Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
Contents 37
- Lecture 1-1: Gospel as a Genre: Biography, History, or Something Else
- Lecture 1-2: Oral Tradition, Written Sources, and How the Gospels Reached Us
- Lecture 1-3: Why Three, and Why They Are Called Synoptic
- Lecture 2-1: The Data: Agreements, Disagreements, and Order
- Lecture 2-2: The Two-Source Theory and the Case for Q
- Lecture 2-3: The Alternatives: Griesbach, Farrer, and the Present State of the Question
- Lecture 3-1: Galilee and Judea under Rome
- Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
- Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
- Lecture 4-1: Structure, Pace, and the Shape of Mark's Story
- Lecture 4-2: Mark's Christology and the Question of the Messianic Secret
- Lecture 4-3: Discipleship, Failure, and the Ending at 16:8
- Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
- Lecture 5-2: Fulfilment, Scripture, and the Law in Matthew
- Lecture 5-3: The Community Addressed: Church, Mission, and Judgment
- Lecture 6-1: Luke's Preface, Sources, and Claim to Orderly Account
- Lecture 6-2: Reversal: The Poor, Women, Samaritans, and Outsiders
- Lecture 6-3: The Spirit, Prayer, and the Journey to Jerusalem
- Lecture 7-1: What Jesus Announced, and What His Hearers Would Have Heard
- Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
- Lecture 7-3: The Sermon on the Mount and the Demands of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-1: How Parables Work, and How They Have Been Misread
- Lecture 8-2: Parables of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal
- Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
- Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil
- Lecture 9-3: How Historians and Theologians Have Handled the Miracle Accounts
- Lecture 10-1: The Sabbath and Purity Controversies
- Lecture 10-2: The Temple Action and What It Meant
- Lecture 10-3: Jesus and the Restoration of Israel: The Twelve and the Nations
- Lecture 11-1: The Last Supper and the Arrest
- Lecture 11-2: Trial, Crucifixion, and the Three Passion Narratives Compared
- Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts
Read straight through the Gospel of Mark with a pencil and mark the setting of each scene, and a pattern appears that most readers have never noticed. The synagogue, which looms large in the popular imagination of Jesus' ministry, is the named setting of only a handful of episodes. The Temple does not appear at all until chapter 11, and then dominates three chapters. What carries the bulk of the narrative is neither: it is the road, the lakeshore, and above all the house. Someone's house, usually unnamed, sometimes Simon's, is where Jesus eats, heals, teaches, is crowded, is interrupted, is anointed, and is asked what he meant.
This lecture takes the three spaces in turn and asks, for each, what we actually know. The answers are uneven. About the Temple we know a great deal, because Josephus describes it at length, the Mishnah preserves detailed traditions about it, and the platform itself still stands. About the first-century synagogue we know much less than confident textbooks suggest, and the honest position on several questions is that the evidence is thin and disputed. About ordinary houses we know a surprising amount, because houses are what archaeologists most often dig, but we know it in the form of floor plans and pottery rather than of the relationships conducted inside them.
The second half of the lecture takes up what happened in those spaces — specifically, meals. Table fellowship is one of the most persistent points of conflict in the Synoptic Gospels, and to a modern reader the intensity of the conflict is puzzling. Explaining it has been the great achievement, and the great risk, of the social-scientific reading of the New Testament associated with Bruce Malina and the Context Group. The lecture presents that approach at its best and then presents the objection that its central model may be an anachronism.
What these 34 minutes give you
- State what the archaeological evidence for pre-70 synagogue buildings actually consists of, and explain why the question "was the synagogue a building or a gathering?" does not have a single answer.
- Describe the Herodian Temple's scale, its system of concentric courts, and the pilgrimage festivals, and explain the economic and political dimensions of the institution alongside the religious one.
- Show, with reference to specific passages, how large a proportion of Synoptic scenes are set in a household, and explain what difference this makes to how the Gospels are preached.
