Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Over the centuries, thinkers have offered arguments that try to lead from something we can observe or think about to the existence of God. These arguments are a classic exercise in reading an argument. They are not a strategy for winning a debate, and this lecture does not treat them as one. The training of the Christian who defends the faith to outsiders belongs to the course on Christian apologetics. Here the aim is smaller and plainer: to see how each family of argument is built, what it does well, where it is questioned, and what a believer may do with it.
We set out four families (ontological, cosmological, design and moral), each as premises and a conclusion, with one strength, one objection and one reply. We name Aquinas's five ways by idea only. We then ask what such an argument can and cannot show, what it is for in the life of a believer, and how Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox writers have judged it.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Set out each of the four families of argument as premises and a conclusion in your own words.
- Give one strength, one objection and one reply for each family.
- Explain what such arguments can show and what they cannot, and name three things an argument may be for a believer.
- Describe in general terms how Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox writers have differed in their judgement of natural theology.
- Say how this lecture's use of the arguments differs from the work of apologetics.
The fool has said in his heart, “There is no God.” They are corrupt. They have done abominable works. There is no one who does good." — Psalms 14:1
World English Bible
For the invisible things of him since the creation of the world are clearly seen, being perceived through the things that are made, even his everlasting power and divinity; that they may be without excuse." — Romans 1:20
WEB
When I consider your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and the stars, which you have ordained;" — Psalms 8:3
WEB
what is man, that you think of him? What is the son of man, that you care for him?" — Psalms 8:4
WEB
What the text says: Psalm 14 speaks of a fool who says in his heart that there is no God, and goes on to describe corrupt deeds. In the Old Testament wisdom language, a fool is one who lives as if God did not matter; the verse is not about a person who has examined an argument. Romans 1:20 says that God's power and divinity can be perceived through what he made. Psalm 8 looks at the night sky and is moved to wonder, and to a question about human beings. A tradition's reading: Catholic teaching has read Romans 1:20 as saying that God can be known from created things by human reason; many Protestant writers have read it as saying that people see something of God in creation and fail to honour him, while differing over what reason can then do. Orthodox writers also read creation as pointing to its maker, and often stress that the knowledge of God is received in worship and life. Our judgement: none of these verses is a premise in a philosophical argument. They speak of wonder and of responsibility. Psalm 14:1 must never be used to call a doubter foolish. It is a poem about a way of living, and a sincere doubter is not what the psalm is about.
1. Why read these arguments at all?
A student of theology will hear arguments for God's existence often: in a book, in a sermon, from a questioner. It helps to know how they are built. Reading an argument well is a skill, and these are good practice because they have been examined by thousands of careful people. Each of the four has a long line of defenders and critics. A fair reader describes both.
An argument here means a chain of reasons: some premises (the starting statements) and a conclusion (what is said to follow). We look at each argument in this form. We keep to short statements and a few famous names. Where a thinker is named, we give "there is an argument that" and not the whole of what he or she held.
2. The ontological argument
The name ontological comes from a Greek word for being. This argument tries to reason from the very idea of God, without looking at the world at all.
There is an argument, associated with Anselm, a medieval archbishop of Canterbury, that goes roughly like this.
- God is a being so great that nothing greater can be thought.
- A being that exists only in the mind is less great than one that also exists in reality.
- So if God existed only in the mind, we could think of something greater, which contradicts the first premise.
- So God exists in reality.
Strength. It is short, it starts from an idea that many believers share, and it has fascinated careful thinkers for nearly a thousand years. Objection. A monk named Gaunilo, a contemporary of Anselm, replied that the same kind of reasoning would seem to prove that a perfect island exists, which is absurd; the form of the argument, he said, must be faulty. Later, Kant argued that existence is not a quality that can make a thing greater, in the way that being kind or wise can. Reply. Defenders say that God is not like an island: an island may be greater or lesser, but a being than which nothing greater can be thought is a special case, and the argument applies to that one only. Some modern thinkers have reworked the argument in the language of what is necessary and possible, and they remain in debate with their critics.
3. The cosmological argument
The name comes from a Greek word for the world. This family starts from the fact that there is a world, or from some general feature of it, and asks what explains it.
Here is a simple form of one version.
