Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
Contents 37
- Lecture 1-1: Gospel as a Genre: Biography, History, or Something Else
- Lecture 1-2: Oral Tradition, Written Sources, and How the Gospels Reached Us
- Lecture 1-3: Why Three, and Why They Are Called Synoptic
- Lecture 2-1: The Data: Agreements, Disagreements, and Order
- Lecture 2-2: The Two-Source Theory and the Case for Q
- Lecture 2-3: The Alternatives: Griesbach, Farrer, and the Present State of the Question
- Lecture 3-1: Galilee and Judea under Rome
- Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
- Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
- Lecture 4-1: Structure, Pace, and the Shape of Mark's Story
- Lecture 4-2: Mark's Christology and the Question of the Messianic Secret
- Lecture 4-3: Discipleship, Failure, and the Ending at 16:8
- Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
- Lecture 5-2: Fulfilment, Scripture, and the Law in Matthew
- Lecture 5-3: The Community Addressed: Church, Mission, and Judgment
- Lecture 6-1: Luke's Preface, Sources, and Claim to Orderly Account
- Lecture 6-2: Reversal: The Poor, Women, Samaritans, and Outsiders
- Lecture 6-3: The Spirit, Prayer, and the Journey to Jerusalem
- Lecture 7-1: What Jesus Announced, and What His Hearers Would Have Heard
- Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
- Lecture 7-3: The Sermon on the Mount and the Demands of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-1: How Parables Work, and How They Have Been Misread
- Lecture 8-2: Parables of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal
- Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
- Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil
- Lecture 9-3: How Historians and Theologians Have Handled the Miracle Accounts
- Lecture 10-1: The Sabbath and Purity Controversies
- Lecture 10-2: The Temple Action and What It Meant
- Lecture 10-3: Jesus and the Restoration of Israel: The Twelve and the Nations
- Lecture 11-1: The Last Supper and the Arrest
- Lecture 11-2: Trial, Crucifixion, and the Three Passion Narratives Compared
- Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts
Matthew is the most obviously organised of the three Synoptic Gospels. Mark moves at speed and joins its episodes with a word meaning "immediately"; Luke frames its material inside a long journey to Jerusalem whose geography does not always cooperate. Matthew, by contrast, gathers teaching into blocks. Almost everything Jesus says in this Gospel is collected into five large speeches, and each of those five ends with a variation on the same sentence: "When Jesus had finished these words." A reader who notices that formula the first time will find it four more times, always at the seam between a speech and the narrative that follows. Something has been designed.
The question is what. This lecture argues that the design is real and that the most famous explanation of it is probably too neat. Benjamin W. Bacon proposed in 1930 that the five discourses were built to answer to the five books of the Pentateuch, so that Matthew presents Jesus as a new Moses delivering a new law. The proposal has been enormously influential; it is also open to an objection that is hard to answer, namely that it turns the birth narrative and the passion narrative into a prologue and an epilogue, which is a strange status for the two blocks a reader would call the most weighty in the book. The lecture states Bacon's case in its strongest form, presses that objection, and then presents Jack Dean Kingsbury's rival proposal — a three-part structure hinged on the repeated phrase "from that time Jesus began," at 4:17 and 16:21 — together with the objections to that.
From structure the lecture turns to the frame the structure sits in. Matthew opens with a genealogy that begins with Abraham, is arranged in three sets of fourteen, and includes four women whose stories are all in some way irregular. That opening is a set of decisions, and each decision commits the book to something. The lecture closes on the long dispute about Matthew's first readers: were they a group still inside the synagogue, arguing for their position within it, or a group already outside it, defining itself over against it? Both reconstructions are inferences from the text, and the lecture will be explicit that neither can be confirmed by anything outside the text.
What these 30 minutes give you
- Identify the five discourses of Matthew by chapter, quote the closing formula that marks each, and explain why the formula is stronger evidence of design than most proposed structures in the Gospels.
- State Bacon's five-books proposal at full strength and give at least two substantive objections to it, including the objection from the placement of chapters 1-2 and 26-28.
- Present Kingsbury's alternative structure, say what it explains better than Bacon's, and say what it explains less well.
- Explain the significance of Matthew's genealogy beginning with Abraham, of the three groups of fourteen, and of the inclusion of Tamar, Rahab, Ruth, and the wife of Uriah.
