Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
Contents 37
- Lecture 1-1: Gospel as a Genre: Biography, History, or Something Else
- Lecture 1-2: Oral Tradition, Written Sources, and How the Gospels Reached Us
- Lecture 1-3: Why Three, and Why They Are Called Synoptic
- Lecture 2-1: The Data: Agreements, Disagreements, and Order
- Lecture 2-2: The Two-Source Theory and the Case for Q
- Lecture 2-3: The Alternatives: Griesbach, Farrer, and the Present State of the Question
- Lecture 3-1: Galilee and Judea under Rome
- Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
- Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
- Lecture 4-1: Structure, Pace, and the Shape of Mark's Story
- Lecture 4-2: Mark's Christology and the Question of the Messianic Secret
- Lecture 4-3: Discipleship, Failure, and the Ending at 16:8
- Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
- Lecture 5-2: Fulfilment, Scripture, and the Law in Matthew
- Lecture 5-3: The Community Addressed: Church, Mission, and Judgment
- Lecture 6-1: Luke's Preface, Sources, and Claim to Orderly Account
- Lecture 6-2: Reversal: The Poor, Women, Samaritans, and Outsiders
- Lecture 6-3: The Spirit, Prayer, and the Journey to Jerusalem
- Lecture 7-1: What Jesus Announced, and What His Hearers Would Have Heard
- Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
- Lecture 7-3: The Sermon on the Mount and the Demands of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-1: How Parables Work, and How They Have Been Misread
- Lecture 8-2: Parables of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal
- Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
- Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil
- Lecture 9-3: How Historians and Theologians Have Handled the Miracle Accounts
- Lecture 10-1: The Sabbath and Purity Controversies
- Lecture 10-2: The Temple Action and What It Meant
- Lecture 10-3: Jesus and the Restoration of Israel: The Twelve and the Nations
- Lecture 11-1: The Last Supper and the Arrest
- Lecture 11-2: Trial, Crucifixion, and the Three Passion Narratives Compared
- Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts
Before anyone asks whether the miracle accounts are historical, it is worth asking a duller question that almost nobody asks: what sort of unit is a miracle account, and how many kinds are there? The answer turns out to be less obvious than the standard textbook lists suggest. The four categories in common use — healing, exorcism, nature miracle, raising of the dead — are a modern editorial convenience. The Gospels do not use them, and at several points the material does not sit inside them. Luke tells the story of a woman bent double for eighteen years as a healing, complete with the laying on of hands, and simultaneously calls her condition a "spirit of infirmity" and describes her as bound by Satan. That is one narrative with a foot in two of our categories, and it is not an isolated case.
This lecture argues that description has to come before evaluation, and that the description available to us is better than students usually realise. Form criticism, whatever one makes of its historical conclusions, established something that can be checked directly against the text: these narratives recur in a stable shape. Rudolf Bultmann and Martin Dibelius identified the shape in the 1910s and 1920s; Gerd Theissen, sixty years later, did the far more detailed work of cataloguing the individual motifs and showing which combinations appear and which do not. The shape is real and it is observable. What it means — whether it reflects the demands of oral performance, the conventions of the ancient genre, or the way events of this kind are in fact narrated by witnesses — is a separate question that the shape by itself does not settle.
The lecture then takes up three further matters. It examines the words the Gospels themselves use — chiefly dynamis, "act of power," and, in reported challenges to Jesus, semeion, "sign" — because the difference between them turns out to carry theological weight. It states, as precisely as the texts allow, what the Synoptic accounts actually say about the relationship between faith and healing, which is more varied and more awkward than either side of the modern healing debate tends to admit. And it sets the Gospel accounts beside other reports of healers and wonder-workers in the same world: Honi the Circle-Drawer, Hanina ben Dosa, the shrines of Asclepius, Apollonius of Tyana, and the emperor Vespasian in Alexandria. That comparative material is regularly used as a knock-down argument in both directions, and it is not strong enough to be one in either.
What these 43 minutes give you
- Classify a Synoptic miracle account by type, and identify two specific narratives where the standard categories overlap or fail.
- Describe the recurring four-part shape of a miracle story as Bultmann, Dibelius, and Theissen analysed it, and state what the existence of that shape does and does not prove.
- Distinguish the force of `dynamis` from that of `semeion` in the Synoptic vocabulary, and explain why demands for a `semeion` are refused in Matthew 12 while acts of `dynamis` are freely performed.
