Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Who Do I Tell? A Participation Plan
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Bodies and Belonging
- Lecture 1-2: Models of Disability and the Words We Use
- Lecture 1-3: When Theology Blames: Sin, Testing and Miracle
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Come: Honest Motives and First Impressions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Church's First Impression and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Moving and Sensing: Mobility, Sight, Hearing and Speech
- Lecture 2-2: Learning, Development and Autism
- Lecture 2-3: Mental Health, Chronic Illness and Hidden Disabilities
- Lecture 2-4: Asking First: How to Offer Help and Take a No
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions I Can Ask
- Lecture 3-1: Paths, Doors and Seats: The Building and the Room
- Lecture 3-2: The Service Itself: Order, Words and Sacraments
- Lecture 3-3: Screens, Print and Online Worship
- Lecture 3-4: Hospitality That Goes Beyond the Door
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Walking Through a Service
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Ministry: Inclusion Within It
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Adult Learning
- Lecture 4-3: Serving: Volunteers, Companions and Roles
- Lecture 4-4: Money, Time and the Small Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Opening One Group to Everyone
- Lecture 5-1: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-2: Supporters, Professionals and Warm Referral
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Consent and Keeping People Safe
- Lecture 5-4: Privacy, Prayer Lists and Photographs
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Who Do I Tell? A Participation Plan
This is the fifth Practice Lab. The last four lectures of this chapter asked you to stand beside families, to know the people around a member, to keep people safe and to keep their private things private. This lab asks you to do two small pieces of work with your hands.
Part A is about telling. You will read a short invented scene, sort what the people in it saw and heard into the right boxes, and decide what to write down and whom to tell. The point is not to solve the scene. The point is to practise the habit from lecture 5-3: notice, write, tell, and not to investigate.
Part B is about a plan. You will read a one-page participation plan for an invented person, written in that person's own words, and then write one yourself: what I like, what is hard, what helps, and who may know what. A plan like this is how a church replaces guessing with asking.
You do not need a role in a ministry to do this lab. You do not need to belong to a congregation. A member who has a disability can do it from the side of the person whose plan it is. The lab has four ways in, so that nobody is left out, and four promises of privacy, so that nobody has to be afraid.
This lab is not safeguarding training. It teaches a habit, not a policy. Church safety policy and law are taught in another course, and your own community's written policy always comes first.
이 29분으로 얻는 것
- Sort a short list of things seen and heard into what I saw, what I heard and what I do not know, and decide what to write down and whom to tell.
- Read a participation plan written in a person's own words and say what each part is for.
- Draft a plan for an invented person or, if you wish, for yourself, in the person's own words.
- State the four promises of privacy and the extra rule that belongs to this lab.
Defend the weak, the poor, and the fatherless. Maintain the rights of the poor and oppressed. Rescue the weak and needy. Deliver them out of the hand of the wicked." — Psalms 82:3-4
World English Bible
The psalm says what justice is for: the weak and the needy are to be defended and rescued. In this lab, the defending is very small. It is a note on a card and a word to the right person. The psalm does not tell us how. The step from the text to the practice is ours, and it is that justice often begins with someone who noticed.
1. Why this lab
Many people who have worried about a member say afterwards, "I did not know what to do, so I did nothing." Many who did something say, "I did it on my own, and I wish I had not." Both are understandable. Both come from the same gap: nobody had practised.
This lab closes that gap in the safest way possible, with an invented scene and an invented person. It also does something quieter. A participation plan turns a hundred small guesses ("Does she want help? Is he all right in a crowd? May we say his name in the prayers?") into a few clear sentences in the person's own words. A congregation that has asked is a safer and kinder place than one that has guessed.
2. The four promises, and one more
Before you pick up a pen, hear the four promises. They apply to every lab in this course.
- Nobody reads what you write. The sheet is yours.
- Nothing is marked or graded. There is no right answer on the form.
- You may pass on any part. Skipping a box needs no reason.
- The leader fills in a sheet too. In a group, the person leading sits down and writes alongside you.
The form asks for roles, never names. Do not name a real member who has a disability, a real family or a real carer. Use "a member" and the invented profiles that the lab provides.
Here is the extra rule that belongs to this lab. If, while you are doing this lab, you realise that you have seen something about a real person that worries you now, stop the lab for that part. Do not discuss it in the group, do not try to work it out on the sheet, and do not investigate. After the session, follow lecture 5-3: write down what you saw and heard, and tell the responsible person the same day. If anyone is in danger now, use the emergency number. The lab is not the place to deal with a real concern, and the group is not the place to share it.
