무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

FS101E Researching and Writing Theology › 요약으로 복습하기

요약으로 복습하기

FS101E 과목의 강의 31편을 요약만으로 훑어봅니다. 시험 전날에 쓰세요.

제 0 장 Introduction: Honest Reading, Honest Writing

  • Theological writing is not decoration for what I already think; it is reading honestly and then saying only as much as I can support.
  • Three common failures: a topic without a question, reading and opinion run together, and a conclusion larger than the evidence.
  • The Bereans (Acts 17:11) heard, returned to the text and checked: an early picture of theological research.
  • Limiting a claim to its evidence is respect for the reader, not timidity (Proverbs 18:13; Ephesians 4:25).
  • The course teaches no one position and no tricks; each assignment's instructions come first, especially about help from tools or people.
  • Every Practice Lab has three ways in (your own work, the practice topic, a partner) and four rules; no lab form is handed in.
Front Back
The central claim Read Scripture and others honestly; say only as much as you can support.
Three failures No question; reading and opinion mixed; conclusion bigger than evidence.
The Bereans Acts 17:11: they heard, went back to the text daily, and checked.
A lab's four rules Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too.

One sentence to remember A reader is a neighbour: say what you found, say where you found it, and say no more than that.

This week's action Take one thing you have written or plan to write, and say aloud in one sentence the question it is trying to answer.

제 1 장 Week 1: Starting with a Question

  • A topic is an area, a question asks something about it, and a thesis is the answer you can support. The order is always topic, question, thesis.
  • A question chooses what to read, what to leave out, what the reader expects, and when you are finished.
  • Test a question: can it be answered, is it open, is it aimed at a text or source, is it worth asking, is it the right size?
  • Three bad questions are the yes/no question, the question that is too wide, and the question with its answer already inside.
  • Good questions often begin in a snag in reading, a problem in ministry, or an old disagreement.
Front Back
Topic, question, thesis An area; a request for an answer aimed at a text; the answer you can support.
Five tests of a question Answerable, open, aimed at a text or source, worth asking, the right size.
Three bad questions Yes/no; too wide; answer already inside.
Three ways to improve a question Add a place, add a relation, or remove the hidden answer.

One sentence to remember Ask something you can answer from the text, and do not ask what you have already decided.

This week's action Write one topic you care about, then turn it into a question that names a passage or source and passes the five tests.

  • The same topic needs different questions at different lengths. Choose the scope on purpose, not by accident of the deadline.
  • Narrow a question by passage, period, viewpoint or audience. Narrowing makes a question more exact, not vaguer.
  • A thesis is a one-sentence answer that a reader could agree or disagree with. A plan such as "this essay will discuss" is not a thesis.
  • Test a thesis with two questions: so what changes, and who could reasonably disagree?
  • Qualifiers mark the edge of what you can support. A thesis may change as you read, and the honest course is to change it openly.
Front Back
Four ways to narrow By passage, by period, by viewpoint, by audience.
Plan or thesis? "This essay will discuss..." is a plan. A thesis says what you found and can be disputed.
Two tests of a thesis So what changes? Who could disagree?
Why qualifiers? They mark the edge of what you can support, so a claim is small, firm and hard to break.

One sentence to remember Choose a scope you can finish, and a thesis you can defend and still change.

This week's action Write one thesis sentence for your question, test it with the two questions, and keep it as "version 1."

  • Theological writing comes in several kinds: reflection essay, exegetical paper, topical report, case or project report, and essay or thesis. Each asks something different and builds differently.
  • Read the assignment's verbs and limits to find the kind. The assignment wins over this course, and unclear instructions should be asked about.
  • Sermon, testimony and devotional writing are not worse than academic writing. They do a different job, and the mistake is handing one in when another was asked.
  • Readers disagree about how far faith shows in academic writing. This course requires only that you say what you assume and do not present a conviction as a proof.
  • A case or project report needs extra care for the people it describes, because details beyond a name can identify them.
Front Back
Five kinds Reflection essay, exegetical paper, topical report, case or project report, essay or thesis.
How to find the kind Read the assignment's verbs, limits and warnings; ask if unclear.
Sermon, testimony, devotional Different jobs from academic writing, not lesser ones.
Faith in academic writing Say what you assume and what you can show; do not present a conviction as a proof.

