FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT602E The Synoptic Gospels

Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil

Contents 37
BT602E The Synoptic Gospels
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Three Gospels, One Subject
  1. Introduction: Three Gospels, One Subject
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: What the Synoptic Gospels Are
  1. Lecture 1-1: Gospel as a Genre: Biography, History, or Something Else
  2. Lecture 1-2: Oral Tradition, Written Sources, and How the Gospels Reached Us
  3. Lecture 1-3: Why Three, and Why They Are Called Synoptic
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The Synoptic Problem
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Data: Agreements, Disagreements, and Order
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Two-Source Theory and the Case for Q
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Alternatives: Griesbach, Farrer, and the Present State of the Question
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The World in Which Jesus Taught
  1. Lecture 3-1: Galilee and Judea under Rome
  2. Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
  3. Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: The Gospel of Mark
  1. Lecture 4-1: Structure, Pace, and the Shape of Mark's Story
  2. Lecture 4-2: Mark's Christology and the Question of the Messianic Secret
  3. Lecture 4-3: Discipleship, Failure, and the Ending at 16:8
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Gospel of Matthew
  1. Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
  2. Lecture 5-2: Fulfilment, Scripture, and the Law in Matthew
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Community Addressed: Church, Mission, and Judgment
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Gospel of Luke
  1. Lecture 6-1: Luke's Preface, Sources, and Claim to Orderly Account
  2. Lecture 6-2: Reversal: The Poor, Women, Samaritans, and Outsiders
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Spirit, Prayer, and the Journey to Jerusalem
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: The Kingdom of God
  1. Lecture 7-1: What Jesus Announced, and What His Hearers Would Have Heard
  2. Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Sermon on the Mount and the Demands of the Kingdom
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: The Parables
  1. Lecture 8-1: How Parables Work, and How They Have Been Misread
  2. Lecture 8-2: Parables of the Kingdom
  3. Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Miracles, Exorcisms, and Healing
  1. Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
  2. Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil
  3. Lecture 9-3: How Historians and Theologians Have Handled the Miracle Accounts
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Jesus, the Law, the Temple, and Israel
  1. Lecture 10-1: The Sabbath and Purity Controversies
  2. Lecture 10-2: The Temple Action and What It Meant
  3. Lecture 10-3: Jesus and the Restoration of Israel: The Twelve and the Nations
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: Passion, Death, and Resurrection
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Last Supper and the Arrest
  2. Lecture 11-2: Trial, Crucifixion, and the Three Passion Narratives Compared
  3. Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: The Historical Jesus and the Gospels Today
  1. Lecture 12-1: The Quests for the Historical Jesus, from Reimarus to the Present
  2. Lecture 12-2: Criteria, Method, and What History Can and Cannot Establish
  3. Lecture 12-3: Preaching and Teaching the Synoptic Gospels

Jump to the key points ↓

38 min

Exorcism is the category of miracle account that modern Western readers find hardest to handle, and it is also the category that carries the most weight in the earliest Gospel. In Mark, the first public act of Jesus after the announcement of the reign of God and the calling of four disciples is an exorcism in the Capernaum synagogue, and the crowd's reaction to it defines what kind of authority the reader is being shown. Mark reports four extended exorcism narratives and refers to many more in summaries; the sending of the Twelve in Mark 6:7 is a commission with exorcism at its centre. John's Gospel, by contrast, contains no exorcism at all. That distribution is a datum requiring explanation whatever one concludes about the events themselves.

This lecture does three things. First, it takes the measure of the material: how much exorcism there is, where it sits structurally, and what the accounts have in common with and how they differ from the healing accounts examined in lecture 9-1. Second, it reconstructs the Beelzebul controversy as a piece of reasoning. This is important and often skipped. Mark 3:22-27 and its parallels in Matthew 12 and Luke 11 preserve one of the very few passages in the Synoptic tradition in which a formal argument, with stated premises and a conclusion, is attributed to Jesus; and its structure, once laid out, illuminates the notoriously difficult saying about blasphemy against the Holy Spirit that follows it in Mark.