- Explain why the composition of a meal was a public claim in this setting, and set out the honour-and-shame reading of that fact together with the charge of anachronism brought against it.
- Describe with appropriate caution the position of women, children, and slaves in a first-century Galilean or Judean household, distinguishing legal norms from the evidence for actual practice.
They went into Capernaum, and immediately on the Sabbath day he entered into the synagogue and taught. They were astonished at his teaching, for he taught them as having authority, and not as the scribes. — Mark 1:21-22
World English Bible
Immediately, when they had come out of the synagogue, they came into the house of Simon and Andrew, with James and John. Now Simon’s wife’s mother lay sick with a fever, and immediately they told him about her. He came and took her by the hand, and raised her up. The fever left her, and she served them. — Mark 1:29-31
WEB
One of the Pharisees invited him to eat with him. He entered into the Pharisee’s house, and sat at the table. Behold, a woman in the city who was a sinner, when she knew that he was reclining in the Pharisee’s house, she brought an alabaster jar of ointment. Standing behind at his feet weeping, she began to wet his feet with her tears, and she wiped them with the hair of her head, kissed his feet, and anointed them with the ointment. — Luke 7:36-38
WEB
He was reclining at the table in his house, and many tax collectors and sinners sat down with Jesus and his disciples, for there were many, and they followed him. The scribes and the Pharisees, when they saw that he was eating with the sinners and tax collectors, said to his disciples, “Why is it that he eats and drinks with tax collectors and sinners?” When Jesus heard it, he said to them, “Those who are healthy have no need for a physician, but those who are sick. I came not to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance.” — Mark 2:15-17
WEB
As he went out of the temple, one of his disciples said to him, “Teacher, see what kind of stones and what kind of buildings!” Jesus said to him, “Do you see these great buildings? There will not be left here one stone on another, which will not be thrown down.” — Mark 13:1-2
WEB
Notice what Mark 1:21-31 does in eleven verses: synagogue, then house, and the transition is made with a single participle. The two settings sit next to each other in the same day, and the narrative gives no sign that moving from one to the other is a move from public to private in our sense. Luke 7:36-38 and Mark 2:15-17 are the lecture's two meal scenes, chosen because they run in opposite directions — in one, Jesus is a guest in a Pharisee's house and an uninvited woman creates the crisis; in the other, he is at a table with tax collectors and the objection comes from outside. Mark 13:1-2 gives the Temple as a disciple from the countryside saw it, and Jesus' answer, which will be taken up properly in chapter 10 of this course.
1. The synagogue: less certain than you were told
Start with the word. Greek synagoge means a gathering or assembly, and it can denote the people assembled or, by extension, the place where they assemble. This ambiguity is not a translation problem to be solved; it reflects a real situation in which both meanings were current, and quite possibly current in different places at the same time.
What does the archaeology show? A small number of buildings in Palestine have been identified as pre-70 synagogues, among them structures at Gamla in the Golan, Masada, Herodium, and — more recently and more relevantly for this course — Magdala on the western shore of the Sea of Galilee, excavated from 2009, which produced a first-century assembly hall with benches and a carved stone block. These finds are real and important. But they are few, and several of the identifications have been argued over, because a rectangular hall with benches along the walls is not self-evidently a synagogue rather than a council chamber or a communal building of another kind.
The famous synagogue at Capernaum illustrates the difficulty precisely. The white limestone building visible today is a later structure, generally dated to the fourth or fifth century. Beneath it excavators found basalt walls that some, notably the Franciscan excavators Virgilio Corbo and Stanislao Loffreda, identified as a first-century synagogue — the very building of Mark 1:21 — while others have questioned whether those foundations are an earlier synagogue or simply an earlier structure. Luke 7:5 says a centurion built the synagogue at Capernaum for the people, which if historical would explain a substantial building in a modest village. Whether the stones under the white synagogue are that building remains disputed.
