Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Christians use the word "know" all the time. We say "I know that Christ is risen," "I know my Lord," "I know the way to the church." We also say "I believe." Are these the same? When is it right to say "I know," and when only "I believe" or "I think"? These look like small questions of grammar. They are the first questions of epistemology, which is the study of knowing: what it is to know something, what separates knowing from believing, and what gives a person good reason to hold a belief.
This lecture gives you the basic words, with everyday examples: belief, truth, justification, evidence, doubt and certainty. It sets out the traditional definition of knowledge and the problem that every beginner meets with it. Then it asks how the Bible itself speaks of knowing. It does not ask you to take any philosophical side. The aim is a clear vocabulary, so that in the next lectures, when Christians disagree about faith and reason, you can hear exactly what is being said.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- Tell apart three everyday kinds of knowing: knowing that, knowing how and knowing someone.
- Explain belief, truth and justification, each with an everyday example.
- State the traditional definition of knowledge and explain, with the stopped clock, why a true and justified belief may still be lucky.
- Explain the difference between degrees of confidence and a feeling of certainty.
- Describe three places in Scripture where knowing is spoken of, keeping apart what the text says, what a tradition reads and what we judge.
This is eternal life, that they should know you, the only true God, and him whom you sent, Jesus Christ." — John 17:3
World English Bible
Now faith is assurance of things hoped for, proof of things not seen." — Hebrews 11:1
WEB
These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life, and that you may continue to believe in the name of the Son of God." — 1 John 5:13
WEB
What the text says. In John 17:3 knowing God and Christ is named as eternal life. Hebrews 11:1 describes faith with two words, "assurance" and "proof". In 1 John 5:13 the writer says he wants readers who already believe to know something, and in the same sentence to keep believing. So the Bible puts knowing and believing close together, in one sentence.
What traditions read. Many readers hear in John 17:3 a knowing that is personal and relational, like knowing a friend, more than the holding of a fact. Others stress that the verse names a true God and a sent Son, so that facts are part of it too. Hebrews 11:1 has been read as a description of faith's nature and also as a description of what faith does, and translators and commentators differ on the Greek words. We have not tried to settle that here.
Our judgement. These verses were not written to give a theory of knowledge. They do not decide the philosophical questions of this lecture. They do show that the people who wrote them did not set knowing and believing against each other.
1. Three kinds of knowing
Start with how people really talk. "I know the road to the market." "I know the headteacher." "I know that the bridge is closed." The same word does three different jobs.
- Knowing how is a skill. I know how to ride a bicycle, bake bread or read a map. I may not be able to explain it in words.
- Knowing someone is acquaintance. I know my neighbour, my teacher, my friend. It grows through time spent together.
- Knowing that is knowing a fact. I know that the bridge is closed, that two and two make four, that my brother lives in another city.
Many languages mark some of these with different words. French has savoir and connaître, Spanish has saber and conocer, German has wissen and kennen. English uses one word for all. That makes it easy to slide from one meaning to another without noticing. When a person says "I know God," they are usually speaking of knowing someone. When they say "I know that God exists," they are speaking of knowing a fact. These are connected, but they are not the same thing, and a good deal of confusion in talk about faith comes from mixing them.
Most of what philosophers mean by epistemology is about knowing that, and that is what the rest of this lecture studies first. Later we come back to knowing someone.
2. Belief, truth and justification
Three words do most of the work.
Belief is holding something to be so. If I believe the bridge is closed, then I would act as if it were closed: I would take another road. Belief is a state of the person who believes. It can be strong or weak.
Truth is how things are. The bridge is either closed or it is not. A belief can be true or false. Whether it is true does not depend on how strongly I believe it. A person may be completely sure of a false thing, and a person may be nervously unsure of a true one.
means having good reasons, or good grounds, for the belief. If my neighbour told me the bridge is closed, and a sign stood at the road's end, I have reasons. If I just had a feeling, I have none, or only weak ones. Justification is about how a belief is held, not about whether it is true.
Here is an everyday way to see the difference. (an invented example) Maria wakes and sees heavy grey clouds. She takes an umbrella. Her belief is that it will rain. The belief is true if rain falls. It is justified if she had reasons: the clouds, and the sound of thunder in the night. Now suppose a second person, Tomas, flips a coin and decides "heads means rain." The coin comes up heads, he takes an umbrella, and it rains. His belief was true. But he had no reason. We would say that he guessed right, and we would not say that he knew.
3. The traditional account, and its problem
From very early times, philosophers have suggested that knowledge is justified true belief. To know that the bridge is closed, three things must be so. I must believe it. It must be true. And I must have good reasons for believing it. Take away any one and what is left is not knowledge. Without belief, I do not hold the thing at all. Without truth, I only thought I knew. Without justification, I only guessed.
This account has a long history and many people still find it a helpful starting point. But in the twentieth century a short and famous paper by the philosopher Edmund Gettier showed that there are cases where a person has a belief that is true and justified, and yet we are not willing to say they know. Here is the idea with an everyday case.
(an invented example) A man walks past a station and looks at the big clock. It says three o'clock. He believes it is three o'clock. In fact it is three o'clock. He has a reason: clocks usually tell the time. But the clock stopped twelve hours ago, and he happens to look at the one moment of the day when a stopped clock is right. His belief is true. He has what seems to be a good reason. But it is only luck that the two fit. We feel that he did not really know the time.