- Some things exist that need not have existed (they are contingent; see lecture 3-2).
- A contingent thing needs something else to explain why it exists.
- A chain of such explanations cannot go on explaining nothing: somewhere there must be something that does not itself need an outside explanation.
- That something is what we call God.
There are different versions. One, developed in medieval Islamic thought and used later by Christians, argues that the world began and so needs a cause that began it. Another, associated with Aquinas and found in other writers, is about sustaining causes, as in lecture 3-2. Another, associated with the seventeenth-century philosopher Leibniz, rests on the principle that everything must have a sufficient reason.
Strength. It begins from the simple fact that things exist, and it seems to answer a question we all ask: why is there something and not nothing? Objection. A critic may say that we have no right to demand an explanation of the whole of things, just because each part has an explanation. Or that the chain might simply go on, or that the world's existence might be a fact with no further explanation. Some critics add that, even if there is a first thing, the argument has not shown it to be the God of Christian faith. Reply. Defenders reply that to accept an unexplained world is itself a choice and not a neutral one; and they add that the argument aims to show that there is a being on which all else depends, and that the further steps (that it is personal, good and wise) have to be taken in other ways.
4. The design argument
This family starts from order and purpose in the world.
- Many things in the world show order that serves a purpose: an eye for seeing, a leaf for catching light, laws that hold steady.
- Where we see order of this kind in things we know made, such as a watch, a mind has made it.
- So the order in the world is probably the work of a mind.
- That mind is God.
A famous form of this was given by William Paley, an English clergyman, in the early nineteenth century, who compared the world to a watch found on a heath. Older forms are found in the ancient world. A modern form points to the fact that the basic laws of nature, and the values of certain features of the universe, seem to be just what is needed for life to exist, and asks why.
Strength. The world does look ordered, and the wonder expressed in verses such as Psalm 8:3 is felt by many people, believers or not. Objection. Hume, in the eighteenth century, raised doubts about how far the comparison to a watch can go: a world is not a watch, and we have seen only one world. In the nineteenth century, Charles Darwin's account of evolution by natural selection gave an explanation of how living things come to be suited to their surroundings, without a designer for each part. In the modern form, some critics reply that, if there are many universes, a universe that fits life would be no surprise. Reply. Many Christians accept evolution and still hold that the laws and the order that make it possible point to a mind. Others dispute the critics' account. Others hold that the argument is better seen as a pointer than a proof. Readers differ, and that is acknowledged on all sides.
5. The moral argument
This family starts from morality.
- There are objective moral truths: some things are really right or wrong, whatever any person or society thinks.
- These truths are best explained if there is a God whose goodness is their source.
- So there is a God.
A different form, from the philosopher Immanuel Kant, did not try to prove God's existence from theory, but argued that belief in God is a rational hope for someone who takes morality seriously and wants goodness and happiness to meet in the end.
Strength. It speaks to something nearly everyone feels: that cruelty is wrong and kindness is right, and that this is not just a matter of taste. Objection. A critic may say that morals can be explained by the needs of living together, or by evolution, without God. An older objection, from Plato, asks: is something good because God commands it, or does God command it because it is good? If the first, goodness seems arbitrary. If the second, goodness seems to stand apart from God. Reply. Many Christian thinkers say that goodness is neither arbitrary nor outside God: God's own nature is good, and his commands flow from it. Others find the reply unconvincing, and the argument continues.
6. Aquinas's five ways
In a short and famous passage in his Summa Theologiae, Thomas Aquinas, a thirteenth-century teacher, gave five brief arguments. They are often called "the five ways". We name them only by their idea. One starts from things in motion or change and asks what moves them. One starts from the order of causes. One starts from things that might not have been, and the need for something that must be. One starts from the fact that we judge things to be better or worse and asks what the standard is. One starts from the way things without minds act for ends, and asks what directs them. These are very short, and scholars have written whole books on each. A student should not suppose that the summary is the argument, or that Aquinas thought these brief arguments were the whole of how we know God. He wrote them within a larger work of theology that begins from revelation.
