무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil

Lecture 6-2: Ways of Answering: Free Will, Soul-Making and More

목차 31
STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
제 1 장 · Week 1: Philosophy and Theology: A Long Conversation
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
  2. Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
  3. Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
  4. Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
제 2 장 · Week 2: Knowing: Epistemology
  1. Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
  2. Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
  3. Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
  4. Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
제 3 장 · Week 3: Being: Metaphysics
  1. Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
  2. Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
  3. Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
  4. Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
제 4 장 · Week 4: Language: How We Speak of God
  1. Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
  2. Lecture 4-2: Analogy
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
  4. Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
제 5 장 · Week 5: Reading and Writing Arguments
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
  2. Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
  3. Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
  4. Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
제 6 장 · Week 6: Evil, and the Place of Philosophy
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Problem of Evil, Stated Fairly
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ways of Answering: Free Will, Soul-Making and More
  3. Lecture 6-3: Against Theodicy, and the Cross
  4. Lecture 6-4: Neither Enemy nor Servant: Putting the Course Together
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Philosophy and My Theology on One Page

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

24분

Lecture 6-1 stated the problem of evil. This lecture sets out some of the main ways that Christian thinkers have answered it. We treat them as exercises in reading arguments, not as a menu from which the student must choose, and not as a strategy for winning a debate. Each answer sees something real, and each has a weak point that its own friends admit. Each has also been felt, by some people, to be a comfort and, by others, to be a wound. We shall try to describe each one as the people who hold it would describe it.

Four answers are set out: the free-will defence, the soul-making idea, the view of evil as a lack of good, and, in one sentence, a process-theology response. Then the lecture describes the emphases of the Catholic and Orthodox traditions as far as we can be sure of them, and gives one paragraph on where readers will not agree. As in lecture 6-1, this is a chapter about arguments. If any part of it touches a loss of your own, you may skip it and return later.

이 24분으로 얻는 것

  • State the free-will defence, with its strength and its weak point.
  • State the soul-making idea (the Irenaean tradition), with its strength and its weak point.
  • Explain in your own words the idea of evil as a lack of good.
  • Say which kind of evil, moral or natural, each answer speaks to best.
  • State fairly the points on which readers disagree, and give the weak point of each answer.

As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good, to bring to pass, as it is this day, to save many people alive." — Genesis 50:20

World English Bible

We know that all things work together for good for those who love God, to those who are called according to his purpose." — Romans 8:28

WEB

What the text says. In Genesis 50:20 Joseph speaks to the brothers who had sold him. Their act was meant for evil, and God turned it toward the saving of many people. Joseph does not say that the act was good, and he does not say that the brothers were not responsible. Romans 8:28 says that for those who love God all things work together for good. A tradition's reading. Many readers have taken these verses to say that God can bring good out of evil, without causing the evil. Translations and readers differ on how to read the opening of Romans 8:28 (who or what it is that "works"), and the verse is spoken to a particular community in a particular situation. Our judgement. These verses are sometimes used as a quick answer to anyone who suffers. That is a misuse. Neither verse says that every evil is good, that every evil has a reason that we can see, or that a sufferer should feel that it is. They say that God's purpose is not defeated by evil. Neither verse is a proof text for any one philosophical answer in this lecture.

1. How to read an answer to evil

Every answer to the problem of evil is an attempt to question one of the premises of lecture 6-1, usually premise 4: a good being who could stop evil would stop it. The answer says: perhaps there is a good that could not be had without allowing the possibility of evil, or perhaps evil is not what it looks like. When you read an answer, ask four things.

  1. What good does it say God is aiming at?
  2. Which kind of evil, moral or natural, does it speak to best?
  3. Is it a defence (it could be so) or a (it is so)?
  4. What is its weak point, as its friends would admit it?

2. The free-will defence

This is the most widely discussed answer. Its root is old, and it is often linked in Christian history with Augustine and the Augustinian tradition, but it has been given a careful modern form by philosophers, among them Alvin Plantinga. We set out only the general idea.

The idea is this. Free will here means the ability to choose between real options, in such a way that the choice is truly one's own. God wishes to create beings who can love, trust and do good freely, and love that is forced is not love. But a being who can freely choose the good can also choose the bad. So a world with free creatures who love is a world in which evil could happen. God is not the author of the bad choice; the creature is. A familiar example is a parent who gives a teenager the freedom to make real decisions. The parent knows that this freedom may be used badly, but the other choice, to control every step, would stop the child from growing up into a person who loves by choice.

Notice what the free-will defence is trying to do in the terms of lecture 6-1. It aims to show that the claims "God is all-good and all-powerful" and "there is evil" are not contradictory, because it might be that a world with free creatures is better than a world without them, even with the risk. As a defence, it needs to say only that this is possible.

Its strength. It takes human responsibility seriously. It speaks directly to moral evil: cruelty and injustice are the misuse of a real gift. And it fits a view of persons as more than puppets, a view that many believers and many non-believers share.

