Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
목차 37
- Lecture 1-1: Gospel as a Genre: Biography, History, or Something Else
- Lecture 1-2: Oral Tradition, Written Sources, and How the Gospels Reached Us
- Lecture 1-3: Why Three, and Why They Are Called Synoptic
- Lecture 2-1: The Data: Agreements, Disagreements, and Order
- Lecture 2-2: The Two-Source Theory and the Case for Q
- Lecture 2-3: The Alternatives: Griesbach, Farrer, and the Present State of the Question
- Lecture 3-1: Galilee and Judea under Rome
- Lecture 3-2: Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and the Rest of Second Temple Judaism
- Lecture 3-3: Synagogue, Temple, Household: Where the Gospel Scenes Take Place
- Lecture 4-1: Structure, Pace, and the Shape of Mark's Story
- Lecture 4-2: Mark's Christology and the Question of the Messianic Secret
- Lecture 4-3: Discipleship, Failure, and the Ending at 16:8
- Lecture 5-1: Structure, the Five Discourses, and Matthew's Jewish Frame
- Lecture 5-2: Fulfilment, Scripture, and the Law in Matthew
- Lecture 5-3: The Community Addressed: Church, Mission, and Judgment
- Lecture 6-1: Luke's Preface, Sources, and Claim to Orderly Account
- Lecture 6-2: Reversal: The Poor, Women, Samaritans, and Outsiders
- Lecture 6-3: The Spirit, Prayer, and the Journey to Jerusalem
- Lecture 7-1: What Jesus Announced, and What His Hearers Would Have Heard
- Lecture 7-2: Present, Future, or Both: The Eschatology Debate
- Lecture 7-3: The Sermon on the Mount and the Demands of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-1: How Parables Work, and How They Have Been Misread
- Lecture 8-2: Parables of the Kingdom
- Lecture 8-3: Parables of Mercy, Warning, and Reversal
- Lecture 9-1: Healings and Nature Miracles in the Synoptic Accounts
- Lecture 9-2: Exorcism and the Conflict with Evil
- Lecture 9-3: How Historians and Theologians Have Handled the Miracle Accounts
- Lecture 10-1: The Sabbath and Purity Controversies
- Lecture 10-2: The Temple Action and What It Meant
- Lecture 10-3: Jesus and the Restoration of Israel: The Twelve and the Nations
- Lecture 11-1: The Last Supper and the Arrest
- Lecture 11-2: Trial, Crucifixion, and the Three Passion Narratives Compared
- Lecture 11-3: The Empty Tomb and the Resurrection Accounts
This is the central lecture of the chapter, and arguably one of the two or three most consequential arguments in the modern study of the Gospels. The question is simple to state and has resisted a settled answer for well over a century. When Jesus announced that the Kingdom of God was at hand, did he mean that it was arriving imminently in the future — within the lifetime of his hearers, in a decisive act that would end the present order? Did he mean that it had already arrived, in his own activity, so that the awaited reign of God was now a present fact to be recognised rather than a coming event to be awaited? Did he mean both, in some ordered relation? Or did he mean neither, because the framework of an awaited end is not his at all but his followers'?
The reason this is not merely a scholar's puzzle is that the Synoptic texts themselves supply strong evidence for more than one answer. There are sayings in which the Kingdom is unmistakably future and unmistakably soon, and some of them attach a time limit to the expectation. There are sayings in which the Kingdom is unmistakably present, in the exorcisms and in Jesus' own presence, with no waiting involved. Both sets are attested in more than one Gospel; neither can be removed as a small textual anomaly. Every position surveyed here is therefore, in part, a strategy for handling the texts that do not fit it — and this lecture will insist on that. It is not enough to know which texts a position stands on. You must know how it handles the texts standing against it, because that is where the real cost of each position is paid.
