무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil

Lecture 6-3: Against Theodicy, and the Cross

목차 31
STEL9E Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
제 1 장 · Week 1: Philosophy and Theology: A Long Conversation
  1. Lecture 1-1: Why Theology Cannot Avoid Philosophy
  2. Lecture 1-2: Athens and Jerusalem: The Early Church and Greek Thought
  3. Lecture 1-3: From Augustine to Aquinas
  4. Lecture 1-4: Reformation, Enlightenment and Today's Conversation
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Stance Toward Philosophy
제 2 장 · Week 2: Knowing: Epistemology
  1. Lecture 2-1: Knowing, Believing, Justifying
  2. Lecture 2-2: Reason, Revelation and Faith
  3. Lecture 2-3: Evidence and Basic Beliefs
  4. Lecture 2-4: Testimony, Community and Virtue
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: When I Say "I Know"
제 3 장 · Week 3: Being: Metaphysics
  1. Lecture 3-1: Being, Substance and Essence
  2. Lecture 3-2: Cause, Possibility and Necessity
  3. Lecture 3-3: Time, Eternity, Providence and Freedom
  4. Lecture 3-4: Arguments for God, Read Fairly
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Take for Granted
제 4 장 · Week 4: Language: How We Speak of God
  1. Lecture 4-1: Speaking of God: Literal and Figurative
  2. Lecture 4-2: Analogy
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Negative Way and Silence
  4. Lecture 4-4: Creeds, Scripture and Translation
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: The Words I Use for God
제 5 장 · Week 5: Reading and Writing Arguments
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Bones of an Argument
  2. Lecture 5-2: Induction, Best Explanation and Evidence
  3. Lecture 5-3: Common Fallacies and Traps
  4. Lecture 5-4: Mystery, Paradox and Contradiction
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing the Bones of a Text
제 6 장 · Week 6: Evil, and the Place of Philosophy
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Problem of Evil, Stated Fairly
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ways of Answering: Free Will, Soul-Making and More
  3. Lecture 6-3: Against Theodicy, and the Cross
  4. Lecture 6-4: Neither Enemy nor Servant: Putting the Course Together
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My Philosophy and My Theology on One Page

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

22분

Lecture 6-2 gave some answers to the problem of evil. This lecture asks a different question: is it right to give such answers at all? Some serious thinkers, believers among them, say that the attempt to explain why God allows evil is itself morally troubling. This lecture sets out that view fairly, with its strongest form and its weak point. It then turns to a different way in which the Christian tradition speaks to evil: not by explaining it but by pointing to a God who is present in suffering, and in particular to the cross. Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox writers have each spoken of this in their own way.

The lecture ends with what a student can and cannot do with this chapter when standing beside a person who suffers. It gives one short sentence of pointer and no method of care. As before, this is a chapter about arguments, and parts of it may touch a loss of your own. You may pass over them.

이 22분으로 얻는 것

  • State the view that attempting a theodicy is morally troubling, in its strongest form, and name its weak point.
  • Explain in plain terms what is meant by the suffering God, and how Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox writers each speak of it.
  • Say why the cross is not offered in Christian tradition as an explanation of evil.
  • Say what a student of this chapter can and cannot say to a person in pain, and where to send that person for help.

He was despised, and rejected by men; a man of suffering, and acquainted with disease. He was despised as one from whom men hide their face; and we didn’t respect him." — Isaiah 53:3

World English Bible

Surely he has borne our sickness, and carried our suffering; yet we considered him plagued, struck by God, and afflicted." — Isaiah 53:4

WEB

But he was pierced for our transgressions. He was crushed for our iniquities. The punishment that brought our peace was on him; and by his wounds we are healed." — Isaiah 53:5

WEB

For it became him, for whom are all things, and through whom are all things, in bringing many children to glory, to make the author of their salvation perfect through sufferings." — Hebrews 2:10

WEB

For we don’t have a high priest who can’t be touched with the feeling of our infirmities, but one who has been in all points tempted like we are, yet without sin." — Hebrews 4:15

WEB

What the text says. Isaiah 53 speaks of a servant who is despised and who carries the suffering of others. Hebrews 2:10 says that the author of salvation was made perfect through sufferings, and Hebrews 4:15 says that Christians have a high priest who is touched with the feeling of their weaknesses. A tradition's reading. Christians have read Isaiah 53 as pointing to Jesus. They differ in how they understand what the cross accomplishes (Reformed readers often stress the bearing of punishment; Catholic readers stress the offering of love and the sacrifice; Orthodox readers stress the defeat of death and the healing of human nature). The Jewish tradition reads the servant in other ways, and the text itself does not name him in the passage. Our judgement. None of these verses explains why evil exists, and none is offered here as an answer to the problem of lecture 6-1. They say something different: that the one whom Christians call God's Son has gone into suffering. Whether this answers the problem, or only changes how we stand in it, is a question on which readers differ.