3. Four ways in
1. In your own congregation or family. Find out what your community already has. Fill in the "Who do I tell?" card at the end of this section for your own setting, using roles and categories, not names: the role of the responsible person, the category of the local reporting body, the emergency number (look it up now; this course does not give it), the place where the written policy is kept. If your community has none of these, write that down. It is a finding, not a failing. Then use the participation plan form in the Diagrams section as a model for how your community might ask a member what they would like. Do not fill in a plan for a real member without that person's own invitation and agreement.
2. The observer's way. If you have no role in a congregation, work from the two invented texts in this lecture: the scene in Part A and the profile in Part B. They are written so that you can do everything the lab asks from them. You do not need to judge any person in them. They are invented.
3. The partner's way. With a trusted partner, take turns to talk through three invented situations (the cards below). One reads a card aloud and the other says what they would do and why; then swap. The situations are invented, and no one plays themselves. Never imitate a disability and never try to "feel" one for a few minutes. Use questions, not simulation: "What would you want to ask? Whom would you tell? What would you write down?"
4. A way for a member with a disability. Do the lab from the side of the person whose plan it is. Write your own participation plan in your own words, if you wish: what you like, what is hard, what helps, who may know what. Then add one line that the form does not ask for: what I would like my church to ask me. You decide what to put in each box. You may leave any box empty, and nobody will read the sheet. If you would rather not write a plan for yourself, do Part B for the invented person and add one thing the plan misses, as you see it.
4. Part A: Who do I tell?
Read the scene. It is invented.
An invented scene (about 300 words)
(an invented example) It is a Sunday in an assembly that meets in a rented hall. Lena helps with the coffee after the service. She has done it for two years and knows most people by name.
Pavel is thirty-four and has an intellectual disability. He sings in the group that leads the songs, and everyone enjoys his voice. He comes each week with Marek, his brother-in-law, who drives him. This morning Lena offered Pavel a coffee token. Pavel said, "I'm not allowed to have money." When Lena asked him what drink he would like, Marek answered for him. Pavel's shoes were torn and he was shivering, and Lena realised that he has worn the same coat for three Sundays. Earlier, while he was reaching for a songbook, she noticed a bruise on his forearm, yellow at the edges.
During the songs, Pavel laughed with the tenors and sang with obvious pleasure. Marek waited by the door through the whole service, although Pavel usually sits with the group. Someone near Lena remarked that Pavel's sister, Marek's wife, "has her hands full and does her best." Lena thinks Marek is controlling. Pavel did not come last Sunday, and Lena does not know why.
Near the end, when Pavel was for a moment beside Lena at the coffee table, in the open hall, he said quietly, "Please don't tell anyone I said that."
What to do with it. Copy the table below onto a sheet (a model is in the Diagrams section). For each of the ten items in the list that follows, decide which box it belongs in. Some belong in more than one. Then answer the last two questions.
| # | Item |
|---|---|
| 1 | Pavel has a bruise on his forearm, yellow at the edges. |
| 2 | Pavel said, "I'm not allowed to have money." |
| 3 | Marek answered when Lena asked Pavel what he would like. |
| 4 | Pavel's shoes were torn, he was shivering, and he has worn the same coat for three Sundays. |
| 5 | Pavel sang with obvious pleasure and laughed with the tenors. |
| 6 | Lena thinks Marek is controlling. |
| 7 | Marek waited by the door through the whole service. |
| 8 | Someone said Pavel's sister "has her hands full and does her best." |
| 9 | Pavel did not come last Sunday. |
| 10 | Pavel said, "Please don't tell anyone I said that." |
The boxes are:
- What I saw. Things you observed yourself.
- What I heard. Words that were actually said, to you or near you.
- What I do not know. Opinions, guesses, hearsay, reasons, and anything not seen or heard by Lena.
- Whom I tell. The role, and by when.
- What I write down. The facts only, in the order they happened, with date and time, using the person's words.
Notes on the sorting.
- A feeling or a theory ("controlling," "has her hands full") is not a fact. It belongs in what I do not know. A note with a theory in it can mislead the person who reads it.
- A good thing seen (the singing) belongs in what I saw. Safety is not only about worry, and a note that includes what Pavel enjoys is a fair note.
