Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
After the early centuries, the conversation between faith and philosophy went on for a thousand years. This lecture follows two of its great moments. The first is Augustine, in the fourth and fifth centuries, who used the Platonist tradition he knew and taught that faith and understanding go together. The second is the Middle Ages in the West, when a great body of Aristotle's writing became available again in Latin, and when Thomas Aquinas, in the thirteenth century, worked out how reason and faith might fit. Along the way we meet Anselm, who is closely linked with the phrase faith seeking understanding, and we note, briefly, the different stress of the Eastern church on mystery.
The lecture describes. It does not decide which tradition got the balance right. It names points where the sources are clear and leaves out what we cannot say with certainty.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- Say in a few sentences how Augustine used the Platonist tradition and how he linked faith and understanding.
- Explain what Anselm meant by faith seeking understanding, in plain words.
- Describe how Aristotle's writings came into the medieval West and what Aquinas did with them.
- Explain the difference between natural theology and revealed theology, with an everyday example.
- Describe, fairly and in outline, the Eastern emphasis on mystery and the negative way, and name one way later writers criticised scholasticism.
because that which is known of God is revealed in them, for God revealed it to them." — Romans 1:19
World English Bible
For the invisible things of him since the creation of the world are clearly seen, being perceived through the things that are made, even his everlasting power and divinity; that they may be without excuse." — Romans 1:20
WEB
The heavens declare the glory of God. The expanse shows his handiwork." — Psalm 19:1
WEB
What the text says. Psalm 19:1 says that the heavens speak of God's glory, as a craftsman's work shows the craftsman. Romans 1:19-20 says that something of God is plain to people through what has been made, and that this leaves them without excuse. The same chapter goes on to speak of people who suppress the truth.
A tradition's reading. Catholic teaching has long read these verses as showing that human reason, by looking at creation, can know that God exists and something of what God is like. Many Protestant writers, including many in the Reformed streams, have also read them as speaking of a real knowledge of God given in creation, though they often add that sin darkens how people use this knowledge. Some Protestant writers stress the second half of Romans 1 more, and say that the verses show people's guilt more than their ability. Orthodox writers read them within the broader teaching that creation shows God's glory but that God remains beyond what creation can tell.
Our judgement. These verses do not by themselves settle how far human reason can go toward God. They are read in several ways, and they do not describe a philosophical argument. We use them here only because the long tradition from Augustine to Aquinas appealed to them when it asked what reason could know of God.
1. Augustine and the Platonist tradition
Augustine (354 to 430) was a bishop in North Africa, and one of the most widely read Christian writers in the Western church. Before he became a Christian, he had been a teacher of rhetoric, and had spent years looking for answers to hard questions: What is God? Where does evil come from? Can the mind know anything for sure? In his own telling, certain writings of the Platonists, philosophers in the tradition that follows Plato, helped him. They gave him a way to think of God as something that is not a body, and not located in space, and they helped him with the question of evil. These are matters he reported about himself, and writers differ about how much he owed to Platonism, and how much he changed what he took.
Two things can be said safely. First, Augustine used the language and ideas of this tradition freely in his own work, and a great deal of later Western theology is shaped by that use. Second, he was also clear that no school of philosophy could bring a person to Christ. What he found in Platonist books, he said, stopped short of what the gospel says about the Word becoming flesh and about God's grace. So he borrowed, and he also drew a line.
Augustine also held that faith and understanding go together. In general terms, he taught that a person comes to faith first, trusting what is taught, and that understanding then grows, so that the believer sees better what she has trusted. In turn, understanding strengthens faith. This is not "believe without thinking", and it is not "think until you are sure and then believe". It is a rhythm in which each helps the other. Faith, here, means trust in God and in what God has made known; understanding means seeing how things fit and why.
An everyday picture. A traveller trusts a map before she has walked the road. As she walks, the map begins to make sense: she sees the river it shows and the hill it marks. Her walking does not make the map true, but it lets her understand it, and her trust in it grows. Augustine's idea is a little like that. The picture is only a picture, and Augustine himself would have said more.
2. Anselm: faith seeking understanding
Anselm (late eleventh and early twelfth century) was a monk and later Archbishop of Canterbury. The phrase faith seeking understanding is linked with him, and it was the original working title of one of his short books. In his writing he takes the stance of a believer who does not doubt God, and who yet wants to see, as far as the mind can, why what he believes is so. His method was a prayerful kind of reasoning: he began in worship and thanks, and the reasoning followed.
We will meet one of Anselm's arguments, the ontological argument, in week 3. Here it is enough to say that Anselm did not offer his reasoning as a proof for sceptics. He was a believer thinking inside the faith, and writing for other believers who wished to understand more. Later readers have argued about how to take his work, and some take it more as a defence to outsiders than he himself seems to have meant.
3. Aristotle comes West
For several centuries, much of what Western Europeans knew of Greek philosophy came from a few books, including some by Plato's followers. In the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, a large number of writings by Aristotle, a Greek philosopher of the fourth century before Christ, were translated into Latin and spread through the new universities. Many of these translations came by way of Arabic, and Jewish and Muslim scholars had written commentaries on Aristotle that Christian scholars also read. This was a major event. Aristotle wrote on logic, nature, the soul, being and ethics, and he did so in a very thorough and organised way. For scholars of the time it was like being handed a whole new set of instruments.
The arrival of Aristotle caused both excitement and alarm. Some of his ideas seemed hard to square with Christian teaching. For example, some readers took him to hold that the world had no beginning, and that seemed to conflict with creation. Teachers argued, and church authorities at times placed limits on what could be taught in the schools. The question was not only intellectual; it was also about who had the right to say how far study could go. After some decades, however, Aristotle became a standard part of the university course, and Christian teachers learned to use his logic and his analysis of things and causes in their own work.