Were there synagogue buildings?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Two positions have been argued at length. Howard Clark Kee argued that purpose-built synagogue buildings in Palestine are essentially a post-70 development, and that in the first century synagoge in the Gospels usually means a congregation gathering in whatever space was available, often a house. Against this, Richard Bauckham, Rachel Hachlili, and others have argued from the excavated halls, from Josephus, from the first-century Theodotus inscription in Jerusalem — a Greek dedication recording the building of a synagogue for the reading of the Law and the teaching of the commandments — and from Philo, that dedicated buildings did exist in the first century, if not everywhere. The present state of the discussion favours something between the two: buildings existed in some places, especially larger settlements and Diaspora cities, while in small villages the assembly might well have met in a courtyard or a house. This is unsatisfying, and it is what the evidence supports.
What went on there is somewhat clearer than what the building looked like. The Theodotus inscription, Philo, Josephus, and the New Testament converge on reading from the Law and the Prophets, translation and exposition, and prayer. Luke 4:16-17 describes Jesus standing up to read from a scroll of Isaiah handed to him, which fits that picture. The synagogue also served communal functions — a place of assembly, hospitality, and local business. What it was not, in this period, is a temple: there was one Temple, in Jerusalem, and no sacrifice happened anywhere else.
Not synagogue clergy
One further caution. The scribes with whom Jesus' teaching is contrasted in Mark 1:22 are not "the synagogue clergy." Scribes were literate professionals — copyists, legal experts, administrators — attached variously to the Temple, to households of the wealthy, and to villages. Their expertise gave them authority; they held no synagogue office.
2. The Temple: scale, courts, and economy
Here the sources are abundant. Herod the Great began a vast reconstruction of the Temple around 20 BCE, and John 2:20 has interlocutors saying it had been forty-six years in building; work continued, on Josephus's account, until a few years before the destruction. Herod doubled the size of the platform, creating the largest sacred enclosure in the Roman world — the retaining walls survive, and the western one is the wall at which Jews have prayed ever since. The disciple's exclamation in Mark 13:1 about "what kind of stones and what kind of buildings" is the reaction of a person from a village where the largest building he had seen was a basalt house.
The layout was concentric, and the concentricity was the theology. From the outside inward: the great outer court, open to anyone including Gentiles; then a barrier with inscriptions in Greek and Latin warning non-Jews not to proceed on pain of death (two copies of that inscription have been found, which is a rare case of an artefact confirming a literary report exactly); then the court of the women; then the court of Israel, for Jewish men; then the court of the priests with the altar of burnt offering; then the sanctuary building itself, and within it the Holy of Holies, entered once a year by the high priest on the Day of Atonement. Each boundary marked a degree of access, and access was graded by ritual status.
Three consequences deserve naming.
Economically, the Temple was the largest institution in the region. It employed thousands — priests serving in rotation, Levites, musicians, guards, and a construction workforce that Josephus numbers in the thousands and whose eventual unemployment, when the work finished, he treats as a civic problem. It received the annual half-shekel from Jewish men throughout the world, tithes, and the constant traffic of sacrificial animals. Money-changing existed at the Temple because the offering was payable in a particular coinage and pilgrims arrived with what they had; this is context for Mark 11:15-17, though chapter 10 of this course will take that scene up properly.
Politically, its leadership served at Roman pleasure. The prefect had custody of the high priest's vestments for part of this period and the power of appointment, and the family of Annas held the office repeatedly across two generations. Luke 3:2 names Annas and Caiaphas together, which as a formal description of the office is imprecise and as a description of where power actually sat is quite accurate.
As a place of pilgrimage, it filled the city periodically to many times its normal size. Josephus gives festival crowd figures that modern historians regard as greatly inflated; estimates derived from the city's area and water supply are far lower, and even the low estimates imply a city under severe strain three times a year. The passion narratives are set during one of those periods, and the nervousness of both the Roman prefect and the priestly leadership in those chapters is entirely intelligible on that basis alone. Luke 2:41-42 describes Jesus' family going up annually — evidence, if the tradition is reliable, that a Galilean household of modest means made the journey.