Third, the lecture takes up two live disagreements about how the exorcism accounts should be understood today: whether the phenomena described are best redescribed in the categories of modern psychiatry and neurology, and whether the political reading of the Gerasene account advanced by Ched Myers — in which the demon's name "Legion" is heard as a reference to Roman military occupation — is exegesis or importation. On the first, the lecture will insist on a point of fact that is frequently misstated in Protestant academic settings: exorcism is not a historical curiosity but a maintained practice, with authorised rites, in the Catholic and Orthodox churches and across large parts of the Pentecostal and charismatic world, which together account for a very large proportion of the world's Christians. Whatever a student concludes, the practice must be described accurately and not as a survival of superstition.

What these 38 minutes give you

  • Describe the distribution and structural placement of exorcism accounts in Mark, Matthew, and Luke, and state the difference between an exorcism narrative and a healing narrative in formal terms.
  • Set out the Beelzebul controversy as an argument, identifying its premises, the parable of the strong man, and the function of the "by whom do your children cast them out" question.
  • Explain the saying about blasphemy against the Holy Spirit in its Markan context, and say why Mark 3:30 constrains the range of defensible interpretations.
  • Present both the redescription of possession in modern medical categories and the theological accounts underlying maintained exorcistic practice, each in its strongest form, without caricature of either.
  • State Ched Myers's political reading of Mark 5:1-20, the textual features that support it, and the principal objections to it.

The scribes who came down from Jerusalem said, “He has Beelzebul,” and, “By the prince of the demons he casts out the demons.” He summoned them, and said to them in parables, “How can Satan cast out Satan? If a kingdom is divided against itself, that kingdom cannot stand. If a house is divided against itself, that house cannot stand. If Satan has risen up against himself, and is divided, he can’t stand, but has an end. But no one can enter into the house of the strong man to plunder, unless he first binds the strong man; and then he will plunder his house. — Mark 3:22-27

World English Bible

But if I cast out demons by Beelzebul, by whom do your children cast them out? Therefore will they be your judges. But if I by the finger of God cast out demons, then the Kingdom of God has come to you. — Luke 11:19-20

WEB

If I by Beelzebul cast out demons, by whom do your children cast them out? Therefore they will be your judges. But if I by the Spirit of God cast out demons, then the Kingdom of God has come upon you. — Matthew 12:27-28

WEB

When he saw Jesus from afar, he ran and bowed down to him, and crying out with a loud voice, he said, “What have I to do with you, Jesus, you Son of the Most High God? I adjure you by God, don’t torment me.” For he said to him, “Come out of the man, you unclean spirit!” He asked him, “What is your name?” He said to him, “My name is Legion, for we are many.” — Mark 5:6-9

WEB

The two central passages are printed in both Lucan and Matthean form deliberately. The double citation puts a small but important piece of Synoptic data in front of the reader: Luke says "finger of God" and Matthew says "Spirit of God," in otherwise closely parallel sentences. Which is the earlier wording is disputed. Most scholars have judged Luke's the more likely original, on the grounds that "finger of God" is the harder and more Semitic phrase, recalling Exodus 8:19, and that Matthew's "Spirit" fits his own usage; a minority argue the reverse. The disagreement is a useful reminder that the reconstruction of a saying is an argument, not a reading off.

1. How much exorcism there is, and where it sits

The bare distribution first.

Mark contains four extended exorcism narratives: the man in the Capernaum synagogue (1:21-28), the Gerasene (5:1-20), the Syrophoenician woman's daughter, healed at a distance (7:24-30), and the boy whom the disciples had failed to help (9:14-29). It contains summary references at 1:32-34, 1:39, and 3:11-12, and it makes exorcism part of the disciples' commission at 3:15 and 6:7, 6:13. It also preserves at 9:38-40 an incident in which an exorcist outside the circle of disciples is using Jesus' name, and is not stopped.

Matthew retains all four Markan narratives but abbreviates them sharply. The Gerasene account, twenty verses in Mark, becomes seven in Matthew (8:28-34), and Matthew has two possessed men rather than one — a doubling that also occurs in his treatment of Bartimaeus. Matthew adds the exorcism of a mute man (9:32-34) and of a man blind and mute (12:22), the latter serving as the occasion for the Beelzebul controversy in his arrangement. Luke retains the Markan material apart from the Syrophoenician account, adds the mute man's exorcism as the occasion of the Beelzebul controversy in his own arrangement (11:14), and adds notices about women who had been delivered, including Mary Magdalene, "from whom seven demons had gone out" (8:2).

