Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
- Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
- Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
- Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
- Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
- Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
- Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
- Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
- Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
- Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
- Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
- Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
- Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
- Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
- Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
- Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
- Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
- Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
- Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
Most writing that goes wrong goes wrong early. The writer starts with a word, such as "forgiveness" or "prayer" or "the Trinity", and begins to write down everything that comes to mind. After three pages the writer has many true sentences and no direction. The reader cannot tell what the paper is trying to do, and often the writer cannot tell either.
The cure is not more effort. It is a different first step. Before you write, you decide what you are asking. This lecture separates three things that beginners often mix together: a topic, a question and a thesis. It gives five tests for a good question, three kinds of bad question, and a short account of where good questions come from.
This is the first lecture of the whole course, so it is the place to state the idea that every later lecture returns to:
Theological writing is not decoration for what I already think. It is reading Scripture and other people honestly and then saying only as much as I can support.
A good question is where that honesty begins. If I already know my answer and only want to dress it up, I do not have a question. If I ask something I cannot answer from the text and the sources I can reach, I will have to pretend. A good question keeps me honest because it can be answered, and because I might be wrong.
One note before we start. Every assignment for this school comes with its own instructions. Those instructions always come first. If an assignment gives you the question, then you do not need to invent one, but you still need to understand it, narrow it and answer it, and everything in this lecture helps with that. Where this course and an assignment differ, follow the assignment.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- Tell a topic, a question and a thesis apart, and give an example of each.
- Apply five tests to a question: answerable, open, aimed at a text or source, worth asking, and the right size.
- Recognise three kinds of bad question: the yes/no question, the question that is too wide, and the question with its answer already inside.
- Name common places where good questions start.
- Rewrite a weak question into a stronger one.
Now these were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of the mind, examining the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so." — Acts 17:11
World English Bible
He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13
WEB
it seemed good to me also, having traced the course of all things accurately from the first, to write to you in order, most excellent Theophilus;" — Luke 1:3
WEB
The people in Berea are praised because they tested a message by going back to the text, "to see whether these things were so." That is a question: is this so? They did not start with a conclusion and look for decoration. Proverbs describes the opposite habit, an answer given before the person has heard. A writer who knows the answer before reading has done exactly that. In Luke, the writer says he has "traced the course of all things accurately" before he writes "in order." Careful tracing comes first, and orderly writing follows it.
These verses do not tell us how to format a paper. They give us an attitude: examine, listen first, trace carefully. Good questions come from that attitude.
1. Three words that are not the same
Here are three words that sound alike and do different jobs.
A topic is an area. "Forgiveness" is a topic. "The " is a topic. "Prayer in the Psalms" is a topic. A topic tells the reader where you will be standing. It does not tell the reader what you will do there.
A question is a request for an answer. It has a shape that a topic does not have: it can be answered, and it points at something to look at. "How does Matthew 18 connect forgiveness with the discipline of a church?" is a question. It names a text, it asks about a relation inside that text, and it expects an answer that can be shown.
A thesis is the answer you can support. It is a sentence that claims something. "In Matthew 18, forgiveness and discipline are not two rival rules but two parts of one aim, which is to win back the brother who has sinned" is a thesis. A reader could agree or disagree with it, and you can point to reasons.
The order is always the same: topic, then question, then thesis. A topic does not become a paper by being made longer. It becomes a paper when you ask something about it and then answer.
(The Matthew 18 sentences above are invented samples of how a question and a thesis are shaped. They are not offered as the right reading of the chapter. That is for a writer to work out from the text.)
A simple way to remember the difference:
- A topic says, "I will talk about this."
- A question says, "I want to find out this."
- A thesis says, "Here is what I found, and here is why."
2. Why the question matters more than it seems
A question does four jobs at once.
First, it chooses what to read. If you ask how Matthew 18 connects forgiveness and discipline, you know what to read: Matthew 18, its neighbours, and a few careful sources on those verses. If you only have the topic "forgiveness", you could read for a year.