- Set out accurately what the Synoptic accounts say about faith and healing, including the cases where the faith is someone else's, where faith is absent, and where healing is nevertheless reported.
- Compare the Gospel healing accounts with the traditions concerning Honi, Hanina ben Dosa, Asclepius, Apollonius, and Vespasian, and explain why the comparison supports neither a simple claim of uniqueness nor a simple claim of derivation.
Four people came, carrying a paralytic to him. When they could not come near to him for the crowd, they removed the roof where he was. When they had broken it up, they let down the mat that the paralytic was lying on. Jesus, seeing their faith, said to the paralytic, “Son, your sins are forgiven you.” — Mark 2:3-5
World English Bible
A certain woman, who had an issue of blood for twelve years, and had suffered many things by many physicians, and had spent all that she had, and was no better, but rather grew worse, having heard the things concerning Jesus, came up behind him in the crowd, and touched his clothes. For she said, “If I just touch his clothes, I will be made well.” Immediately the flow of her blood was dried up, and she felt in her body that she was healed of her affliction. — Mark 5:25-29
WEB
But the woman, fearing and trembling, knowing what had been done to her, came and fell down before him, and told him all the truth. He said to her, “Daughter, your faith has made you well. Go in peace, and be cured of your disease.” — Mark 5:33-34
WEB
He could do no mighty work there, except that he laid his hands on a few sick people, and healed them. He marveled because of their unbelief. He went around the villages teaching. — Mark 6:5-6
WEB
These four passages are chosen to resist a single generalisation. In Mark 2 the faith that is noticed is the faith of the four carriers, not of the paralysed man, who says nothing in the entire scene. In Mark 5 the faith is the woman's own, and it is a faith attached to a physical object — his clothes — which is closer to the logic of a healing shrine than modern readers expect. In Mark 6 there is unbelief and there is nevertheless healing, in the same sentence. Any account of "faith and healing" in the Synoptics has to hold all three of these together, and most popular accounts hold only one.
1. How much of the material this is
Begin with proportion, because it governs everything else. Mark contains about eighteen distinct miracle accounts told as episodes, plus summary statements like Mark 1:32-34 and 6:53-56 that report unnumbered further healings. In a Gospel of sixteen chapters, of which the last six are largely passion and its approach, that is a substantial share of the narrative available. Counting by verses, rather than episodes, roughly a third of Mark chapters 1 to 10 is occupied by these accounts. Matthew retains most of Mark's miracle material but tells it more briefly, so the same episodes occupy a smaller proportion of a longer book. Luke retains most of it too and adds accounts found nowhere else: the widow's son at Nain, the ten men with leprosy, the bent woman of chapter 13, the man with dropsy in chapter 14, and the ear of the high priest's servant restored at the arrest.
These counts are approximate, and different scholars produce slightly different totals because the boundary between an episode and a summary is not always clear and because some incidents — the withered fig tree, the coin in the fish's mouth — are classified differently by different counters. The approximation does not matter for the point being made, which is only that the miracle material is a major structural component of the Synoptic Gospels and not an ornament attached to a teaching core.
2. The four categories, and where they leak
The categories in ordinary use are these.
Healings. Restoration of sight, hearing, speech, mobility, or skin; the ending of a fever or a haemorrhage. Examples: the paralysed man (Mark 2:1-12), the man with a withered hand (Mark 3:1-6), the woman with the flow of blood (Mark 5:25-34), the man deaf and impeded in speech (Mark 7:31-37), the blind man at Bethsaida (Mark 8:22-26), Bartimaeus (Mark 10:46-52).
Exorcisms. Expulsion of a spirit that speaks, resists, or names itself. Examples: the man in the Capernaum synagogue (Mark 1:21-28), the Gerasene (Mark 5:1-20), the Syrophoenician woman's daughter (Mark 7:24-30), the boy whom the disciples could not help (Mark 9:14-29). Lecture 9-2 treats these separately.
Nature miracles. Acts affecting the physical environment rather than a human body: the stilling of the storm (Mark 4:35-41), the feedings (Mark 6:30-44; 8:1-10), the walking on the sea (Mark 6:45-52), the withered fig tree (Mark 11:12-14, 20-21), and in Luke the great catch of fish (Luke 5:1-11).