Philosophers have answered this problem in several ways. Some add a fourth condition. Some say that the reasons must be connected in the right way to the truth. Some say the problem shows that knowing cannot be broken into parts. You do not have to choose between these answers. What the clock shows is useful for a student of theology: a person can have reasons and a true belief and still be only lucky, and so the question "how do I know?" is worth asking even when the answer seems right.
4. Evidence and degrees of confidence
Few of our beliefs are all-or-nothing. We hold some beliefs more firmly than others. I am very sure that the sun will rise tomorrow. I am fairly sure that my friend will come on Thursday. I think, but I am not sure, that the shop is open on Sunday. This is degrees of confidence.
Evidence is whatever counts for or against a belief: what I have seen, what I have been told, what follows from other things I know. Good thinking tries to match confidence to evidence. Strong evidence supports strong confidence. Weak evidence supports caution. This is easy to say and hard to do, because we are often more confident than our evidence allows, and sometimes less.
5. Doubt and certainty
Certainty can mean two different things, and it is worth keeping them apart. It can mean a feeling: I am completely sure, and I cannot imagine being wrong. Or it can mean a standard: the evidence is so strong that there is no reasonable room for doubt. The feeling and the standard do not always go together. A person can feel certain and be wrong. A person can have strong grounds and still feel uneasy. When a student says "I am certain," it helps to ask which of these is meant.
Doubt also has two faces. One kind of doubt is a tool. A careful person asks, "Am I sure of this? What if I am mistaken?" and so finds a weak place in an argument or a fact. Many thinkers, including Descartes whom you met in week 1, used doubt on purpose, to test what could stand. The other kind of doubt is a refusal ever to settle: a person who will not act, will not trust and will not say anything because "we cannot be sure." That kind of doubt can become a trap. In lecture 2-4 we will meet both false certainty and paralysing doubt again. For now, notice only that doubt is not sin and certainty is not a sign of faith. A believer may ask hard questions; a believer may also be too sure.
6. Knowing in Scripture
How does the Bible speak of knowing? A few careful points are enough, because the subject is large and scholars differ.
First, in the Hebrew Bible the common word for "know" is used of facts, of skills and also of persons. It is used of knowing God, of knowing a neighbour and even, in Genesis 4:1, of the closeness of husband and wife. Many readers conclude that Hebrew knowing is often relational: it is knowing someone in a way that involves them. Other scholars warn against turning this into a rule, since the same verb also means simply to be aware that something is so. We say only what we are sure of: the word is wide, and a rule that it always means close relationship goes beyond what it can bear.
Second, in the New Testament the writers use several Greek words for knowing, and the Gospel of John and the First Letter of John use them often. In John 17:3 knowing God is eternal life. In 1 John 5:13 the writer says he wrote "that you may know." That is not a puzzle; it is a plain statement that believers may have assurance. How that assurance should be understood, and what makes it safe, is something Christian traditions describe in different ways, and the next lectures take it up.
Third, Hebrews 11:1 joins faith to "assurance" and "proof". Some readers hear in "proof" a claim that faith has good grounds. Others hear a promise that faith is a firm trust even where nothing is seen. The word can bear more than one reading. We cannot decide here between them, and the verse does not claim to be a lesson in the theory of evidence.
What follows for this course? The Bible does not give a definition of knowledge, and it would be a mistake to take one verse as the whole of what Scripture says. It does show that those who wrote it saw knowing as something that matters and as something that can be received and lost. That is all we need to go on.
7. Why this matters for a student of theology
When a theologian writes "we know that God is good," a careful reader may ask which kind of knowing is meant, and how the writer is sure. When a preacher says "I do not merely believe, I know," the hearer may ask what the difference is. When a doubter says "I cannot know," a pastor may ask whether the person means they have no certainty or they have no good reasons, since these are not the same. These questions help us listen more kindly and think more clearly. They do not decide whether the faith is true.
Diagram 1. From belief to knowledge
핵심 요약
- "Know" has three everyday jobs: knowing how, knowing someone and knowing that. Confusing them causes much muddle in talk about faith.
- Belief is holding something to be so; truth is how things are; justification is having good grounds.
- The traditional account says knowledge is justified true belief; the stopped clock shows a true, justified belief can still be only lucky.
- Confidence comes in degrees and should be matched to evidence; a feeling of certainty is not the same as a standard of evidence.
- Doubt can be a useful tool or a trap; it is not a sin, and certainty is not a sign of faith.
- The Bible joins knowing and believing and gives no definition of knowledge; the Hebrew and Greek words for knowing are wide.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three kinds of knowing | Knowing how (a skill), knowing someone (acquaintance) and knowing that (a fact). |
| Justified true belief | The traditional account of knowledge: I believe it, it is true and I have good grounds. |
| The stopped clock | A true belief with reasons that fit only by luck; it shows that having reasons and truth together is not always enough. |
| Certainty, two senses | A feeling of being sure, or a standard of evidence; the two can come apart. |
One sentence to remember To say "I know" is to claim a belief that is true and well grounded, and a careful person asks which kind of knowing is meant and how the grounds fit.
This week's action Listen for the word "know" in conversation or in a sermon and ask yourself which of the three kinds is meant.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Think of three things you "know" in your daily life, one of each kind: knowing how, knowing someone and knowing that. How does the word "know" change its meaning?
- In your own words, what is the difference between a true belief and a justified true belief? Think of an everyday case where someone guessed right.
- In the stopped clock case, why do we hesitate to say the man knew? What would have to be different for us to say that he did?
- When you say "I am certain," do you mean a feeling or a standard? Can you recall a time the two came apart?
- John 17:3 and 1 John 5:13 both speak of knowing. What might it mean that the writers do not set knowing and believing against each other?