Lecture 12-1: The Quests for the Historical Jesus, from Reimarus to the Present
목차 37
- Lecture 1-1: Gospel as a Genre: Biography, History, or Something Else
- Lecture 1-2: Oral Tradition, Written Sources, and How the Gospels Reached Us
- Lecture 1-3: Why Three, and Why They Are Called Synoptic
- Lecture 2-1: The Data: Agreements, Disagreements, and Order
- Lecture 2-2: The Two-Source Theory and the Case for Q
- Lecture 2-3: The Alternatives: Griesbach, Farrer, and the Present State of the Question
- Lecture 3-1: Galilee and Judea under Rome
- Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
- Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
- Lecture 4-1: Structure, Pace, and the Shape of Mark's Story
- Lecture 4-2: Mark's Christology and the Question of the Messianic Secret
- Lecture 4-3: Discipleship, Failure, and the Ending at 16:8
- Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
- Lecture 5-2: Fulfilment, Scripture, and the Law in Matthew
- Lecture 5-3: The Community Addressed: Church, Mission, and Judgment
- Lecture 6-1: Luke's Preface, Sources, and Claim to Orderly Account
- Lecture 6-2: Reversal: The Poor, Women, Samaritans, and Outsiders
- Lecture 6-3: The Spirit, Prayer, and the Journey to Jerusalem
- Lecture 7-1: What Jesus Announced, and What His Hearers Would Have Heard
- Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
- Lecture 7-3: The Sermon on the Mount and the Demands of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-1: How Parables Work, and How They Have Been Misread
- Lecture 8-2: Parables of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal
- Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
- Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil
- Lecture 9-3: How Historians and Theologians Have Handled the Miracle Accounts
- Lecture 10-1: The Sabbath and Purity Controversies
- Lecture 10-2: The Temple Action and What It Meant
- Lecture 10-3: Jesus and the Restoration of Israel: The Twelve and the Nations
- Lecture 11-1: The Last Supper and the Arrest
- Lecture 11-2: Trial, Crucifixion, and the Three Passion Narratives Compared
- Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts
This lecture is a history of a question. The question is: what can be known about Jesus of Nazareth by the methods historians use on any other figure of antiquity, and how does what is known that way relate to what the churches confess? The question in that form is about two hundred and fifty years old. It could not have been asked much earlier, because it presupposes two things that are themselves modern — a settled distinction between the account a source gives and the events the source reports, and a willingness to treat the Gospels as sources of that kind at all.
The history that follows is usually divided into quests: a First Quest running from the late eighteenth century to Albert Schweitzer's survey of it in 1906, a period of scepticism dominated by Rudolf Bultmann, a New Quest launched by Ernst Kaesemann in 1953, and a Third Quest from around 1980 to the present. That division is a convenience and it is inaccurate at several points, as the lecture will note. Serious historical work on Jesus continued through the supposedly barren decades, and the Third Quest is not one project but several that disagree with each other. Still, the divisions are used in the literature and a student who cannot follow them cannot follow the literature.
The argument of the lecture is that the variety of results in this field is not chiefly caused by the personal bias of researchers, although bias has been present, but by choices of method made early and then not revisited: which sources count, which sayings are taken as the interpretive centre, and whether Jesus is placed inside Second Temple Judaism or over against it. Schweitzer's famous complaint — that each researcher found a Jesus who resembled himself — is often quoted as a general scepticism about the enterprise. Read in context it is more specific and more useful: he was describing what happens when a method has too few constraints, and his response was not to abandon the method but to constrain it, in his case by taking the apocalyptic sayings as the fixed point.
이 37분으로 얻는 것
- Explain what Hermann Samuel Reimarus proposed and why the posthumous publication of his fragments is usually taken as the beginning of critical research on Jesus.
- Describe the nineteenth-century lives of Jesus as a genre, including David Friedrich Strauss's mythical reading and the liberal Protestant portrait represented by Adolf von Harnack, and state Schweitzer's objection to both.
- Distinguish Rudolf Bultmann's historical scepticism from his theological programme, and explain why Ernst Kaesemann thought the question had to be reopened from inside Bultmann's own school.
- Summarise, in one sentence each, the portraits of Jesus associated with E. P. Sanders, John P. Meier, John Dominic Crossan, Marcus Borg, N. T. Wright, James Dunn, and Dale Allison, and identify at least two points where they genuinely contradict one another.
