Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
목차 37
- Lecture 1-1: Gospel as a Genre: Biography, History, or Something Else
- Lecture 1-2: Oral Tradition, Written Sources, and How the Gospels Reached Us
- Lecture 1-3: Why Three, and Why They Are Called Synoptic
- Lecture 2-1: The Data: Agreements, Disagreements, and Order
- Lecture 2-2: The Two-Source Theory and the Case for Q
- Lecture 2-3: The Alternatives: Griesbach, Farrer, and the Present State of the Question
- Lecture 3-1: Galilee and Judea under Rome
- Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
- Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
- Lecture 4-1: Structure, Pace, and the Shape of Mark's Story
- Lecture 4-2: Mark's Christology and the Question of the Messianic Secret
- Lecture 4-3: Discipleship, Failure, and the Ending at 16:8
- Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
- Lecture 5-2: Fulfilment, Scripture, and the Law in Matthew
- Lecture 5-3: The Community Addressed: Church, Mission, and Judgment
- Lecture 6-1: Luke's Preface, Sources, and Claim to Orderly Account
- Lecture 6-2: Reversal: The Poor, Women, Samaritans, and Outsiders
- Lecture 6-3: The Spirit, Prayer, and the Journey to Jerusalem
- Lecture 7-1: What Jesus Announced, and What His Hearers Would Have Heard
- Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
- Lecture 7-3: The Sermon on the Mount and the Demands of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-1: How Parables Work, and How They Have Been Misread
- Lecture 8-2: Parables of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal
- Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
- Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil
- Lecture 9-3: How Historians and Theologians Have Handled the Miracle Accounts
- Lecture 10-1: The Sabbath and Purity Controversies
- Lecture 10-2: The Temple Action and What It Meant
- Lecture 10-3: Jesus and the Restoration of Israel: The Twelve and the Nations
- Lecture 11-1: The Last Supper and the Arrest
- Lecture 11-2: Trial, Crucifixion, and the Three Passion Narratives Compared
- Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts
Almost every Christian who has heard the Gospels read aloud knows what a Pharisee is. That is the problem this lecture exists to address. The word has entered ordinary English as a synonym for a hypocrite and a legalist, and in that form it is doing work in the mind of the reader before a single verse has been examined. It is worth stating at the outset that this popular meaning is not a neutral summary of the evidence. It is the residue of a polemic, and it has a history of consequences that no course on the Gospels can responsibly leave unmentioned.
This lecture proceeds in four steps. First it examines the framework itself: the division of Jewish society into three or four "schools" comes to us from Josephus, who was writing in Greek for a Roman readership and who describes his own people's groups in categories borrowed from Greek philosophy. Before we accept his map, we should ask what it leaves out — and the answer is: most people. Second, it describes each group from the best available evidence, distinguishing carefully between what is well attested and what is guessed. Third, it takes up the Gospels' portrait of the Pharisees as a historical question — is the portrait describing Jesus' opponents, or the evangelists' opponents, or both? Here E. P. Sanders's Jesus and Judaism (1985) reframed the discussion, and his argument deserves to be stated at full strength before it is qualified. Fourth, it takes up the same portrait as an ethical question, because the reception history of these texts is not a separate topic from their interpretation.
One methodological commitment runs through the whole lecture. Jesus was a Jew, his first followers were Jews, and the disputes recorded in the Synoptic Gospels are disputes conducted inside Judaism, in Jewish terms, about how Jewish law and Jewish hope are rightly understood. A reading that treats Judaism as the dark backdrop against which the Gospel shines is not merely offensive; it is bad history, because it misidentifies the participants in every argument it purports to explain.
이 34분으로 얻는 것
- Explain where the three-schools scheme comes from, what genre pressure shaped Josephus's presentation of it, and what proportion of the population it plausibly describes.
- Describe the Pharisees, Sadducees, and Essenes in terms of their distinctive convictions and social location, and state which of those descriptions rest on Josephus, which on the Dead Sea Scrolls, which on the New Testament, and which on later rabbinic sources.
