무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil

Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps

목차 31
STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
제 1 장 · Week 1: Philosophy and Theology: A Long Conversation
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
  2. Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
  3. Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
  4. Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
제 2 장 · Week 2: Knowing: Epistemology
  1. Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
  2. Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
  3. Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
  4. Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
제 3 장 · Week 3: Being: Metaphysics
  1. Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
  2. Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
  3. Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
  4. Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
제 4 장 · Week 4: Language: How We Speak of God
  1. Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
  2. Lecture 4-2: Analogy
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
  4. Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
제 5 장 · Week 5: Reading and Writing Arguments
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
  2. Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
  3. Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
  4. Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
제 6 장 · Week 6: Evil, and the Place of Philosophy
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Problem of Evil, Stated Fairly
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ways of Answering: Free Will, Soul-Making and More
  3. Lecture 6-3: Against Theodicy, and the Cross
  4. Lecture 6-4: Neither Enemy nor Servant: Putting the Course Together
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Philosophy and My Theology on One Page

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

20분

An argument can go wrong in many ways. Some mistakes are honest slips. Some are habits that we fall into when we are angry, tired or afraid of losing. A fallacy is a common pattern of poor reasoning: it looks like a good reason, but it does not support its conclusion as well as it seems. Learning the common patterns helps us notice them in what we read, in what we hear and, hardest of all, in what we say ourselves.

This lecture describes nine common fallacies, each with an everyday or invented example. It then gives a strong warning against using fallacy names as weapons, and ends with the principle of charity: stating another person's view in its strongest form before replying to it. A fallacy name is a tool for examining reasoning. It is not a way to dismiss a person.

이 20분으로 얻는 것

  • Name nine common fallacies and give a short example of each.
  • Explain why a conclusion can be true even when the argument for it contains a fallacy.
  • Explain why naming a fallacy is not the same as winning an argument, and how the habit can become a weapon.
  • State the principle of charity and apply it by restating a view you disagree with in its strongest form.
  • Say what a good reader does when meeting a hard objection.

He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13

World English Bible

He who pleads his cause first seems right; until another comes and questions him." — Proverbs 18:17

WEB

but speaking truth in love, we may grow up in all things into him, who is the head, Christ;" — Ephesians 4:15

WEB

What the text says. Proverbs 18:13 says that answering before hearing is folly and shame, which is close to what we mean by listening before replying. Proverbs 18:17 notes that the one who speaks first seems right until another asks questions, which is a plain observation about how a first account can look complete when it is not. Ephesians 4:15 speaks of "speaking truth in love" as part of growing up. These are short sayings and a short instruction. They are not a manual of logic.

A tradition's reading. Readers in many traditions take these verses as support for patient listening, careful questioning and honest speech in the community. Some stress the proverbs as wisdom for the courts and for everyday quarrels; some read Ephesians 4:15 mainly about the church's shared growth. We do not know that the writers had formal fallacies in mind, and it would go beyond the text to say so.

Our judgement. It is reasonable to say that the spirit of these verses, hearing before answering and speaking truth with love, fits the practice of reading others charitably. This is our judgement, and it is not what the verses say.

1. Nine common patterns

Each pattern below has a name, a short description and an example (invented examples). Names differ a little from book to book; the patterns matter more than the names. For each, we also note when the pattern may not be a fault at all.

1. Attacking the person. Instead of answering what someone has said, we say something against the person. "Brother Daniel says this reading is mistaken, but he has never been to seminary, so we need not listen." Whether Daniel has been to seminary is a separate matter from whether his reading is right. Note: it is fair to ask whether someone is in a position to know. A witness's honesty and access to the facts matter (lecture 5-1). The fault is to let the person's character or background stand in for a reply to the reasons.

2. Straw man. We restate someone's view in a weaker, sillier form and then answer that. "She wants to study the early Fathers, so she thinks the Bible is not enough." She may have said nothing of the kind. A straw man is easy to knock down because someone built it to fall. It is one of the commonest faults in religious debate, and often an unintended one, because we remember an opponent's view in the form that we find easiest to answer.

3. False dilemma. We offer two choices as if there were no others. "Either we sing only the old hymns or we have given up worship." There may be many other options. Check whether the "either/or" is real. Note: some choices truly are two-sided. The fault is claiming that there are two when there may be more.