Second, it chooses what to leave out. Every true thing that is not an answer to your question can stay out. This is a relief to many writers. You are not required to say everything.
Third, it tells the reader what to expect. A reader who meets the question early reads each paragraph as part of an answer.
Fourth, it tells you when you are finished. You are finished when the question has been answered, and not when the page count is reached. This matters most when you are tired.
3. Five tests of a good question
When you have a question, run it through five tests. A question does not need to be perfect on the first day. The tests show you what to repair.
1. Can it be answered? Some questions are real and important but cannot be answered from anything you can reach. "What was Paul thinking on the road to Damascus?" asks about a mind we cannot open. The text gives us some things that Paul later said, and we can ask about those. We cannot ask for the whole mind. If you cannot name the kind of evidence that would help, the question is not yet answerable for you.
2. Is it open? An open question has more than one reasonable answer before you begin. If everyone already agrees on the answer, you are reporting, not arguing. If the question can be answered with one word from a dictionary, it is closed. A question may be open for you and closed for a specialist, and that is acceptable in a course. What matters is that you do not know the answer in advance.
3. Is it aimed at a text or a source? In this school, theological writing usually works on something: a passage, a creed, a document, a writer's argument. A question that floats free of any text invites opinion. A question that is aimed at something gives you a place to stand and a thing the reader can check.
4. Is it worth asking? This does not mean it must change the world. It means someone could care about the answer: the writer, a congregation, a student of the passage, a reader who has met the same puzzle. If you cannot say why anyone would want the answer, ask yourself what snagged you in the first place.
5. Is it the right size? A question must fit the time and the words you have. The next lecture is entirely about this. For now, one rule of thumb: if you can think of three different papers inside your question, it is probably too wide.
4. Three bad questions
Three kinds of question look fine and cause trouble.
The yes/no question. "Is forgiveness important in the Gospels?" The answer is yes, and then there is nothing more to say. A yes/no question can sometimes be rescued by turning it into "how" or "in what way" or "under what conditions". "In what ways does Matthew's Gospel treat forgiveness as a duty and in what ways as a gift?" is more useful.
The question that is too wide. "What does the Bible teach about the church?" is a library, not a question. No one could answer it in a short paper, and a long one would only list. The remedy is to narrow it to a passage, a period, a viewpoint or an audience. The next lecture shows how.
The question with its answer already inside. "Why is my own church's way of choosing leaders the only one that fits the New Testament?" or "Why did the other side in this old debate fail to see the obvious?" (Both are invented examples.) These questions assume the conclusion. They tell the reader what the writer decided before reading. Notice that the problem is not the opinion. A person may hold a firm view and still ask a fair question. The problem is that the question cannot be answered any other way, so it is not a question. A fairer form asks what the reasons are: "What reasons do Christians give for and against baptising infants, and what are the strongest texts each side uses?"
This third kind is the hardest to see in your own writing, because your own view feels like plain fact. One test: could a thoughtful person who disagrees with you accept the question as fair? If not, rewrite it until they could.
5. Three examples taken apart
Here are three invented questions, each tested. (All three are invented examples.)
Example A: "Prayer." This is a topic, not a question. It fails tests 1, 2, 3 and 5 at once.
Example B: "Does God answer prayer?" It is a question, but it is a yes/no question, it is very wide, and it is not aimed at any text. Many readers would also say they already know the answer. It is open only in a loose sense.
Example C: "What does the parable of the persistent widow in Luke 18:1-8 ask of those who pray, according to the way Luke introduces it in verse 1?" This is answerable from a short text. It is open, since readers differ on what the parable asks. It is aimed at a passage and at Luke's own framing. It is worth asking for anyone who has wondered how long to keep praying. It is small enough for a short paper.
You will notice that Example C is longer. That is common. A good question usually takes more words than a topic, because it has to say what it is looking at and what it wants to know.