Raisings. Jairus's daughter (Mark 5:21-24, 35-43), the widow's son at Nain (Luke 7:11-17).
Now the leaks, which matter more than the categories.
First, the bent woman of Luke 13:10-17. The narrative is shaped as a healing — Jesus lays hands on her, she straightens immediately — but her condition is introduced as a "spirit of infirmity," and Jesus afterwards describes her as one "whom Satan had bound." No spirit speaks; nothing is commanded to come out. Whether this is a healing or an exorcism depends entirely on which feature of the narrative one privileges.
Second, the fever of Simon's mother-in-law (Mark 1:29-31). Mark says simply that Jesus took her by the hand and raised her up. Luke, at 4:39, says that Jesus "rebuked the fever" — using the same verb that Mark uses for the silencing of the unclean spirit in 1:25 and for the wind in 4:39. Luke has made the same event sound more like an exorcism than Mark did. A category system that assigns each account to one box has to make a decision here that the evangelists themselves did not make consistently.
Third, the raising of Jairus's daughter. Jesus says the girl is not dead but sleeping, and the crowd laughs at him. Whether the account presents a raising or a healing depends on whether that remark is read as a statement about her condition or as a characteristically Markan piece of misdirection. The text does not resolve it, and interpreters who insist that it does are supplying the answer from outside.
The methodological point is worth stating plainly and then remembering for the rest of the chapter. The categories are ours. They are useful. They are not in the text, and where they cut across the material, the material is right and the categories are wrong.
3. The shape of a miracle story
Here is one of the more secure results of twentieth-century Gospel study, and one a student can verify personally in an afternoon with a synopsis. These accounts recur in a stable four-part shape.
One: the problem is stated. The condition is described, often with an emphasis on duration or severity that establishes that ordinary remedies have failed. Twelve years of haemorrhage; all her money spent on physicians and no better. Eighteen years bent double. Possessed since childhood. The exaggerated-sounding severity is not necessarily exaggeration; it is the narrative establishing that what follows is not a spontaneous recovery.
Two: the act. Word, touch, or both. Sometimes with technique — spittle, fingers in the ears, clay — and sometimes with nothing but a sentence spoken at a distance. Sometimes with a foreign-language formula preserved: talitha koum, "Girl, get up," at Mark 5:41; ephphatha, "be opened," at Mark 7:34.
Three: the demonstration. The result is made publicly checkable. The paralysed man picks up his mat and walks out in front of everyone. The girl gets up and walks, and Jesus orders that she be given something to eat. The man cleansed of leprosy is sent to the priest. This element is not incidental; it is the narrative's own answer to the question a hearer would ask.
Four: the reaction. Amazement, fear, acclamation, or hostility, usually from a crowd whose function is to say aloud what the narrative wants registered. "We never saw anything like this." "What is this? A new teaching?"
Bultmann, in The History of the Synoptic Tradition (German 1921), identified this shape and drew a conclusion from it: a form so regular indicates a tradition shaped by use in the community rather than a report shaped by an event. Dibelius, working at the same period, distinguished between short "paradigms," told to make a point in preaching, and longer "tales" (Novellen) told with the technical detail and the flourish characteristic of Hellenistic wonder narration — and he regarded the second type as the more developed. Theissen's The Miracle Stories of the Early Christian Tradition (German 1974) replaced both schemes with a much finer inventory: thirty-three recurring motifs, catalogued and traced through the material, with attention to which motifs cluster and which never appear together.
Now the caution, and it is a real one. The existence of a stable form does not by itself tell you where the form came from. Three explanations are available, and the form is compatible with all of them. It may be the shape imposed by repeated oral telling, which is Bultmann's inference. It may be the shape that the ancient genre of wonder narration required, in which case the Gospel writers were doing what any narrator of such an event in that world would do. Or it may be, at least in part, the shape that such events take when they are reported at all — a condition, an intervention, a check, a reaction — in which case the form is not evidence about origin in either direction. Theissen himself was careful about this. Students meeting form criticism for the first time frequently take the identification of a form as if it were a demonstration of fictionality, and it is not. It is a demonstration of form.
4. What the Gospels call these events
The Synoptic vocabulary is worth attending to, because the words are not interchangeable.