4. Circular argument. The conclusion is hidden inside the premise, so the argument goes in a circle. "This teacher is reliable because he always tells the truth, and we know he tells the truth because he is reliable." A circle shows nothing to someone who did not already accept the conclusion. Note: it is not always easy to tell a circle from a case where the premises and the conclusion support one another in a larger pattern, and philosophers have argued about how far some circles are harmless. For this lecture it is enough to watch for the plain case in which the reason offered is only the conclusion again.

5. Appeal to authority. We say a claim is true only because an important person said so. "The great preacher said it, so it must be so." Note: relying on authority is not always a fault. We trust doctors, maps and teachers, and lecture 2-4 explained that much of our knowing rests on testimony. A good appeal to authority asks whether the person is really expert in this matter, whether experts agree, and whether the claim is one on which authority can settle anything. The fault is to treat a name as a reason without asking these things. Traditions also differ about what authority is final, and that is a question of 5-2, not a fallacy.

6. Slippery slope. We say that one small step will lead inevitably to a disaster, without showing why. "If we allow one change in the order of service, soon nothing will be left of our worship." Some slopes are real: one step does make the next easier. The fault is to assume it without showing the steps that lead from one to the other. Ask: what would have to happen at each stage, and is there any reason to stop?

7. Genetic fallacy. We judge an idea by where it came from instead of by its merits. "This custom began among a group we do not like, so it must be wrong." Or the reverse: "This is an ancient custom, so it must be right." Where an idea came from can be a reason for care, and can help us understand it, but an idea can come from a poor source and be true, or from a good source and be mistaken.

8. Hasty generalisation. We draw a broad conclusion from too few cases (the weak induction of lecture 5-2). "I met two people from that church and both were unkind, so that church is unkind." Two cases are not enough to say anything about a church of hundreds. A kinder way to say this is: "I met two people who were unkind, and I do not know what the rest are like."

9. Loaded question. The question itself contains an assumption that the one who answers has not agreed to. "Have you stopped doubting the creed?" Any plain yes or no accepts the hidden claim that the person did doubt it. The right response is to name the assumption: "I would need to say first that I have not said I doubted it."

You will find other lists with more names, such as appeals to emotion, to popularity or to tradition, and the false cause. These nine are enough for a start.

2. A conclusion can be true even if the argument is poor

This point is easy to miss. A fallacy is a fault in the argument, not necessarily in the conclusion. A person may give a poor argument for a true claim. If someone says, "Everybody believes it, so it must be true", and what they believe happens to be true, naming the fallacy does not show that the claim is false. It shows that this reason is not enough. The right reply is to ask for a better reason, or to look for one yourself. To say "that is a fallacy, so you are wrong" is itself a fallacy.

3. Fallacy names as weapons

Here is the danger. Once a student learns these names, it is tempting to use them like blows. "That is a straw man!" "You are attacking the person!" Said in the middle of a heated conversation, the name can stop the other person from speaking and make them feel foolish. It can also be used to avoid the real question. A person who calls "slippery slope" may be ignoring a real warning, and a person who calls "appeal to authority" may be ignoring good testimony.

A few habits keep the names in their place.

  • Use the name to examine your own reasoning first. It is much easier to see a fallacy in an opponent than in yourself, and that is a reason for suspicion.
  • Say what the problem is, in plain words, and not only the label. "I think you are assuming that there are only two options. What about a third?" is more useful than "false dilemma".
  • Ask before you name. "Is that what you meant?" may show that the person did not say what you heard.
  • Remember that the names are for argument. A grieving or frightened person who says something illogical is not committing a fallacy for you to correct. They need a listener. This is a point we shall meet again in the last week.

4. The principle of charity

The principle of charity, in reading and discussion, means that we first try to understand another person's view in the strongest and most reasonable form it can take, and we answer that, not a weaker form. It is sometimes called "steelmanning", the opposite of building a straw man, but the plain English phrase is enough.

Charity is not agreement. You may think an argument is mistaken and still state it so well that its holder says, "Yes, that is exactly what I mean." That is the test. Charity is also not flattery. Once you have stated the view fairly, you are free to say where you think it is weak.