John contains none. There is no exorcism in the Fourth Gospel, though it knows the accusation that Jesus has a demon (John 7:20; 8:48-52; 10:20). That absence is one of the sharper differences between John and the Synoptics noted in Chapter 1 of this course.

The structural placement in Mark is worth pausing on. Mark 1:14-15 announces the reign of God; 1:16-20 calls four disciples; 1:21-28 is the exorcism at Capernaum. The reign of God is announced, and then the first thing shown is a confrontation in which an unclean spirit identifies Jesus and is expelled:

Immediately there was in their synagogue a man with an unclean spirit, and he cried out, saying, “Ha! What do we have to do with you, Jesus, you Nazarene? Have you come to destroy us? I know you who you are: the Holy One of God!” Jesus rebuked him, saying, “Be quiet, and come out of him!” The unclean spirit, convulsing him and crying with a loud voice, came out of him. They were all amazed, so that they questioned among themselves, saying, “What is this? A new teaching? For with authority he commands even the unclean spirits, and they obey him!” — Mark 1:23-27 (WEB)

Notice how much is established in five verses. The spirit knows who Jesus is before any human character does — a feature that connects to the theme of the messianic secret treated in lecture 4-2, since Jesus silences it. The crowd's question links teaching and exorcism as a single phenomenon of authority: "a new teaching" is what they call an expulsion. And the confrontation is set in a synagogue on a Sabbath, which locates the conflict inside the ordinary religious life of a Galilean village rather than in some marginal setting.

2. What formally distinguishes an exorcism account

Applying lecture 9-1's four-part shape to an exorcism produces a recognisable but altered pattern, and the alterations are the interesting part.

The problem is stated as in a healing, often at length: the Gerasene has broken every chain, lives among the tombs, cries out night and day, cuts himself with stones. The demonstration and the reaction are present as usual: the man is found "sitting, clothed, and in his right mind," and the townspeople are afraid.

What is different is in the middle. An exorcism account has an opponent who speaks. No fever, no withered hand, and no storm answers back. The spirit recognises Jesus, protests, negotiates, and in the Gerasene account is interrogated and names itself. This gives the exorcism narratives a dialogic structure that no other class of miracle account has, and it also makes them the place where Christological titles are put into non-human mouths: "the Holy One of God," "Son of the Most High God."

A second difference is in technique, and it runs the other way from what students expect. Ancient exorcistic practice, as documented in the Greek magical papyri and in Jewish texts, characteristically involved apparatus: named powers invoked, adjurations, materials, in some accounts a ring and a root, as in Josephus's report of the exorcist Eleazar performing before Vespasian (Antiquities 8.46-49). Tobit 8:2-3 has a fish's liver and heart burned to drive off a demon. The Synoptic accounts have almost none of this. Jesus commands and the spirit leaves. Graham Twelftree, in Jesus the Exorcist (1993), made this comparative observation the centre of his argument, holding that the absence of the standard apparatus is a distinguishing feature of the Jesus tradition. The observation is sound as a description of the texts. The inference from it needs care, because narrative economy could also produce the same result — a writer may omit apparatus he considers unimportant to the point he is making — and because a note like Mark 9:29, "This kind can come out by nothing but by prayer," shows that the tradition did not think all cases equally simple.

3. The Beelzebul controversy as an argument

Now to the passage that is the doctrinal centre of the lecture.

The accusation is reported in Mark 3:22 in two forms that should be distinguished: that Jesus "has Beelzebul," meaning that he is himself possessed or under the control of that power, and that he casts out demons "by the prince of the demons," meaning that he operates with borrowed authority from that power. The name Beelzebul is of uncertain derivation. It is plausibly connected with a title meaning "lord of the exalted dwelling" or "lord of the house," and if that connection holds, the parable of the strong man's house that follows is a play on the name. Some manuscripts and the Latin tradition read "Beelzebub," "lord of flies," reflecting 2 Kings 1:2; the better-attested Greek form is Beelzebul.