Dynamis (plural dynameis), "act of power" or "mighty work," is the Synoptics' most characteristic term. It describes what is done, not what it means. When Mark says that in Nazareth Jesus "could do no mighty work" (6:5), the word is dynamis. When the Nazareth crowd asks how such dynameis come about by his hands (6:2), the same word is used with no implication either way about their source — the crowd is puzzled, not convinced.
Semeion, "sign," points beyond the act to what it signifies. In the Synoptics — and this is a genuine and frequently missed difference from John, where semeion is the standard term and the signs are the framework of the book's first half — demands for a semeion are consistently refused:
Then certain of the scribes and Pharisees answered, “Teacher, we want to see a sign from you.” But he answered them, “An evil and adulterous generation seeks after a sign, but no sign will be given it but the sign of Jonah the prophet. — Matthew 12:38-39 (WEB)
The refusal is striking precisely because it comes in Matthew immediately after an exorcism has been performed and debated. Acts of power are done constantly; a demand for a validating sign is turned down. Whatever the accounts are, they are not presented in the Synoptics as evidence produced on request.
Teras, "wonder" or "portent," is rare and in the Synoptics appears only in combination with semeion, and then in a warning: false messiahs and false prophets will produce "signs and wonders" to lead astray (Mark 13:22). The word carries no positive weight on its own. This is a small but real datum against a reading in which spectacular events straightforwardly authenticate a claim: on the Synoptics' own showing, spectacle proves nothing about who is doing it, which is exactly the point at issue in the Beelzebul controversy of the next lecture.
One other word deserves mention. Mark uses sozo — "to save," "to make well" — in healing contexts, as in "your faith has made you well" (Mark 5:34), where the same verb elsewhere in the New Testament carries the sense of salvation. The overlap is real and should be noted, but it should not be over-read. Greek sozo and its cognates were ordinary vocabulary for rescue and recovery in non-religious contexts too, and the presence of the word does not by itself establish that a healing account is intended as a parable of salvation. That reading has to be argued from the narrative, not from the lexicon.
5. Faith and healing: what the texts actually say
This is where careless summary does the most damage, in both directions, so the evidence should be laid out before any generalisation is attempted.
Faith is sometimes the sick person's own. Mark 5:34 to the woman with the haemorrhage; Mark 10:52 to Bartimaeus — "your faith has made you well." Both are addressed directly to the person healed, and both come after the healing rather than as a condition stated before it.
Faith is sometimes someone else's. In Mark 2:5 it is the faith of the four men on the roof that Jesus sees; the paralysed man neither speaks nor is described as believing anything. In Mark 7:24-30 it is the Syrophoenician mother's persistence; her daughter is not present. In Matthew 8:5-13 it is the centurion's, and the centurion is not the patient.
Faith is sometimes absent, or explicitly inadequate, and healing occurs anyway. The father in Mark 9 says:
Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!” — Mark 9:24 (WEB)
That is not a model of confident faith; it is a man saying that his faith is defective, and the boy is delivered. Elsewhere no faith is mentioned at all: the man with the withered hand in Mark 3, the widow's son at Nain in Luke 7 — who is dead, and whose mother is not asked for anything.
And there is Nazareth. Mark 6:5-6 says Jesus "could do no mighty work there," attributes it to unbelief, and then reports that he healed a few sick people anyway. Matthew, at 13:58, softens the sentence: "He didn't do many mighty works there because of their unbelief." That editorial change is one of the clearest small examples in the Synoptics of a later evangelist easing a difficulty in Mark's wording, and it is worth noticing for the source-critical argument of Chapter 2 as well as here.
What follows from all of this? Something more limited than either party in the modern healing debate would like. The Synoptic accounts do associate faith with healing repeatedly and without embarrassment. They do not present faith as a mechanism, a quantity, or a condition whose absence explains every failure — because in these narratives faith is sometimes located in a third party, sometimes confessed as deficient, and sometimes not mentioned at all.