6. Question, then thesis
Once you have read and thought, you will have an answer. That answer is your thesis. In Example C a possible thesis might be: "Luke tells the reader before the parable that Jesus told it to show that people must always pray and not give up, so the parable asks for steady trust and not for a technique of pleading." (An invented thesis, to show the form.)
Do not write the thesis first and then look for support. That makes the question a decoration on a decision you took earlier, which is the thing the central claim warns against. Write the question, read, and let the thesis form. It may change as you read. That is not failure. The next lecture says more about this.
7. Where good questions come from
Good questions seldom arrive from nowhere. Lecture 1-4 goes into this in detail and adds a fourth source (the claims of other writers). Here are three of the most common, so you can watch for them.
A snag in reading. You are reading a passage and something does not fit: a repeated word, an odd order, a verse that seems to contradict another. The snag is a question waiting to be put into words.
A problem in ministry. A person in your community is grieving, or a group quarrels, or a young person asks something you cannot answer. The problem is real, but a problem is not yet a research question. It has to be turned into one, without turning it into a complaint.
An old disagreement. Christians have disagreed about many things for many centuries. A disagreement is a ready-made question: why do these readers differ, and what do their reasons show? Starting here also protects you from the idea that your question is new and no one has ever asked it.
If you have none of these in front of you, begin with the snag. Read a short passage slowly and write down every place where you hesitate.
8. Rewriting a weak question
Here are two invented before-and-after samples. (Both are invented examples.)
Before: "Why did the early church fail to keep unity?" This assumes a failure, assumes there was a unity, and is far too wide. It also has its answer partly inside.
After: "In Acts 15:1-2, what question causes the dispute, and how does the church decide to deal with it?" This points at a short passage. It does not assume the conclusion. It can be answered by reading the text.
Before: "What does Scripture say about money?" This is a topic with a question mark.
After: "What reason does Paul give in 2 Corinthians 8 and 9 for the Corinthians to give, and how does he avoid commanding them?" It names a text and a relation inside it. It can be answered from the text. It is open, since readers differ about how Paul does it.
A change that improves a question almost always does one of three things. It adds a place (a passage or source), it adds a relation (how, why, in what way) or it removes a hidden answer.
9. A short note on honesty
Before you settle on a question, ask yourself privately: do I want to know the answer, or do I want to defend something? Both are honest wishes, and a paper can serve either. But they are different, and the reader should be told which one you are doing. If you want to defend a view, a good question still helps, because it makes you ask what the strongest objection is and whether your reasons answer it. The question holds you to the evidence, whichever wish started you.
Diagram 1. From topic to thesis
핵심 요약
- A topic is an area, a question asks something about it, and a thesis is the answer you can support. The order is always topic, question, thesis.
- A question chooses what to read, what to leave out, what the reader expects, and when you are finished.
- Test a question: can it be answered, is it open, is it aimed at a text or source, is it worth asking, is it the right size?
- Three bad questions are the yes/no question, the question that is too wide, and the question with its answer already inside.
- Good questions often begin in a snag in reading, a problem in ministry, or an old disagreement.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Topic, question, thesis | An area; a request for an answer aimed at a text; the answer you can support. |
| Five tests of a question | Answerable, open, aimed at a text or source, worth asking, the right size. |
| Three bad questions | Yes/no; too wide; answer already inside. |
| Three ways to improve a question | Add a place, add a relation, or remove the hidden answer. |
One sentence to remember Ask something you can answer from the text, and do not ask what you have already decided.
This week's action Write one topic you care about, then turn it into a question that names a passage or source and passes the five tests.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of a topic you have wanted to write about. What would the question be if you had to put it in one sentence that names a text or source?
- Which of the three bad questions do you think you are most likely to write? Why?
- Acts 17:11 praises people who examined the Scriptures "to see whether these things were so." What would it look like to bring that attitude to a question you care about deeply?
- Take the invented question "What does Scripture say about money?" and rewrite it in two different ways, each pointing at a different passage.
- Is there a question in your own tradition that readers have disagreed about for a long time? What would a fair way to ask it look like?