- Describe the working method of the Jesus Seminar and state the main lines of criticism directed at it, distinguishing criticism of its conclusions from criticism of its procedure.
Since many have undertaken to set in order a narrative concerning those matters which have been fulfilled among us, even as those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and servants of the word delivered them to us, it seemed good to me also, having traced the course of all things accurately from the first, to write to you in order, most excellent Theophilus; that you might know the certainty concerning the things in which you were instructed. — Luke 1:1-4
World English Bible
Now after John was taken into custody, Jesus came into Galilee, preaching the Good News of the Kingdom of God, and saying, “The time is fulfilled, and the Kingdom of God is at hand! Repent, and believe in the Good News.” — Mark 1:14-15
WEB
For John came neither eating nor drinking, and they say, ‘He has a demon.’ The Son of Man came eating and drinking, and they say, ‘Behold, a gluttonous man and a drunkard, a friend of tax collectors and sinners!’ But wisdom is justified by her children.” — Matthew 11:18-19
WEB
Luke 1:1-4 stands over the whole lecture because every phase of research has had to take a position on it. Reimarus read the preface as a claim that could be tested and found wanting; Harnack read it as evidence of a sober historian; Bultmann read it as a conventional literary preface that tells us about Luke's ambitions rather than about his sources; Richard Bauckham reads "eyewitnesses" as a term with weight. The verse has not changed. Mark 1:14-15 is here because it is the summary of Jesus' preaching that Schweitzer and, differently, Sanders both take as the centre — the announcement of a basileia, a "kingdom" or "reign" of God, described as near. Matthew 11:18-19 is here for a different reason: it is a saying that reports an accusation against Jesus, and the fact that his followers preserved an insult about him is the kind of datum on which the criterion of embarrassment, discussed in the next lecture, is built.
1. Before the quests: why the question could not be asked earlier
Ancient and medieval writers were perfectly capable of noticing that the Gospels differ. Augustine wrote a treatise on the subject, De consensu evangelistarum, in the late fourth century, and his solutions are careful and sometimes ingenious. What he did not do — what nobody did before the eighteenth century — was to treat the differences as evidence for reconstructing something behind the texts that might not match any of them.
Two developments made that step possible. The first was the rise of source-critical work on other bodies of ancient literature, especially in classical historiography, which established the habit of asking what a writer had in front of him and how he used it. The second was a change in the standing of miracle reports, associated with English deism and then with the German Enlightenment, in which such reports came to be treated not as data about the world but as data about the reporter. Once both moves were available, the Gospels could be read as documents produced by people with purposes, at some remove from events, and the gap between the document and the event became a research problem.
It is worth saying plainly that this development was not simply hostile. It was carried out largely by Protestant theologians in university faculties of theology, often with the conviction that a faith resting on a defensible historical foundation would be stronger than one resting on ecclesiastical authority. Whether that conviction was sound is one of the questions lecture 12-2 takes up.
2. Reimarus and the first proposal
Hermann Samuel Reimarus (1694-1768) was a professor of oriental languages in Hamburg. During his lifetime he published unobjectionable scholarly work. After his death, Gotthold Ephraim Lessing published portions of a long manuscript Reimarus had kept private, issuing them between 1774 and 1778 as anonymous "fragments" from an unnamed author, which allowed the ideas into circulation while preserving deniability about their source.
The seventh fragment, on the aims of Jesus and his disciples, made the proposal that founds the field. Reimarus argued that Jesus was a Jewish figure with a political aim: the establishment of an earthly kingdom, in continuity with Jewish expectation of that period as Reimarus understood it. That aim failed, and Jesus died as its failure. The disciples, unwilling to return to their former lives, then stole the body and reconstructed the message around a spiritual redeemer who would return, thereby inventing Christianity as a second and different thing from what Jesus had intended.
Almost no part of that reconstruction is defended today. The theft of the body is a charge the Gospels themselves report as a rumour and it is not made plausible by Reimarus's handling; his account of Jewish messianic expectation is far too uniform, as this course has repeatedly noted; and his reading of the disciples' motives is a piece of speculative psychology. What survives is the structure of the question. Reimarus distinguished the aim of Jesus from the aim of those who preached him, and asserted that the second could be a distortion of the first. Every subsequent phase of research has operated inside that distinction, including phases that conclude the distortion is minimal.