This is a point where readers will not agree. One position, associated in the twentieth century with parts of the Pentecostal and charismatic movements and given a strong form in the "Word of Faith" teaching of Kenneth Hagin, treats faith as the operative condition of healing, with the consequence — sometimes drawn explicitly, sometimes not — that persistent illness indicates a failure of faith. A second position, held across most of the historic traditions, treats healing as sovereign gift and reads the faith language as descriptive of the relationship in which healing was received rather than as a condition governing it; the Catholic of anointing, the Orthodox sacrament of holy unction, and the Reformed emphasis on all locate the decision on God's side rather than the patient's. A third position, more common in academic writing than in congregations, holds that "your faith has made you well" is primarily a formula of the healing account as a literary form and should not be turned into a theology of illness at all. The exegetical evidence above tells against the first position in its strong form, because Mark 2:5 and Mark 9:24 are hard to accommodate to it. It does not by itself decide between the second and the third. Note also the pastoral stake, which is not abstract: a doctrine that makes recovery depend on the sufferer's faith places the blame for continued illness on the ill person, and any teacher who states such a doctrine should be able to say what they would tell someone who has not recovered.
Guessing old diagnoses
A further caution about method, and it applies to this section as a whole. Modern readers translate the Gospel conditions into modern diagnoses almost automatically — the boy in Mark 9 has epilepsy, the bent woman has spondylitis, the "leprosy" of the Gospels is not Hansen's disease. The last of these is well founded: Greek lepra and Hebrew tsara'at cover a range of scaly skin conditions and the identification with Hansen's disease is a later confusion. The others are speculative retrodiagnoses from a few narrative details, and medical anthropologists such as John Pilch have argued that the whole exercise is misconceived because ancient reports describe socially constructed illness, what a community recognises and excludes, rather than biomedical disease. Pilch's distinction is useful; his stronger claim, that the ancient categories are simply incommensurable with ours, has been criticised for making the ancient world so alien that nothing at all can be said about it. Retrodiagnosis is a tool to be used tentatively and labelled when used.
6. Nature miracles are a different kind of problem
The healing accounts and the nature miracles have often been treated together, and they should be separated, because they raise different questions and have historically attracted different judgments.
Healing accounts have a comparative context: other reports of healing in the ancient world are numerous, some are well documented, and phenomena like the recovery of function under conditions of high expectation are recognised in modern medicine as well. That does not settle what happened, but it means that a healing account is not by its form outside the range of the reportable.
The nature miracles have no such context. A storm stilled by a command, five thousand fed from five loaves, a man walking on open water — these are not events for which a naturalistic reduction is straightforwardly available, and correspondingly they have been the first to be reclassified as symbolic even by scholars who accept a historical core to the healings. This is not a modern squeamishness alone: the accounts themselves are more heavily loaded with allusion. The stilling of the storm has the vocabulary of the Psalms of God's rule over the sea; the feedings echo the manna in the wilderness and Elisha feeding a hundred men with twenty loaves in 2 Kings 4:42-44; the walking on the sea in Mark 6:48 contains the strange note that Jesus "would have passed by them," which several commentators, including Adela Yarbro Collins, read as an allusion to the passing-by of the divine glory in Exodus 33 and 1 Kings 19.
He awoke, and rebuked the wind, and said to the sea, “Peace! Be still!” The wind ceased, and there was a great calm. He said to them, “Why are you so afraid? How is it that you have no faith?” They were greatly afraid, and said to one another, “Who then is this, that even the wind and the sea obey him?” — Mark 4:39-41 (WEB)
The closing question is the narrative's own indication of what the account is for. It is Christological before it is anything else. Recognising that does not settle whether the event occurred, and it would be a mistake — one made in both directions — to think it does. A symbolic function and a historical occurrence are not alternatives; ancient writers routinely narrated events they believed to have happened in language chosen for its resonance. But it does mean that a reader who treats the stilling of the storm purely as a meteorological report has missed the point the text is making, whatever else may be true about the day in question.
7. Other healers in the same world
The Gospel accounts did not appear in a world without healers, and the comparative material is important. It is also, in practice, one of the most abused bodies of evidence in New Testament study, deployed as though it settled matters that it cannot settle.
Honi the Circle-Drawer (first century BCE) is reported in the Mishnah (m. Ta'anit 3:8) as having drawn a circle, stood inside it, and refused to move until God sent rain; the rain came. Josephus reports the same figure as Onias (Antiquities 14.22). The tradition concerns weather, not healing, and the account has a striking feature: the contemporary religious authority Simeon ben Shetah is reported as reprimanding him for his familiarity with God while acknowledging that God indulged him.