The lecture will set out five positions in roughly chronological order: consistent (or thoroughgoing) eschatology, realised eschatology, inaugurated eschatology, the non-eschatological Jesus of the Jesus Seminar and its associates, and the recent reassertion of an apocalyptic Jesus by Dale Allison and, in a distinctive form, by N. T. Wright. Each is presented in the strongest form its own advocates would recognise before any objection is raised. At the end there is no verdict. This is deliberate and is not evasion: the exercise a student needs here is to be able to state each position well enough that its holders would accept the statement, and a chapter that concluded with a winner would train the opposite habit.
이 38분으로 얻는 것
- State the case for consistent eschatology as Johannes Weiss and Albert Schweitzer made it, including the specific texts it rests on and the conclusion about Jesus that Schweitzer accepted rather than avoided.
- State C. H. Dodd's realised eschatology, identify the texts and the Greek verb forms it turns on, and explain what it must do with the imminence sayings.
- Explain inaugurated eschatology as developed by Joachim Jeremias and George Eldon Ladd, and identify the specific objection that it is a synthesis reached by assertion rather than by argument.
- Present the non-eschatological reconstruction associated with the Jesus Seminar, John Dominic Crossan, and Marcus Borg, in its own terms and with its own criteria, and state the main criticisms of its method.
- For any given Kingdom saying, identify which position it supports most naturally and describe how each of the other positions accounts for it.
He said to them, “Most certainly I tell you, there are some standing here who will in no way taste death until they see the Kingdom of God come with power.” — Mark 9:1
World English Bible
Most certainly I tell you, this generation will not pass away until all things are accomplished. — Luke 21:32
WEB
But if I by the finger of God cast out demons, then the Kingdom of God has come to you. — Luke 11:20
WEB
But if I by the Spirit of God cast out demons, then the Kingdom of God has come upon you. — Matthew 12:28
WEB
Being asked by the Pharisees when the Kingdom of God would come, he answered them, “The Kingdom of God doesn’t come with observation; neither will they say, ‘Look, here!’ or, ‘Look, there!’ for behold, the Kingdom of God is within you.” — Luke 17:20-21
WEB
Most certainly I tell you, I will no more drink of the fruit of the vine, until that day when I drink it anew in the Kingdom of God.” — Mark 14:25
WEB
But when they persecute you in this city, flee into the next, for most certainly I tell you, you will not have gone through the cities of Israel, until the Son of Man has come. — Matthew 10:23
WEB
But of that day or that hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father. — Mark 13:32
WEB
These eight passages are the working material of the whole debate, and they are placed together at the front so that the difficulty is visible before any position is described. Mark 9:1, Luke 21:32 (paralleled in Mark 13:30 and Matthew 24:34), and Matthew 10:23 are the imminence texts: they promise something within a bounded stretch of time. Luke 11:20 and its Matthean parallel are the presence texts, and the pair is worth a second look — the two Gospels differ on "finger of God" and "Spirit of God" while agreeing that the exorcisms mean the Kingdom has arrived. Luke 17:20-21 refuses the question of timing outright. Mark 14:25 puts the Kingdom in a future beyond Jesus' death. Mark 13:32 denies knowledge of the timing to Jesus himself. No position surveyed below can take all eight at face value in the same sense.
1. Before the positions: what the sayings actually say
Three points of detail are worth establishing first, because arguments in this field frequently turn on them and a student who takes them on trust cannot follow the argument.
The verb in Luke 11:20 and Matthew 12:28. The Greek is ephthasen, from phthano, and the ordinary sense is "has arrived," "has reached," "has come upon." It is aorist, and the natural reading is that something has happened, not that something is approaching. Some interpreters have argued that phthano can mean "has drawn near" without arrival, and there is a little classical evidence for a weaker sense; but in Hellenistic Greek, including the Greek Old Testament, the verb regularly means arrival. This saying is present in both Matthew and Luke in nearly identical wording, which on the Two-Source Theory means it comes from Q, and on the Farrer hypothesis means Luke took it from Matthew — either way it is not the invention of one evangelist. Its evidence for presence is as strong as any single saying's evidence gets.