Its weak point. Three weak points are usually named, and its friends admit them. First, it speaks best to moral evil. It is much harder to see how the freedom of creatures explains an earthquake or a disease. Some defenders reply that natural evils may be connected to the choices of other free beings (some traditions speak of fallen powers, or of a fallen creation), but this reply asks the reader to accept more, and many do not. Second, a critic asks whether the amount of evil that freedom allows is worth the good of the freedom: is a free choice for good really worth the suffering of the innocent victim of a free choice for evil? Third, a critic asks whether God could have made free creatures who always freely choose the good, and, if so, why did God not do so? Defenders reply with arguments about what freedom is, and this is a technical debate, which we leave to further reading.

A further point: traditions differ over what freedom is, and these differences matter here. Some Reformed and Lutheran writers hold that God's sovereignty is such that the picture of free will in the defence needs care. Some Catholic, Orthodox and Arminian writers stress human freedom more strongly. We will not decide this. We note only that the free-will defence, in the form given above, does not claim to be the only Christian answer, and Christians who have a different view of freedom have answered in other ways.

3. Soul-making: the Irenaean tradition

A second answer begins from a different picture of what God is doing with human beings. It is often linked with the early Christian writer Irenaeus, and for that reason is called the Irenaean tradition (one need not follow the details of what Irenaeus himself said, which is a matter for historians). A modern philosopher, John Hick, set out a form of this idea at length. We give the idea only.

The idea is that the world is not a finished paradise that went wrong, but a place in which persons are grown. On this view God did not make human beings complete, but as beings who are able to grow in goodness, love, courage and trust, through real challenge and real choice. For that kind of growth, a world is needed in which there are real dangers, real needs and real losses. A world with no pain would be a world with no courage, no compassion, and no deep love, because there would be nothing to be brave about and no one to comfort. The name for it is soul-making: the world is a place for the making of souls. Think of a parent who knows that a child who is never allowed to struggle will not learn to walk. The picture is that suffering can be, though it is not always, the setting in which the best in human beings grows.

Its strength. It does speak to natural evil as well as moral evil: a world with real dangers is needed for the growth it describes. It also gives a hopeful picture of the human story, as a story of growth toward God, and it takes seriously that people do sometimes grow through hardship.

Its weak point. It faces a hard and often voiced objection: much suffering does not seem to build anyone up. Some suffering crushes, and some ends a life before it has begun to grow, as when a very young child dies. Some people are broken by pain and not made. Defenders reply in different ways. Some say that the story does not end in this life, so that the growth may continue beyond death; others say that the good of the world as a whole is meant, and not a good for each person at each moment. Critics say that these replies make the answer depend on things we cannot see. A second weak point: many readers feel that to tell a suffering person that their pain is for their growth is cruel. This is not an objection to the argument as a defence, but it is an objection to its use, and we return to it in lecture 6-3. A third: some Christians feel the picture of a world made imperfect so that persons may grow sits uneasily with the biblical story of a good creation that was spoiled. Defenders of the Irenaean view reply that it is a way of reading that story, not a rejection of it. Readers differ.

4. Evil as a lack of good

A third idea is older still and goes back at least to Augustine, and many later Catholic and Orthodox writers have used a form of it. We give the idea.

The idea is that evil is not a thing that God made, like a stone or a tree, but a lack or loss of some good that ought to be there. (The old word for this is privation.) A familiar example is blindness. Blindness is not a thing in the eye. It is the absence of sight where sight should be. Or consider a hole in a coat: the hole is not made of anything. It is a lack of cloth. In the same way, the idea says, cruelty is a lack of love in a will, sickness is a lack of health in a body, and so on. If this is right, then God did not create evil, because evil is not a created thing; it is what happens when a good thing falls short.

Its strength. It protects the goodness of creation: everything God made is good, and evil is a spoiling of the good, not a rival creation. It also fits the way we speak, since we recognise evil by what is missing.

Its weak point. A critic replies that this changes the way we speak but does not remove the problem. A lack of good can hurt terribly, and a hole in a coat does not scream. If God allowed or made a creation in which such lacks can happen, we may still ask why. Another critic says that pain is something real and present, not just an absence, and that the idea seems to ignore it. Defenders reply that the idea is meant to explain what evil is, not to explain why God allows it; it is a piece in a larger answer, not a whole answer. Readers differ about whether it helps at all with the problem as stated.

5. A process response, in one sentence

Some theologians in the process tradition, which holds that God and the world are in a shared and changing relationship, answer that God does not have the power to prevent all evil by force but works by persuasion, so that the premise "all-powerful" is understood differently. Readers differ strongly on this view, and many Christian traditions do not accept it, because they hold that God's power is not limited in that way.

6. Catholic and Orthodox emphases

We say only what we are sure of, and the traditions are large.