One sentence to remember Before you write, say aloud what this reader expects from you.

This week's action Take one real or invented assignment and underline the verbs, limits and warnings. Name the kind it wants.

  • Questions often begin as a small discomfort that is noticed, named and put into words. Four rich sources are Scripture reading, tradition, ministry and other writers.
  • A snag in reading, such as a repeated word or two passages that differ, becomes a question when it names a text and a relation.
  • Turn a ministry problem into a research question by describing it without blame, choosing a bearing text or source, asking to understand before judging, and narrowing.
  • Keep a question log with the date, the snag, the question and its source. The rough entries are the useful ones.
  • Ask who has already asked your question. That saves you from false claims of novelty and gives you a fair account of the other answers.
Front Back
Four sources of questions Scripture reading, tradition, ministry, other writers.
Problem versus research question A problem needs a response; a research question can be answered by reading and thinking.
Question log entry Date, snag, question, and where it came from.
Why ask who asked it already? To avoid false novelty, to learn the other answers, and to sharpen your question.

One sentence to remember A question is often a discomfort that has been named without blame and aimed at a text.

This week's action Start a question log and write three entries from this week's reading or ministry.

  • The lab takes you once along the whole path: topic, three candidate questions, five tests, a chosen question, a scope, and a thesis in draft.
  • There are three ways in: your own piece of writing, the invented practice topic, and the partner's way of explaining aloud and answering questions.
  • Four rules govern the lab: nobody reads your notes, nothing is marked, you may pass on any part, and the leader fills in a sheet too. The form is never handed in.
  • The result is a question better than before and a clear next step, not a finished paper.
  • Running it in a group, ask which test a question misses, never whether it is a good topic, and let each person name one next step.
Front Back
The task Topic, three candidate questions, test them, choose one, set its scope, draft a thesis.
The three ways Your own writing; the invented practice topic; the partner's way, explaining aloud.
The most common repair Add a place (a passage or source) and a relation (how, why, in what way).
The leader's question "Which test does this question miss?", never "Is that a good topic?"

One sentence to remember A question is easiest to see when it stands beside two others.

This week's action Do the lab in one of the three ways, and write down your next step.

제 2 장 Week 2: Reading Well

  • Read the passage first, whole and aloud, with its neighbours, then read what others say about it. If it is too hard, read the neighbouring passages first, and still read the text before any commentary.
  • The three rings are the paragraph, the book and the whole Bible. A connection in the third ring must be shown, not assumed.
  • A kind of writing (narrative, law, poetry, wisdom, prophecy, gospel, letter) changes what a sentence does.
  • Compare translations, mark differences, and name the translation you quote. Readers differ about which kind of translation to trust.
  • Without the original languages you can compare translations and report scholars, but you cannot build a conclusion on one word.
Front Back
The order of reading The text first, then the reading of the text, and a record of which is which.
The three rings The paragraph, the book, the whole Bible.
A kind of writing Narrative, law, poetry, wisdom, prophecy, gospel or letter; it changes what a sentence does.
Without the original languages Compare translations and report scholars; never rest a conclusion on one word.

One sentence to remember Read the passage yourself first, so that you can tell the reader what you saw and what someone else saw.

This week's action Take one short passage, read it aloud twice with its neighbours, and write what you notice and the questions you have before you open any book about it.