- Set out the "inside the synagogue" and "outside the synagogue" reconstructions of Matthew's community, naming representatives of each, and identify what evidence each depends on.
The book of the genealogy of Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham. — Matthew 1:1
World English Bible
So all the generations from Abraham to David are fourteen generations; from David to the exile to Babylon fourteen generations; and from the carrying away to Babylon to the Christ, fourteen generations. — Matthew 1:17
WEB
Seeing the multitudes, he went up onto the mountain. When he had sat down, his disciples came to him. He opened his mouth and taught them, saying, — Matthew 5:1-2
WEB
When Jesus had finished saying these things, the multitudes were astonished at his teaching, for he taught them with authority, and not like the scribes. — Matthew 7:28-29
WEB
From that time, Jesus began to preach, and to say, “Repent! For the Kingdom of Heaven is at hand.” — Matthew 4:17
WEB
From that time, Jesus began to show his disciples that he must go to Jerusalem and suffer many things from the elders, chief priests, and scribes, and be killed, and the third day be raised up. — Matthew 16:21
WEB
These six passages are the lecture's working material rather than its illustration. Matthew 1:1 and 1:17 are the two verses that frame the genealogy and state its arithmetic. Matthew 5:1-2 is the opening of the first discourse and contains the detail — a mountain, and a seated teacher — that Bacon's reading leans on. Matthew 7:28-29 is the first occurrence of the closing formula, and the reader should notice that the formula is followed here by a comment about authority which will matter for the community question. Matthew 4:17 and 16:21 are quoted together because Kingsbury's structural proposal rests entirely on the fact that they open with the identical phrase, and a student needs to see that phrase twice, in the same translation, before judging whether it can carry the weight put on it.
1. The pattern that is not in dispute
Begin with what can be checked. Five times in Matthew a block of teaching is closed by a formula, and the five formulas are variations on one sentence:
- 7:28, closing the Sermon on the Mount (chs. 5-7): "When Jesus had finished saying these things"
- 11:1, closing the mission discourse (ch. 10): "When Jesus had finished directing his twelve disciples"
- 13:53, closing the parable discourse (ch. 13): "When Jesus had finished these parables"
- 19:1, closing the discourse on community relations (ch. 18): "When Jesus had finished these words"
- 26:1, closing the discourse on the last things (chs. 24-25): "When Jesus had finished all these words"
The Greek behind these is a fixed construction with a fixed verb, varying only in the object. Nothing comparable occurs in Mark or Luke. Between the discourses stand narrative sections, and the alternation is regular: narrative, discourse, narrative, discourse, and so on five times, with an infancy narrative before the first cycle and a passion narrative after the last.
This is a firmer structural claim than most made about the Gospels, and the reason is worth stating precisely: the marker is verbal and repeated, not thematic. A structure proposed on the basis of shared themes can almost always be proposed differently by a reader with different themes in mind. A structure marked by the same clause five times, at the same kind of seam, is a fact about the wording. What that fact means is a separate question, and it is where the disagreement starts.
2. Bacon's proposal, stated at full strength
Benjamin W. Bacon, in Studies in Matthew (1930), argued that the five discourses correspond to the five books of the , and that Matthew has built a "new Pentateuch" in which Jesus stands as a new Moses giving a new law from a mountain.
The case is not merely the number five, and it would be weak if it were. Bacon and those who developed his reading pointed to a convergence of features:
The mountain. The first discourse is delivered from a mountain, and Matthew says so explicitly (5:1) where Luke's parallel sermon is delivered on "a level place" (Luke 6:17). A teacher ascending a mountain to deliver authoritative instruction is not a neutral image in a book that has just quoted Hosea's "Out of Egypt I called my son."
The infancy narrative's Moses colouring. Matthew 2 has a ruler who kills male children, a child who escapes, a return from Egypt when those who sought the child's life are dead. The verbal echo of Exodus 4:19 in Matthew 2:20 is close. Whatever one concludes about the structure of the whole, the opening chapters do evoke the Moses story.
Fulfilment and law. The book's most sustained block of teaching is precisely about the law: what it requires, whether it stands, how it is to be read. If a Gospel is going to be built on a Pentateuchal pattern, this is the Gospel.
The closing formula's own resonance. Deuteronomy 31:1 and 32:45 use comparable formulas for Moses finishing his words. The parallel is not decisive but it is not nothing.