1. An objection to the whole business

In lecture 6-2 we studied answers to the problem of evil. A reader may by now feel uneasy, and the unease has a name and a long history. It is the view that to attempt a is itself a mistake, and a moral one. This is sometimes called the anti-theodicy view.

Here is its strongest form. Suppose that someone has suffered a terrible loss, and another person says to them: "Here is why God allowed it." The one who speaks has claimed to know the mind of God. If the reason is wrong, he has misled; if it is right, it may seem to say that the evil was worth it, and the sufferer is asked to agree that what was done to them, or to someone they loved, was part of a good plan. Many people feel that this is an insult. They say that some evils are so terrible that to find a use for them is already to betray the victims. A famous novel, which many readers know even if they have not read it, puts this protest into the mouth of a character who says that no future harmony could justify the suffering of an innocent child, and that he respectfully hands back his ticket. We mention it only as an example of how deeply the feeling runs. It is a story, and the character is not the author's last word.

A thinker who holds this view might add three points. First, the defender of faith is not forced to give a theodicy, since a defence, as in lecture 6-1, claims less. Second, the Bible does not give a theodicy: Job's friends offer one and are rebuked. Third, an answer that is offered to the sufferer is often not for the sufferer at all but for the comfort of the one who speaks. We do not want to look at a pain that has no explanation, so we make one.

This is a point where readers will not agree: whether attempts at theodicy are legitimate. One side holds that they are. In its strongest form: Christians make claims about God, and a claim about God's goodness that could not even in principle be defended against the evidence would be empty. Thoughtful believers and doubters want to know whether the faith can be held with an honest mind, and refusing to try to answer is a refusal to think. This side adds that a general argument is different from a word to a person in pain, and that the two should not be confused: a theodicy written in a study is not a sentence spoken at a bedside. The weak point of this side is that the line between a study and a bedside is not always clear, and arguments made in one place are carried to the other, often by people who did not mean harm; and that a theodicy may claim to know what God has not told us.

The other side holds that theodicy is a mistake, either because it claims knowledge that we do not have, or because it treats the evil as a problem to be solved when it is a wrong to be resisted and a grief to be shared. In its strongest form: the right response to terrible evil is to oppose it, to comfort those who suffer and to lament, not to explain; and a faith that needs an explanation to survive is a thin faith. The weak point of this side is that it can leave a thoughtful person with a question and no way of thinking about it, and that those who refuse to explain may seem to leave unanswered the doubts of people who sincerely seek an answer. Some people who hold this view reply that they are not refusing to think, only refusing a certain kind of thought, and they keep a place for careful defences.

This course asks you to state each side fairly and to say why you think as you do. It does not require you to choose. A person may hold that careful defences are good in the study and that explanations at the bedside are wrong. Many do.

2. The cross: not an explanation but a presence

If the Christian faith does not mainly answer the problem of evil with a theory, what does it do? Here is a place where the tradition says something that is different in kind: it points to the cross.

Notice first what the cross is not said to be. It is not said to be an explanation of why there is evil. Christians do not say that Jesus died in order to show us why children suffer. The cross is held to be an act: God, in Christ, entering the world of suffering and death, taking part in it, and acting to overcome it. Whether this is an answer to the problem is a question on which readers differ. But it changes the question. The believer who asks, "Where is God when people suffer?" is, in the Christian story, pointed to a God who is not far away from suffering, who has been despised and rejected, who cried out in pain, and who died.

3. The suffering God: three voices

Christians speak of this in different ways, and the differences matter. We describe each as it would describe itself, as far as we are sure, and we do not rank them.

Many Protestant writers, especially in the last two centuries, have stressed the cross as the place where God is most fully shown. Some, such as Jürgen Moltmann in a well-known twentieth-century book called The Crucified God, have argued that the cross must be understood as something that happens in God, so that God is not untouched by suffering but shares it. Others in the Reformed, Lutheran and Evangelical traditions hold that God's being is unchanged, and speak instead of God taking suffering on himself in the person of the Son. These are different positions, and there is a long debate among Protestants about them.

The Catholic tradition has long held that God, in the divine nature, does not change or suffer, and that Jesus Christ, who is one person and truly God, suffered and died in his human nature. In this view, it is truly God who suffers on the cross, though not in the divine nature as such. Catholic writers in the twentieth century have gone further in different directions, and some have spoken of suffering as in some way in the life of God. A reader should not assume that all Catholic theologians say the same thing; a Catholic reader would say more than we do.

The Orthodox tradition also holds that the divine nature does not change, and stresses that one of the persons of the suffered in the flesh, a way of speaking that has deep roots in the early church. Orthodox worship, especially in Holy Week, dwells on Christ's suffering and death, and on his descent to the place of the dead and his rising, as the defeat of death itself. Here suffering and death are met by a victory that is also a healing, and the whole of the church is the setting in which this is known.

