무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

FS101E Researching and Writing Theology

Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test

목차 31
FS101E Researching and Writing Theology
제 0 장 · Introduction: Honest Reading, Honest Writing
  1. Introduction: Honest Reading, Honest Writing
제 1 장 · Week 1: Starting with a Question
  1. Lecture 1-1: Topic, Question and Thesis
  2. Lecture 1-2: Scope and the Thesis Test
  3. Lecture 1-3: Kinds of Theological Writing
  4. Lecture 1-4: Where Questions Come From
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: From Topic to Question
제 2 장 · Week 2: Reading Well
  1. Lecture 2-1: Reading Scripture Before Reading About It
  2. Lecture 2-2: Kinds of Sources and How to Weigh Them
  3. Lecture 2-3: Reading in a Second Language and in Translation
  4. Lecture 2-4: Keeping a Record of Your Reading
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Build a Source List
제 3 장 · Week 3: Building an Argument
  1. Lecture 3-1: Claim, Reason, Evidence and Objection
  2. Lecture 3-2: Using Scripture as Evidence
  3. Lecture 3-3: Treating Other Positions Fairly
  4. Lecture 3-4: Where Readers Disagree: Authority and Method
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Map an Argument
제 4 장 · Week 4: Writing It Down
  1. Lecture 4-1: Outlines and Structure
  2. Lecture 4-2: Paragraphs and Plain Style
  3. Lecture 4-3: Quoting, Summarising and Paraphrasing
  4. Lecture 4-4: Writing in a Second Language
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Draft Paragraph
제 5 장 · Week 5: Honest Sources
  1. Lecture 5-1: Footnotes and Bibliographies
  2. Lecture 5-2: Citing Scripture and Ancient Sources
  3. Lecture 5-3: Plagiarism and Academic Honesty
  4. Lecture 5-4: Copyright, Permission and the Public Domain
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Check Your Sources
제 6 장 · Week 6: Revising and Finishing
  1. Lecture 6-1: Revising in Layers
  2. Lecture 6-2: Giving and Receiving Feedback
  3. Lecture 6-3: Case Studies, Confidentiality and Care
  4. Lecture 6-4: Claims the Right Size
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: Final Check and Research Plan

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

22분

A good question can still be the wrong size. "How does Matthew 18 connect forgiveness and the discipline of a church?" is a fair question. In 1,000 words it needs a very short treatment. In 8,000 words it needs a different one. If you do not decide the size, the size will be decided by the deadline, and usually at the worst moment.

This lecture is about scope: how much ground your piece of writing will cover. It shows how the same topic looks at two different lengths, and four ways to narrow a question: by passage, by period, by viewpoint and by audience. Then it turns to the thesis, the one-sentence answer to your question. It gives two tests for a thesis ("so what changes?" and "who could disagree?"), explains why a plan is not a thesis, shows how a qualifier can make a thesis stronger, and says why a thesis is allowed to change while you read.

Scope and thesis belong together. A thesis can only be supported if the scope is small enough to support it. And a thesis you cannot say in one sentence is usually a sign that the scope or the question is still unclear.

The central claim of the course applies here in a plain way. Saying "only as much as I can support" means choosing a scope that you can actually cover with the sources and the time you have.

As always, the assignment comes first. If it gives a word limit, a set passage or a required kind of paper, those decisions are made for you, and this lecture helps you work inside them.

이 22분으로 얻는 것

  • Explain how the same topic is treated differently at 1,000 words and at 8,000 words.
  • Narrow a question by passage, period, viewpoint or audience.
  • Write a thesis in one sentence and test it with "so what changes?" and "who could disagree?".
  • Explain why "this essay will discuss" is a plan and not a thesis.
  • Say why a thesis may change as you read, and what to do when it does.