- An absence ("did not come last Sunday") is a fact, but the reason is not known.
- Pavel's last sentence matters. If Lena says "I will tell no one," she cannot keep that promise if she tells the responsible person. A better sentence is in lecture 5-4: I will keep this private, and I will not tell anyone without your permission, unless I think you or someone else may be in danger. Then I will tell only the person who needs to know. Practise saying it aloud in your own words.
- None of the items tells you that anyone has done anything wrong. Several have innocent explanations. That is the point: Lena does not have to know. She has to write, tell and stay kind.
- Lena does not ask Pavel more questions to "get to the bottom of it," does not speak to Marek or to the family, and does not look for evidence. That would be investigating alone.
5. Part B: The participation plan
A participation plan is one page, in the person's own words, kept by the person. It says what a congregation should know in order to welcome them well, and nothing more. It is made with the person, not about them.
Here is a model for an invented person. Read it as an example of the voice and of what it leaves out.
An invented plan: Samuel
(an invented example) My participation plan. Samuel, 41. Written on a Friday with my friend Elena beside me.
What I like. I read the lessons on the first Sunday of the month. I like being given the passage a week early. I like the quiet coffee after the service, at the table by the window. I like being asked to help set out the chairs.
What is hard. Sudden changes to the order of service. Loud clapping. Being touched without being asked. People talking about me as if I was not there.
What helps. An order of service sent on Friday. A seat at the end of a row. Two choices rather than an open question. If I am going to read, a quiet minute before.
If I am overwhelmed. I may go to the quiet room. I do not need anybody to follow me. Elena will come after a while if I am not back. Please do not touch me.
Who may know what. The pastor may know everything I choose to tell. The coffee team may know what helps. The congregation does not need to know anything about my diagnosis, and I do not want it in the prayers or in a group message. Please ask before taking my photograph.
Please ask me again in the autumn. I may change my mind.
Notice what the plan does not contain: no diagnosis, no medicine, no family history, no benefits. It says what Samuel likes and what helps, in his words.
Now write one yourself, using one of these ways.
- For the invented person. Rina is sixteen. She uses a wheelchair and a communication board. She plays the drums in the youth band, and she is the one who sets the tempo. She likes it when people ask her questions directly. Her mother is often there and usually answers first, which Rina finds tiring. She finds long talks after a service hard. Write Rina's plan in her words. Remember that you are guessing at someone invented, and say so in a note at the foot of the page: This is an invented plan. Rina would change it.
- For yourself, if you wish and if you are comfortable. Use the same boxes. Decide what you want a church to know and what you do not.
- As a leader, write the plan you would ask a member to fill in. Does it ask for too much? Does it ask for what a volunteer actually needs?
6. Three situations for the partner's way
Take turns reading a card aloud. The listener says what they would do, and what they would write down or whom they would tell. Do not play the person with the disability. Talk about what the church worker would do.
Card 1. A mother says to a Sunday teacher, "Please don't tell anyone about my daughter's diagnosis." A week later, another teacher asks why the girl sometimes leaves the room. What does the first teacher say?
Card 2. After an evening event at the hall, a volunteer is the last adult there with a member who says he needs the toilet. His support worker is late. What does the volunteer do, and what does the volunteer not do?
Card 3. A member says to a small-group leader, "Promise you will not tell anyone." Then she says something that worries the leader. What does the leader say before she answers?
7. What the lab does for the central claim
The central claim of the course is that a person with a disability is a member of the body and made in God's image before being someone to help, and that inclusion is changing the church's thresholds, words and habits, by asking the person first. Part A is a habit of safety that does not depend on certainty. Part B is a habit of asking that does not depend on guessing. Both put the person's voice first: in Part A, by not acting behind a person's back or on a theory; in Part B, by writing in the first person.
8. Leader's note, for running this in a group
Privacy comes first
State the four promises out loud, and the extra rule, before anyone writes. Nobody reads the sheet. Nothing is marked. Anyone may pass. You will write too. If a real concern about a real person comes to mind, it is not shared in the group; it goes to the responsible person after the session.
Fill in your own sheet. A leader who watches while others write turns the room into an examination. Sit down and write.
Give the time. About thirty minutes for Part A and thirty for Part B. They can be run in two sessions. Allow silence while people write.