- State E. P. Sanders's argument that the Gospels' controversy scenes may reflect the evangelists' later situation, and identify both its strengths and the objections raised against it.
- Explain why the Gospels' polemical portrait of the Pharisees is an ethical problem, with reference to its reception history, and describe at least two concrete practices for handling these texts responsibly.
- Read a Synoptic controversy scene as an argument within Judaism rather than an argument against it, and say what changes when you do.
Then the Pharisees, and some of the scribes gathered together to him, having come from Jerusalem. Now when they saw some of his disciples eating bread with defiled, that is, unwashed, hands, they found fault. (For the Pharisees, and all the Jews, don’t eat unless they wash their hands and forearms, holding to the tradition of the elders. They don’t eat when they come from the marketplace, unless they bathe themselves, and there are many other things, which they have received to hold to: washings of cups, pitchers, bronze vessels, and couches.) The Pharisees and the scribes asked him, “Why don’t your disciples walk according to the tradition of the elders, but eat their bread with unwashed hands?” — Mark 7:1-5
World English Bible
He spoke also this parable to certain people who were convinced of their own righteousness, and who despised all others. “Two men went up into the temple to pray; one was a Pharisee, and the other was a tax collector. The Pharisee stood and prayed to himself like this: ‘God, I thank you, that I am not like the rest of men, extortionists, unrighteous, adulterers, or even like this tax collector. I fast twice a week. I give tithes of all that I get.’ But the tax collector, standing far away, wouldn’t even lift up his eyes to heaven, but beat his breast, saying, ‘God, be merciful to me, a sinner!’ I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other; for everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, but he who humbles himself will be exalted.” — Luke 18:9-14
WEB
There came to him Sadducees, who say that there is no resurrection. They asked him, saying, — Mark 12:18
WEB
saying, “The scribes and the Pharisees sat on Moses’ seat. All things therefore whatever they tell you to observe, observe and do, but don’t do their works; for they say, and don’t do. — Matthew 23:2-3
WEB
Four passages, chosen because they pull against one another. Mark 7:1-5 contains an explanatory aside for readers who do not know Jewish practice — and an overstatement, "the Pharisees, and all the Jews," that we will have to examine. Luke 18:9-14 is the single most influential text in forming the popular image of the Pharisee, and its opening verse shows Luke framing it as a parable about self-righteousness rather than about a party. Mark 12:18 gives, in half a verse, the one thing about the Sadducees that every source agrees on. And Matthew 23:2-3 stands at the head of the harshest chapter in the Synoptic Gospels while conceding the teaching authority of the very people it goes on to denounce — a tension that any responsible reading has to hold rather than resolve in one direction.
1. Josephus's three schools, and what the scheme hides
Our organising framework comes from one man. Flavius Josephus, born into a priestly family in Jerusalem around 37 CE, commanded Galilee in the revolt against Rome, surrendered, and spent his later life in Rome writing Jewish history in Greek for a Roman audience. In the Jewish War and again at greater length in the Antiquities he describes three haireseis among the Jews — the word is the origin of "heresy" but at this date means a school of thought or party — namely Pharisees, Sadducees, and Essenes, and in the Antiquities he adds a "fourth philosophy" associated with Judas the Galilean. He presents them very much as Greek readers would expect philosophical schools to be presented: distinguished by their doctrines, especially their positions on fate and free will and on the survival of the soul.
Two things follow. The first is that the scheme is shaped by its audience. Josephus is making Judaism intelligible and respectable to Romans, and the comparison of the Essenes to the Pythagoreans, which he makes explicitly, shows the strategy. The doctrinal contrasts he foregrounds may be real, but the emphasis is his.
The second is arithmetic. Josephus gives numbers: about 6,000 Pharisees and about 4,000 Essenes, and he does not number the Sadducees but describes them as few and drawn from the leading families. Against a Jewish population in Palestine usually estimated somewhere between half a million and a million — the estimates vary widely and the wide variation is itself the honest report — these groups together account for a very small fraction, on the order of one or two per cent. Whatever else the three schools are, they are not a description of how most Jews lived. They are the organised and self-conscious minority.