The reply, in Mark's version, is a chain of reasoning:

  1. Reductio. "How can Satan cast out Satan?" If the accusation were true, one power would be attacking its own operations.
  2. Two supporting analogies. A kingdom divided cannot stand; a house divided cannot stand. These are not proofs; they are illustrations of a principle everyone accepts.
  3. Application. If Satan is divided against himself, he is finished. The accusation, taken seriously, entails the collapse of the very power it credits.
  4. Counter-proposal. "No one can enter into the house of the strong man to plunder, unless he first binds the strong man." The exorcisms are not collaboration with the strong man but a raid on his house, which presupposes that he has already been bound.

The Q version preserved in Matthew 12:27-28 and Luke 11:19-20 adds two further moves that Mark lacks, and both are significant.

The first is the question, "by whom do your children cast them out?" This is an argument from consistency: other Jewish exorcists were active and were not accused of collaborating with the enemy, so the accusation, if applied evenhandedly, would condemn the accusers' own associates. Two things follow that are worth stating explicitly, because both cut against a common misreading. Jesus is not presented here as the only exorcist of his time; he takes the existence of other successful exorcists for granted. And the argument would be pointless if their exorcisms were regarded as ineffective, so their effectiveness is presupposed. An early Christian writer had no incentive to invent this saying, which is the substance of the argument, familiar from Chapter 12's discussion of criteria, that its awkwardness tells in favour of its being early.

The second addition is the conclusion of Luke 11:20 / Matthew 12:28: if the exorcisms are worked by the finger, or Spirit, of God, then the reign of God "has come to you" — in Matthew, "upon you." This is the single verse in the Synoptic tradition where Jesus is reported as giving an interpretation of his own exorcisms, and it interprets them eschatologically. The exorcisms are not humanitarian relief plus a religious label; they are presented as the arrival of God's rule in a contested territory. This connects directly to the eschatology debate of Chapter 7, and it is one of the texts on which C. H. Dodd's realised eschatology rested most heavily, since the verb in question most naturally means arrival rather than approach.

4. Blasphemy against the Holy Spirit

Mark places immediately after this exchange the saying that has caused more anxiety than perhaps any other in the Gospel:

Most certainly I tell you, all sins of the descendants of man will be forgiven, including their blasphemies with which they may blaspheme; but whoever may blaspheme against the Holy Spirit never has forgiveness, but is subject to eternal condemnation.” — Mark 3:28-29 (WEB)

Two features of the context constrain interpretation, and both are regularly ignored when the verse is discussed as a free-standing puzzle.

The first is Mark 3:30, which supplies the evangelist's own explanatory note: the saying is given "because they said, 'He has an unclean spirit.'" Mark, in other words, tells the reader what the unforgivable blasphemy in this scene consists of. It is not a general category of especially grave sin, nor a private inner state, nor — as generations of frightened readers have supposed — a sin one might commit accidentally and then worry about having committed. It is the specific act of attributing the work of God's Spirit to an unclean spirit, made by people who have watched it and drawn that conclusion.

The second is the sweep of the first half of the saying. The emphasis of Mark 3:28 is on the extent of forgiveness — all sins, including blasphemies. The unforgivable case is stated as an exception against a background of remarkable generosity, and reading the passage as though its subject were the fragility of divine mercy inverts its structure.

Unforgivable sin views

Beyond that, interpretation divides, and it divides across confessional lines in ways worth naming rather than smoothing. The Catholic tradition, following a line running through Augustine and Thomas Aquinas and stated in the of the Catholic Church (1864), identifies the sin as final impenitence — the deliberate refusal of the mercy that is offered, which cannot be forgiven because forgiveness is refused, not because it is unavailable. The Orthodox tradition characteristically treats it in terms of a hardening that renders the person unwilling to repent, again locating the impossibility in the will rather than in a limit on divine mercy. Reformed writers have historically debated whether the sin can be committed after the apostolic period at all, some restricting it to those who witnessed the works directly. Wesleyan and later revivalist traditions, having a stronger doctrine of the possibility of falling away, have discussed it more anxiously and, in the judgment of a good deal of pastoral writing since, sometimes to their people's harm.

What these accounts share, and what the text supports, is that the passage concerns a settled refusal rather than an inadvertent lapse. What they do not share is the question of who can commit it and when. That question is not answered by Mark, and a lecture in Synoptic studies should say so rather than pick a confessional answer and present it as .

5. Possession and modern medical categories

This is a point where readers will not agree. Here are the two principal positions, each stated as its holders would state it.