The verb in Mark 1:15. The phrase translated "is at hand" is engiken, perfect of engizo, "to draw near." Whether that means "has arrived" or "has come close but not arrived" was argued at length between C. H. Dodd, who wanted the stronger sense, and Kenneth Clark and others, who insisted the verb means approach and not arrival. The philological consensus has settled closer to Dodd's opponents: engizo means to come near. This matters, because the summary sentence in Mark that opens the whole preaching is therefore a sentence about nearness, not about arrival, and a realised reading cannot start from it.
The phrase in Luke 17:21. The Greek entos hymon can be rendered "within you," as in the World English Bible, or "among you" / "in your midst." Both are grammatically possible and the translations of the last century have moved back and forth. The interior reading — the Kingdom as an inward spiritual condition — was widely favoured in the nineteenth century and is now generally doubted, on the ground that the saying is addressed to Pharisees who are being told the Kingdom is not visible in the way they expect, and that Luke elsewhere shows no interest in an interior kingdom. Most current commentators prefer "in your midst" or "among you." A student should know that the English text in front of them has made a choice here, and that a great deal of devotional writing rests on the choice that most specialists no longer prefer.
2. Consistent eschatology: Weiss and Schweitzer
Johannes Weiss published Die Predigt Jesu vom Reiche Gottes in 1892. It is a short book with a large target. Nineteenth-century liberal Protestant theology — his own father-in-law Albrecht Ritschl's, among others — had made the Kingdom of God the central category of Christian ethics, understanding it as a moral community built up gradually through human faithfulness. Weiss argued, on straightforwardly exegetical grounds, that this was not what Jesus meant. In Jesus' preaching the Kingdom is not built; it is a wholly future, wholly supernatural act of God that breaks in from outside, ends the present age, and is not extended by human effort. Weiss was not attacking the church; he said in the preface that he was distinguishing what Jesus meant from what the modern church might properly teach, which is a distinction worth noting because it is often forgotten in summaries.
Albert Schweitzer, in Von Reimarus zu Wrede (1906, in English The Quest of the Historical Jesus), pressed the position further and drew the consequences Weiss had left partly implicit. On Schweitzer's reconstruction, Jesus expected the end within a very short span. Matthew 10:23 is the pivotal text: Jesus sends out the disciples expecting the Son of Man to come before they finish their circuit of the towns of Israel, and the end does not come. Schweitzer read Jesus' subsequent turn toward Jerusalem and death as a response to that non-arrival — an attempt to force the end, to take upon himself the that must precede it. The final cry from the cross, on this reading, is what it sounds like.
Two things must be said clearly about Schweitzer's position, because both are regularly mishandled.
First, he held that Jesus was mistaken about the timing, and he said so. This is not an implication drawn out by hostile readers; it is his own conclusion. He also held that the ethical content of Jesus' teaching survived the mistake, and he gave it a name — Interimsethik, an ethic for the interim before the end — which lecture 7-3 will take up.
Schweitzer is not only critic
Second, Schweitzer's book is often remembered only for its famous critique of the nineteenth-century lives of Jesus: that each researcher looked down the well of history and saw his own face reflected at the bottom. That critique is genuinely devastating and genuinely his. But it is not his position. His position is the reconstruction described above, and it deserves to be assessed as a reconstruction. Treating Schweitzer as a purely negative critic — a common shortcut — makes it impossible to see that his own Jesus is as sharply drawn, and as vulnerable to the same critique, as any of the ones he demolished.
Where consistent eschatology is strong. It takes the imminence sayings at face value, and there are a good number of them, distributed across Mark, Q material, and Matthew's special material. It explains why the earliest Christian letters we possess, 1 Thessalonians in particular, are so concerned with an imminent return: the expectation was there from the start because it was Jesus'. And it explains a fact that a comfortable reading struggles with, namely that the tradition preserved a saying like Mark 9:1 and had to work to reinterpret it. Nobody invents a difficulty of that kind.