3. The household: the most common setting and the least discussed
Now the neglected space. Consider how much of Mark happens in a house: the healing of Simon's mother-in-law (1:29-31); the paralysed man let down through the roof, in a house so crowded that "there was no more room, not even around the door" (2:1-2); the meal with tax collectors (2:15); the accusation that Jesus is beside himself, brought by his family to a house (3:20-21); the private explanation of parables (7:17; 9:28; 10:10); the child set in the midst (9:33-37); the anointing at Bethany (14:3). Luke adds Martha and Mary (10:38-42), the Pharisee's dinner (7:36-50; 11:37; 14:1), and Zacchaeus (19:1-10). Any count depends on judgment calls about unnamed settings, but on a reasonable reckoning the household is the single most frequent identifiable setting in the Synoptic tradition, ahead of both synagogue and Temple.
What was such a house? Excavation at Capernaum and comparable Galilean sites shows a characteristic form: small rooms of basalt with a beaten earth or stone floor, roofs of beams, branches, and packed mud — a roof through which a determined party could indeed dig, as Mark 2:4 says, and which had to be repaired annually — grouped around a shared courtyard where the cooking, the grinding, and much of the work of daily life took place. Several related families would share a courtyard complex. There was little that a modern reader would recognise as privacy. This matters for reading: when Mark says Jesus went into a house and a crowd gathered so that they could not even eat, he is not describing an unusual intrusion into a private space. A courtyard was already semi-public.
The Greek oikos or oikia, house, accordingly means more than a building. It means a household — the people, the property, the dependents, the slaves if any, and the standing of the whole in the eyes of neighbours. When the Gospels speak of a household believing, or of peace coming to a house, they mean this unit.
4. Why the composition of a meal was an argument
To eat with someone in this world was to declare something publicly. Meals were conducted where others could see; guest lists were known; the seating expressed rank, which is why Luke 14:7-11 can build a parable on the choice of places. A shared table implied acceptance, and acceptance implied a judgment about the other person's standing.
Two further considerations sharpen the point in a Jewish setting. Food itself was subject to law — what could be eaten, how it was tithed, whether it had been prepared in a state of purity — so that eating with a person about whose practice one was uncertain raised real questions, not merely social ones. And the term "sinners," in the Gospels' controversy scenes, is not a general description of human moral failure; in these contexts it appears to denote people whose occupation or way of life placed them outside acceptable practice, tax collectors being the standing example. This is why Mark 2:16 is a serious question rather than a piece of snobbery: "Why is it that he eats and drinks with tax collectors and sinners?"
Luke 7:36-38 shows the same dynamic from the other side. Jesus is the guest of a Pharisee, reclining at table — the posture indicates a formal meal — and a woman known in the town as a sinner comes in and touches him. She can come in because such a meal was not a closed private occasion. The host's objection, which Luke reports as an inward thought, is not about hospitality but about what Jesus' acceptance of the contact implies about his discernment.
This is a point where readers will not agree. How should this material be theorised? Bruce Malina's The New Testament World: Insights from Cultural Anthropology (1981) and the work of the Context Group — John Pilch, Jerome Neyrey, Richard Rohrbaugh — proposed that the ancient Mediterranean was a culture organised around honour and shame as its central social values, in which honour was a limited good, publicly contested and publicly conferred, and in which the individual was dyadic, understanding himself through the group rather than as a modern autonomous self. On this reading, table fellowship, challenge-and-riposte dialogues, and the frequency of public questioning in the Gospels all fall into place at once.
The gain is genuine: this approach put the social dimension of the texts on the agenda and produced readings of specific scenes that are hard to improve on. The objection is equally genuine, and has been pressed by Louise Joy Lawrence, Zeba Crook, and others. The honour-and-shame model was constructed by twentieth-century anthropologists working in modern Mediterranean villages, and applying it to the first century risks a double error: assuming that a modern region is culturally continuous with an ancient one, and treating a model as evidence, so that texts are read to confirm what the model already predicted. Zeba Crook has argued specifically that the model's account of honour as a fixed, limited quantity does not survive scrutiny of the ancient sources. A moderate position, and the one this lecture recommends, is to use the model as a source of questions rather than answers: it is a good instrument for noticing that a meal is a public act, and a poor instrument for deciding what any particular participant felt.
