Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Two questions sit side by side in this lecture, and they are closely tied. The first is about time: what is time, and how is God related to it? The second is about freedom: if God knows and guides all things, in what sense are human choices free? Christians have asked both questions since the early church. They have given different answers, and they still do.
We begin with two simple pictures of time. We then look at the main ways Christians have spoken of God and time, set out as a point where readers will not agree. We then turn to providence, predestination and human freedom, using three terms (determinism, compatibilism and libertarian freedom) that are explained as they come. We describe the emphases of the traditions only where we are sure of them, and we do not rank them. We end with the old puzzle of God's knowledge of what we will choose.
This is one of the harder lectures of the course. If a section is too heavy, read the first paragraph of each section and the Key Points, and return later.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Describe two pictures of time, one in which time flows and one in which it is laid out like a map.
- State the main ways Christians have spoken of God and time, and give a strength and a weak point of each.
- Explain determinism, compatibilism and libertarian freedom in plain words.
- Describe in general terms how Reformed, Lutheran, Arminian, Catholic and Orthodox writers have each spoken of providence and human choice, without ranking them.
- State the puzzle of God's knowledge and human freedom and one family of replies.
Before the mountains were born, before you had formed the earth and the world, even from everlasting to everlasting, you are God." — Psalms 90:2
World English Bible
But don’t forget this one thing, beloved, that one day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day." — 2 Peter 3:8
WEB
in whom also we were assigned an inheritance, having been foreordained according to the purpose of him who works all things after the counsel of his will;" — Ephesians 1:11
WEB
I call heaven and earth to witness against you this day, that I have set before you life and death, the blessing and the curse. Therefore choose life, that you may live, you and your descendants;" — Deuteronomy 30:19
WEB
What the text says: the psalmist places God before the mountains and says he is God from everlasting to everlasting. Peter says that, for the Lord, one day and a thousand years may be alike. Ephesians says that believers were foreordained according to God's purpose, and that he works all things after the counsel of his will. Deuteronomy sets life and death before the people and tells them to choose. A tradition's reading: Christians have read the first two as saying God is outside time, or beyond it, or without end within it; they have read the second two as saying either that God's plan covers everything, or that people are really called to choose, or both together. Our judgement: none of these verses is a decisive proof text for one theory. Psalm 90:2 and 2 Peter 3:8 are poetry and counsel, not lessons in physics. Ephesians 1:11 is spoken about believers in Christ, and Deuteronomy 30:19 is spoken to a people at a moment of . Readers who weigh them differently are reading in good faith.
1. Two pictures of time
Think about a week. You can think of it in two ways.
In the first picture, time flows. Only the present is fully real. Yesterday has gone and tomorrow has not yet come. The present moves forward like a river past a bridge, and what was future becomes present and then past. This is the way most of us feel time.
In the second picture, time is laid out, like a map or a road seen from above. Monday, Wednesday and Saturday are all there, in order, in the way that London, Paris and Rome are all on the map at once. We move along the road, but the road is already there. This picture is how a historian or a scientist may find it convenient to speak.
Philosophers argue over which picture is true, or whether each catches part of the truth. Notice why it matters for theology. If the future is simply not yet real, can anyone, even God, know it fully now? If every moment is equally real, then perhaps the future is already "there" to be known. These questions are about time itself, before any religion enters in. Christians have simply asked them about God.
2. God and time
Christians agree that God is eternal. They have not agreed on what that means. Two main views are described below, with several in-between positions. (Another word you will see is timeless: not located in time at all. By everlasting we mean lasting through all time without end.)
God outside time. On this view, God is not in time at all. He does not have a past that is gone or a future that has not come. All of time is present to him together. This view is found in Augustine, who wrote that time itself is a part of the created world, and in the late ancient writer Boethius, who described God's eternity as the whole of unending life possessed all at once. Aquinas and a great many later Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant writers followed it. Its strength is that it fits the sense of God as the maker of time and not a prisoner of it, and that it helps to explain how God can know all things. Its weak point is that Scripture seems to speak of God as acting in sequence, answering prayer, changing course, and entering history, and it is hard to see how a being wholly outside time can do these things. The idea is also hard to picture.