Put together, Bacon's reading offers something valuable: it explains why the material is in blocks at all, rather than distributed as in Mark, and it ties that arrangement to the book's stated preoccupation.
3. The objections
The frame problem. This is the serious one. On Bacon's scheme the five discourse-plus-narrative units are the book, and chapters 1-2 and 26-28 are a preamble and a conclusion outside the structure. But the passion narrative is the longest continuous stretch of narrative in the Gospel, and the infancy narrative contains five of the formula quotations. A structural theory that assigns the crucifixion and resurrection to an epilogue has, as W. D. Davies and Dale C. Allison put it in their commentary, arranged the book in a way its own proportions resist. Structures should account for the mass of a text, not only for its symmetry.
The number five may be over-read. Groups of five are frequent in Matthew and in Jewish literature generally — the Psalter is in five books, and so is the Mishnaic tractate collection Pirqe Avot in some reckonings — without implying a Pentateuchal claim in each case. Five is a convenient number for memorised material. That the discourses are five may say more about memory than about Moses.
Moses is present without being structural. Dale Allison's The New Moses: A Matthean Typology (1993) makes what is probably the strongest available case that Matthew consciously draws Moses parallels — and Allison is careful to argue that the typology runs through the book as a theme rather than dictating its outline. That distinction matters. One can accept a great deal of Moses typology and still reject Bacon's architecture.
The discourses are not five equal things. Chapters 5-7 and 24-25 are long and thematically unified; chapter 13 is a parable collection; chapter 18 is short. Treating them as five parallel members flattens real differences in kind.
Five discourses, one blueprint?
This is a point where readers will not agree. Bacon held that the five discourses are the deliberate skeleton of a new Pentateuch. Davies and Allison hold that the fivefold pattern is real, that Moses typology is real, and that neither yields the outline of the book — the alternation is a compositional habit rather than a blueprint. Jack Dean Kingsbury holds that the discourse formula marks paragraphs and not the primary divisions at all, and that the book's real joints lie elsewhere. Each of these is arguing from the same undisputed data; what separates them is how much interpretive weight a repeated formula can bear.
4. Kingsbury's alternative
Kingsbury, in Matthew: Structure, Christology, Kingdom (1975), proposed that the book falls into three parts, marked by an identical phrase at 4:17 and 16:21 — rendered in the World English Bible as "From that time, Jesus began." On this reading:
- 1:1-4:16 presents the person of Jesus Messiah
- 4:17-16:20 presents his proclamation to Israel
- 16:21-28:20 presents his going to Jerusalem to suffer, die, and be raised
The strength of this proposal is that it makes the passion central rather than appended, and that it too rests on a repeated verbal marker rather than on themes. It also fits a genuine narrative turn: after 16:21 the material does change character, and the movement toward Jerusalem does become the book's spine.
The objections are equally concrete. The phrase occurs only twice, and two occurrences are a thinner base than five. The phrase is also unremarkable Greek — a common temporal transition — where the discourse formula is distinctive. And a three-part structure has to treat the discourses, which are the most visible feature of the book, as subordinate furniture. Most current commentators take a mediating position: the discourse formula marks the book's teaching blocks, and the "from that time" phrase marks turns in the narrative line, and both are the author's, because a book can be organised on more than one axis at once. That mediating position is sensible, and this course's own build principle requires flagging that sensible mediating positions are also the easiest kind to reach without evidence. What can be verified is the wording; the rest is inference about intention.
5. The genealogy and what it commits the book to
Matthew opens not with a preface to a patron, as Luke does, nor with a proclamation, as Mark does, but with a list of names. Three features of that list are decisions.
It begins with Abraham. Luke's genealogy, running in the other direction, goes back past Abraham to Adam and so to God (Luke 3:38). Matthew stops at Abraham. The effect is to place Jesus inside the history of Israel specifically, rather than inside humanity generally. Both are theological statements; they are not the same statement. Matthew 1:1 also names David before Abraham even though the list runs Abraham-to-David, which puts the royal title first and the covenant ancestor second — an ordering that anticipates the book's interest in Jesus as son of David.
