Lecture 1-2: Before There Was a Canon
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Word "Canon" and the Question It Answers
- Lecture 1-2: Before There Was a Canon
- Lecture 1-3: What "Criteria" Can and Cannot Explain
- Lecture 1-4: Who Decides? Church and Scripture
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading the Front and Back of My Bible
- Lecture 2-1: Law, Prophets and Writings
- Lecture 2-2: The Greek Old Testament
- Lecture 2-3: The Scrolls from the Desert and the Shape of Scripture
- Lecture 2-4: Three Old Testaments
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Three Lists Side by Side
- Lecture 3-1: The Gospels and Paul's Letters Are Gathered
- Lecture 3-2: Reading the Early Lists
- Lecture 3-3: The Books Still Discussed
- Lecture 3-4: Councils and Fathers: Deciding or Confirming?
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Following One Book Through the Lists
- Lecture 4-1: Scribes, Papyrus and the Codex
- Lecture 4-2: Great Uncials and Many Minuscules
- Lecture 4-3: The Hebrew Text and Its Witnesses
- Lecture 4-4: What Careful Copying Looks Like, and Where It Fails
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Copy a Sentence
- Lecture 5-1: Kinds of Variants and Why They Arose
- Lecture 5-2: How Scholars Weigh Readings
- Lecture 5-3: Three Hard Cases
- Lecture 5-4: Ancient Translations as Witnesses
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Footnote
Lecture 1-1 said that the reading came first and the lists came later. This lecture goes back to the time before the lists. It asks a simple question: before anyone wrote down which books were Scripture, what did God's people actually do with their books?
The answer is not "nothing" and it is not "they had a Bible like ours". They wrote. They copied. They read aloud in assemblies. They kept writings in holy places and handed them to the next generation. They sent letters from one church to another. They gathered what they had into collections. Long before there was a canon as a closed list, there was Scripture as a living practice: books received, guarded and heard.
We look at two communities. First, Israel and the Jewish people, whose holy writings, the Law and the Prophets and other books, were already received and read in Jesus' day. Second, the earliest Christian churches, who read those same writings and soon began to read new ones beside them: accounts of Jesus and letters from apostles. In both cases we look at what the sources say, and we keep apart what is certain from what is debated. This lecture gives no numbers; it is about practices, not counts.
What these 24 minutes give you
- Describe how Israel's holy writings were kept and read in public, using Deuteronomy 31 and the synagogue scenes in Luke and Acts.
- Explain the difference between a scroll and a codex, and why the difference matters for the story of the canon.
- Describe how letters from apostles were read aloud and passed between churches, using Colossians 4:16 and 1 Thessalonians 5:27.
- Summarise, in your own words, what an early Christian writer reported about readings in Sunday worship.
- Explain why "Scripture before the canon" is not a contradiction.
Moses wrote this law, and delivered it to the priests the sons of Levi, who bore the ark of the covenant of Yahweh, and to all the elders of Israel. Moses commanded them, saying, “At the end of every seven years, in the set time of the year of release, in the feast of tents, when all Israel has come to appear before Yahweh your God in the place which he will choose, you shall read this law before all Israel in their hearing. Assemble the people, the men and the women and the little ones, and the foreigners who are within your gates, that they may hear, and that they may learn, and fear Yahweh your God, and observe to do all the words of this law; and that their children, who have not known, may hear, and learn to fear Yahweh your God, as long as you live in the land where you go over the Jordan to possess it.”" — Deuteronomy 31:9-13
World English Bible
He came to Nazareth, where he had been brought up. He entered, as was his custom, into the synagogue on the Sabbath day, and stood up to read. The book of the prophet Isaiah was handed to him. He opened the book, and found the place where it was written," — Luke 4:16-17
WEB
When this letter has been read among you, cause it to be read also in the assembly of the Laodiceans; and that you also read the letter from Laodicea." — Colossians 4:16
WEB
I solemnly command you by the Lord that this letter be read to all the holy brothers." — 1 Thessalonians 5:27
WEB
Every one of these passages is about hearing. A law is written down so that it can be read aloud to everyone, children and foreigners included. A scroll is handed to a reader in the synagogue. A letter is read in one assembly and sent on to the next. Before Scripture was a list, it was something people heard together.
1. Written, kept, read aloud
Deuteronomy 31 describes a pattern that runs through Israel's story. Moses writes the law. He hands it to the priests who carry the ark and to the elders. And he commands that it be read aloud, at a fixed feast, to the whole people: men, women, children and the foreigners living among them.
Three things happen in that passage, and they are worth naming because they come back again and again in this course.
- The words are written down. Something that could have stayed only in memory is fixed in writing.
- The writing is entrusted to keepers. Priests and elders are responsible for it. It is kept with the ark, in a holy place.
- The writing is read in public. It is not a private book for experts. Its purpose is that the people may hear, learn and obey, and that their children may learn after them.
Notice what the passage does not do. It does not give a list of all the books Israel would one day hold sacred. It speaks of "this law". The habit of writing, keeping and reading came before any list.
