 | Gives the setting of the passage |
| 3 | Gives the first reason, with the text |
| 4 | Gives the second reason, with the text |
| 5 | Tells a story about a church I know |
| 6 | Gives the strongest objection |
| 7 | Repeats the first reason |
| 8 | Concludes |
Look at the list the way a stranger would. Questions to ask:
- Is every reason in the thesis here? Is anything here that the thesis does not need? (Paragraph 5 may belong to another paper.)
- Is any paragraph a repeat? (Paragraph 7 says again what paragraph 3 said.)
- Is the order the best one? Should the objection come before the second reason, or after?
- Is anything missing? The list shows the argument; if a step is not there, the reader will not find it either.
Cutting and moving at this layer can be painful, because the paragraphs may be well written. But a well-written paragraph in the wrong place is still in the wrong place. Keep it in a separate file if you cannot bear to lose it. Often you will find you do not return to it.
6. Layer three: the paragraphs
Now go through each remaining paragraph with lecture 4-2 beside you. Does it have a topic sentence? Does it make one claim? Is the evidence there: the text, the source, the page? Does the last sentence link to the thesis, or does the paragraph simply stop?
A useful test is to read only the first sentence of every paragraph in order. You should get the outline of the argument. If you do not, either the first sentences are weak or the paragraphs are doing more than one job.
Also look for paragraphs where text and inference are blended. If a sentence says what Paul wrote and what you conclude from it in the same breath, separate them (lecture 3-2).
7. Layer four: the sentences
Here you work on clarity. The rules of lecture 4-2 apply: short sentences, the person acting near the verb, no idiom that needs a native ear. Questions for this layer:
- Which sentence did I have to read twice? Can it be split?
- Where did I use a long word when a short one was enough?
- Where did I write "it is believed" or "it can be said"? Who believes it? Who says it?
- Where did I use a term I have not explained?
Here is a short before-and-after. (an invented example)
Before: "It would seem that, in the matter of forgiveness, there is a tendency in the text to which attention has been drawn to emphasise the priority of reconciliation."
After: "In this passage, reconciliation comes first. Jesus tells the offended person to go to his brother before he worries about anything else."
The second version names the agent, uses two sentences, and commits to a claim that can be checked against the text. If you cannot make a sentence clearer, it may be because you are not sure what you mean. That is information. Go back to layer one.
8. Layer five: proof-reading
Only now do you look for errors. Check:
- spelling, especially of names (people, places, books of the Bible);
- the numbers in your references, and that every quotation matches its source;
- that every note has a bibliography entry and the reverse (lecture 5-1);
- that you name the translation of each Bible quotation (lecture 5-2);
- the formatting the assignment asks for, including the word count.
Change how the text looks to you, so that your eye does not slide over what it expects. Print it if you normally read on a screen. Read the last paragraph first, then the one before, and so on backwards, so that you read each paragraph without the story carrying you along. For names and numbers, put a finger under each.
9. Reading aloud, and time away
Two cheap tools help at every layer.
Reading aloud. Your ear finds what your eye forgives. You will stumble where a sentence is too long, where a word is missing, where a link is absent. If you stumble, mark it and go on; fix it after the reading. A student who reads in a second language may find this especially useful, because the ear often notices that a sentence "does not sound like English" before the eye can say why. (Lecture 4-4 says more.)
Time away. If you can, leave the draft for a day before you revise. After a day you read it more like a stranger. You will find that a sentence that seemed clear is not, and a paragraph that seemed weak is better than you thought. If the deadline allows no day, even an hour and a walk helps. This is one reason to start early.
10. What to cut
Cut things that do no work. Some common ones:
- Repetition. Say it once, in the best place. If a sentence adds no information, delete it (the deletion test, lecture 3-1).
- Side paths. An interesting point that does not serve the thesis belongs in another paper. A single footnote may hold it, or you may leave it out.
- Quotations that do no work. If a long quotation only says what you have already said, replace it with a short citation. Keep a quotation when the exact wording is the evidence (lecture 4-3).
- Preparation that never arrives. "In this essay I will first consider several things before turning to others" tells the reader nothing. A route is useful only if it is specific.
- Claims you cannot support. Delete them, or turn them into questions for further study. Lecture 6-4 returns to this.
11. When the draft is short
Students often add words to reach a length. This is the wrong response. A short draft usually means that something is missing, and padding hides it. Ask instead:
- Which reason have I not given? Is there a step in the argument I skipped?
- Which objection have I not stated fairly (lecture 3-3)? What would a careful reader who disagrees say?
- Which text have I not looked at closely? Is there a nearby passage that would test my reading?
- Which term have I used without explaining it?
- Which example would show the point, instead of only asserting it?
These additions make the paper longer because they make it better. If you have honestly asked all these and the paper is still short, then it may be that the question was a small one. Say so and hand in the paper that answers it. Check the assignment: it may say how a short paper is to be treated.
12. Our own faults are the hardest to see
The psalmist's question is a warning. You know what you meant, so you read what you meant. You skip the gap in the argument because your mind fills it. You miss the missing word because you supply it.
That is why the method uses tricks (a reverse outline, reading backwards, reading aloud, time away): each is a way of making the draft strange to you. And it is why, once you have done all you can alone, the next step is a reader. Lecture 6-2 is about that step.
13. A revision plan
Here is a plan for a 3,000-word paper with a week to spare. (an invented example)
| Day | Reading | The one question |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Finish the draft | Have I said what I think? |
| 2 | Rest | (none) |
| 3 | First reading | Does the paper answer the question? |
| 4 | Second reading | What does each part do? Cut and move. |
| 5 | Third reading | Is each paragraph one claim with its evidence? |
| 6 | Fourth reading, aloud | Which sentence trips me? |
| 7 | Final reading, backwards | What have I mis-spelt, mis-numbered, mis-cited? |
If you have less time, keep the order and shorten each step. If you must drop a step, drop the smaller ones last.
Diagram 1. The five layers of revision
핵심 요약
- A first draft shows how far your thinking has come; revision makes the paper match the thinking you have reached.
- Revise from large to small: thesis, structure, paragraphs, sentences, proof-reading.
- Proof-read last, because earlier layers can delete whole paragraphs.
- Use one question per reading, a reverse outline for structure, and reading aloud and time away to see your own draft as a stranger would.
- Cut repetition, side paths and idle quotations. If a draft is short, ask which reason or objection is missing before adding words.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The five layers | Thesis, structure, paragraphs, sentences, proof-reading. |
| Why proof-read last? | Earlier layers may delete the paragraph you corrected. |
| A reverse outline | One line per paragraph saying what it does, made after drafting. |
| When the draft is short | Ask what reason, objection or text is missing before adding any words. |
One sentence to remember Revise the large things first, the small things last, and one question at a time.
This week's action Make a reverse outline of a draft you have, and mark one paragraph to move, cut or strengthen.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- In your own experience of writing, which layer do you usually skip? What would change if you did it?
- Write your thesis in one sentence from memory, without looking. Does it match what the draft argues? What does the difference tell you?
- Make a reverse outline of any piece you have written. Is there a paragraph that does nothing, or a step that is missing?
- What is one thing you tend to over-explain, and one thing you tend to leave out?
- How can you plan your next assignment so that you have a day away from the draft?