Notice what the three have in common, and what they do not. All three say that God, in Christ, is not distant from suffering. They differ on how to speak of what happens in God. The disagreement is partly about words: what does it mean to say that God "suffers"? Lecture 4-2 and lecture 4-3, on analogy and the negative way, showed how hard it is to use human words of God. The same difficulty is here. The doctrines of God and of Christ themselves belong to the doctrine courses; for us it is enough to see how the philosophical question of evil meets the Christian story at this point.

4. What the suffering God does and does not do

It helps to be exact. Saying that God suffers with us does not solve the problem of evil in the sense of lecture 6-1. A critic can reply: if God is with us in suffering, why does God allow it? The point does not remove the question. What it does is to change how the believer stands. The believer is not asked to praise a God who looks on from a safe place. The believer is told of a God who has gone through the worst, and who is, in the faith of the church, at work to overcome it, with a hope that Christians call resurrection. For many people in pain this is a great comfort. For others it is not: it does not take the pain away, and a God who suffers may seem weaker, not better. Readers differ, and they are not wrong to differ.

Nor does the cross make suffering good. Christians have been warned against the idea that suffering is good in itself, or that a person who suffers is closer to God than one who does not, or that a person should seek pain. The cross is not an endorsement of pain. It is held to be a defeat of it.

5. What a student can and cannot do with this chapter

A student who has read this chapter may be asked, by a friend, a church member or a family member, a hard question about why a loved one suffers or died. What can the student say?

A short and honest answer is this. The arguments in this chapter are for study, for teaching and for clear thought. They are not words for a person in pain. At a bedside the student has no need to explain, and is wise not to. Presence, silence and a willingness to hear are worth more than any argument. This lecture gives no method of , and it should not be used as one. For that, a student should go to a pastor or priest, and to the course on the theology of suffering mentioned in lecture 6-1.

If anyone you know, or you yourself, is in danger, or speaks of ending their life, do not try to answer with an argument, and do not leave them alone. Speak at once to a pastor or priest and to your local emergency number or a local crisis line.


Diagram 1. Two ways of meeting evil

Against theodicy, and the cross A debate readers will not settle, and a presence that is not an explanation For attempting a theodicy Claims about God should face the evidence. A study is not a bedside. Weak point: the line blurs; may claim to know God's reasons. Against theodicy To find a use for evil can betray victims. Evil is to be resisted and mourned. Weak point: may leave honest questioners with no way to think. The cross: God not far from suffering Protestant: the cross as the place God is shown; debate over whether suffering is in God. Catholic: God the Son suffers in his human nature; writers go further in different ways. Orthodox: one of the Trinity suffered in the flesh; death is defeated and healed. All three: God is not distant. Differences: what to say of God's own being. This chapter gives arguments, not pastoral care. In danger: pastor or priest, and your local emergency number or crisis line.

핵심 요약

  • Some thinkers say that attempting a theodicy is itself morally troubling, because it can find a use for evil and claim to know God's reasons.
  • Others say that careful defences are needed, since claims about God must face evidence, and that a study is not a bedside.
  • Christians do not offer the cross as an explanation of evil; they point to God in Christ going into suffering and death to overcome them.
  • Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox writers speak differently of God and suffering, but all say that God is not distant from it.
  • Saying that God suffers with us does not remove the question why evil is allowed; it changes how the believer stands in it.
  • The arguments of this chapter are not words for a person in pain; in danger, turn to a pastor or priest and local emergency help.
Front Back
Anti-theodicy view Attempting to explain why God allows evil can wrong victims and claim knowledge we lack; evil is to be resisted and mourned.
Reply to it Claims about God must face the evidence, and a study is not a bedside; weak point: the line blurs.
The cross and evil Not an explanation, but God in Christ entering suffering and death to overcome them.
Three voices on the suffering God Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox differ on how to speak of what happens in God; all say God is not distant.

One sentence to remember Whether or not we explain evil, the Christian story points to a God who has gone into suffering, and a person in pain needs company more than an argument.

This week's action Write down, for yourself, one thing you would not say to a person in pain, and one thing you could do instead.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Why might an explanation of evil, offered to a sufferer, feel like an insult? Can you state the objection so that someone who holds it would agree with your wording?
  • State both sides of the question whether attempts at theodicy are legitimate, each with its weak point. Is there a position between them?
  • Why does the Christian tradition not present the cross as an explanation of why evil exists? What does it present it as?
  • How do Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox writers each speak of God and suffering? What do all three share?
  • If God is with us in suffering, does that answer the problem of evil, or only change how we stand in it? Why might readers differ?
  • What can a student of this chapter do for a person who suffers, and what should be left to a pastor or priest?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.