For which of you, desiring to build a tower, doesn’t first sit down and count the cost, to see if he has enough to complete it?" — Luke 14:28

World English Bible

Or perhaps, when he has laid a foundation, and is not able to finish, everyone who sees begins to mock him," — Luke 14:29

WEB

saying, ‘This man began to build, and wasn’t able to finish.’" — Luke 14:30

WEB

Furthermore, my son, be admonished: of making many books there is no end; and much study is a weariness of the flesh." — Ecclesiastes 12:12

WEB

In its own setting, the saying about the tower is about the cost of following Jesus, and this lecture does not claim that it is about writing. But it describes a common human situation: a person begins a large work without counting what it will take. A writer who starts an eight-page question with a two-page plan knows this situation. The lesson we may take is a modest one, an ordinary piece of wisdom about work: count the cost first.

Ecclesiastes says that there is no end to making books. For a writer, that means there is always more to read, and no one reads everything. A scope is a decision about where to stop reading and start writing, and this verse reminds us that the decision is unavoidable.

1. The same topic at two lengths

Take one topic: forgiveness in Matthew's Gospel. Here is what it looks like at two sizes. (Both outlines are invented examples, to show how size changes the work.)

At 1,000 words you have room for one passage and one question. You might ask, "In the parable of the unforgiving servant (Matthew 18:21-35), what reason does the king give for the servant to have forgiven?" You would read the parable, read what comes just before and after, give a short answer and stop. You would not discuss the Lord's Prayer, or the cross, or what other Gospels say. You would not survey scholars.

At 8,000 words you have room for a pattern. You could ask, "How does Matthew connect God's forgiveness of us with our forgiveness of one another, in the Lord's Prayer, the parable of the unforgiving servant and the teaching on a brother who sins?" You would read three passages, set them side by side, ask how each treats the link, and look at what several careful readers have said. You would need an introduction that explains the question, a part for each passage, a part that gathers what they show, and a conclusion.

The topic is the same. The questions are different, the sources are different, and the thesis would be different. A writer who tries to give the 8,000-word treatment in 1,000 words produces a list of remarks. A writer who tries to stretch the 1,000-word question to 8,000 words produces repetition. Neither writer has done anything wrong in effort. The mistake is in the size.

2. Four ways to narrow

When a question is too wide, there are four ordinary ways to make it smaller. Often you will use two together.

By passage. Choose one chapter, one parable, one letter, one psalm. "What does Paul say about the law?" becomes "What does Paul say about the law in Galatians 3:19-25?" A passage gives you a text that you can read in full and that the reader can check.

By period. Choose a time. "How have Christians understood the Lord's Supper?" becomes "How did the writers of the fourth century describe what happens at the Lord's Supper?" A period gives you a set of writers who were speaking to similar questions.

By viewpoint. Choose a person, a tradition or a school, and ask what it says in its own terms. "What do Christians believe about the Spirit?" becomes "How does one named confession describe the work of the Spirit in its own article on the subject?" A viewpoint gives you a voice to report fairly, and the reader knows whose view it is.

By audience. Choose who is asking, or who the text first spoke to. "How should Christians handle conflict?" becomes "What does Matthew 18 ask of a small community in which one member has wronged another?" Or, for a ministry question: "What does the teaching on forgiveness in the Lord's Prayer offer to a congregation that has just come through a bitter quarrel?" An audience gives you a situation to keep in view.

None of these four makes the question smaller by making it vaguer. Each makes it smaller by making it more exact. If narrowing leaves you with a question that is hard to say clearly, you have probably removed the aim instead of reducing the size.

3. How to tell whether the size is right

Try three checks.

The reading check. Can you read the main sources, whole, in the time you have? If the answer is no, the question is too wide, or you need fewer sources.

The paragraph check. Can you list the parts of the answer and give each part about a paragraph or a few paragraphs? If you would need thirty paragraphs for a 1,000-word piece, the question is too wide. If you would have only two paragraphs for 5,000 words, it is too narrow, or you have not yet found the objections and the alternative readings.

The sentence check. Can you say what your paper is about in one sentence? If you cannot, the scope is still loose. Try the sentence: "In this paper I ask ______ in ______, and I argue ______." If the blanks will not fill, that is useful information. It tells you where to work.