The redescriptive position. On this reading, the phenomena reported in the Gospel exorcism accounts are recognisable, and modern medicine recognises them: convulsion, foaming, rigidity, and loss of consciousness in the boy of Mark 9 correspond closely to a generalised tonic-clonic seizure; the Gerasene's self-injury, social isolation, and disordered speech correspond to conditions that appear in modern psychiatric classification; mutism and deafness have organic and functional causes both. The first-century world had no such categories and possessed a well-developed spirit aetiology, so it described in the vocabulary available what a modern clinician would describe differently. The strong form of this position holds that the underlying realities are exhaustively captured by the medical description, and that the demonic vocabulary is a discarded first-century theory of causation, like the four humours. A more moderate form holds only that the descriptions are compatible with medical conditions and that the historian cannot say more. Rudolf Bultmann's programme, examined in the next lecture, gave this position its classic theological expression: the spirit-world of the New Testament belongs to a picture of reality that modern people cannot inhabit, and the task is to state what the text means without it.

The strongest evidence for the position is the fit of the details in Mark 9. The strongest objection to its strong form is that it is not derived from the evidence but presupposed: the claim that spirit causation is unavailable is a claim about what the world contains, and it is brought to the text rather than found there. A second objection, pressed from within anthropology by scholars such as Erika Bourguignon and I. M. Lewis, is that possession phenomena are widely and currently attested across many societies with a consistency that a simple mapping onto Western diagnostic categories does not capture, and that they characteristically occur among the socially marginal and function in ways a purely clinical description misses.

The continued-practice position. Exorcism is not a historical topic for a large part of the world church, and the practice as it actually exists is very different from the popular image of it. The Catholic Church revised its rite of exorcism in 1999 (De Exorcismis et Supplicationibus Quibusdam); the rite is reserved to a priest with the express permission of the local bishop, and the accompanying instructions require that medical and psychiatric assessment precede any judgment, with the explicit expectation that most cases presented will have other explanations. The Orthodox churches preserve exorcistic prayers, including those attributed to Basil the Great and John Chrysostom, and use them within the baptismal rite as well as in specific cases. Pentecostal and charismatic churches, which constitute several hundred million Christians, practise deliverance ministry widely, though with far more variation in oversight and considerably more internal criticism of abuses than outside observers usually realise.

The theological rationale in each case is not the claim that medical explanations are generally wrong. It is the claim that the category of medical explanation does not exhaust the possible causes of human affliction, combined in the Catholic and Orthodox cases with strict procedural requirements designed to prevent the misidentification of illness as possession. Stated that way, the position is not obviously less careful than the redescriptive one; it makes a metaphysical claim, but so does the strong form of the redescriptive position.

Two things need saying about the disagreement itself. First, the risk of harm runs in both directions and should be named honestly: treating a treatable illness as possession can and has led to the withholding of care, to prolonged confinement, and in documented cases to death; and treating every report of the kind as a category error can leave people whose distress has a social and moral shape with a purely pharmacological response to it. Second, the disagreement is not settled by exegesis. The Gospels describe what they describe; the question of what was happening is asked from outside, and each answer reflects a prior view of what can happen. A student who notices that has understood the shape of the problem, which is the aim of this section.

6. The Gerasene account and the political reading

The account in Mark 5:1-20 is the longest exorcism narrative in the Gospels and the strangest. A man among the tombs, unrestrainable; a confrontation; a demand for a name; the answer "Legion, for we are many"; a negotiation; a herd of about two thousand pigs drowned in the sea; a delivered man found in his right mind; and a town that asks Jesus to leave.

Ched Myers, in Binding the Strong Man: A Political Reading of Mark's Story of Jesus (1988), argued that the account carries a political charge that Western commentators had systematically failed to hear. His textual observations are these. The name given is legion, a Latin loanword denoting a Roman military formation of several thousand men, in a Gospel written under Roman rule. The verb used of the demons' request to be sent into the pigs, and the noun used for the herd, both have military resonance in Greek — the herd is described with a word used of a band of soldiers, and the pigs "charge" down the slope. The pig was the emblem of the Legio X Fretensis, stationed in the region after 70 CE. And the setting is the Decapolis, an area of Gentile cities associated with Roman administration. On Myers's reading, the narrative depicts the reign of God confronting the occupying power in symbolic form, and the town's request that Jesus depart is the reaction of a population that has accommodated itself to that power.