Who were the rest? The later rabbinic literature uses the term am ha-aretz, "the people of the land," for those who did not keep the stricter tithing and purity practices. It is tempting, and common in older Christian scholarship, to build on that term a picture of a despised mass, excluded and oppressed by a religious elite, waiting for a liberator. This should be resisted. The term appears in sources compiled well after the period, its sharpness varies from passage to passage, and no first-century source describes a formal class of outcasts. What can be said with more confidence is simply that most people farmed, fished, traded, kept the Sabbath and the festivals as best they could, went to Jerusalem when they could afford to, and did not belong to a party.
2. The Pharisees
Our sources for the Pharisees are three, and they do not fit together comfortably: Josephus, who was himself sympathetic to them and says so; the New Testament, which is hostile; and the rabbinic literature, which does not use the name much and which is later. Jacob Neusner argued influentially that the rabbinic traditions attributed to pre-70 figures concentrate heavily on purity, tithing, and Sabbath — which, if the attributions can be trusted, points to a movement whose distinguishing concern was the extension of priestly-style purity practice into ordinary life. That is a defensible characterisation, and it fits Mark 7's dispute exactly.
Several points deserve emphasis because they cut against the popular picture.
They were a lay movement, not a priesthood. Their authority came from learning and from reputation for piety, not from birth or office. This made them influential without making them powerful in any formal sense.
They believed in the resurrection of the dead, in angels, and in a divine compatible with human responsibility. On the first two points the New Testament itself confirms Josephus. Acts 23:8 states it flatly: "For the Sadducees say that there is no resurrection, nor angel, nor spirit; but the Pharisees confess all of these." On these questions the Pharisees stood closer to the early Christian movement than any other group named in our sources, which is why Paul, in the same passage, can identify himself as a Pharisee (Acts 23:6) in the middle of a Christian defence.
Their "tradition of the elders" was not an addition designed to evade the Law. It was an interpretive tradition intended to make the written commandments practicable in circumstances the text did not directly address. Mark 7:3-4 describes it accurately in outline while overstating its reach: the claim that "the Pharisees, and all the Jews" washed in this manner is not supported by the archaeological or literary evidence for general practice, and the aside itself shows that Mark expected readers who needed the custom explained. That is a useful clue about Mark's audience and a caution about using Mark as a description of Judaism.
Their relation to later rabbinic Judaism is real but not simple. After the destruction of the Temple in 70 CE, the sacrificial system ended and the priestly aristocracy lost its base; what emerged over the following centuries as rabbinic Judaism drew substantially on Pharisaic approaches. But the rabbinic movement was not simply the Pharisees renamed, and reading the fully developed rabbinic literature back into the first century — a habit of much older Christian scholarship, which then criticised first-century Pharisees for positions attested only centuries later — is a methodological error of the first order.
3. The Sadducees
Here the evidence is thinner, and the reason is significant: we have nothing written by a Sadducee. Everything we know comes from people who disagreed with them. They were associated with the chief priestly families and the Jerusalem aristocracy; they rejected the resurrection, which is what Mark 12:18 reports and what Acts 23:8 confirms; Josephus says they accepted only what was written and rejected the Pharisees' traditions, though scholars now caution against the older inference that they accepted only the five books of Moses, which is not clearly stated in any source. They disappear from history after 70 CE, for the plain reason that their institutional base disappeared with the Temple.
Their position in the Gospel narratives is worth noting. They appear rarely in Galilee — essentially not at all, which makes sense if their power was tied to the Temple — and they come into view in Jerusalem in the last week. In terms of who actually moved against Jesus, the Synoptic passion narratives point to the chief priests and the Temple establishment rather than to the Pharisees, who largely disappear from the story after Jesus reaches Jerusalem. That distribution is easy to miss and important to notice.
4. The Essenes and the Dead Sea Scrolls
Josephus, Philo, and Pliny the all describe a group called the Essenes: communal property, strict purity, an elaborate initiation, in Josephus's account a general avoidance of marriage, though he also knows of a marrying branch. Pliny locates a settlement of them on the western shore of the Dead Sea.