  • Primary sources are what you study, secondary sources are writing about them, and tertiary sources collect and summarise.
  • The kind depends on the question. The same work can be primary for one question and secondary for another.
  • Weigh a source by author, publisher, date, use by others, and whether it argues or only asserts. A bold claim needs a strong source.
  • For online sources, record the date read and the full address, and ask the same five questions.
  • For a creed or confession, record the document, the translation and translator or body, the article number and the rights. Look beyond your own language, region and tradition.
Front Back
Primary, secondary, tertiary What you study; writing about it; collections and summaries.
Why the kind depends on the question One work can be the evidence for one question and an opinion for another.
Five questions to weigh a source Author, publisher, date, use by others, argues or only asserts.
A creed in translation: record The document, the translation and translator or body, the article number, the rights.

One sentence to remember A claim is only as strong as the source it stands on, so weigh each source before you lean on it.

This week's action Pick three sources for a question of your own, write down the kind of each and the answer to the five questions, and say which one you would trust most.

  • Read a hard page in two passes: the shape first (title, headings, first sentences), then the detail, paragraph by paragraph.
  • Find the main sentence of each paragraph and write it in your own words; break a long sentence into subject, main verb and extras.
  • Keep a personal glossary that records each term as the author uses it, and mark entries you are unsure of.
  • A translation changes range of meaning, wordplay, technical terms and structure, and always interprets. Cite the translator and edition.
  • A machine-made rendering is not a source, and a translated quotation is checked against its source. The words and argument must be your own; follow the assignment and ask.
Front Back
Two passes The shape first, with no dictionary; then the detail, with a marked main sentence in each paragraph.
A personal glossary Terms recorded as the author uses them, in your own words, with doubts marked.
Citing a translation Original author and title, translator or body, edition, page or section.
A machine-made rendering Not a source: no translator, edition or record. Check translated quotations against the source.

One sentence to remember Read for accuracy, not for speed, and trust only what you have checked against a real source.

This week's action Read one hard page in two passes, mark the main sentence of each paragraph, and write a two-sentence note on the author's claim and evidence.

  • Keep three kinds of note apart and mark each: exact words (Q, with quotation marks and page), summary in your own words (S) and your own reaction (M).
  • Make a source card at the time you read, with author, title, publication details, translator, pages and, for online sources, address and date read.
  • Mark uncertainty with a word such as "check", so that doubt does not become fact in your draft.
  • After reading, write the author's claim in one or two sentences and check that you kept the qualifiers and did not take a view the author was answering.
  • Keep a reading log of what you read, how much, and what you did not.
Front Back
Three kinds of note Exact words with page; a summary in your own words; your own reaction. Each is marked.
A source card Author, title, publication details, translator, pages; for online, address and date read.
Checking a summary Is it the claim and not only the topic? Are the qualifiers kept? Is it the author's view, not the one answered?
A reading log The date, the source, how much you read, and what you did not read.

One sentence to remember If you cannot tell whose words a note holds, you cannot use it honestly.

This week's action Take notes on one article or chapter using the marks Q, S and M, add a source card, and write the author's claim in two sentences.

  • The lab asks you to build a list of ten sources for one question, with kind, strength, use, details kept and one weakness for each.
  • There are three ways in: your own piece of writing, the invented practice topic, and the partner's way of explaining your list aloud.
  • Four rules govern the lab: nobody reads your notes unless you choose, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader writes too.
  • A source list is a working map, not a bibliography. It should say what is missing and mark works not yet read.
  • In a group, ask what a source lets you say and what it does not. Do not state a rule on tools; point to the assignment.
Front Back
The task Build a list of ten sources for one question and weigh each.
The three ways Your own question; the invented practice topic; the partner's aloud way.
A source list is not A bibliography; it is a working map that shows weakness and what is missing.
The leader's question "What does this source let you say, and what does it not?"

One sentence to remember A source list with its weaknesses marked shows you exactly how far your argument can stand.

This week's action Do the lab in one of the three ways, and write down the one weakness in your list that you will try to repair.