The reading has been influential, particularly in liberationist and postcolonial interpretation, and it has been developed further by writers such as Richard Horsley.

The objections are serious and should be stated with equal care. The military resonances of the Greek vocabulary are real but not univocal; the word used of the herd can denote a group of animals without any military sense, and building an argument on the accumulation of such resonances risks finding a pattern that a first-century hearer would not have registered. The Legio X association is chronologically awkward if Mark is dated before 70 CE, and it is at best suggestive if the tradition is older than Mark. Pigs were farmed in the Decapolis for straightforward economic reasons in a region with a substantial Gentile population; their presence requires no symbolic explanation. And the account has a plain narrative function — a Gentile territory, a delivered man commissioned to proclaim in the Decapolis — that does not need a political subtext to work. Adela Yarbro Collins, among others, accepts that the name has connotations that a first-century audience would notice while resisting the conclusion that anti-Roman polemic is the account's organising purpose.

There is also a methodological warning here that applies well beyond this passage, and it is the trap that this course's build principle names most sharply. Myers's reading is elegant: several details align to yield a single striking meaning. Elegance of that kind should prompt a second look, because a reading that makes every detail signify is precisely the reading most likely to have been generated by the interpreter's frame rather than found in the text. That caution does not refute Myers, and it should be applied with equal force to readings that find every detail confirming a familiar doctrinal scheme. The most defensible position is probably the middle one: the name "Legion" is unlikely to have been heard as politically neutral by anyone living under occupation, and that is a long way short of the claim that the pericope is a coded anti-imperial allegory.

The first diagram lays out the Beelzebul controversy as a structure of argument, marking which elements are in Mark and which are added in the Matthew-Luke material.

The Beelzebul controversy as an argument Mark 3:22-30 · Matthew 12:22-32 · Luke 11:14-23 The charge (Mark 3:22) Two forms: (a) he is himself possessed — "he has Beelzebul"; (b) he expels by borrowed authority — "by the prince of the demons". In Mark 1. Reductio: how can Satan cast out Satan? 2. Analogy: a divided kingdom cannot stand. 3. Analogy: a divided house cannot stand. 4. Application: then Satan is finished. 5. Counter-proposal: the strong man's house is plundered only after he is bound. The exorcisms are a raid, not a partnership. Added in Matthew and Luke 6. Consistency: "by whom do your children cast them out?" — other exorcists exist, and their success is presupposed. 7. Conclusion: if by the finger of God (Luke) or the Spirit of God (Matthew), then the reign of God has arrived. The one place Jesus interprets his own exorcisms. Mark alone appends the saying on blasphemy against the Spirit (3:28-30) 3:28 All sins and blasphemies are forgiven — the emphasis falls on the extent of forgiveness. 3:29 The exception is stated against that background, not as a limit on mercy. 3:30 Mark's own note fixes the reference: they had said "He has an unclean spirit."

The second diagram sets the two contemporary readings of possession side by side, with what each is strongest at and what each has been criticised for.

Two readings, each in its strongest form Neither is settled by exegesis; each rests on a prior view of what the world contains Medical redescription Strongest at: the fit of Mark 9:17-27 with a generalised seizure, described in the only vocabulary the first century had. Criticised for: in its strong form, assuming rather than showing that spirit causation is unavailable; and for not accounting for the cross-cultural pattern anthropologists report. Continued practice Strongest at: it is a live, regulated practice. Catholic rite revised 1999, bishop's permission required, medical assessment mandated first. Criticised for: the difficulty of specifying criteria that medicine has not already covered, and for abuses where oversight is weakest — a criticism made loudly from inside as well. The risk of harm runs both ways: a treatable illness left untreated, or distress with a social and moral shape met with medication alone. Anyone who teaches on this should be able to say what they would do in the case where they are wrong.