Catholic teaching has used both the free-will defence and the idea of evil as a lack of good, with a strong stress on God's goodness in creation and on human freedom. Within it there is also a long tradition of holding that God's ways are not fully known to us, and that suffering has been given meaning by Christ's own suffering. Catholic thinkers hold different views on how far a human argument can explain evil, and some have been wary of any theodicy that claims too much.

Orthodox Christianity has also valued the idea that evil is not a created thing, and it puts great weight on the freedom of the person, on the reality of death as an enemy that Christ has defeated, and on the mystery of God's ways. Orthodox writers often prefer to speak of the problem in terms of death, healing and the life of the church, rather than as a question to be settled by an argument. An Orthodox reader would say more than is said here.

7. Where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree: how far any argument can answer the problem of evil, and which answer is the best. Some hold that the free-will defence, or a larger version of it joined with other ideas, answers the problem well enough for an honest believer to hold the faith with a clear mind. In its strongest form, this view says that the argument only needs to show that evil and God are compatible, that this has been done, and that what remains is a matter of trust and not of logic. Others hold that no answer works, or that each works only against a weaker form of the question, and that the honest path is to say so and to hold faith in the face of an unanswered question. In their strongest form, they say that the evidence of terrible suffering is real, that the answers rely on possibilities nobody can check, and that faith should not pretend. A third group holds that the answers are best used together, each speaking to a different part of the question: freedom for moral evil, a lack of good for what evil is, growth for some suffering, and the mystery of God's ways for what is left.

The weak point of the first view is that showing that something is possible may not touch the force of the question as people actually feel it; possible is not probable, and a defence does not speak to the evidential form. The weak point of the second is that it can seem to treat the believer's trust as having no reasons at all, and that it must say what trust is based on. The weak point of the third is that it can seem to gather answers like tools in a box, without asking whether they fit together, and a critic may say that a list of partial answers does not add up to an answer. This course requires that you can state each of the three fairly and name its weak point. It does not require you to choose, and it neither urges nor forbids any of them.

8. What the answers do not do

It is worth saying what none of these answers does. None of them tells a person why a particular evil happened to them. They are general arguments about whether God and evil can both be real; they are not explanations of any one life. Used on a person who suffers, they can wound. In lecture 6-3 we turn to this.


Diagram 1. Four answers, side by side

Four ways of answering Each sees something; each has a weak point its friends admit Free-will defence Love must be free, so evil is possible. Strength: speaks to moral evil. Weak point: natural evil is harder; is the cost of freedom too high? Linked with the Augustinian tradition. Soul-making The world is a place for persons to grow. Strength: speaks to natural evil too. Weak point: pain often crushes, and some lives end before growth begins. Linked with the Irenaean tradition. Evil as a lack of good Evil is a loss, like blindness, not a thing. Strength: creation stays good. Weak point: a lack can hurt terribly; it says what evil is, not why allowed. Used in Catholic and Orthodox writing. What none of them does None explains why one person suffers. They ask whether God and evil can both be real, in general. Used on a sufferer, an answer can wound. See lecture 6-3. Ask of each: what good? which evil? defence or theodicy? what weak point?

핵심 요약

  • Each answer to evil questions a premise of the argument; ask what good it aims at, which evil it speaks to, whether it is a defence, and its weak point.
  • The free-will defence says that free love makes evil possible; it speaks best to moral evil and finds natural evil harder.
  • Soul-making, in the Irenaean tradition, pictures the world as a place where persons grow; it faces the objection that much pain crushes.
  • Evil as a lack of good keeps creation good, but says what evil is, not why God allows it.
  • Catholic and Orthodox writers have used these ideas with their own emphases, and often stress mystery; readers differ on whether any argument answers the problem.
  • None of these answers explains why a particular person suffers, and used on a sufferer they can wound.
Front Back
Free-will defence Love must be free, so evil is possible; strong for moral evil, weaker for natural evil.
Soul-making The world is a place for growth of persons (Irenaean tradition); objection: much pain crushes.
Evil as a lack of good Evil is a loss of good, like blindness; it keeps creation good but does not say why evil is allowed.
Questions to ask of an answer What good? Which evil? Defence or theodicy? What weak point?

One sentence to remember Each answer to evil sees something real and has a weak point; none explains why one person suffers.

This week's action Choose one answer, write it fairly in four sentences, and add its weak point in one sentence.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • State the free-will defence in your own words, using one everyday example. Which kind of evil does it explain best, and which does it leave harder?
  • Why might the soul-making idea comfort one reader and hurt another? What does the objection that much pain crushes people add?
  • What is meant by calling evil a lack of good? Does the example of blindness help, or does it mislead?
  • Why do Genesis 50:20 and Romans 8:28 not work as quick answers to anyone who suffers? What do they say, and what do they not say?
  • Take the three views in the paragraph where readers will not agree. State each so that someone who holds it would say, "Yes, that is what I mean", and name its weak point.
  • Why do these answers not explain why one person suffers?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.