5. Women, children, and slaves in these spaces
Here caution has to be doubled, because the sources describe norms and the norms were not uniformly practised.
Women. Legal and literary sources of the period assume male authority in the household, place women's work primarily in the household economy, and restrict women's role in public legal and religious life; the Temple's court of the women marks a boundary of access. But the same sources show women managing property, trading, and travelling, and the Gospels themselves show women following Jesus and supporting the movement financially (Luke 8:1-3), receiving teaching in a posture Luke describes as sitting at his feet (10:39), and being the first at the tomb in all three Synoptics. Older claims that Jewish women were forbidden to learn or excluded from the synagogue rest largely on later rabbinic passages, and are now treated with considerable caution — this is one of the places where a Christian reader should be most alert to the temptation identified in lecture 3-2, of making Judaism dark so that Jesus may appear bright.
Children. A child had no legal standing and no social honour of its own; children died in very large numbers before adulthood, and the household's economy depended on their labour from an early age. This is what gives Mark 10:13-16 its edge. The disciples' rebuke is the conventional response, not a lapse in manners, and the saying that one must receive the Kingdom of God like a little child is an unsettling one precisely because it asks the hearer to identify with the household's least significant member.
Slaves. The Greek doulos, in the Gospels usually rendered "servant," means a slave, and the parables are full of them — stewards, debtors, watchmen, the slave beaten for negligence. The Gospels neither defend nor attack the institution; they use it as narrative furniture, which is itself a fact worth registering rather than passing over. Modern readers who hear "servant" as an employee lose both the harshness of several parables and the force of the sayings that invert the relation.
6. Where this leaves the reader
The claim of this lecture is not that knowing the floor plan of a Capernaum house unlocks the Gospels. It is narrower and, if accepted, more demanding: that a number of scenes which appear to modern readers to be about interior states — sincerity, humility, self-righteousness — are in their setting about public acts with public meanings. Who is at the table, who touches whom, who is admitted to which court, who is allowed to interrupt. The interior reading is not wrong, but it is a second step, and taking it first has a cost. It quietly converts a set of arguments about the shape of a community into a set of lessons about attitudes, which is a considerably easier thing to agree with.
The first diagram shows the three settings with what we know about each and how securely we know it.
The second diagram shows the Temple's concentric courts, which are the architecture of graded access.
6. Further Reading
- Anders Runesson, Donald D. Binder, and Birger Olsson, The Ancient Synagogue from Its Origins to 200 C.E.: A Source Book (Brill, 2008) — the primary evidence gathered in one place, which is the only way to judge how thin or thick it is.
- Lee I. Levine, The Ancient Synagogue: The First Thousand Years, 2nd edition (Yale University Press, 2005) — the standard large-scale treatment.
- E. P. Sanders, Judaism: Practice and Belief, 63 BCE - 66 CE (SCM/ Press, 1992) — part two is the fullest accessible account of the Temple, its personnel, and the festivals.
- Jonathan L. Reed, Archaeology and the Galilean Jesus (Trinity Press International, 2000) — on Capernaum's houses, size, and material culture.
- Bruce J. Malina, The New Testament World: Insights from Cultural Anthropology, 3rd edition (Westminster John Knox, 2001) — the honour-and-shame reading in its own voice.
- Zeba A. Crook, "Honor, Shame, and Social Status Revisited," Journal of Biblical Literature 128 (2009), 591-611 — the principal methodological objection to that reading.
- Carolyn Osiek and David L. Balch, Families in the New Testament World: Households and House Churches (Westminster John Knox, 1997) — on the household as a social and architectural unit.