Where it strains. It must give a reduced account of the presence sayings, and Luke 11:20 in particular. Schweitzer's solution was that these refer to signs of the coming end rather than to its arrival, but the verb resists that. It must also handle Mark 13:32 and the parables of growth, in which something is already underway. And there is a methodological objection: the reconstruction requires a psychological narrative of Jesus' inner development — expectation, disappointment, decision — which the sources do not report and which Schweitzer supplies.
3. Realised eschatology: C. H. Dodd
C. H. Dodd, in The Parables of the Kingdom (1935), argued the reverse. On his reading the decisive event has already occurred in Jesus' ministry. The Kingdom has come; the eschatological hour has struck; what the prophets awaited is now present in the works and words of Jesus. Dodd's central texts are Luke 11:20 and its Matthean parallel, the parables of growth read as parables of a harvest already arrived rather than of a slow development, and the beatitudes read as declarations of a present state.
Dodd's argument was not merely exegetical. He was also correcting what he saw as a distortion, in the opposite direction from Weiss's target: the reduction of Jesus' message to a prediction that did not come true. If the Kingdom is present in Jesus, then the message is not a failed forecast, and the church's proclamation is about something that happened rather than something that did not.
Where it is strong. It takes the presence sayings at full strength, including the strongest one. It gives a good account of why the parables so often turn on something small that is nonetheless the decisive thing — a seed, a pearl, a treasure in a field. And it makes sense of the Synoptic report that the exorcisms and healings mean something, rather than merely accompanying a message about the future.
Where it strains. The imminence sayings, and Mark 14:25, in which Jesus explicitly places a Kingdom event beyond his own death. Dodd's handling of these was the weakest part of his case, and he modified his position over the following decades, eventually speaking of the Kingdom as "inaugurated" and acknowledging a future dimension he had initially minimised. That modification is itself instructive: the sharpest form of realised eschatology proved difficult to hold, and its own author loosened it.
Future or present Kingdom
This is a point where readers will not agree. The disagreement between Weiss and Schweitzer on one side and Dodd on the other is not about a detail. Weiss and Schweitzer hold that Jesus' central expectation was future and did not occur; Dodd holds that it was present and did occur. Each side can produce texts the other must explain away. Any reader who finds one side obviously right should test that impression by writing out the three texts hardest for their preferred side and attempting an explanation of each — the difficulty of that exercise is the actual state of the evidence.
4. Inaugurated eschatology: Jeremias, Ladd, and the "already and not yet"
The position that has been most widely adopted in the second half of the twentieth century holds that both sets of texts mean what they say, because the Kingdom has genuinely begun in Jesus' ministry and has genuinely not yet arrived in fullness. Joachim Jeremias called it "eschatology in process of realisation" — sich realisierende Eschatologie, a phrase he credited in substance to Ernst Haenchen — and George Eldon Ladd, in The Presence of the Future (1974), developed the fullest English-language statement of it, usually summarised as "." Oscar Cullmann's version, using an image from the Second World War, distinguished the decisive battle from the final surrender: the outcome is settled while the fighting continues.
Set the case out properly. It is not simply the observation that both kinds of text exist; that observation belongs to everyone. The argument is that the structure of two-stage arrival is itself present in the Jewish material Jesus drew on, and that the parables of growth positively require it. Mark 4:26-29 describes a sowing already accomplished, a growth that proceeds without the sower's knowledge, and a harvest still to come. That is not a compromise between two positions; it is one thing said in one parable. Ladd argued further that the Kingdom, understood dynamically as God's reign rather than as a realm, can perfectly well be exercised now in one mode and later in another without contradiction — which is where the translation question of lecture 7-1 does real work.
Where it strains, and this must be said plainly. Inaugurated eschatology is very often adopted because it is comfortable rather than because it is argued. It permits every text to be retained and requires no saying to be judged mistaken or secondary, and that convenience should make a careful reader suspicious, not relieved. Two specific objections are worth stating.