It is arranged in three fourteens. Matthew says so at 1:17. The arithmetic is not automatic: the third group has thirteen generations by most counts, and the list omits several kings known from Kings and Chronicles. So the pattern is imposed on the material rather than found in it, which tells us the pattern matters to the author. Why fourteen? The commonest proposal is that the Hebrew consonants of David's name have the numerical value fourteen, which would make the structure itself a repeated assertion that this line is David's. That explanation is attractive and not certain; a genealogy in three equal parts also simply organises memory, and Matthew may be doing both. The honest statement is that the number is deliberate and its rationale is inferred.
It names four women. Tamar, Rahab, Ruth, and "her who had been the wife of Uriah" appear in a list otherwise of fathers. What they have in common has been debated for centuries. That all four are Gentiles or associated with Gentiles is one proposal, and it fits a book that ends by sending disciples to all nations — though Tamar's origin is not stated in Genesis. That all four are involved in irregular unions is another, and it would prepare the reader for the irregularity of 1:18-25. Raymond E. Brown, in The Birth of the Messiah, argued for a combination: each represents both an irregularity in the line and God's use of it. What should be resisted is the tidy version in which the four women are simply "outsiders included," which flattens four quite different stories into one point. This is exactly the kind of elegance that this course treats as a warning sign.
6. Who was reading this book
The last question is the one that most affects how the rest of the chapter will be read. Matthew is intensely concerned with the law, with scriptural interpretation, with Sabbath and purity disputes, with the practice of almsgiving and fasting and prayer. He assumes his readers know what phylacteries are (23:5) and does not explain Jewish customs as Mark does (compare Mark 7:3-4, which stops to explain hand-washing to outsiders; Matthew's parallel at 15:1-2 does not). At the same time, the book contains the sharpest denunciations of scribes and Pharisees in the New Testament and ends by sending disciples to all nations.
Two reconstructions have dominated.
Still inside. J. Andrew Overman (Matthew's Gospel and Formative Judaism, 1990) and Anthony J. Saldarini (Matthew's Christian-Jewish Community, 1994) argued that Matthew's group is best understood as a deviant association within the Jewish community of its city, competing for influence with the emerging rabbinic movement after 70 CE. On this reading the violence of chapter 23 is sibling rivalry, the sort of language groups use against rivals with whom they share almost everything. The evidence is the book's unexplained Jewish assumptions, its concern with law observance, and the sociological observation that such rhetoric is characteristic of factions inside a group rather than across a boundary.
Already outside. Graham N. Stanton (A Gospel for a New People, 1992) argued that the phrase "their synagogues" (4:23, 9:35, 10:17, 12:9, 13:54) is decisive: a writer who calls them their synagogues is not in them. Add 21:43, where the kingdom is said to be given to a nation producing its fruit, and 28:19's unrestricted mission, and the picture is of a community that has separated and is now defining itself. On this reading Matthew is written for people who have recently gone through a painful break and need to be told why they were right to.
Both readings account for a great deal, and both have to explain away something. The "inside" reading has to soften "their synagogues" and 21:43; the "outside" reading has to explain why a separated community remains so preoccupied with the details of Jewish law and so uninterested in explaining Jewish customs. A third possibility, which several recent scholars have preferred, is that the categories themselves are too sharp — that the parting of ways was gradual, local, and uneven, so that a community could be in the process of separation without being clearly on one side of a line that did not yet exist everywhere. That is likely correct and it is also the least falsifiable of the three, which is a reason to hold it loosely rather than to treat it as the settled answer.
What a student should take from this is a habit rather than a verdict. Every claim about "the Matthean community" is an argument that runs from the text back to a situation, on the assumption that what a writer emphasises reflects what his readers face. We have the book. We do not have the congregation, its minutes, its address, or any independent witness to it.
The diagram lays the two proposals over the same chapter sequence so that they can be compared rather than described in turn. The shaded blocks in the upper scheme are the sections Bacon has to place outside the structure, which is the objection stated visually; the note beneath the lower scheme states the corresponding weakness in Kingsbury's. Neither is drawn as the winner, because the evidence does not settle it.
6. Further Reading
- W. D. Davies and Dale C. Allison Jr., A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Gospel according to Saint Matthew, vol. 1 (Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark, 1988). The introduction contains the fullest recent discussion of Matthew's structure and of Bacon's proposal.
- Dale C. Allison Jr., The New Moses: A Matthean Typology (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993). The strongest case for Moses typology in Matthew, argued as theme rather than as outline.
