Lecture 6-3: Hard Moments and Putting Things Right
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Bodies and Belonging
- Lecture 1-2: Models of Disability and the Words We Use
- Lecture 1-3: When Theology Blames: Sin, Testing and Miracle
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Come: Honest Motives and First Impressions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Church's First Impression and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Moving and Sensing: Mobility, Sight, Hearing and Speech
- Lecture 2-2: Learning, Development and Autism
- Lecture 2-3: Mental Health, Chronic Illness and Hidden Disabilities
- Lecture 2-4: Asking First: How to Offer Help and Take a No
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions I Can Ask
- Lecture 3-1: Paths, Doors and Seats: The Building and the Room
- Lecture 3-2: The Service Itself: Order, Words and Sacraments
- Lecture 3-3: Screens, Print and Online Worship
- Lecture 3-4: Hospitality That Goes Beyond the Door
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Walking Through a Service
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Ministry: Inclusion Within It
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Adult Learning
- Lecture 4-3: Serving: Volunteers, Companions and Roles
- Lecture 4-4: Money, Time and the Small Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Opening One Group to Everyone
- Lecture 5-1: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-2: Supporters, Professionals and Warm Referral
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Consent and Keeping People Safe
- Lecture 5-4: Privacy, Prayer Lists and Photographs
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Who Do I Tell? A Participation Plan
A church that welcomes disabled people will have hard moments. A person will be overwhelmed by noise and run out of the room. A teenager will shout in the middle of the prayers. A member will hit someone, or throw a chair, or walk out in tears. A volunteer will say something thoughtless, and a member who was left out of a plan will say so. None of this shows that inclusion has failed. Hard moments happen in every community. What matters is how the church meets them.
This lecture has two halves. The first is about the moment itself: how to respond to a person in distress with safety and dignity, and what to agree beforehand so that no one is deciding in a panic. The second is about the days afterwards: how to say sorry to someone who was left out or hurt, how to receive a complaint, how to think about people who left, and how to stay in the work when it has been difficult.
The lecture teaches a stance and a few habits, and it does not teach a clinical method. A church is not a clinic. It cannot treat, diagnose or manage anyone. It can arrange a calm place, a clear plan, a trained person where there is one, and the honesty to say when it needs help.
이 28분으로 얻는 것
- Describe a safe and dignified response to a person who is loud, runs, hits or is overwhelmed, and say what is agreed beforehand and with whom.
- State the lines that are never crossed: no restraint, no confinement, no giving or withholding of medicine, and no touching without agreement.
- Explain why limits are written down with the leader and reviewed, and why a limit is not a quiet disappearance.
- Describe the parts of a good apology to someone who was left out or hurt, and what a church should not ask of that person.
- Explain how a church can receive complaints, think about those who have left, and remain in the work.
If therefore you are offering your gift at the altar, and there remember that your brother has anything against you, leave your gift there before the altar, and go your way. First be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift." — Matthew 5:23-24
World English Bible
He who conceals his sins doesn’t prosper, but whoever confesses and renounces them finds mercy." — Proverbs 28:13
WEB
Confess your offenses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The insistent prayer of a righteous person is powerfully effective." — James 5:16
WEB
Jesus puts reconciliation before the offering. The wisdom writer and James say that honest admission is where mercy begins. Keep these three in mind for the second half of the lecture.
1. Two kinds of hard moment
Not every hard moment is the same, and a response that suits one will harm another. It helps to separate them.
A person is overwhelmed. Noise, crowds, light, a change of plan, a sudden touch, pain or fatigue can become too much. The person may cover their ears, rock, shout, cry, leave the room or run. This happens to some autistic people, to some people with an intellectual or developmental disability, to people in pain, to people with mental-health conditions, and to many people who have no label at all. It is rarely "bad behaviour." Often it is the person's way of coping with something that has become unbearable. The response is to lower the pressure.
A person is a danger to themselves or to someone else. A person is running toward a road, or has struck another member, or is saying that they want to end their life. This is a different category. Here the response is about safety first and about getting help quickly.