제 3 장 Week 3: Building an Argument

  • An argument gives a reader a claim and the reasons for it, so that the reader can weigh them. It is not a quarrel.
  • The four parts are the claim, the reasons, the evidence and the objection.
  • A sentence that only repeats the claim in other words is not a reason.
  • If deleting a sentence loses no information, the sentence is repetition.
  • An argument map shows gaps between a reason and its evidence; fix a gap with more evidence or a smaller claim.
Front Back
The four parts Claim, reasons, evidence, objection.
A restated claim A "reason" that a person who rejects the claim must also reject, only because they reject the claim.
The deletion test Remove a sentence. If the reader has lost nothing, it was repetition.
Two ways to fix a gap Add the missing step with evidence, or make the claim smaller.

One sentence to remember An argument is a set of reasons placed where a reader can check them, offered to answer, not to win.

This week's action Take one paragraph of your own and mark the claim, the reasons and the evidence. Then apply the deletion test.

  • Using Scripture as evidence has three jobs: what the text says, what follows from it, and what I apply.
  • The application is the part on which readers differ most; mark it as your judgement with a phrase such as "on this text I judge".
  • A lifted verse is quoted without regard to speaker, audience, kind of writing and surroundings.
  • A textless principle says "Scripture teaches" and names no passage the reader can check.
  • Narrative, law, poetry, proverb, prophecy, gospel and letter give evidence in different ways; name the kind and the setting in a phrase.
Front Back
The three jobs What the text says; what follows from it; what I apply.
"On this text I judge" A phrase that marks an application as the writer's judgement and names the text it rests on.
Two dangers The lifted verse, taken out of its setting; the textless principle, with no passage named.
A proverb as evidence It gives a general observation about how life commonly goes; it is not a promise or a law.

One sentence to remember Say what the text says, show what follows, and mark what you apply as your own judgement.

This week's action Take one paragraph on Scripture and underline the three jobs in three colours. Rewrite any "the Bible says" that is really an application.

  • State another position in its strongest honest form before you answer it; the test is whether its holders would say, "Yes, that is what we mean."
  • A straw man is a weak copy of a view; an attack on the person answers the speaker and not the argument.
  • Describe a tradition in its own terms and from its own sources, and expect differences inside it.
  • Apply the same standard to your own tradition, including where its reading of a text is contested.
  • Reply by conceding what is right, showing the evidence again and naming the difference in assumptions.
Front Back
The holders' test Would the people who hold this view say, "Yes, that is what we believe, and why"?
Straw man A weak copy of a position, built to be easy to knock down.
Attack on the person Rejecting a view because of who holds it or why, and not on the evidence.
Three moves in a reply Concede what is right; show the evidence again; name the difference in assumptions.

One sentence to remember Say the other side so well that its holders would thank you, and then say where you differ.

This week's action Write the strongest objection to your own claim in two or three sentences, and ask whether its holders would accept your wording.

  • An authority is what a writer appeals to as decisive or weighty when settling a question; a writer should say which one is assumed.
  • Catholic, Orthodox, Reformation, Wesleyan and Pentecostal traditions all treat Scripture as central and differ in how they relate it to church teaching, reason and experience.
  • Readers will not agree here; this course asks only that you state your assumption and show the text and reasons.
  • Rest as much weight as you can on ground any reader can check, and mark where a different assumption would change the answer.
  • Do not rank traditions with words such as "purer" or "more biblical"; if you think one approach is better, argue for it.
Front Back
Authority (in this lecture) What a writer appeals to as decisive or weighty when settling a question of faith or practice.
The writer's three tasks Say what you assume; show the text and reasons; mark where a different assumption changes the answer.
Shared ground Text in a named translation, historical records, how a word is used and the logic of a step: checkable by readers of any tradition.
What the course does not do It does not say which tradition's ordering of authority is correct.

One sentence to remember Say what you stand on, show the reasons, and let a reader who stands elsewhere still follow each step.

This week's action Write one sentence stating the authority you assume in your current piece of writing.