3. The nineteenth century: lives of Jesus as a genre
Between roughly 1820 and 1900 a very large number of "lives of Jesus" were published, mostly in Germany, and they constitute a genre with recognisable conventions: a narrative from birth to death, a psychological account of Jesus' developing self-understanding, a rationalising or bracketing treatment of miracle reports, and a climax in which Jesus' inner consciousness of God is presented as the substance of his significance.
David Friedrich Strauss's Das Leben Jesu, kritisch bearbeitet (1835-36) belongs to this period but breaks its conventions, which is why it cost him his career. Strauss argued that the deadlock between supernaturalist readings, which accepted the miracle accounts as reports, and rationalist readings, which explained them as misdescribed natural events, was produced by a shared mistake: both assumed the accounts were meant as reports. Strauss proposed instead that many Gospel narratives are myth in a technical sense — the expression of an idea in narrative form, generated by a community working with the categories of the Hebrew Bible. The transfiguration is not a report of an event nor a garbled memory of a trick of light; it is a narrative statement about who Jesus is, formed on the pattern of Moses on the mountain.
The liberal Protestant portrait that dominated the end of the century is best represented by Adolf von Harnack's lectures published as Das Wesen des Christentums (1900), translated as What Is Christianity?. Harnack argued that the essence of Jesus' message could be stated in three points: the kingdom of God and its coming, God the Father and the infinite value of the human soul, and the higher righteousness and the commandment of love. The apocalyptic material — the imminent end, the judgment, the Son of Man coming on clouds — Harnack treated as the time-bound husk in which the kernel had been carried.
Harnack and his critics
This is a point where readers will not agree. Harnack's procedure was not arbitrary; it was governed by a substantive theological judgment, that the permanently valid content of a religion can be distinguished from its historical vehicle. That judgment has real defenders and real critics. Schweitzer's objection, taken up in a moment, was historical: the husk is not detachable because it is the frame of the whole. Others objected theologically, holding that a religion whose content survives the removal of its historical particulars is no longer the religion in question. Karl Barth's break with after 1918 is the most consequential form of that objection. A student should be able to state Harnack's position in a form Harnack would accept before criticising it; the caricature of liberal theology as sentimental moralism is a caricature.
4. Schweitzer, and what he actually argued
Albert Schweitzer's Von Reimarus zu Wrede (1906), translated as The Quest of the Historical Jesus, is two books in one. The first is a survey and critique of the lives of Jesus written over the preceding century and a quarter. The second, much shorter, is Schweitzer's own reconstruction.
The critique is the part that is quoted. Schweitzer observed that the nineteenth-century researchers had, with remarkable consistency, produced a Jesus who embodied their own highest values — a Kantian moral teacher, a Hegelian idea, a Romantic religious genius. His metaphor is of a man looking into a deep well and seeing his own reflection. The point of the metaphor is not that historical study is futile but that a method which supplies no resistance will return what was put into it. Schweitzer thought the resistance was available and had been refused, because it lay in exactly the material Harnack had set aside.
Schweitzer's own reconstruction, developing a line already taken by Johannes Weiss in a short book of 1892, made the apocalyptic expectation central and consistent. On this reading, Jesus expected the imminent, God-wrought end of the present age; he sent out the twelve in the expectation that the end would arrive before they returned; when it did not, he went to Jerusalem to force the issue, and he died with the expectation unfulfilled. Schweitzer took this to be a portrait no one would have invented for edification, and he said as much: the Jesus he had found was a stranger to his own age and to Schweitzer's.
Two things follow that are worth stating carefully. First, Schweitzer's Jesus is not a comfortable result, and a student who suspects that Schweitzer merely reflected his own values in the well has to explain why the reflection was so unwelcome. Second, Schweitzer did not thereby escape the problem he identified. His reconstruction rests on the historicity of a specific set of sayings and on a particular reading of Matthew 10 as a mission that failed, and both have been contested since. Identifying the mechanism of a bias does not immunise a scholar against it.
5. Bultmann: scepticism about the facts, seriousness about the tradition
Rudolf Bultmann is regularly described as having held that almost nothing can be known about Jesus. The description is based on a real sentence — in Jesus and the Word (1926) he wrote that we can now know almost nothing concerning the life and personality of Jesus — but the sentence has to be read with the two qualifications it contains. "Life and personality" is a reference to the genre just described, the developmental psychological biography, and Bultmann is denying that the sources support it. He was not denying that Jesus existed, that he taught, or that his teaching can be substantially recovered; the same book proceeds to expound that teaching at length.