From 1947 onward, manuscripts were recovered from caves near Qumran, on the north-western shore of that sea, together with the excavation of a nearby settlement. The standard identification — that the Qumran settlement was an Essene community and the sectarian scrolls its library — was proposed early and remains the majority position. It rests on the convergence of Pliny's location, the communal organisation described in the Community Rule, and the shared emphasis on purity and calendar.
Who lived at Qumran?
This is a point where readers will not agree. The identification has been contested on several grounds. Norman Golb argued that the scrolls are not a sectarian community's library at all but material removed from Jerusalem libraries for safekeeping during the revolt, and that the settlement was a fortress. Others, including Yizhar Hirschfeld, proposed non-sectarian functions for the site such as an agricultural estate or manor. Still others accept a sectarian community but question whether "Essene" — a name that never appears in the scrolls themselves — is the right label. The majority view remains the Essene identification, and this lecture follows it while marking it as an inference rather than a datum.
For the Gospels, the Essenes matter mainly as a control. They show that first-century Judaism contained a movement far stricter than the Pharisees, with its own calendar, its own priesthood, and a settled conviction that the Jerusalem Temple was in the wrong hands. That is worth knowing when one is tempted to speak of "the Judaism of Jesus' day" as a single system. There was no such single system. Attempts to make John the Baptist or Jesus an Essene run well beyond the evidence and are not accepted in current scholarship, but the older claim that the Scrolls have nothing to contribute is equally wrong: they give us, for the first time, Jewish religious writing from this period that is neither biblical nor filtered through later editors.
5. Sanders, and the question of whose opponents these are
This is a point where readers will not agree, and it is the central disputed question of this lecture.
E. P. Sanders's Paul and Palestinian Judaism (1977) and Jesus and Judaism (1985) changed how this material is discussed. His argument, in its strongest form, runs like this. The picture of Judaism as a religion of anxious legal bookkeeping, in which one earned salvation by accumulating observances, cannot be found in the Jewish sources of the period. What those sources show is what Sanders called covenantal nomism: one is in the by God's , one keeps the commandments as the covenant's terms, and the same Law provides atonement for failure. If that is right, then the standard Christian reading of the Pharisee in Luke 18 as a representative Jewish believer misdescribes the religion. Sanders pressed further with respect to Jesus: examining the controversy stories one by one, he found remarkably little in which Jesus is shown actually transgressing the written Law, as distinct from disputing about its interpretation — and disputes about interpretation were entirely normal within Judaism, indeed constitutive of it. From this he concluded that the sharp, systemic hostility between Jesus and "the Pharisees" that the Gospels present is likely to have been shaped by the later conflict between the evangelists' communities and the synagogue, read back into the ministry.
The objections are serious and should not be waved away.
- That intra-Jewish debate could be extremely fierce is amply documented — the sectarian scrolls from Qumran denounce the Jerusalem priesthood in language quite as harsh as Matthew 23. A polemical tone therefore does not by itself prove a late date; it may simply prove a real quarrel.
- Sanders's argument works better for the earlier layers of the tradition than for all of it, and critics including John P. Meier have argued that some controversies show signs of being early, and that Jesus did claim an authority in relation to the Law that goes beyond ordinary interpretive dispute.
- N. T. Wright and others have argued that Sanders's covenantal nomism, while a corrective, flattens real diversity in the sources and understates the presence of judgment and of works-language in some of them.
- Martin Hengel objected that Sanders's reconstruction produces a Jesus so at home in his environment that his execution becomes hard to explain — a criticism that applies to more reconstructions than Sanders's alone.
Where does this leave a reader? With a distinction worth keeping. The likelihood that the Gospels' Pharisee portraits have been sharpened by later conflict is high, and it is accepted well beyond any one school. That is not the same as saying Jesus had no conflicts with Pharisees, which would be an odd conclusion given how deeply the conflict is embedded across independent strands of the tradition. The two Gospels furthest apart on this are instructive: Matthew is the harshest of the three toward the Pharisees and is also the most thoroughly Jewish of the three in its concerns — a combination that fits a bitter argument between close relatives far better than an attack from outside.