  • The lab asks you to map one argument on one page: claim, reasons, evidence, objection, response and assumed authority.
  • There are three ways in: your own writing, the invented practice argument, and the partner's way of arguing both sides aloud.
  • Four rules apply: nobody reads your notes unless you choose, nothing is marked, you may pass on any part, and the leader fills in a sheet too.
  • A map shows gaps, repeated claims and universal claims with no evidence; the usual fix is more evidence or a smaller claim.
  • In a group, ask "Where is the biggest gap?", never "Whose argument is weakest?"
Front Back
The task Map one argument on one page and find its biggest gap.
The three ways Your own writing; the invented practice argument; the partner's way, arguing both sides aloud.
The usual result The claim becomes smaller and closer to what the evidence supports.
The leader's question "Where is the biggest gap?", never "Whose argument is weakest?"

One sentence to remember A gap you have seen can be mended; a gap you have not seen is one your reader will find first.

This week's action Do the map in one of the three ways, and choose one change to make in your claim or your evidence.

제 4 장 Week 4: Writing It Down

  • An outline is a plan made before the draft. It shows whether you have an argument and gives you a place to return to.
  • The introduction states the question, why it matters, the thesis and the route. The conclusion gathers, says what the result means and where it stops.
  • In the body, each part carries one reason. The strongest objection has its own place.
  • The conclusion brings no new evidence.
  • A sentence outline is better than a topic outline, because a sentence cannot hide a part with no point.
  • Test an outline by removing a part, changing the order, and marking every point you only pretend to know.
Front Back
What an outline is for To show whether you have an argument, to give you a place to return to, and to let you change the order cheaply.
The four jobs of an introduction The question, why it matters, the thesis, and the route.
The rule for the body Each part carries one reason.
The rule for the conclusion Gather, say what it means, say where it stops. Bring no new evidence.

One sentence to remember A reader who has to guess where the argument is going has been failed, and a clear outline is the first way to prevent it.

This week's action Write a sentence outline for a piece of your own writing, or for the practice topic, and test it by removing one part.

  • One paragraph makes one claim, stated in a topic sentence, and the other sentences support it.
  • Read only the first sentences of your paragraphs. They should give the argument of the paper in order.
  • Common faults are no topic sentence, no links, no evidence from the text, and text and inference blended.
  • Plain sentences are short, keep the subject near the verb, prefer the active voice, avoid idiom, and define a technical word once.
  • Hiding the agent ("it is believed") hides the evidence. Name who says it and cite the source.
  • On the writer's voice and inclusive language, follow the assignment, and if it is silent, be consistent.
Front Back
The paragraph rule One paragraph, one claim, stated in the topic sentence.
The first-sentence test Read only the first sentences. They should give the argument in order.
Four plain habits Short sentences; subject near verb; active voice; no idiom.
Why "it is believed" is a fault It hides who believes it, so the evidence cannot be checked.

One sentence to remember Plain style does not make ideas simple. It lets the reader see them and judge them.

This week's action Take one paragraph of your own and rewrite it with a topic sentence, short sentences and no hidden agent.

  • Quotation gives exact words, paraphrase gives a short passage in your own words, and summary gives the main claim in fewer words. All three need a citation.
  • Quote exactly mainly when the wording is the evidence or the thing you analyse, and keep it short.
  • A quotation is evidence, not an argument. Say why you give it before, and what it shows after.
  • A paraphrase is made by reading, closing the book, writing from memory, comparing and citing. Changing a few words is not a paraphrase.
  • A summary keeps the author's claim, strength and qualifiers.
  • Quote a whole Bible verse, copy it exactly, name the translation, and do not build a large conclusion on one word.
Front Back
When to quote exactly When the wording is the evidence, or the wording is what you are analysing.
The paraphrase method Read, close the book, write from memory, compare, cite.
What a summary keeps The author's claim, strength and qualifiers.
The rule for all three Cite, whichever method you use.