The same pattern appears in other scenes. In the days of King Josiah, the high priest Hilkiah reports that he has found "the book of the law" in the temple, and it is read before the king and then before the people (2 Kings 22-23). Scholars discuss what exactly that book was, and readers differ on it; the scene shows at least that a written book could be lost, found, recognised and read aloud as binding. Much later, after the return from exile, Ezra the scribe reads the law before the assembly in Jerusalem, and others help the people understand it (Nehemiah 8). Week 6 returns to that scene, because it is one of the Bible's own pictures of explaining Scripture in a language people understand.
2. The Law, the Prophets and other books
By the time of Jesus, Jewish communities read their holy writings every Sabbath in the synagogue. Two scenes in Luke's writings show this plainly. In Luke 4, Jesus stands up to read in the synagogue at Nazareth, and the book of the prophet Isaiah is handed to him. In Acts 13, Paul and his companions sit in a synagogue in Pisidian Antioch, and the rulers invite them to speak "after the reading of the law and the prophets" (Acts 13:15).
Those two words, the Law and the Prophets, were a common way of naming Israel's Scriptures. In Luke 24:44, quoted in lecture 1-1, Jesus uses three names: "the law of Moses, the prophets, and the psalms". A Jewish book from before Jesus' time, the book of Sirach (also called Ecclesiasticus), has a preface written by the author's grandson when he translated the book into Greek. In it he speaks of the law, the prophets and the other books that followed them. Sirach is a book that Catholic and Orthodox Christians receive as Scripture and that Protestant Bibles usually leave out or print in a separate section; whichever way your church reads it, its preface is valuable as a witness to how Jews of that time spoke of their holy writings.
What these sources show is that a body of holy writings was received and read as Scripture well before the first Christians. What they do not settle is whether the outer edge of that body was already fixed, and which books lay inside it. The Law was clearly central. The Prophets were clearly read. Beyond that, scholars of every tradition disagree on when the third group of writings reached its final form, and the disagreement touches the differences between Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox Old Testaments. Week 2 takes up that question in each tradition's own reasons. For now it is enough to see that Jesus and his first followers grew up inside a community that already had Scripture, read it aloud, and argued from it.
3. Scrolls: one book at a time
When Jesus was handed "the book of the prophet Isaiah", what he held was almost certainly a scroll: a long strip made of sheets of papyrus or leather joined together, written in columns and rolled up at both ends. The reader unrolls with one hand and rolls up with the other.
A scroll has three features that matter for our story.
- It holds one large book, or a few small ones. A long book like Isaiah filled a scroll by itself. There was no single object that held "the whole Bible". A synagogue might have a cupboard or chest with several scrolls in it.
- It is hard to search. To find a place, you unroll to it. Luke says Jesus "found the place where it was written" (Luke 4:17), which a reader of a scroll had to do by knowing the text well.
- Its order is not printed anywhere. The scrolls in a chest do not have to sit in a fixed order. A contents page, in the sense of lecture 1-1, did not yet exist.
So when we say Israel had Scripture in Jesus' day, we should picture a set of scrolls, read in public, kept with care, and known by heart by many. We should not picture a single bound volume with a fixed number of books inside.
4. Letters that travel
The earliest Christian writings we have are letters. Paul wrote to churches in cities he had visited or hoped to visit. The letters were not written as books for a library. They were written to be read aloud to an assembly, most of whose members could not read.
Paul says so himself. At the end of 1 Thessalonians, he puts the Thessalonians under a solemn charge to have the letter read to all the brothers (1 Thessalonians 5:27). At the end of Colossians, he asks that the letter be read in the church at Laodicea as well, and that the Colossians read "the letter from Laodicea" in turn (Colossians 4:16). This second verse shows three things.
- A letter written to one church was meant to be shared with another.
- Churches therefore copied letters, because a letter cannot be in two cities at once.
- Not every letter mentioned survived as a book we now have. Readers have long discussed what "the letter from Laodicea" was: a lost letter, or one we know under another name. The verse is honest that the collection we inherited is not a complete archive of everything that was written.
Over time, the letters of Paul were gathered into a collection. When and how is a question for week 3, where the sources for it are read in some detail. Already within the New Testament, 2 Peter 3:15-16 speaks of "all of his letters" and sets them beside "the other Scriptures", which shows that at the time of that letter Paul's letters were known as a group and treated with great seriousness.
5. Accounts of Jesus
Alongside the letters, churches had accounts of the words and deeds of Jesus. Luke opens his Gospel by saying that many had already set out to write an orderly account, drawing on those who were eyewitnesses and ministers of the word, and that he too had followed everything carefully (Luke 1:1-4). Luke does not pretend that his book fell from heaven. He describes research, sources and a purpose: that his reader may know the certainty of what he has been taught.
That opening is worth keeping in mind for the whole course. The Bible itself shows writers who gathered, checked and wrote down what had been handed on. It does not hide the human work. Christians of every tradition hold that God was at work in and through that human work; they do not usually hold that the human work did not happen.
6. The codex: a Christian choice
At some point in the early centuries, Christians began to copy their writings in a different form: the codex. A codex is made of sheets folded and stacked, then sewn along one edge, the shape of an ordinary book today. It was not invented by Christians; it was used for notebooks and everyday writing. But the surviving evidence shows that Christians used it for their sacred books far more readily, and earlier, than their neighbours used it for literature.