We do not decide which kind it is by diagnosing. We watch what is happening, we respond to what we see, and we use the plan that was agreed beforehand. Most hard moments are of the first kind.
2. Agree beforehand, with the person
The best preparation happens on a quiet weekday and not in the middle of a service. The principle is the one the course has used from the start: ask the person first. Where a person's family or supporters are involved, they take part, and the person's own wishes lead as far as possible (lecture 5-3).
A short, written plan, kept by the leader, might cover:
- What helps. A quiet room, a particular person to sit near, a break, headphones, an object, a short word. Ask the person and ask the people who know them.
- Early signs. How do they look or sound when things are becoming too much? What can a nearby volunteer do at that moment?
- What does not help. Crowding, many questions, a hand on the shoulder, a raised voice, being told to "calm down."
- Who steps in. One named person, with a named second, agreed by the person where possible. Not three people at once.
- Where to go. A quiet place that is easy to reach and that is not a place of punishment. Anyone may use it. (Lecture 3-2 describes this.)
- What the church will do if someone may be hurt. Who moves other people away, who calls for help, and when the local emergency number is used.
- Who is told afterwards, and what is not shared (lecture 5-4).
Keep the plan to one page. Review it with the person after a few months. People change; so do the places where they are comfortable.
The plan is for the church's use. It is not a medical document, and it records no diagnosis.
3. In the moment
A few habits help in most situations. They are not a technique to be applied to a person; they are a way of being calm and small.
- Lower the pressure. Fewer people, a lower voice, less light and noise if you can change it. The one agreed person steps in; the others step back.
- Few words. Short sentences. One question at a time, or none. "I am here. Would you like water, or to go outside?" is better than "What is wrong?"
- Give room. Stand a little to the side, not facing the person, and not blocking the way out.
- Do not touch unless this was agreed. A hand on a shoulder can be a threat to someone who is overwhelmed.
- Wait. A hard moment usually passes. Do not fill the silence.
- Do not shame. Not "behave," not "everyone is watching," not an apology made loudly for the person.
When the first words do not help, when a person may hurt themselves or others, or when the person is in danger, the stance changes. Call for the responsible person at once. Move others away from the danger, not the person away from the room if that can be avoided. Use your local emergency number if anyone is in danger. A church worker is not expected to stop a person by force and must not try.
The lines that are never crossed. Never restrain a person. Never confine a person: no locked room, no blocked door, no standing in a doorway to stop someone leaving. Never give or withhold medicine. Never touch a person who has said no. These lines are as firm as anything in this course. They protect the person and they protect the volunteer, who is not trained for restraint and could injure someone, and could be injured. Where a person's safety truly requires physical help, the right people are those trained and entitled to give it, and the emergency services.
If a person speaks of wanting to end their life or to hurt themselves, the stance is the one lecture 2-3 described. Take every remark seriously. Do not argue and do not debate. Do not promise to keep it secret. Stay beside the person. Connect them at once to the responsible person, to professional help and to a local crisis line, and use your local emergency number if life is in danger. Never discuss methods.
A word for different communities. In a large liturgical parish, the quiet place may be a side chapel, a vestibule or a room off the entrance, and an usher may know the way. In a house church it may be the kitchen or the garden. In both, the aim is that leaving the room is not shameful, and that the person who steps out is not followed by the stares of the congregation.
(An invented example.) Karim is an in a mid-sized church. He is Deaf, and he leads the small team that writes the plans for hard moments, because he knows, from his own life, how often well-meant people crowd a person who is already overwhelmed. At a Sunday service, a teenager named Daniel, who is autistic, began to cover his ears when the hall filled with singing, and then walked quickly toward the door. His agreed plan named his aunt as the person to step in. She followed at a distance, and a volunteer at the door, who knew the plan, opened it and said nothing. Outside, Daniel sat on the step for ten minutes. The service went on. Afterwards, Karim asked Daniel, with his aunt beside him if he wished, whether the plan had worked and what he would change. Daniel asked that the volunteer bring him a cup of water next time, and the plan was changed.