4. Aquinas: reason and faith
Thomas Aquinas (about 1225 to 1274) was a friar and a university teacher. His largest work, the Summa Theologiae, sets out Christian teaching in order, and it uses the language and method of Aristotle throughout. Aquinas did not accept everything in Aristotle, and he did not put Aristotle in the place of revelation. He took what he judged true and useful, and he rejected what he judged contrary to the faith.
One of his central ideas is that truth is one. God is the author of the world that reason studies and also of the revelation that faith receives. So, he held, what is truly known by reason and what is truly given by revelation cannot finally contradict each other. If they seem to, something has been misunderstood on one side or the other. In very general terms, this is the idea of harmony between faith and reason. Aquinas also said that reason has a limit: some truths about God, such as the , are known only because God has made them known. A short way to put it, which many later writers have used, is that grace does not destroy nature but completes it.
From this follows a distinction that is still used today.
- Natural theology is what can be known about God by reason alone, from creation and from the human mind, without relying on the Bible or the church's teaching. Example: a person looks at the order of the world and reasons that there must be a cause behind it.
- Revealed theology is what can be known about God only because God has made it known, in Scripture and in Christ. Example: that God became a human being in Jesus is not something a person could reason out from looking at the stars.
On this view the two work together. Natural theology reaches some truths, and revealed theology reaches more, and does not cancel the first.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Whether natural theology is possible, and how much it can do, has been disputed in all the churches. The Catholic tradition has taught that reason, rightly used, can know that God exists and something of God's nature, and it counts this as a real gift. The strongest argument for this is that Scripture itself, in Romans 1 and Psalm 19, speaks of a knowledge of God from creation. The weak point is that this knowledge, in history, seems to have been uncertain and mixed with error, and that people have drawn very different conclusions from the same world. Some Protestant writers, especially some in the Reformed and Lutheran streams, have been cautious. They accept that creation shows God, but they hold that human reason, damaged by sin, cannot be trusted to get from there to the God of the gospel without revelation. The strongest argument for caution is that sin affects the mind as well as the will. The weak point is that it may seem to leave no common ground to speak with people who do not share the faith, and may sit uneasily with Romans 1. Other Protestants and many Orthodox writers fall between these positions or in other places, so that "the Catholic view" and "the Protestant view" are not neat blocks. This course does not require you to pick a side. It asks you to state each fairly and name its weak point.
5. The Eastern stress on mystery
The story told so far is mostly a Western one. The Eastern church, with its own history, took a somewhat different emphasis. Eastern writers have used the tools of Greek thought skilfully, as the Cappadocians did in the fourth century. But they have often stressed that God is beyond everything the mind can grasp, and that knowing God is first of all a matter of worship, prayer and life in the church, not of argument. Because of this, Eastern teachers have valued what is called the negative way: saying what God is not (not limited, not changing, not made) as a safeguard against thinking we have God in a definition. We take this up in week 4. Orthodox writers themselves would say far more about it than a short lecture can, and some of them would say that the contrast between "Eastern" and "Western" is too sharp. We offer only the sure point: mystery and the negative way are central in the Eastern tradition's way of speaking of God.
6. Later questions, foreshadowed
The great medieval synthesis did not satisfy everyone, then or later. Some late medieval thinkers pressed hard on how much reason can show about God, and asked whether the careful systems of the schools claimed more than they could know. In the sixteenth century, the Reformers would raise sharp questions about the way reason had been used in the schools. We take this up in lecture 1-4. For now, it is enough to see that the tradition from Augustine to Aquinas gave a strong answer to the question of how faith and reason fit, and that the answer was never the only one.
Diagram 1. From Augustine to Aquinas
핵심 요약
- Augustine used the Platonist tradition freely, held that no school of philosophy could bring a person to Christ, and taught that faith and understanding go together.
- Anselm is linked with the phrase faith seeking understanding: a believer who reasons within the faith to see better what is believed.
- In the twelfth and thirteenth centuries many writings of Aristotle came into Latin, and caused both excitement and alarm.
- Aquinas held that truth is one, so reason and revelation cannot finally contradict each other; he distinguished natural from revealed theology.
- Readers disagree about how far natural theology can go; the strongest forms and weak points of each side can be stated fairly.
- The Eastern tradition stresses mystery and the negative way, and the medieval synthesis was not the only answer.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Augustine | Borrowed from the Platonists, drew a line at what the gospel alone says, and held that faith and understanding go together. |
| Faith seeking understanding | A believer, trusting God, reasons within the faith to see better what is believed; linked with Anselm. |
| Natural and revealed theology | What reason can know of God from creation, and what is known only because God has made it known. |
| Eastern emphasis | Mystery, worship and the negative way: saying what God is not as a safeguard against a neat definition. |
One sentence to remember From Augustine to Aquinas, the church used reason inside faith, held that truth is one, and never agreed on exactly how far reason can go.
This week's action Write one sentence of your own that gives an example of natural theology and one that gives an example of revealed theology.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- How did Augustine both borrow from the Platonists and draw a line? Why did he think no school could bring a person to Christ?
- What does faith seeking understanding mean? How is it different from "believe without thinking"?
- Why did the arrival of Aristotle cause both excitement and alarm in the medieval West?
- Give your own example of natural theology and of revealed theology. What would be lost if only one existed?
- In the paragraph on natural theology, what is the strongest argument and what is the weak point of each side? Which would be hardest for you to state fairly?