God within time. On this view, God is everlasting: he has no beginning or end, but he lives through time, and what we call the past, present and future are real for him as they are for us. Many modern writers hold a form of this view, and some Christians in earlier periods spoke in ways that point toward it. Its strength is that it matches the story told in Scripture, where God speaks, waits, is grieved and acts, and that it makes sense of a real relationship between God and people. Its weak point is that, if God is within time, it is hard to see how he knows the future, and some have asked whether it makes God into a very great creature, bound by the same flow as we are.
Between these, some hold that God is timeless in himself and takes on time in his dealings with creatures, and some hold other views. A lecture of this length can only name them.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Those who hold that God is outside time say that anything else makes God smaller, ties him to the thing he made, and cannot explain how he is the Lord of history and not a fellow traveller in it. They answer the worry about Scripture by saying that the Bible speaks of God in the language of human experience, as a parent speaks to a child, and that the language bends to our understanding. Their weak point is the one named above, how such a God acts in sequence, and the fear that the answer gives up what the story says. Those who hold that God is within time say that the God of Scripture is a living God who hears and responds, and that to explain this away is to explain away the gospel. They answer the worry about knowledge by saying that God's knowledge of the future may be understood in other ways, such as knowing every possibility and every likely result, or by saying that his knowledge is of an unusual kind. Their weak point is that these answers seem to some readers to limit God's knowledge or to make the future less secure. What this course requires of you is less than either side requires: that you can state each view in its strongest form, name its weak point, and give reasons for the position you take, or for holding that you do not yet know.
3. Providence: the idea
The word names the Christian belief that God cares for his creation and guides it to its end. It is a belief about God's rule over history, nature and each life. Christians of every tradition hold some form of it. They differ on how God's guiding relates to what creatures choose and do. This is where the second question begins.
4. Three words about freedom
Before describing the traditions, we need three words. They are explained here in plain terms, and the traditions below do not all use them.
Determinism is the view that everything that happens is fixed by what came before, so that given the past and the laws of nature there is only one way the future can go. If determinism were true of human choices, then in the strict sense nobody could have chosen differently from how they did.
Libertarian freedom (the word has nothing to do with the political movement of the same name) is the view that a free choice is one that is not fixed in advance: when you choose, you could really have chosen otherwise, even if everything before were exactly the same. This is sometimes called the power of contrary choice.
Compatibilism is the view that freedom and determinism can go together. It says that a choice is free when it comes from the person's own wants and reasons and is not forced from outside, even if those wants and reasons were themselves shaped by earlier causes. A person who loves music and goes to the concert freely has not been forced, whatever made them love music.
Each of the three has a strength and a weak point. Determinism gives a tidy picture of cause, but it has trouble with the sense that our choices are ours. Libertarian freedom matches that sense, but it has trouble explaining how an uncaused choice would be mine and not mere chance. Compatibilism keeps both, but critics ask whether a freedom that could not have gone otherwise is the kind that holds a person responsible.
5. How the traditions speak of God's guiding and our choosing
What follows is a set of broad strokes. Each tradition has many voices, and some of the people described would say more or say it differently. We describe each as it would describe itself, as far as we are sure.
Reformed writers stress God's sovereignty: God's eternal purpose covers all things, including who will be saved. Reformed confessions also teach that God is not the author of sin and that he does not force the will of creatures; many Reformed writers have understood human freedom in a way that is compatible with God's plan. They find comfort in the thought that nothing falls outside God's care, and they warn against turning the teaching into an excuse for idleness.
Lutheran writers speak strongly of God's grace as the cause of salvation and speak of in Christ, and many of them are cautious about asking why some are saved and others are not, preferring to point the troubled person to the promises made in Christ. They are also careful to say that a person is not a mere object in the saving work.
Arminian writers (named for the Dutch theologian Jacobus Arminius, sixteenth and seventeenth centuries) hold that God's grace comes first and enables a person to respond, but that the response is the person's own and could be refused. They commonly hold a form of libertarian freedom and often say that God's election is in view of his knowing who would trust in Christ. They stress that God desires all to be saved, and that real love must be freely given.
