Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
- Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
- Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
- Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
- Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
- Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
- Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
- Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
- Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
- Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
- Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
- Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
- Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
- Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
- Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
- Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
- Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
- Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
- Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
Reading well is not finished when you close the book. A week later you will remember that something was said, and you will not remember whether it was the author's words, your summary or your own idea. If you then write it down as it comes to mind, you may put another writer's words under your name without meaning to, or give an author a claim the author never made.
A record of reading prevents this. It does not need to be complicated. It needs to keep three things apart, to carry the details of each source, and to be honest about what you did not read.
This lecture shows a simple system. It is the practical heart of the week's rule: read the text first, then the reading of the text, and keep a record of which is which. It also serves the central claim of the course. You can only say as much as you can support if you know what you have, where it came from and how sure you are.
이 16분으로 얻는 것
- Keep exact words, summary and your own reaction apart, and mark each.
- Write a source card with the details a reader will need.
- Mark what you are unsure of, so that doubt does not turn into certainty.
- Write an author's claim in one or two sentences and check it for missing qualifiers.
- Keep a reading log that says what you read and what you did not.
But Mary kept all these sayings, pondering them in her heart." — Luke 2:19
World English Bible
Furthermore, my son, be admonished: of making many books there is no end; and much study is a weariness of the flesh." — Ecclesiastes 12:12
WEB
Luke 2:19 describes two actions together: Mary "kept" what she heard, and she "pondered" it. A record of reading has the same two parts, keeping and thinking, and they should not be confused. Ecclesiastes 12:12 admits something every reader feels: there are more books than anyone can read. A careful record does not pretend otherwise. It says what you read and where your reading stopped.
1. Three things, kept apart
Every note you take is one of three kinds. The first task of a good record is to know which.
1. Exact words. You copy the author's words exactly, put them in quotation marks, and write the page number. If a quotation runs across two pages, mark where the page changes. If you leave out a word, show it. If you add a word of your own for clarity, put it in square brackets. Copy slowly and check once against the page.
2. A summary in your own words. You close the book, or look away, and write what the author said in your own sentences. Mark it clearly as a summary, with the page or pages it covers. A summary is shorter than the original and keeps the author's claim and strength. (Lecture 4-3 develops this.)
3. Your own reaction. This is what you think about it: a question, a doubt, a link to another source, an objection, an idea of your own. Mark it as your own, and keep it apart from the other two kinds.
A simple way to mark them is a letter at the start of each note. Use whatever letters you will remember.
- Q for a quotation, then the page.
- S for a summary, then the page.
- M for "mine", your own reaction.
(An invented example of a page of notes. The source is plainly fictitious.)
Source: A. Example, An Invented Study of Letters (Nowhere: Imaginary Press, 2000).
- Q (p. 14): "The letter was read aloud to the whole assembly before it was copied."
- S (pp. 14–15): The author says that letters were first heard and only later copied. He gives this as the reason for their repeated phrases.
- M: If this is right, the repeated phrases in my passage may be there for the ear. I should check whether he shows this or only says it.
When you return to this page in a month, you will know at a glance which line is the author's own voice, which is a report of it and which is yours.
2. The source card
For every source you use, make a card, or a page at the top of your notes, with the details a reader will need. Do this at the time you read, not later. A missing page or date is very hard to recover.
Record:
- Author (or editor), full name.
- Title, and the title of the larger work if you read a chapter or an article.
- Publication details: place, publisher, year, and the edition if it is not the first.
- Translator, if you read a translation, and the original title if you know it.
- Page numbers for each note you take.
- For an online source: the full address and the date you read it.
A simple form with placeholders looks like this:
Author, *Title* (Place: Publisher, Year).
The style your assignment asks for will arrange these pieces in a certain order. You do not need to learn the order now. You need to have the pieces. Lecture 5-1 shows how they are arranged.
3. Mark what you are unsure of
Uncertainty is information, and it is lost quickly if you do not write it down. Use a mark such as a question mark, or the word "check", whenever:
- you are not sure that you copied a quotation exactly;
- you are not sure that you understood a sentence;
- you are not sure that a page number is right;
- you think the author may be overstating, but have not checked;
- you took a note from a second-hand report and did not see the original.