Here is a short example of the practice (an invented example).

A friend says, "I do not think a church needs a creed. Scripture is enough."

An uncharitable reply: "So you think the church should believe anything it likes."

A charitable restatement: "You think that Scripture is the final authority and that a creed can come to stand in its place or be used to shut out people who read it differently. Is that right?"

After the friend says yes, you may answer: "I see why you would want to guard against that. I wonder whether a creed could serve Scripture as a short summary, and not replace it."

Notice that the second reply does not give way, and does not win by trickery. It lets both people see the real question: not whether the church may believe anything, but what a creed is for.

Charity also applies to the Christian tradition across history. When you read a thinker from another century or another church, ask what question they were trying to answer, and what they were afraid of. Many positions that look odd become understandable when we see the danger they were meant to guard against.

5. Reading a hard objection well

Sometimes a person brings an objection that is hard: to a doctrine, to a practice, or to the church. A good reader does several things.

  1. Listen to the end. Proverbs 18:13 warns about answering before hearing.
  2. Restate the objection and ask whether you have it right.
  3. Find the premises. Draw the bones (lecture 5-1). What is it really claiming?
  4. Ask which part is strongest. There is often one point in a hard objection that is true, or that points at a real difficulty, even if the whole does not follow.
  5. Say what you do not know. "I do not have an answer to that yet" is an honest reply, and it is not a defeat.
  6. Ask about the person. Sometimes the objection is a question about an argument, and sometimes it is a cry. The reply is different in each case.

The aim is not to be unmoved. The aim is to be fair, so that if you do hold your ground you do so for reasons, and if you change your view you do so for reasons.


Diagram 1. Nine patterns at a glance

Nine common patterns A sign of each; names differ from book to book 1. Attacking the person Answers the speaker, not the reasons. 2. Straw man Answers a weaker version than the one given. 3. False dilemma Two options offered when there are more. 4. Circular argument The conclusion is hidden in the premise. 5. Appeal to authority A name used as a reason without asking if it fits. 6. Slippery slope Disaster follows, with no steps shown. 7. Genetic fallacy Judges an idea by its source, not its merits. 8. Hasty generalisation A broad claim from too few cases. 9. Loaded question The question contains a claim not yet agreed. A fallacy is a fault in the argument, not proof that the conclusion is false.

Diagram 2. Charity in three steps

1. Listen To the end, before answering. 2. Restate In the strongest form; ask, "Is that right?" 3. Answer The view as restated, with reasons. Charity is not agreement: after restating, you are free to say where you think the view is weak.

핵심 요약

  • A fallacy is a common pattern of poor reasoning that looks better than it is; nine are described: attacking the person, straw man, false dilemma, circular argument, appeal to authority, slippery slope, genetic fallacy, hasty generalisation and loaded question.
  • Some patterns are not always faults (authority, slopes, origins), and the fault lies in using them without the needed steps.
  • A fallacy is a fault in the argument; the conclusion may still be true.
  • Fallacy names should examine reasoning, beginning with our own, and should not be used as weapons.
  • The principle of charity states another's view in its strongest form before replying; it is not agreement.
  • A good reader of a hard objection listens, restates, finds the premises, notices the strongest point and says what is not yet known.
Front Back
Straw man Answering a weaker or sillier version of someone's view than the one they hold.
False dilemma Offering two choices as if there were no others.
Fallacy and truth A fallacy shows a fault in the argument; the conclusion may still be true.
Principle of charity State the other view in its strongest form, until its holder says "yes, that is what I mean", then reply.

One sentence to remember Use the names of fallacies to examine reasoning, yours first, and answer another person's view only after you have stated it at its strongest.

This week's action In your next disagreement, restate the other person's view and ask "Is that right?" before you reply.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Which of the nine patterns do you find easiest to fall into yourself when you are tired, angry or afraid? Which do you most often hear?
  • A person gives a poor argument for a conclusion that you believe to be true. What should you do, and what should you not do?
  • In what circumstances is relying on an authority reasonable, and in what circumstances is it a fallacy?
  • Why might calling out a fallacy by name make a conversation worse? What could you say in plain words instead?
  • Try restating a view you disagree with in a form its holder would accept. What was hardest?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.