The Catholic tradition has spoken of God as working in and through the free acts of creatures, so that the same act is wholly God's as its first cause and wholly the creature's as its immediate cause. Within that tradition there were long debates among schools about how grace and free will relate; the church allowed more than one account to stand. Catholic writers also stress that God wills the salvation of all and that human beings can cooperate with grace.
Orthodox writers often speak of the relation between God and human beings as one of synergy, a Greek word meaning working together: God's grace comes first and gives life, and the human person responds and takes part. They are generally wary of speaking about God's plan in a way that seems to make the human person a mere instrument. They also tend to say less in the language of "decrees" and more in the language of communion.
These descriptions are brief, and a member of each tradition would add much and might want to correct a sentence. The point for us is that all five hold that God is sovereign and that human beings are responsible. They differ in how they hold the two together, and each fears a different danger: that God is made small, or that the human person is made a puppet. A person who has heard only one of them may suppose the others hold something far worse than they do.
6. God's knowledge and our freedom
A famous puzzle connects the two parts of the lecture. Suppose God knows everything that will happen, including what you will choose tomorrow. Then it seems your choice is already fixed: it must be what God knows. If it were otherwise, God would have been wrong. So how are you free?
Here is one family of replies. The puzzle supposes that God's knowing causes your choice. But knowing is not the same as causing. If I look at a clock and see that it is noon, my seeing does not make it noon. In the same way, some argue, God's knowing what you freely choose does not make you choose it; he knows it because you choose it. This reply is easiest for those who say that God is outside time, since for him your choice is not "ahead" but present. Others reply that God knows what you would freely choose in any situation, and others that the future choices of free creatures are not yet settled and so there is nothing yet to know, a view that some regard as a loss to God's knowledge and others as a gain in the reality of freedom.
None of these replies is accepted by all Christians. A student does not need to choose. It is enough to see that knowing and causing are different, that the puzzle depends on a picture of time, and that the way a person answers it is bound up with how they have answered the earlier question about God and time.
7. A word of care
For many people these questions are not abstract. A person who feels that nothing they do matters, or that they were never chosen, may hear this lecture with pain. The lecture treats ideas and arguments. The pastor or priest, not the study of philosophy, is the right person to speak with about a troubled conscience.
Diagram 1. Two pictures of time
Diagram 2. Freedom: what each view protects
핵심 요약
- Time may be pictured as flowing, with only the present real, or as laid out like a map; the picture shapes the question of what God can know.
- Some Christians hold that God is outside time, others that he is within time; each view has a strength and a weak point.
- Determinism holds that all is fixed; libertarian freedom that I could have chosen otherwise; compatibilism that a choice is free if it comes from my own wants, unforced.
- Reformed, Lutheran, Arminian, Catholic and Orthodox writers all hold that God is sovereign and people are responsible, and differ in how they join the two.
- The puzzle of God's knowledge and freedom turns on whether knowing is the same as causing, and on a picture of time.
- Scripture's verses on these questions do not settle one theory.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Two pictures of time | Flowing (only the present is fully real) and laid out (all moments equally there, like places on a map). |
| God and time | Outside time (all present to him at once) or within time (everlasting, living through time); each has a strength and a weak point. |
| Three words on freedom | Determinism: all fixed. Libertarian freedom: I could have chosen otherwise. Compatibilism: free if from my own wants, unforced. |
| Knowing and causing | One family of replies says God's knowing a choice does not cause it, as seeing the time on a clock does not make it noon. |
One sentence to remember Christians of every tradition hold that God is sovereign and people are responsible, and they differ in how they join the two.
This week's action Write the strongest form of a view on providence and freedom that you do not hold, as someone who holds it would say it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which picture of time, flowing or laid out, comes more naturally to you? What difficulty does each raise for talk about what God knows?
- State in your own words the strongest argument for God being outside time and the strongest for God being within time. What is the weak point of each?
- Explain the difference between determinism, compatibilism and libertarian freedom using the example of a person who goes to a concert.
- Choose one of the five traditions described. What danger does it most fear, and how does that shape what it says about providence and choice?
- In the puzzle of God's knowledge and our freedom, what is the difference between knowing and causing? Does this reply convince you, and why or why not?