The first is that "already and not yet" does not by itself dispose of Mark 9:1 and Matthew 10:23. Those sayings do not merely say the Kingdom is future; they attach a limit — some standing here, before you finish these towns. A two-stage structure explains why there is a future stage. It does not explain why the future stage was expected within a stated period and did not come within it. Answers exist: that Mark 9:1 refers to the transfiguration which follows it immediately, or to the resurrection, or to the destruction of the temple, or to the growth of the church. Each has been argued seriously. But each is a solution to a difficulty, and a reader should count them as such rather than letting the general framework absorb the problem silently.
The second objection is methodological, and it is the one this course's build principle names directly: elegance is a warning sign. A position that resolves a century-old dispute by affirming both sides, loses nothing, costs nothing, and offends no constituency has arrived at its result too easily to be trusted without a second look. That is not a refutation. Inaugurated eschatology may well be right, and its parable evidence is real. It is a reason to ask, of any particular text, whether the framework is explaining the text or absorbing it.
5. The non-eschatological Jesus: the Jesus Seminar, Crossan, and Borg
A quite different reconstruction gained prominence in North America in the 1980s and 1990s. On this view, the apocalyptic and imminence material does not come from Jesus at all. It comes from the early Christian movement, and specifically from a movement shaped by John the Baptist before Jesus and by an intensifying expectation after his death. The Jesus who remains, once that layer is removed, is a teacher of subversive wisdom whose Kingdom language describes a present, alternative way of living — open table fellowship, healing without brokerage, a social order without the usual hierarchies.
Present the case in its own terms, since it is frequently caricatured. Three supports are offered.
First, a source argument. John Kloppenborg's stratigraphic analysis of Q proposed that its earliest layer consists of wisdom sayings and that the apocalyptic and judgment material belongs to a later redaction. If that stratigraphy holds, the earliest recoverable sayings tradition is not apocalyptic. Second, a comparative argument: the Gospel of Thomas, which the Seminar dated early and treated as independent, contains Kingdom sayings with present and sapiential force and lacks the apocalyptic scenario. Third, a substantive argument, made most forcefully by Marcus Borg: the imminence sayings often turn on the coming of the Son of Man, and if the Son of Man sayings are secondary — the church's confession of the risen Christ read back — then the imminence framework falls with them. John Dominic Crossan, in The Historical Jesus: The Life of a Mediterranean Jewish Peasant (1991), assembled a Jesus of peasant social radicalism, an itinerant whose Kingdom was enacted in shared meals and free healing rather than announced as a coming event.
The criticisms, which are extensive. Kloppenborg's stratification of Q has been widely questioned even by scholars who accept Q's existence — Kloppenborg himself has cautioned that a literary stratigraphy is not automatically a chronology of the traditions, and Dale Allison and Christopher Tuckett have argued that the layering is too fine an instrument for the evidence. The early dating and independence of the Gospel of Thomas is a minority position; many specialists date it into the second century and see Synoptic influence. And the sequence argument cuts hard the other way: Jesus was baptised by John, whose preaching was unmistakably one of imminent judgment, and the movement immediately after Jesus was unmistakably expectant. A non-apocalyptic Jesus has to sit between an apocalyptic predecessor and apocalyptic successors, and explain the discontinuity twice. E. P. Sanders and Dale Allison have both pressed that argument, and it has proved hard to answer.
The Jesus Seminar's voting procedure — coloured beads, a published tally of which sayings the participants judged authentic — attracted criticism out of proportion to its importance, some of it fair and some of it merely mocking. The fair criticism is that a vote records the distribution of opinion among a self-selected group and is not evidence about the first century. The unfair version treats the whole enterprise as unserious, which it was not; the individual scholarship of Crossan and Borg is substantial and has to be engaged on its merits rather than dismissed by way of the beads.