4. Limits that are written down
Sometimes the church faces a real limit. A person may hit others repeatedly, and a volunteer has been hurt. A child may run from the building and the church has too few adults to follow. A member may need more care than anyone in the congregation is trained to give.
A church should not respond by deciding quietly that a person will not be welcome. It should not use anger as a reason for a ban. And it should not impose a limit without the person hearing the reason and having a chance to answer.
A limit that is truly needed (for example, that a family member or a supporter will sit with the person during the service, or that the person will come to the earlier and smaller gathering) should be:
- written down, in a short note, with the reason;
- agreed with the leader and discussed with the person and, where it applies, the family, who are given the chance to say what they think;
- the smallest limit that keeps people safe;
- reviewed after a stated time, not left in place forever;
- accompanied by an offer. If the church cannot meet a need alone, it says so honestly and refers warmly (lecture 5-2): asks the person's permission, says whom to see and what to expect, offers to go along, and follows up.
A limit is not a closed door. The person stays a member, and the church keeps in touch. If someone has to be asked to stay away from a particular gathering for a time, the church should stay in contact, visit or write, and say when it will look again. A silent disappearance is one of the hardest forms of exclusion because the person may never learn why.
Where harm has been done, both sides matter. The member who was hit needs care. The person who hit needs dignity and a plan. These are not in competition. The church writes down what happened, not what it believes the person to be, and does not add a diagnosis or a name for the "problem."
5. Putting things right
Hard moments will also come from the church's own failings. A notice names a member without asking. A volunteer speaks to a companion instead of the person. A Deaf member is left out of a meeting. A family is told "we will see what we can do" and never hears more. The question is not whether this will happen but what the church does next.
Jesus says that when you remember that someone has something against you, you leave your gift at the altar and go to be reconciled first (Matthew 5:23-24). Note the order. The one who remembers must go, and the one who has been wronged is not told to hurry to forgive. A church that wants to apologise should take the first step.
A good apology has parts:
- Name what happened, plainly and specifically: "We put your name on the prayer list without asking you."
- Say that it was wrong, without excuses and without the word "if." "I am sorry if anyone was offended" is not an apology.
- Say what you will change, and then change it.
- Offer something real, if appropriate: a meeting, a note in writing, a different arrangement.
- Leave the other person free. They may accept, refuse, answer later, or never answer. An apology is not a request for forgiveness.
And there are things a church should not do. Do not ask the person to educate the church for free, as though the hurt were their work. Do not ask them to relive it in front of others. Do not make them into a story for the congregation (see lecture 5-4: ask before any telling). Do not announce the apology from the front in a way that names them again unless they have said they want it. Do not defend the volunteer in the same breath; the apology should be given by the person or the leader responsible, and a second conversation can look at what to change.
Proverbs 28:13 says "he who conceals his sins doesn’t prosper, but whoever confesses and renounces them finds mercy." James 5:16 says to "confess your offenses to one another." These texts describe a culture where saying "we got that wrong" is not shameful. A church in which leaders can do that has made it safer for everyone else to do it. They do not mean that anyone should be pressed to confess in public, or that a hurt member must hear a confession they did not ask for.
(An invented example.) Teodor, who uses a wheelchair and chairs the building committee, had asked in writing that his health not be mentioned in the prayers. In a service, the person leading the intercessions mentioned him by name and said he was "struggling." Teodor did not speak that day. A week later he sent a short note to the pastor. The pastor and the intercessor met him together at his house. The intercessor said what she had done and that it had been wrong, and said she would check every name before using it. The pastor said that the church would add a line to the intercessions sheet: "Names only with permission." Teodor said he was glad, and that he would like it if the committee heard no more about it. They did not mention it further.
6. A way to hear complaints
Many people who are hurt in a church do not complain, because they do not know who to tell, they are afraid of being a nuisance, or they fear that the person complained about is a friend of the leader. A church can make complaints easier to give:
- Say plainly, in a notice or a leaflet, how to raise a concern and with whom.
- Offer more than one route: a person other than the one complained about, a form, a note, a signed message, a phone call, a conversation with someone the person trusts.