One sentence to remember Another writer's words and ideas strengthen your argument only when the reader can see where they begin, where they end, and what they prove.

This week's action Paraphrase one short passage from a source you are using, by the five steps, and cite it.

  • A writer in a second language is not at a disadvantage in the work that matters most: question, reading, fair treatment of others and argument.
  • Plan in the language you think best in if the assignment allows it, and move ideas, not sentences, into English.
  • Write the thesis in one simple English sentence before the rest, and keep a personal glossary.
  • Short sentences are an advantage. Check for common traps: articles, prepositions, tense in summaries and sentences copied from sources.
  • Read aloud, and ask readers about clarity before grammar.
  • On help from tools and other people, schools differ. The words and the argument must be yours; follow the assignment; ask if unsure.
Front Back
First step Plan in the language you think best in, if allowed, and move ideas, not sentences.
Safe base A one-sentence thesis in simple English and a sentence outline.
What to ask a reader first About clarity: the main claim, where they read twice, where they were lost.
The rule on help The words and the argument must be your own. Follow the assignment. Ask if unsure.

One sentence to remember A short sentence that a reader can follow is not a poor sentence; it is in the spirit of 1 Corinthians 14:19.

This week's action Write the thesis of your current work in one simple English sentence, and read it aloud to someone.

  • The lab asks you to build or repair one paragraph: a topic sentence, three supporting sentences with a source each, and a link to the thesis.
  • There are three ways in: your own writing, the invented practice topic, and the partner's way, in which you say the paragraph aloud.
  • Four rules govern the lab: nobody reads your draft, nothing is marked, you may pass on any part, and the leader writes too.
  • Mark each supporting sentence as text or as your inference. A sentence with no source is a guess.
  • The best test of a paragraph is a listener who says back what they understood.
Front Back
The task Build or repair one paragraph, and test it on a listener.
The parts of the form Topic sentence; three supports with sources; a link to the thesis.
The three ways Your own writing; the invented practice topic; the partner's way aloud.
The leader's question "What did you hear as the claim?", never a request to correct or mark.

One sentence to remember If a listener cannot say back your claim, the paragraph is not yet plain, however correct its grammar.

This week's action Build one paragraph on the form, and read it aloud to someone who will tell you what they understood.

제 5 장 Week 5: Honest Sources

  • We cite for two reasons: so the reader can find the source, and so a debt to another writer is acknowledged.
  • A note stands beside the claim and gives the exact place; the bibliography lists the whole work.
  • A reader needs author, title, publication details, page and, for online sources, the address and the date you looked.
  • Follow the assignment's style. If it names none, pick one, say which, and use it throughout.
  • Notes and bibliography must agree. The common errors are a missing page, year or translator and a source listed but not read.
Front Back
Two reasons to cite So the reader can find the source; so a debt to another writer is acknowledged.
Note and bibliography The note gives the exact place beside the claim; the bibliography lists the whole work.
Details every source needs Author, title, place, publisher, year, page, translator or editor; online, the address and the date you looked.
Which style? Follow the assignment; if none, choose one, say which, and keep to it.

One sentence to remember A citation is a route you leave for the reader, and a broken route is as bad as none.

This week's action Take one page of your own writing and check that each note has a page and agrees with your bibliography.

  • A Scripture reference gives book, chapter and verse in one consistent form; the translation is named at the first quotation.
  • Mark any change of translation inside a paper. Check the verse number against the translation you quote.
  • Readers disagree about which kind of translation to use. Name yours and do not build a large conclusion on one word.
  • Quote a whole verse; trimming with ellipses can change what it says.
  • For creeds and ancient authors give the section, the edition and the translator; for a second-hand quotation say which book you saw.
Front Back
A Scripture reference Book, chapter and verse, in one form every time; the translation named.
Changing translation Mark the change at the point you use the second one.
Whole verse Quote it complete; trimming can drop a clause that changes the meaning.
Ancient or creedal text Cite by section, then name the edition or translation and the translator.