6. The ethical problem, stated plainly
This part of the lecture cannot be optional, because the texts under discussion have a history.
For most of Christian history the Pharisee of the Gospels was read as the typical Jew, and the denunciations of Matthew 23 were applied to the Jewish people as such. The result contributed to a long tradition of Christian contempt, exclusion, and violence toward Jews in Europe, whose worst consequences fall within living memory. Whatever one concludes about the historical questions above, this reception history is a matter of record, and a course that teaches the Gospels without mentioning it teaches only half of what the texts have done.
Small word, big effect
There is also a translation problem, small and consequential. Where a Gospel says "the Jews" or "the crowd," a preacher can slide without noticing into a contrast between "them" and "us" that the text does not license, since everyone in the scene, including Jesus, is a Jew. And the popular gloss of "Pharisee" as "hypocrite" does the same work in a single word.
Several practices follow, and they are practices rather than opinions:
- Keep the arguments inside Judaism. When a Synoptic controversy is read, name the position on both sides as a Jewish position. Mark 7 is not Christianity against Judaism; it is a dispute about whether an interpretive tradition rightly extends a written commandment.
- Do not let one text stand for a whole group. The Pharisee in Luke 18 is a character in a parable about self-regard, as Luke's own introduction at 18:9 says: it is addressed to "certain people who were convinced of their own righteousness," a description of a disposition rather than of a party. Luke elsewhere shows Pharisees inviting Jesus to dinner (7:36; 11:37; 14:1) and warning him of danger (13:31).
- Report the concessions. Matthew 23:2-3 grants that the scribes and Pharisees teach with authority and tells the hearers to do what they say. Mark 12:28-34 has a scribe agree with Jesus and be told he is not far from the Kingdom of God. These passages exist and are usually left out.
- Distinguish the historical question from the ethical one. Deciding that a controversy scene is early does not license using it against living people. Deciding that it is late does not make it dishonest. These are separate judgments.
A final caution, in both directions. It is possible to overcorrect — to produce a Jesus with no disagreements, whose execution then becomes inexplicable, and to treat the Gospels as simply unreliable wherever they record conflict. That is not the argument here. The argument is that the conflict was a conflict among Jews about Jewish questions, that its literary presentation has been shaped by later circumstances to a degree we cannot precisely measure, and that the caricature which entered European Christianity is answerable to neither the history nor the texts.
The first diagram gives the groups in proportion, using Josephus's own figures, and names the source behind each description.
The second diagram sets out the two readings of the Gospels' Pharisee material and what each has to account for.
6. Further Reading
- E. P. Sanders, Jesus and Judaism (SCM, 1985) — the argument summarised above, in the author's own form; read it before reading anyone's summary, including this one.
- E. P. Sanders, Judaism: Practice and Belief, 63 BCE - 66 CE (SCM/ Press, 1992) — the fuller descriptive account of common Judaism, including his treatment of the parties.
- Anthony J. Saldarini, Pharisees, Scribes and Sadducees in Palestinian Society: A Sociological Approach (Eerdmans, 1988) — a careful sifting of what each source can and cannot support.
- Jacob Neusner, The Rabbinic Traditions about the Pharisees before 70, 3 volumes (Brill, 1971) — the source-critical study behind most later claims about the Pharisees' distinctive concerns.
- John P. Meier, A Marginal Jew, volume 3: Companions and Competitors (Doubleday, 2001) — extended treatment of Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and Samaritans, with sustained argument against Sanders at several points.
- Amy-Jill Levine, The Misunderstood Jew: The Church and the Scandal of the Jewish Jesus (HarperOne, 2006) — a New Testament scholar who is also a Jew, writing directly about how Christians preach these texts.
- Géza Vermes, The Complete Dead Sea Scrolls in English, revised edition (Penguin, 2004) — the primary texts, with introductions that state the Essene identification and its grounds.