Hanina ben Dosa (first century CE) appears in the Babylonian Talmud (b. Berakhot 34b) praying for the son of Rabbi Gamaliel and knowing, from the fluency of his own prayer, that the fever had left — an intriguing formal parallel to healing at a distance. Geza Vermes, in Jesus the Jew (1973), placed both Honi and Hanina in a category he called the Galilean hasid, the charismatic holy man, and argued that Jesus is intelligible within that Jewish category rather than against it. That argument was a genuine contribution and remains valuable, particularly as a corrective to portrayals of Jesus as an isolated figure over against Judaism. It has also been criticised on a specific ground that students should know: the Hanina material is preserved in rabbinic collections redacted centuries later, and reconstructing a first-century social type from them involves a chain of inference that Vermes did not always make explicit. Sean Freyne and William Scott Green have both pressed this objection.
Asclepius. The healing shrines of the god Asclepius, above all at Epidaurus and Pergamum, preserved inscriptions in which cured petitioners recorded what had happened: incubation in the sanctuary, a dream, a cure on waking, often described in the same narrative sequence as a Gospel account — condition, encounter, cure, testimony. These are the closest formal parallels available and they are contemporary. Their existence is sometimes presented as showing that the Gospel accounts are a familiar genre and nothing more. It shows the genre; it does not by itself show what generated any particular instance of it.
Apollonius of Tyana, a first-century wandering sage whose Life was written by Philostratus around 220-230 CE, is credited with healings, an exorcism, and the raising of a girl who may or may not have been dead — Philostratus himself notes the ambiguity. Apollonius is regularly cited as a pagan parallel to Jesus. Two things must be said. The biography is written more than a century after its subject, at the commission of an empress with philosophical interests, and possibly with knowledge of Christian accounts; and Philostratus's own attitude to his subject's wonders is more sceptical and more literary than the citations usually convey. The parallel is real but the direction of any influence is not determinable, and it certainly cannot be assumed to run from Apollonius to the Gospels, which are earlier.
Vespasian. Tacitus (Histories 4.81) and Suetonius (Vespasian 7) both report that in Alexandria in 69 CE the emperor healed a blind man with spittle and a lame or withered-handed man by touch, at the prompting of the god Serapis. This is the most awkward parallel for a simple apologetic argument, because Tacitus is a first-rate historian writing about a public event roughly forty years after it, which is a shorter interval than that between Jesus and Mark, and because the technique — spittle, touch — is the same as in Mark 7 and 8. Tacitus reports it, notes that witnesses continued to attest it, and reports too that Vespasian's own advisers thought the political advantage worth pursuing.
What does all this establish? Less than either of the standard uses claims. It does not establish that Jesus is unique in performing acts of this kind, since the reports show that he is not unique in being credited with them. It does not establish that the Gospel accounts are derivative, since a shared genre of reporting is what one would expect in a shared world, and the specific literary dependence that would be needed for a derivation argument has not been demonstrated in any of these cases. The most defensible conclusion is the modest one: healing and wonder-working were a recognised phenomenon in the first-century Mediterranean, reports of them followed recognisable narrative patterns, and the Gospel accounts belong to that world rather than standing outside it. What distinguishes the Gospel accounts is not the bare fact of the acts but the framework in which they are set — in the Synoptics they are consistently tied to the announcement of God's reign, which is not a feature of the Asclepius inscriptions or of Philostratus.
The first diagram sets out the four-part shape of a Synoptic miracle account, with the elements of Mark 2:1-12 filled in beneath, and marks the point where the four standard categories overlap.
The second diagram places the Synoptic vocabulary on a single line, from the term that describes only what was done to the term that carries the heaviest interpretive load, and marks where each is used.
6. Further Reading
- Gerd Theissen, The Miracle Stories of the Early Christian Tradition, trans. Francis McDonagh (Fortress, 1983). The motif catalogue in part two is the reference tool for form analysis of this material.
- Rudolf Bultmann, The History of the Synoptic Tradition, rev. ed., trans. John Marsh (Blackwell, 1972). Read the miracle sections directly rather than in summary; the argument is more careful than its reputation.
- Wendy Cotter, Miracles in Greco-Roman Antiquity: A Sourcebook (Routledge, 1999), and her The Christ of the Miracle Stories: Portrait through Encounter (Baker Academic, 2010). The first gives the comparative texts; the second reads the Gospel accounts against ancient social expectations.