If a piece is short of words after you have answered the question, do not pad. Ask what reasons, objections or alternative readings are missing. Lecture 6-1 says more about this.

4. What a thesis is

A thesis is your answer to the question, stated in a sentence a reader could agree or disagree with. It is not the topic. It is not the question with the question mark removed. It is not a list of things you will mention.

Here is a plain test. Put the words "I claim that" in front of your sentence. If it still makes sense, it is probably a thesis. If it reads strangely, it is probably a topic or a plan.

  • "I claim that forgiveness" is not a sentence.
  • "I claim that this essay will discuss forgiveness in Matthew" is a sentence, but it is a statement about the essay and not about Matthew.
  • "I claim that in Matthew 18:21-35 the king's mercy comes first and is the reason the servant is expected to show mercy" is a thesis. (An invented example, offered to show the form and not as a verdict on the passage.)

5. A plan is not a thesis

The most common false thesis is a plan. "In this essay I will discuss the meaning of baptism and look at what several traditions say" is a plan. It tells the reader what will happen. It does not tell the reader what you found.

A plan can be useful in an introduction, after the thesis, to show the route. But it cannot stand in the thesis's place. Compare these two. (Both are invented examples.)

Weak: "This essay will discuss how Luke presents the Holy Spirit in the book of Acts."

Stronger: "In Acts, Luke presents the Spirit most often as the power that carries the message across new boundaries, and less often as a gift to the individual believer."

The first tells the reader what the essay touches. The second tells the reader what the writer thinks Luke does, and the writer can now be asked for evidence. The second is also more risky. That risk is what makes it worth reading.

6. Two tests of a thesis

Once you have a sentence, test it twice.

Test 1: So what changes? If your thesis is true, what is different? A good thesis changes something: how a passage should be read, how two positions relate, what a community might do, what a reader should look for. If nothing changes, the thesis may be correct and still not worth a paper. "Matthew 18 is about forgiveness" is correct, and nothing changes.

Test 2: Who could disagree? Name a real person or a real group of readers who could reasonably say "I do not think so." If you cannot, your sentence may be too obvious, or you may not yet know the other readings. If you can, you have found your first objection, and you can begin to treat it fairly. (Lecture 3-3 is about this.) Name them as they would name themselves, without a judging word.

Here is an invented thesis taken through both tests. (An invented example.)

"Luke 14:28-30 shows that Jesus asks his hearers to count the cost before following him."

So what changes? Not much. This is a restatement of what the verses say on their surface. Who could disagree? No one. The sentence passes neither test.

"In Luke 14, the sayings about the tower and the king come after a saying about hating family and carrying a cross and before a saying about giving up all possessions, so that the counting of cost is a call to look at what takes away, and not a call to calculate whether discipleship is a good bargain."

So what changes? How a reader hears the sayings: not as advice to be cautious, but as a statement of what is at stake. Who could disagree? A reader who thinks the sayings are mainly about prudence could disagree, and could point to the wording. The second sentence passes both tests. It may or may not be right. That is the point of a thesis: it can be tested.

7. Qualifiers make a thesis stronger

A beginner may think that a firm thesis must be a loud one: "Paul always teaches…", "The early church never…", "It is clear that all…". But a loud claim is usually a weak one, because it is easy to break with a single counter-example.

A qualifier is a small word or phrase that limits the claim to what you can support: "in this letter", "most often", "in the passages examined here", "at least in the second century". A qualifier is not a retreat. It marks the exact edge of what you know.

(Invented examples.)

Loud: "Paul never speaks of works in a positive way." Qualified: "In Galatians, Paul speaks of works of the law in a negative way, and he uses the word in a different sense when he speaks of the believer's life."

The second claim is smaller and stronger. A reader who knows one other passage cannot break it with a single example. The reader will also see that you know where the edges are.

Use qualifiers where you are unsure, and drop them where you are sure. Too many hedges make a thesis soft, and too few make it brittle. Lecture 6-4 returns to this.