- Jack Dean Kingsbury, Matthew: Structure, Christology, Kingdom (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1975). The three-part proposal in its original form.
- J. Andrew Overman, Matthew's Gospel and Formative Judaism: The Social World of the Matthean Community (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1990). Matthew as a sectarian document within Judaism.
- Anthony J. Saldarini, Matthew's Christian-Jewish Community (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994). A sociologically careful statement of the "still inside" reading.
- Graham N. Stanton, A Gospel for a New People: Studies in Matthew (Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark, 1992). The "already outside" reading, with a detailed treatment of "their synagogues."
- Raymond E. Brown, The Birth of the Messiah, new updated ed. (New York: Doubleday, 1993). The standard treatment of the genealogy and of the four women in it.
- Ulrich Luz, Studies in Matthew, trans. Rosemary Selle (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2005). Essays on structure and on the history of Matthew's interpretation.
In short
- Matthew closes five speeches with a fixed formula ("When Jesus had finished..." at 7:28, 11:1, 13:53, 19:1, 26:1), which is stronger structural evidence than most proposed Gospel outlines because it is verbal and repeated, not thematic — narrative and discourse alternate five times between an infancy narrative and a passion narrative.
- Bacon's 1930 proposal that the five discourses form a "new Pentateuch" (Jesus as a new Moses on a mountain, 5:1, versus Luke's "level place," 6:17) is undercut by the objection that it makes the passion narrative — the Gospel's longest continuous stretch of narrative — into a mere epilogue outside the structure.
- Kingsbury's rival three-part structure hinges on the identical phrase "From that time, Jesus began" at 4:17 and 16:21, making the passion central rather than appended, but rests on only two occurrences of an unremarkable temporal phrase against Bacon's five occurrences of a distinctive formula.
- Matthew's genealogy begins with Abraham rather than Adam (unlike Luke 3:38), is arranged in three groups of fourteen despite the third group actually containing thirteen by most counts (1:17), and names four women — Tamar, Rahab, Ruth, and "her who had been the wife of Uriah" — whose common thread (Gentile connection, irregular union, or both, per Raymond Brown) has been debated for centuries.
- Whether Matthew's community was still inside the synagogue arguing as a faction (Overman, Saldarini) or already separated and self-defining (Stanton, citing "their synagogues" at 4:23/9:35/10:17/12:9/13:54 and the unrestricted mission of 28:19) cannot be settled from the text alone, since we have only the book and no independent record of its readers.
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Matthew organizes its teaching into five blocks, each closed by the same formula ("When Jesus had finished..."), and Bacon read this as a deliberate "new Pentateuch" with Jesus as a new Moses — a reading whose fatal weakness is that it turns the passion narrative into a mere epilogue. Kingsbury's rival proposal hinges the whole book on the phrase "From that time, Jesus began," appearing only at 4:17 and 16:21, making the road to Jerusalem central instead. Matthew's opening genealogy is equally deliberate: it begins at Abraham rather than Adam, forces its generations into three fourteens (fudging the count to do it), and includes four women whose stories are all in some way irregular. Whether Matthew's community had already broken from the synagogue or was still arguing its case inside it remains genuinely unresolved — the text supports both readings and we have no outside witness to decide between them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The lecture treats a repeated verbal formula as stronger structural evidence than a repeated theme. Explain why, and then try to construct a case against that principle: is there a situation in which thematic evidence would be the stronger?
- Bacon's proposal is criticised for putting the passion narrative outside the structure. Could a defender of Bacon answer that objection — for instance, by arguing that a frame is a position of honour rather than of demotion? Assess that answer.
- Matthew imposes a three-times-fourteen pattern on a genealogy that does not naturally produce it, and says so openly at 1:17. What does an author's willingness to display his own arrangement tell you about what he expects his readers to do with it?
- The four women in the genealogy are often summarised as "outsiders included." The lecture calls that summary too tidy. Take one of the four — Tamar, Rahab, Ruth, or the wife of Uriah — read her story, and say whether the summary fits her case.
- Weigh the phrase "their synagogues" against the fact that Matthew, unlike Mark, does not explain Jewish customs to his readers. Which is the stronger indicator of his community's position, and why?
- If the "parting of the ways" was gradual, local and uneven, the question "inside or outside?" may be badly posed. What would a better-posed question look like, and could the text answer it?