- Geza Vermes, Jesus the Jew: A Historian's Reading of the Gospels (Collins, 1973). The classic case for reading Jesus within the category of the Galilean charismatic; read alongside the criticisms of the rabbinic dating.
- John J. Pilch, Healing in the New Testament: Insights from Medical and Mediterranean Anthropology (Fortress, 2000). The illness/disease distinction, applied throughout, with the strengths and the overreach both on display.
- Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark: A Commentary, Hermeneia (Fortress, 2007). Consistently strong on the Hellenistic and Jewish literary background of the individual miracle accounts.
- Eric Eve, The Jewish Context of Jesus' Miracles (Sheffield Academic, 2002). Surveys the Jewish comparative material carefully and reaches more cautious conclusions than Vermes about how much of a category there was.
In short
- The four standard miracle categories (healing, exorcism, nature miracle, raising) are modern conveniences that the Gospels do not use consistently: Luke 13:10-17's bent woman is healed by laying on of hands yet also called bound by a "spirit of infirmity" from Satan, and Luke 4:39 has Jesus "rebuke" Simon's mother-in-law's fever with the same verb used for silencing an unclean spirit.
- Bultmann, Dibelius, and Theissen identified a stable four-part shape in miracle accounts (problem stated, act performed, demonstration made publicly checkable, crowd reaction) — but the lecture insists this form is compatible with oral shaping, ancient genre convention, or simply how such events get reported, and does not by itself prove fictionality.
- The Synoptics distinguish
dynamis("act of power," describing the deed without implying its source) fromsemeion("sign," pointing beyond the act) — and Matthew 12:38-39 shows demands for asemeionbeing refused even immediately after an exorcism has been performed. - Faith and healing do not follow one pattern: Mark 2:5 credits the faith of the four men carrying the paralytic, not the paralytic himself; Mark 9:24 has a father confess "I believe, help my unbelief" and the boy is delivered anyway; and Mark 6:5-6 reports Jesus healing only a few in Nazareth "because of their unbelief."
- Comparative healers in the same world — Honi the Circle-Drawer, Hanina ben Dosa, the Asclepius shrine inscriptions, Apollonius of Tyana, and Vespasian's spittle-healing reported by Tacitus in Alexandria — show the Gospel accounts share a recognized ancient genre without settling whether any account depends on another.
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Before asking whether the Synoptic miracle accounts are historical, this lecture asks a prior question: what kind of unit are they, and the honest answer is that the four familiar categories of healing, exorcism, nature miracle, and raising are ours, not the Gospels' — Luke's bent woman is healed by touch yet named as bound by Satan, and Luke turns Mark's plain healing of Simon's mother-in-law into something closer to an exorcism by having Jesus "rebuke" her fever. The accounts share a stable four-part shape (problem, act, public demonstration, reaction) first mapped by Bultmann and Dibelius and catalogued in detail by Theissen, but that regularity proves only that a form exists, not where it came from. The Synoptics themselves refuse to treat these acts as self-certifying: dynamis describes what was done without saying who did it, and demands for a semeion are turned down flat even after an exorcism. And faith turns out not to be a mechanism — sometimes it belongs to bystanders, sometimes it is confessed as defective, and in Nazareth healing occurs despite the very unbelief Mark blames for its scarcity.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Take Mark 5:25-34 and mark the four elements of the form directly in the text. Where does Mark add material that does not belong to any of the four, and what is that material doing?
- Luke changes Mark's account of Simon's mother-in-law so that Jesus "rebukes" the fever. Argue first that this is a theologically significant editorial choice, then argue that it is simply a stylistic variation with no weight. Which argument is stronger, and what would settle it?
- Mark 2:5 credits the faith of the four carriers; Mark 9:24 records a father confessing that his faith is defective. What would a doctrine of healing have to look like in order to accommodate both verses honestly?
- Tacitus reports that Vespasian healed a blind man with spittle in Alexandria in 69 CE, and does so at a shorter remove from the event than Mark stands from Jesus. What, if anything, should a reader of the Gospels do with that report?
- Nature miracles have often been reclassified as symbolic even by scholars who accept a historical core to the healings. Is that a defensible distinction or an inconsistent one? Give the strongest case for each answer.
- This lecture claims the four standard categories are "ours, not the text's." Propose a different classification that the Synoptic material itself suggests, and say what your scheme obscures that the standard one shows.