Bultmann's scepticism was a consequence of his form-critical work, described in this course's first chapter, in which the units of the Synoptic tradition were classified by their form and assigned to settings in the life of the early communities. If a unit's shape is explained by its use in the community, then the unit is direct evidence for the community and only indirect evidence for Jesus. Sequence and setting in particular he took to be the evangelists' framework rather than inherited data, following Karl Ludwig Schmidt.
The theological argument matters more for our purposes. Bultmann held that Christian faith does not and must not rest on the results of historical research, because such results are always provisional and because a faith secured by historical proof would be a form of works. What faith rests on is the proclamation, the kerygma — the church's preached message that in this crucified man God has acted. That is why he could combine severe historical scepticism with a theology of great confidence, a combination that looks incoherent only if one assumes faith must be historically grounded.
6. Kaesemann and the New Quest
The reopening came from inside Bultmann's own circle. In a lecture to a reunion of former Marburg students in 1953, published as "Das Problem des historischen Jesus," Ernst Kaesemann argued that Bultmann's position was theologically unstable. If the church's proclamation is about a particular man who lived, and if no continuity between that man and the proclamation can be shown, then the proclamation floats free and becomes myth in the pejorative sense. Kaesemann's concern was specifically anti-docetic: the confession that God acted in a human life requires that the human life not be a blank.
The New Quest, pursued by Kaesemann, Guenther Bornkamm, Ernst Fuchs and others, was accordingly modest in aim. It did not attempt a biography. It looked for points of continuity between the preaching of Jesus and the preaching about Jesus, working chiefly through sayings and using the criterion of dissimilarity heavily. Bornkamm's Jesus of Nazareth (1956) is its most readable product. The New Quest's dependence on dissimilarity is precisely what lecture 12-2 will examine, because that dependence built a defect into the results.
7. The Third Quest: what changed
From around 1980 the field changed in ways that justify a new label, though "Third Quest" was coined by N. T. Wright and is not accepted by everyone.
Four changes matter. First, Jesus is placed within Second Temple Judaism rather than as its critic or transcender; this owes a great deal to the reassessment of Judaism in the same period by scholars including Sanders himself, and to a wider post-war reckoning within Christian scholarship. Second, the evidence base widened: the Dead Sea Scrolls became fully available, archaeological work in Galilee expanded enormously, and Josephus was reread with more care. Third, actions rather than sayings became the starting point for several major reconstructions, on the grounds that actions are harder to invent and less subject to the transmission problems of sayings. Fourth, the field became international and interconfessional in a way it had not been — Catholic, Jewish, and secular scholars are central to it, where the earlier phases were overwhelmingly German Protestant.
Here are seven contemporary positions, each stated in one sentence. The one-sentence form is a teaching device and each of these scholars would object to the compression; the point is to make the disagreements visible.
E. P. Sanders. Jesus was a Jewish prophet of the restoration of Israel who expected God to act soon, whose temple action was a symbolic announcement of destruction and rebuilding, and who did not in fact break the law in ways that would explain his execution as a legal matter.
John P. Meier. Jesus was a marginal Jew — a Galilean layman without office or standing — who preached the kingdom as both future and already breaking in, worked deeds his contemporaries took as miracles, and can be reconstructed only by explicit, publicly stated criteria applied case by case.
John Dominic Crossan. Jesus was a Jewish peasant teacher of a radically egalitarian wisdom, expressed in open table fellowship and free healing, whose message was social and immediate rather than apocalyptic, and whose Cynic-like style should be read against the economic pressures of Roman Galilee.
Marcus Borg. Jesus was a Spirit-filled Jewish mystic, healer, wisdom teacher, and social prophet whose criticism was directed at a purity system, and whose message concerned transformation in the present rather than an imminent end.
N. T. Wright. Jesus was an eschatological prophet who believed and enacted the claim that Israel's long exile was ending and that Israel's God was returning to Zion in and through his own ministry, so that the crucifixion was the intended climax of a deliberate .
James D. G. Dunn. The proper object of study is not a Jesus behind the tradition but the remembered Jesus — the impact he made, preserved in oral performance from the beginning, so that the tradition's stable core and variable surface are both explained by how oral communities remember.
Dale C. Allison Jr. Jesus is best approached through the recurrent patterns and general impressions of the tradition rather than through verified individual units, and those patterns yield an apocalyptic prophet substantially like Schweitzer's, a conclusion Allison holds while candidly discussing the difficulties it creates for faith.