One sentence to remember The reader should be able to tell which words you quoted, in which wording, and which book you actually held.

This week's action Look through a piece of your writing and add the translation name wherever a verse is quoted without one.

  • Plagiarism is presenting another's words, ideas, structure or work as your own, whether by copying, by swapping a few words, or by hiding the source.
  • Intention does not remove responsibility for what a paper claims, so habits matter more than good intentions.
  • Put quotation marks and a page in your notes the moment you copy, and write the note as you write the sentence.
  • When in doubt, cite. Never invent data and never list a source you did not read.
  • The words and the argument must be your own; follow the assignment's instructions about tools and help; if unsure, ask.
Front Back
What plagiarism is Presenting another's words, ideas, structure or work as your own, on purpose or by accident.
Why intention does not settle it You answer for what your paper claims; the reader has the same loss either way.
Habits that prevent accidents Quotation marks and page in notes; mark quote, summary and own thought; note as you write.
On tools and help The words and argument are yours; follow the assignment; ask if unsure.

One sentence to remember The words may be yours, but the idea still has an owner, and the reader is owed the name.

This week's action Re-read one page of your own writing and, for each sentence, ask where it came from and whether that is marked.

  • Copyright rules differ by country and by work and they change, so do not assume you know the rule.
  • Four steps: find the rights statement, quote only what you need, name the source, and ask when you plan to publish or share widely.
  • A citation names a source but does not by itself make a copy permitted.
  • A work in the public domain may be copied, but a modern edition of an old text may still be protected.
  • Images, charts, another student's paper and a teacher's lecture need the same care; this is a habit, not legal advice.
Front Back
Why not trust a rule of thumb Copyright rules differ by country and by work, and they change.
The four steps Find the rights statement; quote only what you need; name the source; ask before wide use.
Public domain No one holds the exclusive right to copy; the period varies, and a modern edition of an old text may be protected.
A licence The owner's statement of what you may do and on what conditions, such as attribution.

One sentence to remember Naming a source is honest, but it is not the same as having permission to copy it.

This week's action Find the rights statement in one book or on one website you often use, and read what it allows.

  • The lab follows each claim in one paragraph back to its source, asking where it came from and which page.
  • For every claim record the source, the page, whether the words are exact or paraphrased, the translation and any rights note.
  • A note that exists does not prove the claim is sourced; the page must support the sentence.
  • Write the claim, not the person; a gap you find yourself can be mended before anyone else sees it.
  • Four rules govern the lab: nobody reads your notes, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader writes too.
Front Back
The task Follow each claim in one paragraph back to its source and record what you find.
The three ways Your own paragraph; the invented practice paragraph; the partner's way, aloud.
What the form records Source, page, exact or paraphrased, translation, rights, and the fix needed.
The rule of the form Write the claim, not the person.

One sentence to remember A gap you find in your own paragraph can be mended before anyone else has to find it.

This week's action Do the check on one paragraph of your own, and fix the first gap you find.

제 6 장 Week 6: Revising and Finishing

  • A first draft shows how far your thinking has come; revision makes the paper match the thinking you have reached.
  • Revise from large to small: thesis, structure, paragraphs, sentences, proof-reading.
  • Proof-read last, because earlier layers can delete whole paragraphs.
  • Use one question per reading, a reverse outline for structure, and reading aloud and time away to see your own draft as a stranger would.
  • Cut repetition, side paths and idle quotations. If a draft is short, ask which reason or objection is missing before adding words.
Front Back
The five layers Thesis, structure, paragraphs, sentences, proof-reading.
Why proof-read last? Earlier layers may delete the paragraph you corrected.
A reverse outline One line per paragraph saying what it does, made after drafting.
When the draft is short Ask what reason, objection or text is missing before adding any words.

One sentence to remember Revise the large things first, the small things last, and one question at a time.