7. What an argument can and cannot show
Suppose an argument of one of these kinds is sound, in the sense that its premises are true and its conclusion follows (we will look at soundness in week 5). What has it shown? At most, it has shown that something fitting the description exists: a first cause, a designer, a ground of morality. It does not by itself show that this being is the Father of Jesus Christ, that he forgives sins, or that he has spoken. Christians who use these arguments have always said that the further steps come from revelation, not from the argument. Equally, if one of the arguments fails, that does not show that there is no God. It shows only that this way of reasoning does not do what was hoped. A bad argument for a true conclusion is still a bad argument.
8. What an argument is for
For a believer, an argument may be one of several things.
- A ground: a reason that supports belief, in the way a foundation holds a house. A person might say, "Part of why I believe is that the world seems to need a cause."
- A map: a way to see the shape of the question and what depends on what, without being the reason one believes. A person might say, "I believe for other reasons, but I find it helpful to see how these ideas fit together."
- A help to others: a way of showing someone who doubts that belief is not unreasonable, or of answering a question put in good faith.
And for some people, an argument is none of these, because they believe that their trust in God does not rest on arguments at all. We looked at that view last week under the name of Reformed epistemology and its rivals. These are not exclusive: a person may use an argument as a map and not as a ground, and may change the use over a lifetime.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Many Catholic writers, following Aquinas and the teaching of the First Vatican Council (nineteenth century), hold that the existence of God can be known with certainty by human reason from created things, and that natural theology is a real and honourable work. They add that reason does not reach the or the gospel, which are known by revelation. The weak point they face is that the arguments have not convinced everyone, and critics ask how something so certain could be so disputed. Some Protestant writers, such as Karl Barth in the twentieth century, have been strongly critical of natural theology, holding that God is known only where he reveals himself in Christ, and that an argument from the world risks building a god in our own image. The weak point of that view is that it seems to some readers to leave no common ground with the one who does not believe, and to sit uneasily with Romans 1:20. Other Protestant writers have held that natural theology has a place but a smaller one, and still others, as in the Reformed tradition's emphasis on a sense of God given to all people, that belief in God does not need the arguments in order to be reasonable. Some Orthodox writers are wary of trying to prove God, and stress that God is known in worship, prayer and the life of the church, and that he is beyond all that a proof can reach. Each sees something the others miss. This course requires only that you can state each position fairly, name its weak point, and give your own reasons for your view or for holding that you have not yet formed one.
9. A pointer
Using arguments like these to answer questions put to the church is the work of Christian apologetics, which has its own course (Christian Apologetics). Here they have been exercises in reading an argument, and the one skill we want is to read each fairly.
Diagram 1. The four families
Diagram 2. What an argument may be for
핵심 요약
- The four families are ontological (from the idea of God), cosmological (from the world's existence), design (from order and purpose) and moral (from right and wrong).
- Each can be set out as premises and a conclusion, and each has a strength, an objection and a reply.
- Aquinas's five ways are brief arguments, named by idea; they are not the whole of his thought.
- A sound argument might show that a first cause or designer exists, not that he is the Father of Jesus Christ.
- A believer may use an argument as a ground, as a map or as a help to others, or not at all.
- Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox writers have judged natural theology differently; this lecture reads the arguments and does not train apologetics.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four families | Ontological, cosmological, design, moral; each starts from a different point and has its own objections. |
| What a sound argument shows | At most that something fitting the description exists; revelation, not argument, says that he is the Father of Jesus Christ. |
| What an argument may be for | A ground of belief, a map of the question, or a help to others; for some, nothing at all. |
| Different judgements | Catholic writers value natural theology; some Protestants criticise it; some Orthodox writers stress that God is known in worship and life. |
One sentence to remember Read each argument as premises and a conclusion, give it its strongest form and its weak point, and keep clear what it could show.
This week's action Take one argument for God that you have heard and write it as numbered premises and a conclusion, then mark the premise you think a critic would attack first.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Choose one of the four families and restate it as premises and a conclusion in your own words. Which premise would a critic question first?
- Why is it a mistake to read Psalm 14:1 as a verse about a person who has examined an argument and doubts?
- Which of the objections in this lecture do you find strongest? What is the best reply you can give, and what is its weak point?
- If an argument for God fails, what has been shown, and what has not? If one succeeds, what has been shown, and what has not?
- Describe the Catholic, the critical Protestant and the Orthodox stances toward natural theology as each would put it. What does each want to protect?