Where the portraits conflict
This is a point where readers will not agree. These positions are not variations of emphasis; several are contradictory. Crossan and Borg hold that Jesus was not an apocalyptic figure; Allison, Sanders, Meier and Wright hold in different ways that he was, and the difference determines what is done with Mark 1:15, Mark 9:1, and Mark 13. Wright holds that Jesus consciously understood his death as the decisive redemptive act; Sanders holds that the evidence does not reach that far and that the claim reads later theology into the sources. Dunn and Allison agree that the criteria approach is inadequate but propose different replacements. A student who says "scholars disagree" has said almost nothing; the useful skill is naming the textual decision on which a given disagreement turns.
8. The Jesus Seminar
The Jesus Seminar, convened by Robert Funk in 1985 and including Crossan and Borg among its most prominent members, deserves separate treatment because it is the piece of this history most likely to be known outside the academy and most often described inaccurately.
Its procedure was as follows. A roster of fellows met twice a year to consider the sayings, and later the deeds, attributed to Jesus, and voted on each using coloured beads: red for a saying the fellow judged Jesus certainly said or something very like it, pink for probably, grey for improbable though containing his ideas, black for not his. Votes were weighted and averaged, and the results published in The Five Gospels (1993) with the text printed in the corresponding colours. Roughly eighteen per cent of the sayings received red or pink. The Gospel of Thomas was treated as an independent source of comparable value to the Synoptics, which is a methodological decision with large consequences.
The criticism came from several directions and it is important to separate them.
Criticism of procedure: voting does not produce historical knowledge, and averaging weighted votes across a group whose composition was self-selected produces a number that has the appearance of a measurement without its substance. The publicity apparatus — press releases, colour-coded editions for general readers — was held to convert provisional judgments into apparent findings.
Criticism of composition: the fellows were not a representative sample of qualified scholars, and the group's published conclusions were therefore presented as the state of the field when they were the state of one part of it.
Criticism of substance: the non-apocalyptic Jesus that emerged depends on treating the apocalyptic sayings as later community formation, which requires the prior judgment that Jesus was not apocalyptic; and the elevation of Thomas depends on an early dating that many specialists reject. Richard Hays, Luke Timothy Johnson, N. T. Wright and Dale Allison all published sustained criticisms, and their objections do not all coincide.
Two things should nevertheless be said in fairness, in line with this course's rule about caricature. The Seminar's insistence on stating its criteria publicly and applying them visibly is a virtue that much other work in the field lacks, and its results are at least auditable. And its members were not amateurs; Crossan's The Historical Jesus (1991) is a serious book whatever one concludes about it.
9. What the history shows
Three conclusions can be drawn without settling any of the disputes.
First, the disagreements track methodological choices closely enough that method is the productive place to argue. Whether one starts from sayings or actions, whether the apocalyptic material is primary or secondary, whether Thomas counts — these decisions, made early, largely determine the portrait.
Second, the field's centre of gravity has moved decisively toward reading Jesus as a Jew among Jews, and this has consequences well beyond historical accuracy. A Jesus reconstructed as the opponent of his own religion is not merely a historical error; it is the engine of a long and destructive reading tradition, as chapters 3, 8, 10 and 11 of this course noted at their own points.
Third, and against the temptation to tell this as a story of progress: the oldest live position in the field, Schweitzer's apocalyptic Jesus, is also one of the best defended today. That is not what a narrative of advancing knowledge would predict, and the mismatch is a useful warning about narratives of advancing knowledge.
The diagram sets the phases of research along a single line, with the driving question of each phase above it and the characteristic weakness identified by its critics below.
6. Further Reading
- Albert Schweitzer, The Quest of the Historical Jesus, ed. John Bowden (Fortress, 2001) — read the concluding chapter first, then the survey.
- Rudolf Bultmann, Jesus and the Word, trans. Louise Pettibone Smith and Erminie Huntress Lantero (Scribner, 1958) — short, and the corrective to most summaries of Bultmann.
- Guenther Bornkamm, Jesus of Nazareth, trans. Irene and Fraser McLuskey with James M. Robinson (Harper, 1960) — the New Quest at its most accessible.
- E. P. Sanders, Jesus and Judaism (Fortress, 1985), and his shorter The Historical Figure of Jesus (Penguin, 1993).