- Steve Mason, Flavius Josephus on the Pharisees: A Composition-Critical Study (Brill, 1991) — on how Josephus's own purposes shape the descriptions on which so much depends.
핵심 요약
- Josephus's three-school scheme (Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, plus a "fourth philosophy") is shaped for a Roman audience and describes only a tiny fraction of the population — about 6,000 Pharisees and 4,000 Essenes against an estimated half a million to a million Jews in Palestine — so most people belonged to no party at all.
- The Pharisees were a lay movement, not a priesthood, whose authority came from learning rather than birth; Acts 23:8 confirms Josephus that they, unlike the Sadducees, believed in resurrection, angels, and providence, putting them closer to the early Christian movement than any other named group, which is why Paul could call himself a Pharisee in his own defense (Acts 23:6).
- Nothing written by a Sadducee survives; everything known about them — priestly and aristocratic status, denial of the resurrection (Mark 12:18), disappearance from history after the Temple fell in 70 CE — comes from people who disagreed with them, and they are nearly absent from Galilee and from the Gospels' account of who actually moved against Jesus in Jerusalem.
- E. P. Sanders's "covenantal nomism" argues that Jewish sources show no religion of anxious legal bookkeeping, and that Jesus' controversies rarely show him transgressing the written Law rather than disputing its interpretation — leading Sanders to conclude the Gospels' systemic hostility toward "the Pharisees" was likely sharpened by the later conflict between the evangelists' communities and the synagogue; Martin Hengel objected that this makes Jesus so at home in his environment his execution becomes hard to explain.
- The Gospels' Pharisee portrait has a documented reception history of contributing to Christian contempt and violence toward Jews, so responsible reading requires naming both sides of a controversy as Jewish positions, refusing to let one text (like the parable in Luke 18:9-14, explicitly addressed to "certain people convinced of their own righteousness") stand for a whole group, and reporting concessions such as Matthew 23:2-3's acknowledgment that the Pharisees teach with authority.
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: "Pharisee" has become an English synonym for hypocrite, but the historical Pharisees were a small lay movement (perhaps 6,000 people) known for extending purity practice into daily life, believing in resurrection and angels, and standing closer to the earliest Christians on those points than any other Jewish group of the period. E. P. Sanders's influential argument holds that the Gospels' picture of systemic hostility between Jesus and the Pharisees likely reflects the later split between church and synagogue read back into the ministry, since Jesus is rarely shown breaking the written Law itself rather than disputing its interpretation — though Martin Hengel's objection, that this makes Jesus' execution hard to explain, has real force. Every dispute in the Synoptic Gospels is an argument within Judaism, conducted by Jews about Jewish questions, and reading it as Christianity against Judaism is not just an ethical failure but bad history — one with a documented, catastrophic reception history in European Christian antisemitism that no responsible teaching of these texts can leave unmentioned.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Mark 7:3 says "the Pharisees, and all the Jews" wash their hands before eating, and then explains the custom to the reader. What do those two features together suggest about Mark's audience, and how does that affect the use of Mark as evidence for what Jews generally did?
- Luke introduces the parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector as addressed to "certain people who were convinced of their own righteousness." Does that framing make the parable less about Pharisees, or does the choice of a Pharisee as the character still carry weight? Argue both ways.
- Sanders argues that the Gospels' systemic hostility toward the Pharisees reflects the evangelists' situation. Hengel objects that a Jesus fully at home in his environment becomes hard to execute. Can both be substantially right? What would a reconstruction that satisfies both look like?
- Nothing written by a Sadducee survives. What limits does that place on what can responsibly be said about them, and how should a teacher signal those limits without simply falling silent?
- This lecture asks that Synoptic controversies be read as arguments inside Judaism. Take one such scene and rewrite its opening sentences as you would present them to a congregation, making the intra-Jewish character explicit. What did you have to change?
- The identification of the Qumran community as Essene is an inference from converging evidence rather than a direct statement in any source. Where else in this chapter have you accepted an inference of similar strength without noticing?