Lecture 6-1: The Problem of Evil, Stated Fairly
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
- Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
- Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
- Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
- Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
- Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
- Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
- Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
- Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
- Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
- Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
- Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
- Lecture 4-2: Analogy
- Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
- Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
- Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
- Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
- Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
- Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
Before we begin, one plain word. This chapter treats arguments. It looks at the problem of evil the way a student looks at a map: from above, with care, at a distance. That is useful work, and it is not the work that a person in pain needs first. Beside someone who is grieving, ill or afraid, other words are needed: few words, presence, and often silence. This lecture does not offer those. If you are carrying a loss of your own, you may read the lecture slowly, skip any part, or leave it for another day. For the theology of suffering and for care, see Week 5 of Bioethics and Technology, where a whole chapter is given to it.
The problem of evil is the question of how the existence of real evil and suffering can be understood if God is good and all-powerful. It is one of the oldest and most serious questions in the philosophy of religion, and it is asked from inside the Bible as well as from outside. This lecture sets the problem out fairly, in its strongest form, in plain steps. It separates the main kinds of evil and the two main forms of the argument, shows how Scripture meets the problem in a way that is different from an argument, and explains the difference between a defence and a theodicy. It does not yet say how Christians have answered. That is for lecture 6-2.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why this chapter treats the problem of evil as an argument, and why an argument is not what a suffering person needs first.
- Set out the problem of evil as a short argument with premises and a conclusion.
- Distinguish natural evil from moral evil, and the logical form of the problem from the evidential form.
- Describe how Job and the lament psalms meet evil as appeal and struggle, not as a philosophical solution.
- Explain the difference between a defence and a theodicy.
Then Yahweh answered Job out of the whirlwind," — Job 38:1
World English Bible
Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth? Declare, if you have understanding." — Job 38:4
WEB
How long, Yahweh? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me?" — Psalm 13:1
WEB
How long shall I take counsel in my soul, having sorrow in my heart every day? How long shall my enemy triumph over me?" — Psalm 13:2
WEB
Yahweh, how long will I cry, and you will not hear? I cry out to you “Violence!” and will you not save?" — Habakkuk 1:2
WEB
Why do you show me iniquity, and look at perversity? For destruction and violence are before me. There is strife, and contention rises up." — Habakkuk 1:3
WEB
What the text says. In Psalm 13 and in Habakkuk a person speaks to God, not about God, and asks "how long?" and "why?" The question is not polite. It is a complaint, and the Bible keeps it. In Job 38 God answers Job from the whirlwind, but the answer is a set of questions and not an explanation of why Job suffered. A tradition's reading. Many readers, Jewish and Christian, have seen in these passages permission to bring the hardest questions to God. Some read the answer to Job as a rebuke of Job's complaint, others as a gift of God's presence, and others as both. Our judgement. These passages do not solve the philosophical problem, and it would be a mistake to use any one of them as a proof text for a particular solution. They show how the question lives in faith. Scripture is not a philosophy textbook, and this lecture does not make it one.
1. A word to those who read in pain
Suppose that you are reading this and a name comes to mind: a child, a friend, a parent, yourself. Then this lecture may feel like an insult. A neat argument about evil can seem cold when evil has a face. That feeling is not a failure of faith or of understanding. It is a good sign: it means that you know that the question is not only a puzzle. Philosophers who study the problem of evil say the same. A great deal of the writing on it is a careful attempt to think clearly about something that, in life, is met with tears, silence and prayer. If you need to stop, stop. If you are in danger or thinking of harming yourself, please speak at once to a pastor or priest and to your local emergency number or a local crisis line. This course does not cover that care, and it should not.
For everyone else, there is a reason to study the problem as an argument. Students, preachers, teachers and friends meet this question constantly, in their own doubts and in the doubts of others. A person who has never looked at its shape may meet it unprepared. And a person who confuses the argument with the pain may answer a grieving friend with a lecture, or answer a hard philosophical question with a platitude. Seeing the two clearly protects both.
2. The problem in plain steps
Here is the problem in a form that most careful writers would accept as fair. In lecture 5-1 we met the idea of an argument as a map: claims, premises and a conclusion. Here is the map of this argument.
- God is all-good. (All-good here means that God is perfectly good and wants good for creatures.)
- God is all-powerful. (All-powerful, or omnipotent, here means that God is able to do whatever can be done.)
- There is real evil and suffering in the world.
- A good being who is able to stop evil would stop it, and so there would be none.
- Therefore, either God is not all-good, or God is not all-powerful, or there is no real evil, or there is no God.