6. The apocalyptic reassertion: Allison, Sanders, and Wright's variant
The most vigorous recent argument runs the other way. Dale Allison, in Jesus of Nazareth: Millenarian Prophet (1998), argued that the apocalyptic material is too widely attested across sources and forms to be a later addition, and that Jesus is best understood alongside other millenarian prophets — figures who announce an imminent, divinely wrought transformation, gather a following, and impose demanding requirements. Allison also faced the failure question directly, arguing that unfulfilled expectation is characteristic of millenarian movements and is not a reason to deny the expectation was held. E. P. Sanders reached a comparable conclusion by a different route in Jesus and Judaism (1985), reasoning from the temple action and from the appointment of the Twelve to a programme of Jewish restoration eschatology.
N. T. Wright, in Jesus and the Victory of God (1996), agrees that Jesus' framework was apocalyptic and disagrees sharply about what apocalyptic language does. On Wright's reading, first-century Jewish apocalyptic imagery — stars falling, the Son of Man coming on clouds — is metaphorical language for events within history, above all the vindication of Jesus and the judgment on Jerusalem realised in AD 70. Jesus therefore expected something imminent, and what he expected happened; there is no failed prediction because the prediction was not about the end of the physical world. Wright's position is elegant, and it is the most contested part of his work precisely for that reason. Allison has objected that some texts resist a purely this-worldly reading, and Edward Adams has argued at length that ancient Jewish and Christian sources do sometimes envisage genuine cosmic dissolution rather than only metaphor. A student should be able to state Wright's reading accurately and also to state that it is a minority reading of the imagery among specialists in Jewish apocalyptic.
7. How each position handles the hard texts
The table in section 4 sets this out systematically, and it is the most useful single thing in the lecture. The point it makes is one a student should carry into every future encounter with this material: every position has a cost, and the cost is always paid in the same currency, namely a text that has to be read in a way that is not its most natural reading. Consistent eschatology weakens ephthasen. Realised eschatology reassigns or reinterprets Mark 9:1. Inaugurated eschatology accepts both but has to explain the time limits. The non-eschatological reading assigns a large body of material to the early church. The apocalyptic reassertion accepts an unfulfilled expectation, and Wright's variant avoids that at the price of a contested account of what the imagery means.
Comparing costs is a better exercise than comparing strengths, and it is the exercise the chapter quiz will assume you have done.
The table is built so the last column can be read on its own, because that column is the argument of the lecture. Notice that only one cell is shaded as a warning, and it is not the cell of a position the lecture rejects — it is the cell of the position most students arrive already holding. Inaugurated eschatology is marked because its danger is not that it is false but that it is easy: it can absorb a difficulty without registering that a difficulty was there. The Wright row is cut short in the diagram at the point where his cost begins, which is the space that the discussion above fills in: the price of avoiding an unfulfilled prediction is a contested account of what apocalyptic imagery meant to first-century readers.
6. Further Reading
- Johannes Weiss, Jesus' Proclamation of the Kingdom of God, trans. R. H. Hiers and D. L. Holland (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1971). The 1892 book that began the modern debate; short, and best read before any summary of it.
- Albert Schweitzer, The Quest of the Historical Jesus, first complete edition, ed. John Bowden (London: SCM, 2000). Read the constructive final chapters, not only the famous critique of the nineteenth-century lives.
- C. H. Dodd, The Parables of the Kingdom, rev. ed. (London: Nisbet, 1961). Realised eschatology in its author's own words, with the later softening visible in the revisions.
- Joachim Jeremias, New Testament Theology: The Proclamation of Jesus, trans. John Bowden (London: SCM, 1971). The fullest statement of eschatology in process of realisation, with detailed philological argument on the key verbs.
- George Eldon Ladd, The Presence of the Future: The Eschatology of Biblical Realism, rev. ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1974). The standard English-language argument for "already and not yet."
- John Dominic Crossan, The Historical Jesus: The Life of a Mediterranean Jewish Peasant (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1991). The most substantial statement of the non-apocalyptic reconstruction, with its method set out explicitly enough to be criticised.