- Tal Ilan, Jewish Women in Greco-Roman Palestine (Mohr Siebeck, 1995) — a source-critical study that distinguishes legal norm from attested practice.
In short
- Evidence for pre-70 synagogue buildings is thin and disputed: only a handful of identified halls exist (Gamla, Masada, Herodium, Magdala from 2009), the famous Capernaum synagogue's white limestone structure is 4th-5th century, and whether basalt walls beneath it are first-century is contested — so "was the synagogue a building or a gathering?" has no single answer and likely depended on the place.
- The Herodian Temple's concentric courts (outer court open to all including Gentiles, a warning barrier confirmed by two surviving inscribed stones, the court of women, the court of Israel, the court of priests, the Holy of Holies entered once yearly) graded access by ritual status, and the Temple was simultaneously the region's largest employer, its main tax-collection point (the half-shekel, tithes), and an institution whose high priest served at Roman pleasure under the Annas family.
- The household, not the synagogue or Temple, is the single most frequent identifiable Synoptic setting — Simon's mother-in-law's healing, the paralytic through the roof, the tax collectors' meal, the family's "he is beside himself" accusation, and the anointing at Bethany all occur there — and a Galilean courtyard house afforded little privacy, so a crowd "not even around the door" (Mark 2:2) was the normal condition, not an intrusion.
- Sharing a meal was a public claim about the other person's standing, sharpened in a Jewish setting by food laws and purity concerns, which is why the question "why does he eat with tax collectors and sinners?" (Mark 2:16) is a serious challenge rather than snobbery, and why an uninvited "sinner" woman touching Jesus at a Pharisee's table (Luke 7:36-38) creates a public crisis.
- Bruce Malina's honour-and-shame model (limited good, publicly contested honour, the dyadic self) illuminates why meals and public challenge-dialogues mattered so much, but Zeba Crook and others object that it was built from modern Mediterranean anthropology and risks reading ancient texts to confirm a model rather than testing it — the recommended use is as a source of questions, not answers.
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Popular imagination puts most Gospel scenes in the synagogue, but the evidence for pre-70 synagogue buildings is thin (a handful of disputed sites like Gamla and Magdala, with Capernaum's famous structure actually dating centuries later), while the Temple is extensively documented as a graded, concentric space that was simultaneously the region's largest employer and its most politically fraught institution. The setting that actually dominates the narrative is the ordinary household — crowded, courtyard-based, with little of what a modern reader would call privacy — where Jesus eats, heals, and teaches more often than anywhere else. Because a shared table was a public declaration about someone's standing, meals like the one with "tax collectors and sinners" (Mark 2:15-17) or the anointing by an uninvited woman at a Pharisee's house (Luke 7:36-38) were genuine social controversies, not backdrops to an interior lesson about attitudes — a public reading the honour-and-shame model helps recover, even though critics rightly warn it can be pressed further than the ancient evidence supports.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Mark 1:21-31 moves from synagogue to house in a single sentence. If a courtyard house afforded little privacy, what happens to the common preaching distinction between Jesus' "public ministry" and his "private teaching to the disciples"?
- This lecture claims the household is the most frequent identifiable setting in the Synoptic tradition and the least preached. Test the first half of the claim by counting scenes in one Gospel. What judgment calls did you have to make, and could someone counting carefully reach a different result?
- Present the honour-and-shame model as its best advocates present it, and then state Zeba Crook's objection. Is there a way of using the model that survives the objection, or does the objection require abandoning it?
- The lecture warns against using later rabbinic sources to describe first-century women's exclusion, on the ground that it makes Judaism dark so that Jesus may appear bright. Where else in a typical sermon on the Gospels does that pattern appear, and what would replace it?
- Mark 10:13-16 is usually read as a scene about tenderness toward children. Read in terms of a child's actual standing in a first-century household, what is the saying asking of the hearer, and is the usual reading adequate?
- If the basalt walls beneath the Capernaum synagogue are not first-century, does anything in the reading of Mark 1:21 change? Consider what turns on archaeological confirmation and what does not.