The argument is valid if the conclusion follows from the premises. Most writers on the problem agree on that point, or at least that it is a fair try. The real work is in asking whether the premises are true. A defender of faith will usually question premise 4 (is it true that a good being would always stop all evil at once?), or premise 3 (are all the things we call evil really evil?), or will say that premises 1 and 2 have to be understood with care. A critic will say that none of these moves works, or that they work only by making God's goodness or power into something we would no longer recognise. Notice how an everyday example helps. A parent who can easily prevent a child's fall and does not looks neglectful. But a parent who prevents every difficulty from a child's life may also be failing the child. Does the comparison work for God? That is exactly what the problem asks.
3. Two kinds of evil
Writers on this problem often separate two kinds of evil, and the separation is helpful, though it has blurred edges.
Moral evil is evil that people do or allow: cruelty, injustice, war, neglect. It comes from the choices of persons, and it can be blamed on someone.
Natural evil is suffering that does not come, in any direct way, from anyone's choice: an earthquake, a disease, a drought, the death of a child by an illness. It comes from the way the world works.
The two are not always easy to tell apart. A famine may follow a drought (natural) and a failure to share food (moral). A disease may spread because of a human choice. Even so, the distinction is useful, because the answers that have been given differ. An answer that appeals to human freedom speaks naturally to moral evil. An answer that speaks to natural evil needs something else. As you read lecture 6-2, notice which kind of evil each answer speaks to best.
4. The logical form and the evidential form
The problem of evil comes in two main forms, and it is worth separating them.
The logical form says that the existence of evil is impossible to square with the existence of a God who is all-good and all-powerful. The claim is strong: that God and evil cannot both be real, the way a square circle cannot be real. There is an argument of this kind, associated in the modern discussion with writers such as J. L. Mackie. To answer it, a defender does not need to show why God allows evil. It is enough to show that there could be a good reason, that the two claims can both be true. Many philosophers, believers and non-believers alike, now think this form of the argument has been answered, and they say the logical form is generally weaker than the other. We should say this carefully: not every philosopher agrees, and the question of whether the answer works depends on the answers one accepts to lecture 6-2.
The evidential form says something more modest and, for many people, harder: that the amount, the kind and the spread of evil in the world is evidence against the existence of a good and powerful God. It does not claim a contradiction. It claims that some evils seem pointless, such as great suffering that seems to bring no good, and that the best explanation for such evil is that there is no God, or no God of this kind. There is an argument of this kind associated with writers such as William Rowe. The evidential form is a claim about probability and degrees, as in lecture 5-2. A defender of faith might reply that we are not in a position to know whether an evil is pointless, since our view is small; a critic might answer that if we cannot tell, then we have lost the ability to say that any evil counts against God, and the reply proves too much. Both points have weight. Neither is a knock-down blow.
A short way to remember: the logical form asks, Can these claims both be true? The evidential form asks, Given the evil we see, how likely is it that they are?
5. How Job and the lament psalms meet the problem
It is worth noticing what the Bible does with this question. It does not offer a theory. It offers voices.
The lament psalms, of which Psalm 13 is one, are prayers in which a person says to God that things are wrong and asks how long they will last. Habakkuk speaks to God as a prophet and asks why God looks at violence and seems to do nothing. In these texts the person complains, argues, and keeps speaking to God. Many Jewish and Christian readers have seen in this a pattern: the question is not hidden, and it is not answered with a doctrine. It is an appeal and a struggle, made inside a relationship. Some of these psalms end in trust; some, such as Psalm 88, hardly end that way.
The book of Job is a long poem about a man who suffers and whose friends try to explain it. In the story the friends give explanations, and the book as a whole does not accept them. When God speaks at the end, God does not give Job a reason. God asks Job questions about creation. How the speech should be read is argued: some say it humbles Job; some say it comforts him by showing that God is present, and that creation is larger than Job's pain; some say it is a rebuke to the friends' neat theories. The text itself does not say. What we can say is that Job is not given an argument, and that the book as a whole treats the neat explanations of the friends as inadequate.
This is a point where readers will not agree: whether the Bible gives an answer to the problem of evil at all. Some readers hold that Scripture gives a framework of answers (creation good, human sin, God's judgement and mercy, the cross, a final renewal) and that a Christian philosopher's work is to make these hang together. In their strongest form, they say that Scripture is full of answers to why evil exists and what God will do about it, even if it does not answer every question about each suffering. Others hold that the Bible's treatment is mainly a practice of lament and trust, and that to turn it into a theory misses its point. In their strongest form, they say that the Bible never states the problem as a puzzle for the intellect, and that to treat it so changes the question. The weak point of the first view is that it can pass over the many places where Scripture simply refuses to explain. The weak point of the second is that it can leave a student with no way to think about the question at all, and the questions of thoughtful people do not go away because they are not asked in the Bible's form. This course asks only that you can state each view fairly. It does not ask you to choose.