- Dale C. Allison Jr., Jesus of Nazareth: Millenarian Prophet (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1998). The strongest recent case for an apocalyptic Jesus, and the most candid treatment of unfulfilled expectation.
- N. T. Wright, Jesus and the Victory of God (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1996). The metaphorical reading of apocalyptic imagery; read alongside Edward Adams, The Stars Will Fall from Heaven (London: T. and T. Clark, 2007), which contests it directly.
- Marcus J. Borg, Jesus in Contemporary Scholarship (Valley Forge: Press International, 1994). Borg's own account of why he abandoned the apocalyptic reading, useful for hearing the position from a participant rather than a critic.
핵심 요약
- Eight passages anchor the whole debate: Mark 9:1 and Matthew 10:23 promise the Kingdom within a bounded time; Luke 11:20/Matthew 12:28 (
ephthasen, "has arrived") and Luke 17:20-21 claim it is already present; Mark 14:25 places a Kingdom event beyond Jesus' death; Mark 13:32 denies even Jesus knowledge of the timing. - Schweitzer's consistent eschatology (Von Reimarus zu Wrede, 1906) held that Jesus expected the end within a short span, was mistaken, and turned toward Jerusalem to force the end — a position he stated himself, not one imposed by hostile readers.
- Dodd's realised eschatology rested heavily on the aorist
ephthasenin Luke 11:20 ("has arrived," not merely "drawn near"), but Dodd himself later softened the position toward "inaugurated" because Mark 14:25 and the imminence sayings resisted it. - Inaugurated eschatology (Jeremias's "eschatology in process of realisation," Ladd's "already and not yet") is criticized in the lecture itself for being suspiciously comfortable: it absorbs every text without cost, and it still has to explain why Mark 9:1 and Matthew 10:23 attach a specific time limit rather than just a general futurity.
- N. T. Wright reads apocalyptic imagery (stars falling, the Son of Man on clouds) as metaphor for historical events, above all AD 70, so that Jesus' imminent expectation was fulfilled rather than mistaken — a minority reading among specialists in Jewish apocalyptic, contested by Allison and Edward Adams.
If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Five positions try to hold together two sets of Synoptic sayings that will not sit quietly side by side — the imminence sayings (Mark 9:1: some standing here will not taste death before the Kingdom comes with power) and the presence sayings (Luke 11:20: if I cast out demons by the finger of God, the Kingdom has arrived). Weiss and Schweitzer took the future sayings straight and concluded Jesus was wrong about the timing; Dodd took the presence sayings straight and concluded the decisive hour had already struck; Jeremias and Ladd tried to hold both as "already and not yet," at the cost of still needing to explain Mark 9:1's stated time limit; the Jesus Seminar assigned the imminence material to the early church; and Wright kept the imminence but redefined what the apocalyptic language meant. Every position pays a cost in some text that resists its most natural reading, and the lecture's point is that naming the cost matters more than picking a winner.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Take Mark 9:1 and write four short paragraphs, one from each of the first four positions surveyed, explaining the saying. Which of the four required you to say something you do not believe the text says?
- The verb `ephthasen` in Luke 11:20 is doing heavy work in this debate. What would change in the argument if the weaker sense — "has drawn near" — were correct? Which positions gain and which lose?
- Schweitzer accepted that Jesus was mistaken about the timing of the end. Some readers regard that as a conclusion no Christian interpretation can accept, and others regard it as a historical judgment that leaves theological questions open. Set out both views and identify the assumption about the relation of history and doctrine that divides them.
- The lecture treats the elegance of inaugurated eschatology as a reason for suspicion. Is that fair? Construct the reply that a defender of the position would give, and assess it.
- The non-eschatological reconstruction has to explain two discontinuities — with John the Baptist before Jesus and with the earliest communities after him. What kinds of evidence could, in principle, make those discontinuities plausible? Does any such evidence exist?
- Mark 13:32 says that the timing is unknown to the Son. How does that saying sit with each of the five positions, and why is it so rarely made central in the debate?