Then ask about feelings and about habits, never about contents. For Part A: "What was it like to sort what you saw from what you guessed?" and "What is one thing you would do differently from your first instinct?" For Part B: "What was it like to write in someone else's words?" Do not ask anyone to read their sheet.
If anyone asks, "What is the right sorting?", offer the suggested sorting below as one way, not as an answer key. Nothing is marked.
| Item | A suggested sorting |
|---|---|
| 1, 4 | What I saw. Write down. |
| 2, 10 | What I heard. Write down the exact words. |
| 3, 7 | What I saw. Write down. They have innocent explanations, and the note does not say otherwise. |
| 5 | What I saw. Write down: it is a fair part of the picture. |
| 6, 8 | What I do not know: an opinion and hearsay. Leave out of the note, or label as opinion. |
| 9 | What I saw (absence). The reason is what I do not know. |
| Whom I tell | The responsible person named in the community's policy, the same day. |
Do not turn the scene into a trial. Someone may say "It is obviously Marek." Gently return to the sheet: Which box does that go in? The scene is built so that nobody can know. Do not invent an ending.
Allow anyone to pass. Say the words: "If you would rather not say anything, pass." Then move on at once.
Expect that some people have lived something like the scene. If a person is upset, stay with them for a moment, do not hurry the group on, and follow up in private. If what you hear is beyond you, say so and help the person find someone who can carry it. (Listening in depth is the subject of LM205E, Listening Well: Foundations of Lay .) If a person in the group is a member who has a disability, ask them privately beforehand how they would like to take part; they may wish to lead Part B.
Run it for a liturgical community or a free church alike. The scene happens in a hall, but it could be a sacristy, a parish lounge or a living room. The responsible person might be a safeguarding officer, a , an or the leader of a house group. The habit is the same.
Diagram 1. Form A: Who do I tell?
Diagram 2. The "Who do I tell?" card for your own setting
| Item | Write here (roles and categories, not names) |
|---|---|
| The responsible person in our written policy (role) | |
| Where the written policy is kept | |
| The local reporting body (category) | |
| The emergency number (look it up now) | |
| A crisis line for emotional distress (category) | |
| Date this card was last checked |
Diagram 3. Form B: My participation plan
Diagram 4. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Stated the four promises and the extra rule out loud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet alongside the group | [ ] |
| Gave the time for Part A and Part B, with silence | [ ] |
| Did not ask anyone to read their sheet or name a real person | [ ] |
| Asked about feelings and habits, not contents | [ ] |
| Offered a genuine option to pass, and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Kept the scene from turning into a trial; did not invent an ending | [ ] |
| Stayed with anyone who was upset, and followed up in private | [ ] |
| Reminded the group that a real concern goes to the responsible person, not the group | [ ] |
핵심 요약
- The lab practises two habits: notice, write and tell without investigating, and ask a person for a plan in their own words.
- Things seen and things heard are written down as facts with the date and the exact words; opinions, hearsay and reasons go in "what I do not know."
- A real concern about a real person never goes into the lab or the group. It goes to the responsible person the same day, and to the emergency number if anyone is in danger.
- A participation plan is one page, in the person's own words, kept by the person, and says what helps rather than what the diagnosis is.
- There are four ways in: your own congregation, the observer's way, the partner's way (never imitating a disability) and a way for a member with a disability.
- The four promises govern the lab: nobody reads the sheet, nothing is marked, anyone may pass, and the leader writes too.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The sorting boxes | What I saw; what I heard; what I do not know; whom I tell; what I write down. |
| What goes in the note | Facts only: date, time, place and exact words. No guesses, no theories. |
| A participation plan | One page in the person's own words: what I like, what is hard, what helps, who may know what. Made with the person and kept by them. |
| The extra rule of this lab | A real, present concern about a real person goes to the responsible person after the session, never into the group. |
One sentence to remember I do not have to know what happened; I have to write down what I saw and heard, tell the right person, and ask the person what they would like.
This week's action Fill in the "Who do I tell?" card for your own community, and keep it where you will find it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What was it like to sort what you saw from what you guessed? Answer with a feeling or a habit, not with the contents of your sheet.
- Which item in the scene was hardest to put in a box? Why do you think so?
- In Part B, what did it feel like to write in someone else's voice? What did you want to add that the form did not ask for?
- What is one thing in your own community's habits (a notice, a prayer list, a way of speaking to a carer) that Part B suggests you might ask about?
- If you would like to say what you plan to do about the "Who do I tell?" card, do. If not, pass.