6. Defence and theodicy
Two words are often used in this field, and a student should know the difference.
A defence (sometimes called a defense) is a limited reply. It tries to show only that the claim "God and evil can both be real" is not contradictory, that there could be a good reason for God to allow evil. It does not say it knows God's actual reason. Think of a person accused of a crime who shows that it was possible that someone else did it. The accused is not saying who did it; he is showing that the case against him has a gap.
A (a word that joins the Greek for "God" and for "justice") is a larger project. It tries to say what God's reasons actually are, or at least to give a plausible account of them, and so to show that God is just in allowing evil. The word was made in the early modern period. A theodicy asks more, and risks more: if the story it tells is not true, or is not believable, the whole thing fails.
Many philosophers in the modern discussion prefer defences, because they claim less. Others say that a defence is not enough for someone who actually suffers, and that a theodicy is what the question seeks. Others say that a theodicy is a mistake, in itself or morally: we will meet that view in lecture 6-3. As you read lecture 6-2, ask of each answer: is it a defence, a theodicy, or something in between?
7. The objection in its strongest form
It is a duty of fair study to state an objection so that the person who holds it would say, "Yes, that is what I mean." Here is the objection to faith in its strongest form, without softening.
Imagine the worst suffering of which you can think, especially the suffering of those who could not have done anything to deserve it and who could not have learned from it, a young child in pain, a person who suffers and dies with no one to comfort them. A being who loves, and who can stop this, and who does not: what kind of love is that? The believer says that God has good reasons. But the more terrible the evil, the harder it is to believe that any reason could be good enough, and the more it seems that a God who allowed it would be less good than we are. And if we were told that the reasons are beyond us, then we have been asked to trust a goodness that we cannot see in action. The objector is not necessarily cold or proud. Often the objector is someone who cares so much about those who suffer that they cannot accept a God who seems not to.
This objection should not be answered quickly. A believer who has never felt its force may not yet have understood the question. And a believer who has felt it, and who still prays, is not unfaithful: Psalm 13 and Habakkuk 1 show that the objection has been voiced inside faith itself.
8. What this lecture asks of you
It asks you to be able to say the argument in your own words; to tell moral evil from natural evil; to say how the logical form differs from the evidential form; to say what Job and the lament psalms do and do not offer; to say what a defence is and what a theodicy is; and to state the objection so that a person who holds it would recognise it. It does not ask you to choose an answer. It does not claim that an argument settles a question that is, for many, a matter of the whole of life.
Diagram 1. The problem of evil as a map
핵심 요약
- This chapter treats the problem of evil as an argument; a suffering person needs presence and other words before any argument.
- The problem asks how a good and all-powerful God can allow real evil; it can be set out as premises and a conclusion.
- Moral evil comes from human choices; natural evil does not, though the two blur at the edges.
- The logical form asks whether the claims can both be true; the evidential form asks how likely a good God is, given the evil we see.
- Job and the lament psalms meet evil as appeal and struggle, in prayer, and do not offer a philosophical solution.
- A defence shows that no contradiction is proven; a theodicy tries to say what God's reasons actually are.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The problem of evil | How real evil and suffering can be understood if God is good and all-powerful; set out as premises and a conclusion. |
| Moral and natural evil | Moral evil comes from what people do or allow; natural evil from the way the world works; the two blur at the edges. |
| Logical and evidential forms | Logical: can the claims both be true? Evidential: given the evil we see, how likely is a good, powerful God? |
| Defence and theodicy | A defence shows that a good reason is possible; a theodicy tries to say what God's reasons are. |
One sentence to remember The problem of evil can be studied as an argument, but the Bible meets it first as a cry to God, and a person in pain needs a companion before an argument.
This week's action Write the five steps of the argument on one sheet in your own words, and mark the premise you would question first.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Why does this chapter begin by saying that arguments are not what a suffering person needs first? What would you say, and not say, to a friend who asks you this question in tears?
- Restate the five steps of the argument in your own words. Which premise would you question first, and why?
- Give one example each of moral evil and natural evil. Can you think of a case where the two are mixed?
- What is the difference between the logical form and the evidential form of the problem? Which do you find harder to answer, and why?
- How do Psalm 13, Habakkuk 1 and Job 38 meet the problem differently from a philosophical argument? What is gained, and what is lost, by turning them into a theory?
- What is the difference between a defence and a theodicy? Why might a thinker prefer one to the other?