6. Further Reading

  • Graham H. Twelftree, Jesus the Exorcist: A Contribution to the Study of the Historical Jesus (Mohr Siebeck, 1993). The standard monograph; the comparative chapters on ancient exorcistic technique are the most useful part.
  • Amanda Witmer, Jesus, the Galilean Exorcist: His Exorcisms in Social and Political Context (T&T Clark, 2012). Uses anthropological work on possession without reducing the accounts to it.
  • Ched Myers, Binding the Strong Man: A Political Reading of Mark's Story of Jesus, 20th anniversary ed. (Orbis, 2008). The political reading in full; read it alongside a commentary that resists it.
  • Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark: A Commentary, Hermeneia (Fortress, 2007). Careful, sceptical treatment of the Gerasene account's supposed political vocabulary.
  • Eric Sorensen, Possession and Exorcism in the New Testament and Early Christianity (Mohr Siebeck, 2002). Traces the practice from its Near Eastern background into the early church, which is where the continuity with later rites becomes visible.
  • Francis MacNutt, Deliverance from Evil Spirits: A Practical Manual, rev. ed. (Chosen, 2009). A practitioner's account from within the Catholic charismatic renewal; included so that the continued-practice position can be read in its own words rather than in a summary.
  • Joel Marcus, Mark 1-8, Anchor Bible (Doubleday, 2000). The excursus on Beelzebul and the notes on Mark 3:28-30 are unusually clear on the philological questions.

In short

  • Mark places an exorcism (1:21-28) as the very first public act after Jesus announces the reign of God and calls four disciples; John's Gospel, by contrast, contains no exorcism at all, only the accusation that Jesus has a demon.
  • The Beelzebul controversy (Mark 3:22-27) is a formal argument: a reductio ("how can Satan cast out Satan?"), two supporting analogies (a divided kingdom or house cannot stand), and a counter-proposal that the exorcisms are a raid on a bound strong man's house, not collaboration with him.
  • The Q addition in Luke 11:19-20/Matthew 12:27-28 — "by whom do your children cast them out?" — assumes other Jewish exorcists were active and successful, and concludes that if Jesus casts out demons by the finger (or Spirit) of God, the Kingdom of God "has come to you."
  • Mark 3:30 supplies its own gloss on the unforgivable blasphemy against the Holy Spirit: it is specifically the act of attributing the Spirit's work to an unclean spirit, spoken against a background emphasizing the extent of forgiveness ("all sins... including their blasphemies"), not a general or accidental sin.
  • Ched Myers reads "Legion" in the Gerasene exorcist (Mark 5:1-20) as a coded reference to Roman military occupation, given the Latin loanword, the military vocabulary used of the herd's "charge," and the pig as emblem of Legio X Fretensis — but the reading's very elegance, aligning many details into one striking meaning, is exactly what the lecture flags as a warning sign.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Exorcism is the miracle category earliest and most emphasized in Mark — the very first thing Jesus does publicly after announcing the Kingdom — and it is structurally distinct because the opponent speaks: the unclean spirit at Capernaum names Jesus "the Holy One of God" before any human character does. The Beelzebul controversy shows Jesus reasoning formally, not just asserting: if Satan casts out Satan his kingdom falls, so the exorcisms must instead be a raid on an already-bound strong man's house, and Q's addition claims that this activity means the Kingdom "has come to you." The unforgivable blasphemy that follows (Mark 3:28-30) is not a vague or accidental sin but Mark's own named case: calling the Spirit's work an unclean spirit's. And Ched Myers's charged political reading of "Legion" in the Gerasene demoniac — Roman legion, charging pigs, Legio X's boar emblem — is presented as a real possibility whose very cleverness should make a careful reader look twice.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Set Mark 5:1-20 beside Matthew 8:28-34 in a synopsis. List every element Matthew has removed. Is there a single editorial motive that accounts for the whole list, or several? Be suspicious of the tidy answer.
  • The Q form of the Beelzebul reply assumes that other Jewish exorcists were both active and successful. What does that assumption do to a reading of the exorcism accounts as demonstrations of unique authority?
  • Mark 3:30 tells the reader what the blasphemy against the Spirit consists of in this scene. Why do you think discussion of the saying has so often proceeded without that verse, and what changes when it is included?
  • State Ched Myers's reading of "Legion" in the strongest form you can manage, then state the strongest objection to it. Where does the evidence actually leave the question?
  • The Catholic rite requires medical and psychiatric assessment before an exorcism may be authorised. Does that requirement strengthen or weaken the theological rationale for the practice? Argue both ways.
  • Mark places an exorcism as the first public act of Jesus; John contains no exorcism at all. What explanations of that difference are available, and how would you test between them?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.