- Say what will happen next and by when. Acknowledge the complaint quickly, even if the answer will take time.
- Tell the person what was done. People who raise a concern and hear nothing conclude that nothing was done.
- Keep it private unless the person agrees otherwise.
Complaints that involve harm to a person, or concern about abuse, are not handled by the method above. Follow your community's written policy and the law of your country, tell the responsible person, and do not investigate alone (lecture 5-3).
7. People who left
Every church that tries to change learns that some people left earlier, sometimes because of something the church did or failed to do. It is tempting to leave them alone out of embarrassment. A short and honest message can help: "We have thought of you. We are sorry for how things were. The door is open if you want it. We would like to hear what we could do better, and you do not have to answer."
Such a message should be sent only if the person is likely to welcome contact, and it should never be sent by someone who was involved in the hurt without that person's agreement. It should not include pressure to return. A person may have left on purpose, to a church that suits them better, or to a time of rest. If the answer is no, the church accepts it.
8. Staying in the work
Church workers are tired, and a hard moment can bring tiredness to a point. A volunteer who was hit may not want to come back. A leader who was criticised may feel it was all for nothing. A group should have a way of looking after those who carry the work: a word of thanks, a rest, a chance to say what was hard, a person to speak to. Counselling skills belong to another course, and LM205E, Listening Well: Foundations of Lay , is a place to start.
A failure is not the end. A hard moment that is met with honesty, an apology and a changed plan can leave a church more trusting than one that never had a hard moment at all. The aim is not to be a church where nothing goes wrong. It is to be one where, when something goes wrong, the person who was hurt is believed, the person in distress is treated with dignity, and everyone learns.
Diagram 1. Before, during and after a hard moment
Diagram 2. The parts of a good apology
| Part | What it sounds like | What it is not |
|---|---|---|
| Name it | "We put your name on the list without asking." | "I am sorry if anyone was upset." |
| Say it was wrong | "That was wrong." | "We meant well." |
| Say what will change | "From now on every name is checked first." | "We will try to do better." |
| Offer something real | A meeting, a note, a different arrangement | A request to forgive |
| Leave the person free | "You may answer, or not." | A deadline for a reply |
핵심 요약
- Most hard moments are overwhelm and not misbehaviour; the response is to lower pressure, use few words, give room and wait, following a plan agreed beforehand with the person.
- Never restrain, never confine, never give or withhold medicine, and never touch a person who has said no; where anyone may be hurt, call the responsible person and use your local emergency number.
- A limit is written down with the leader, is the smallest that keeps people safe, is reviewed, is explained to the person, and comes with a warm referral; it is never a quiet disappearance.
- A good apology names what happened, says it was wrong, says what will change, offers something real and leaves the person free to answer or not.
- A church can make complaints easy, tell people what was done, and message those who left only if contact is likely to be welcome.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The plan for hard moments | One page, agreed beforehand with the person: what helps, early signs, what does not help, who steps in, where to go. No diagnosis. |
| Lines never crossed | No restraint, no confinement, no giving or withholding medicine, no touching against a no. |
| A written limit | The smallest that keeps people safe, explained to the person, reviewed, with a warm referral. Never a quiet disappearance. |
| A good apology | Name it, say it was wrong, say what will change, offer something real, leave the person free. |
One sentence to remember A hard moment met with calm, a plan agreed beforehand, and an honest apology afterwards can leave a church more trusted than before.
This week's action Ask your leader whether your community has a written plan for a person in distress, and if not, offer to help write a one-page draft with the people it concerns.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Why is it better to agree a plan beforehand, on a quiet weekday, than to decide in the middle of a service?
- Why does the lecture say that a quiet room should be available to anyone and not be a place to send people? Who could be sent there by mistake?
- A church worker is tempted to stand in a doorway to stop a person leaving, "for their safety." What does the lecture say, and why?
- Think of a time when you received an apology that helped and one that did not. What did the first one include that the second did not?
- A member who left a year ago is on your mind. What would you need to think about before sending a message, and whom would you ask?