Why they did so is debated, and no single reason is certain. Some suggest that a codex was cheaper, since it is written on both sides. Some suggest it was easier to carry, which suited travelling teachers and churches spread across the empire. Some suggest it was easier to search, which helped people who compared passages and quoted them in argument. Some suggest that it allowed several writings, such as four Gospels or a set of letters, to be held together in one volume. These reasons do not exclude one another.
The codex matters for the in one plain way: a codex can hold a collection, and a collection has an order and an edge. When several books are bound together, someone has to decide which ones go in and in what sequence. The form of the book did not decide the canon, but it made the question of the list more visible. Week 4 returns to the codex and to the scribes who copied it.
7. Reading in Sunday worship: a second-century witness
The clearest early description of Christian reading in worship comes from Justin, a teacher and philosopher who became a Christian and taught in Rome in the middle of the second century. He was later put to death for his faith, and the church remembers him as Justin Martyr.
Justin wrote a defence of Christianity addressed to the emperor, in which he tried to explain what Christians actually did, since rumours about them were dark. Near the end of it he describes a Sunday gathering. As he tells it, on the day called Sunday believers from the city and the countryside come together, and the memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read, for as long as time allows. When the reader stops, the one presiding speaks, urging the people to imitate these good things. Then all stand and pray, and the bread and the cup are brought.
Three features of Justin's account deserve notice.
- Two kinds of writing are read side by side. The writings of the prophets are Israel's Scriptures. The memoirs of the apostles are, as Justin explains elsewhere, the accounts we call Gospels. The church had begun to read accounts of Jesus in the same act of worship as the Scriptures of Israel.
- Reading is followed by teaching. A reading is not left alone; it is explained and applied.
- No list is given. Justin does not say which memoirs, or how many. His purpose was to describe worship, not to settle a canon.
How Justin was received is part of the story too. He wrote to outsiders, and he wanted them to see that Christians were not dangerous. His report is therefore a defence and not a neutral description. But it agrees in its broad outline with what other sources suggest, and readers of every tradition use it as an early window into Christian worship.
8. Why "Scripture before the canon" is not a contradiction
Put the pieces together and you can see why it is fair to say that the church had Scripture before it had a canon in the sense of a closed list.
- Israel received, kept and read its holy writings long before any surviving list of all of them.
- The first Christians read those writings as Scripture, and argued from them about Jesus.
- Within a few generations, Christians read accounts of Jesus and letters of apostles beside them in worship.
- Letters were copied and passed on; accounts were gathered; codices held collections.
- Only after all this, as lecture 1-1 said and week 3 will show, did Christian writers make lists and use the word canon for them.
This does not mean the list was unimportant, or that the books were loosely held. It means that a canon as a norm, writings heard as the word of God, came before a canon as a list. The list described, tested and finally fixed what churches had been hearing for a long time.
The order of things
Writing, keeping and reading aloud came first. Gathering into collections came next. The written lists came after that. Any account that reverses the order should be checked against the sources.
It also means that the early history was shared. No single person made the Scriptures of Israel, and no single person made the reading practice of the churches. Many scribes, readers, teachers and congregations were involved. That is part of what the course means when it speaks of God's people receiving, guarding, copying and translating these books.
Diagram 1. Before the lists: what communities did
In short
- Before any list, Israel wrote its law down, entrusted it to keepers and read it aloud to the whole people.
- In Jesus' day the Law and the Prophets were read in synagogues; when the outer edge was fixed is still debated.
- A scroll held one large book with no fixed order among scrolls; a codex could hold a collection, with an order and an edge.
- Paul's letters were read aloud in assemblies and passed between churches, so they were copied.
- Justin, in second-century Rome, describes the prophets and the memoirs of the apostles read in Sunday worship, then explained.
- The church had Scripture as a norm before it had a canon as a closed list.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Deuteronomy 31:9-13 | The law is written, entrusted to priests and elders, and read aloud to the whole people. |
| Scroll and codex | A scroll holds one large book; a codex binds sheets and can hold a collection in an order. |
| Colossians 4:16 | A letter read in one church is to be read in another: letters were shared and copied. |
| Justin's Sunday | The memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read; then the one presiding teaches. |
One sentence to remember Before Scripture was a list, it was something God's people heard together.
This week's action At your next worship service, notice which parts of Scripture are read aloud, and by whom.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Deuteronomy 31 says the law was to be read so that children and foreigners would hear it too. What does that suggest about who Scripture was for?
- Most early hearers of Paul's letters could not read them for themselves. How might hearing a letter read aloud in an assembly differ from reading it alone?
- Colossians 4:16 mentions "the letter from Laodicea". How do you respond to the thought that not every letter mentioned in the New Testament has survived?
- Why might the shape of a book (scroll or codex) affect the question "which books belong together?"
- Justin describes readings followed by teaching. In your own congregation, what is read aloud, and what follows the reading?
- Luke describes research and sources behind his Gospel (Luke 1:1-4). Does that strengthen or trouble your trust in his account? Why?