- John Dominic Crossan, The Historical Jesus: The Life of a Mediterranean Jewish Peasant (HarperSanFrancisco, 1991) — the method is set out explicitly in the prologue and appendix, which is where to begin.
- N. T. Wright, Jesus and the Victory of God (Fortress, 1996), and Dale C. Allison Jr., Constructing Jesus (Baker Academic, 2010) — best read against each other.
- Robert W. Funk, Roy W. Hoover and the Jesus Seminar, The Five Gospels (Macmillan, 1993), with Luke Timothy Johnson, The Real Jesus (HarperSanFrancisco, 1996) as the sharpest reply.
- Gerd Theissen and Annette Merz, The Historical Jesus: A Comprehensive Guide, trans. John Bowden (Fortress, 1998) — the standard textbook, and unusually even-handed in its surveys.
핵심 요약
- Hermann Samuel Reimarus (1694-1768), whose manuscript fragments were published anonymously by Lessing between 1774 and 1778 after his death, first proposed that Jesus had a failed political aim and that the disciples invented the resurrection message after stealing the body — almost none of that specific reconstruction survives scrutiny, but the underlying distinction between Jesus's own aim and the church's later message founded the whole field.
- Albert Schweitzer's 1906 survey used the image of a researcher looking into a deep well and seeing his own reflection; his actual response was not to abandon historical reconstruction but to constrain it by taking the apocalyptic sayings as the fixed point, producing a Jesus who expected an imminent end that did not come.
- Rudolf Bultmann's famous claim that we can know almost nothing of Jesus was specifically about "life and personality" (developmental biography), not about his existence or teaching; he grounded Christian faith instead in the church's proclamation (kerygma), which is why Ernst Kaesemann's 1953 lecture reopened the question from inside Bultmann's own school, warning that a proclamation with no demonstrable continuity to a real human life collapses into myth.
- The Jesus Seminar (convened by Robert Funk in 1985) voted with colored beads on the authenticity of sayings and judged roughly eighteen percent authentic, treating the Gospel of Thomas as an independent source of comparable value to the Synoptics — criticized for its procedure (voting is not historical method), its composition (a self-selected, unrepresentative panel), and its substance (assuming in advance that Jesus was not apocalyptic).
- Seven one-sentence portraits of contemporary scholarship genuinely contradict one another: Crossan and Borg hold Jesus was not apocalyptic, while Sanders, Meier, Wright, and Allison hold in different ways that he was — the same evidence, read through different methodological choices about which sources and sayings count as the interpretive center, yields incompatible historical Jesuses.
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: The historical study of Jesus began when Reimarus proposed, and Lessing published after his death, that Jesus's own failed political aim was different from what his disciples later preached — a specific reconstruction almost no one defends today, but a distinction every later phase of research still works inside. Schweitzer's warning that nineteenth-century researchers found their own reflection in a well is often misquoted as blanket skepticism, when his actual solution was to anchor the search in the hardest material, the apocalyptic sayings, producing an unwelcome and alien Jesus rather than a comfortable one. Bultmann's severe skepticism about Jesus's "life and personality" coexisted with theological confidence in the church's proclamation, a combination Kaesemann judged theologically unstable. And the field's more recent, most visible product, the Jesus Seminar's colored-bead voting, drew criticism on three separate and distinguishable grounds: its procedure, its unrepresentative membership, and its prior assumption about what kind of Jesus it would find.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Reimarus's specific reconstruction is defended by nobody, yet his question founded a field. What distinguishes a question worth inheriting from an answer worth discarding?
- Schweitzer criticised the nineteenth century for producing a Jesus in its own image, and then produced a Jesus he found alien. Does the second fact protect the first argument, or is it possible for a reconstruction to be both unwelcome and projected?
- Bultmann held that faith must not rest on historical results because those results are always provisional. Kaesemann held that a proclamation with no recoverable human life behind it becomes myth. Where, precisely, do these two claims conflict, and is there a position that holds both?
- Two members of the Third Quest, Crossan and Allison, work from largely the same texts and reach a non-apocalyptic and an apocalyptic Jesus respectively. Identify the specific textual decisions that separate them.
- The Jesus Seminar published its criteria and applied them visibly, which most of its critics did not. Does that transparency count in its favour, and if so, how much?
- This lecture warns against telling the history as a story of progress. What would count as evidence that a field had actually progressed, as distinct from having changed fashion?