(An invented example.) "S (p. 22): The author says the practice began in the second century. Check: is this his claim, or the claim he is repeating from another writer?"
A mark like this costs one word. Without it, the doubt becomes a fact in your draft.
4. After reading: the author's claim in one or two sentences
When you finish an article or a chapter, close it and write what the author is claiming, in one or two sentences, from memory. Then open it again and check yourself. Two questions help.
- Have I got the claim, or only the topic? "The author writes about the council's decision" is a topic. "The author argues that the council's decision was a judgement of principle, not a compromise" is a claim.
- Have I kept the qualifiers? Authors choose small words with care: often, in most cases, probably, in this period, for the letters of this group. A summary that drops them makes the author sound bolder than the author was.
(An invented example.) The author wrote: "In the sources we have, the practice appears to have been widespread in this region by the end of the century." The student's note says: "The practice was widespread by the end of the century." The note has dropped "to have been," which marks the claim as an inference, and "in this region," which limits it. The corrected note keeps both.
5. Do not give an author the view the author was arguing against
A common error in notes is to record a view that the author set out in order to refute it. Writers often state an opposing position first, in its strongest form, and then answer it. If you take notes in the middle of such a passage, you may write down the opposing view as the author's own.
(An invented example.) The invented author writes: "Some readers hold that the letter was meant only for private use. This view has real support in the opening lines. It cannot explain, however, the instruction to read it to the whole assembly." The note "The author thinks the letter was for private use" is wrong. The author states that view, gives it credit and then shows what it cannot explain. The right note is: "The author considers the view that the letter was private, grants that the opening lines support it, and rejects it because of the instruction to read it aloud."
A habit that guards against this error is to read to the end of the paragraph, and to the end of the section, before you write down what the author thinks.
6. A reading log
A reading log is a simple list kept over weeks. For each source, write:
- the date;
- the source, in short form;
- how much you read: the whole, a chapter, a few pages, or only the introduction and conclusion;
- whether you took notes.
The log is useful for two reasons. First, it shows you what you have used and what you have not. When you write your list of sources later, you will not be tempted to list a book you only looked at. Lecture 5-3 explains why listing a source you did not read is dishonest. Second, it lets you say, honestly, what your reading covered. "I read the first three chapters and the conclusion, and I did not read the section on later history" is a true sentence, and it tells your reader how far your claim can go. It echoes Ecclesiastes: no one finishes the books, so say what you did.
A reading log also helps with the questions of the next lecture and of Week 5. Everything that reaches your final page has a line in your log.
7. Keeping it light
Some students do not keep a record because they imagine it must be elaborate. It does not. A notebook, a folder of sheets or a plain file on your device is enough, and so is a stack of cards. What matters is the three marks, the source details and the habit of writing them at the time. If you keep the system small, you will keep it.
Diagram 1. A page of notes: three kinds, three marks
핵심 요약
- Keep three kinds of note apart and mark each: exact words (Q, with quotation marks and page), summary in your own words (S) and your own reaction (M).
- Make a source card at the time you read, with author, title, publication details, translator, pages and, for online sources, address and date read.
- Mark uncertainty with a word such as "check", so that doubt does not become fact in your draft.
- After reading, write the author's claim in one or two sentences and check that you kept the qualifiers and did not take a view the author was answering.
- Keep a reading log of what you read, how much, and what you did not.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three kinds of note | Exact words with page; a summary in your own words; your own reaction. Each is marked. |
| A source card | Author, title, publication details, translator, pages; for online, address and date read. |
| Checking a summary | Is it the claim and not only the topic? Are the qualifiers kept? Is it the author's view, not the one answered? |
| A reading log | The date, the source, how much you read, and what you did not read. |
One sentence to remember If you cannot tell whose words a note holds, you cannot use it honestly.
This week's action Take notes on one article or chapter using the marks Q, S and M, add a source card, and write the author's claim in two sentences.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- In your last piece of writing, could you tell for each idea whether it was a quotation, a summary or your own thought? What would have helped?
- Which details on a source card are hardest for you to keep? What would you change in your habits?
- Think of a time when you remembered a claim more strongly than the author stated it. What small words might have been lost?
- Why is it a mistake to record, as an author's view, a position that the author set out in order to answer?
- What would an honest reading log of your last project have said about what you did not read?