This week's action Make a reverse outline of a draft you have, and mark one paragraph to move, cut or strengthen.

  • Feedback is a reader's report of what happened in the reading. It is not a verdict on the writer.
  • To give it, point to the place, describe your experience, ask a question and name what works.
  • A reader stays within what was asked, speaks of the text and not the person, does not rewrite it, and does not repeat what was read.
  • To receive it, listen to the end, ask, thank, wait a day and decide. If two readers stumble in one place, there is probably a real problem there.
  • You may decline advice, but you should be able to give your reason. The assignment decides how much help is allowed.
Front Back
Feedback versus verdict Feedback reports a reading and leaves the writer something to do; a verdict only judges.
The four moves of a reader Point to the place; describe your experience; ask; name what works.
The five steps of a writer Listen to the end; ask; thank; wait; decide.
Two readers, one place A sign that the text has a real problem there.

One sentence to remember A reader reports what happened in the reading, and the writer decides what to do about it.

This week's action Ask one person to read a page of your writing, give them one specific question, and write down what you will and will not change.

  • Use a real case only if the paper needs it. If a general description or a published source makes the point, leave the person out.
  • A changed name is not enough. Age, work, place, church, time and circumstances can identify a person.
  • Choose honestly: leave it out, change it enough, obtain free consent, or present a labelled composite.
  • Never present an invented case as real, and say in the paper what kind of case it is.
  • Take extra care with children and vulnerable people. Safeguarding duties differ by country, so follow the assignment and your community's policy. This is not legal advice.
Front Back
A name is not enough Age, work, place, church, time and circumstances can identify a person.
Four honest options Leave it out; change it enough; free consent, stated; a labelled composite.
Invented cases Always labelled; never presented as real.
Duties to report or protect They differ by country and community; know your policy and follow the assignment.

One sentence to remember Say only as much about a person as you have the right to tell, and say plainly what kind of case you are using.

This week's action Find your community's safeguarding or confidentiality policy, or ask a leader where it is kept, and read it once.

  • Every claim has a size, and the evidence must match it: no bigger, and no smaller.
  • Words such as all, always, never, clearly, the church and scholars should make you ask whether you have shown the claim.
  • Accurate hedging is firm where the evidence is strong and careful where it is not. Evasive hedging hides the claim.
  • Say what you did not check and what the paper does not cover. Do not take your own setting for the whole world.
  • Humility about interpretation means giving your best reading, saying that others read differently, and leaving room to be shown wrong.
Front Back
The right size No bigger than the evidence, and no smaller.
Accurate hedging Firm where the evidence is strong, careful where it is not.
A limits statement A short note saying what you did not check and what the paper does not cover.
"People today" A claim about vast numbers; name the place and the group you actually know.

One sentence to remember Claim what your evidence can carry, and tell the reader where it stops.

This week's action Underline every claim in a draft, write its evidence in the margin, and shrink, support or cut each one that has none.

  • The lab has two parts: a final check to run before handing in, and a one-page research plan to start the next piece.
  • The final check has six groups: question, thesis, structure, sources, honesty and confidentiality. Each "no" gets one thing to do.
  • The plan has a question, a thesis in draft, three sources and an outline. It may change, and the change should be written down.
  • There are three ways in: your own writing, the practice topic, or the partner's way, speaking the plan aloud.
  • Four rules hold: nobody reads your notes, nothing is marked, you may pass, and the leader writes too. Nothing is handed in.
Front Back
The six groups of the final check Question, thesis, structure, sources, honesty, confidentiality.
The four parts of the plan A question, a thesis in draft, three sources, an outline.
Why a plan may change Reading teaches you; the plan makes the change visible.
The leader's care Keep real names out of the room and let anyone pass.

One sentence to remember Check the finished paper against the whole path, and start the next one with a plan you are willing to change.

This week's action Fill in the research plan for your next assignment and say it aloud to one person.