8. A thesis may change as you read

You write a thesis early, so that you have something to test. You will probably change it. That is a sign that you read honestly.

Suppose you begin with the thesis that the king's mercy in Matthew 18 is the reason for the servant's duty to forgive. You read more, and discover that the text puts the reason in a different place than you thought. You can then do one of three things: change the thesis, narrow it, or keep it and explain what the text does not show. What you may not do is keep the old sentence and quietly ignore what you found. That is the opposite of the attitude the course recommends.

It helps to keep the old version. Write at the top of your notes: "Thesis, version 1", and put the date. Later, you will be able to see how your thinking moved. This record also helps when you explain your work to another reader.

9. An example taken from start to finish

Here is one invented journey. (All stages are invented examples.)

  • Topic: the Lord's Prayer.
  • First question: "What does the Lord's Prayer teach?" (Too wide. Answerable only by a list.)
  • Narrowed by passage: "What does the request about daily bread in Matthew 6:11 mean?" (Better. A single line. But perhaps too small for 3,000 words.)
  • Narrowed by passage and relation: "How do the requests for bread, forgiveness and rescue in Matthew 6:11-13 fit together as a group, and what does the order suggest?" (A passage, a relation, and room for different readings.)
  • First thesis: "The three requests are a movement from physical need to moral need to spiritual danger." (Tested: who could disagree? A reader who thinks the three belong together for other reasons.)
  • After reading: "The three requests are linked by the word 'us', so that the group asks for a shared life and not for individual benefit." (A different thesis, qualified: "in this text".)

The question and the thesis moved together. The writer ended up with a piece that could be written in the time available, with a claim that could be tested.


Diagram 1. Narrowing a question, and testing a thesis

Scope and the Thesis Test Make the question the right size, then test the sentence that answers it Too wide (invented): "What does the Bible teach about forgiveness?" PASSAGE One parable, one chapter, one letter Matthew 18:21-35 PERIOD A time and its writers The fourth century VIEWPOINT A person or a tradition, in its own terms AUDIENCE Who asks, or who the text first spoke to Right size (invented): "In Matthew 18:21-35, what reason does the king give for the servant to forgive?" TWO TESTS OF A THESIS So what changes if it is true? Who could reasonably disagree? No answer to either: look again. A PLAN IS NOT A THESIS "This essay will discuss..." tells what the essay touches, not what the writer found. Qualifiers mark the edge of what you can support. A thesis may change as you read.

핵심 요약

  • The same topic needs different questions at different lengths. Choose the scope on purpose, not by accident of the deadline.
  • Narrow a question by passage, period, viewpoint or audience. Narrowing makes a question more exact, not vaguer.
  • A thesis is a one-sentence answer that a reader could agree or disagree with. A plan such as "this essay will discuss" is not a thesis.
  • Test a thesis with two questions: so what changes, and who could reasonably disagree?
  • Qualifiers mark the edge of what you can support. A thesis may change as you read, and the honest course is to change it openly.
Front Back
Four ways to narrow By passage, by period, by viewpoint, by audience.
Plan or thesis? "This essay will discuss..." is a plan. A thesis says what you found and can be disputed.
Two tests of a thesis So what changes? Who could disagree?
Why qualifiers? They mark the edge of what you can support, so a claim is small, firm and hard to break.

One sentence to remember Choose a scope you can finish, and a thesis you can defend and still change.

This week's action Write one thesis sentence for your question, test it with the two questions, and keep it as "version 1."

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Think of a piece you have written or must write. What word count do you have? Does your question fit that count by the paragraph check?
  • Take a wide question from your own interests and narrow it in two different ways, for example by passage and then by audience. Which version would you rather write?
  • Write a thesis for a question of your own. Then ask, "So what changes?" and "Who could disagree?" What did you learn?
  • Have you ever kept a conclusion after you found evidence that did not fit it? What would it have cost to change?
  • The tower saying in Luke 14 speaks of counting the cost. What does it cost to write a short, narrow piece well, and what does it cost to write a wide one badly?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.