요약으로 복습하기
STEL9E 과목의 강의 31편을 요약만으로 훑어봅니다. 시험 전날에 쓰세요.
강의 제목만 보고 내용을 먼저 떠올린 뒤에 펼쳐 보세요. 그냥 다시 읽는 것보다 훨씬 오래 남습니다.
제 0 장 Introduction: Why Does a Student of Theology Need Philosophy?
요약 보기
- Theology cannot speak without philosophy, but philosophy does not settle theology's conclusions.
- Every theologian already uses some philosophy; the choice is between using it with open eyes or without noticing.
- "Philosophy is the enemy" and "philosophy is the servant" are both too simple; the course treats philosophy as conversation partner, toolbox and challenger.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox thinking are each described in their own terms and not ranked.
- Where readers will not agree, the course gives each side fairly with its weak point.
- Every Practice Lab has three ways in and four privacy promises, and never asks about personal pain.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The central claim | Theology cannot speak without philosophy, but philosophy does not settle its conclusions; we borrow its tools and know their limits. |
| Two stories to avoid | "Philosophy is the enemy" and "philosophy is the servant." |
| The six weeks | History; knowing; being; language; argument; evil and the place of philosophy. |
| What it leaves to others | Apologetics (STEL1E); modern theologians (STEL2E); writing skills (FS101E); the doctrines themselves. |
| Three ways into a lab | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
One sentence to remember Philosophy is neither the enemy of faith nor its servant: it is a conversation partner that helps us ask honestly.
제 1 장 Week 1: Philosophy and Theology: A Long Conversation
요약 보기
- Faith seeking understanding asks questions, and distinguishing, defining and giving reasons are tools of philosophy.
- Scripture raises questions it does not settle, such as what "eternal" or "know" means, and answering them needs philosophical decisions.
- Every theologian uses some philosophy; the choice is between named and unnamed, careful and careless.
- Four stances are enemy, servant, conversation partner and toolbox, each with a real concern and a real danger.
- Readers disagree about which stance is best; the course asks only that you describe each fairly and give reasons for your own view.
- Theology needs philosophy, but philosophy does not settle theology's conclusions.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Faith seeking understanding | A believer who trusts God also wants to understand what is believed; faith, being alive, asks questions. |
| Three tools | Distinguishing, defining and giving reasons: the simple tools of philosophy used in theology. |
| Four stances | Enemy, servant, conversation partner, toolbox; each has a real concern and a danger. |
| Named or unnamed | Everyone uses some philosophy; naming it lets us test it instead of being ruled by it unseen. |
One sentence to remember Theology cannot speak without philosophy, but philosophy does not settle what theology concludes.
This week's action Write down one word from your tradition's teaching that Scripture does not use, and say in one sentence what it means.
요약 보기
- The early church spoke into a Greek-speaking world with many schools of thought, not one "Greek philosophy".
- Paul's speech in Athens and the warning of Colossians 2:8 are each read in more than one way by careful readers.
- Early writers mixed welcome and warning: apologists, Clement, Origen and Tertullian each did both, in different proportions.
- The church borrowed words such as nature, person and of one being, tested them against Scripture and worship, and changed their meaning.
- Two warnings are early: do not let an outside system rule the message, and do not refuse every outside word.
- Calling the borrowing simply corruption, or simply support for the faith, says more than the evidence allows.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Acts 17 and Colossians 2:8 | Each is read in more than one way; neither is a rule for how a church must treat philosophy. |
| Early voices | Apologists, Clement, Origen and Tertullian mixed welcome and warning in different measures. |
| Borrow and bend | The church took words like nature and person from Greek speech and shaped them to fit Scripture and worship. |
| Two warnings | Do not let an outside system rule the message; do not refuse every outside word. |
One sentence to remember The early church neither simply welcomed nor simply refused Greek thought: it borrowed, tested and changed what it borrowed.
This week's action Read Acts 17:22-34 in full and write down, in two lines, which reading of Paul's speech seems stronger to you and what its weak point is.
요약 보기
- Augustine used the Platonist tradition freely, held that no school of philosophy could bring a person to Christ, and taught that faith and understanding go together.
- Anselm is linked with the phrase faith seeking understanding: a believer who reasons within the faith to see better what is believed.
- In the twelfth and thirteenth centuries many writings of Aristotle came into Latin, and caused both excitement and alarm.
- Aquinas held that truth is one, so reason and revelation cannot finally contradict each other; he distinguished natural from revealed theology.
- Readers disagree about how far natural theology can go; the strongest forms and weak points of each side can be stated fairly.
- The Eastern tradition stresses mystery and the negative way, and the medieval synthesis was not the only answer.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Augustine | Borrowed from the Platonists, drew a line at what the gospel alone says, and held that faith and understanding go together. |
| Faith seeking understanding | A believer, trusting God, reasons within the faith to see better what is believed; linked with Anselm. |
| Natural and revealed theology | What reason can know of God from creation, and what is known only because God has made it known. |
| Eastern emphasis | Mystery, worship and the negative way: saying what God is not as a safeguard against a neat definition. |
One sentence to remember From Augustine to Aquinas, the church used reason inside faith, held that truth is one, and never agreed on exactly how far reason can go.
This week's action Write one sentence of your own that gives an example of natural theology and one that gives an example of revealed theology.
요약 보기
- The Reformers criticised reason set above Scripture, and used logic, grammar and rhetoric every day.
- Later writers speak of reason used ministerially, as a servant under Scripture, and magisterially, as a master over it.
- Protestant universities kept the tools of the schools; writers differ on whether this was fruitful or a drift toward system.
- Descartes asked what cannot be doubted, Hume asked what grounds belief in cause, and Kant argued that reason has limits.
- Theologians responded to the modern challenge in several ways: answering on its terms, resting faith on experience, rejecting it, or rebuilding.
- Philosophy of religion revived in the late twentieth century, alongside a continental tradition with its own path.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Ministerial and magisterial | Reason as servant under Scripture, and reason as master over Scripture; a way of describing the Protestant concern. |
| Descartes, Hume, Kant | What cannot be doubted; what grounds belief in cause; the limits of reason. |
| The modern challenge | Reason asked to be the judge of religion, and religion asked to justify itself; responses varied. |
| Four stances revisited | Enemy, servant, conversation partner, toolbox: ways of holding one question that return in every age. |
One sentence to remember From the Reformers to today the same question has returned: how far to trust reason in matters of faith, and in what role.
This week's action Name one writer or teacher you know and say which of the four stances they seem to hold most often, and what concern lies behind it.
요약 보기
- The lab asks you to look at your own stance toward philosophy: enemy, servant, conversation partner or toolbox.
- It never asks about a crisis of faith, a bereavement or personal pain, and nothing of that should be written.
- Name one assumption you use without naming it, and state the strongest case for a stance you do not hold.
- State the weak point of your own stance, one question you hold, and one step you will take.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Looking at your own stance toward philosophy, naming an unspoken assumption, and choosing one step. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What the lab never asks | A crisis of faith, a bereavement or personal pain; a real name or confidential matter. |
One sentence to remember Look honestly at how you stand toward philosophy, name one assumption you use, and take one small step.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper and keep it where only you will find it.
제 2 장 Week 2: Knowing: Epistemology
요약 보기
- "Know" has three everyday jobs: knowing how, knowing someone and knowing that. Confusing them causes much muddle in talk about faith.
- Belief is holding something to be so; truth is how things are; justification is having good grounds.
- The traditional account says knowledge is justified true belief; the stopped clock shows a true, justified belief can still be only lucky.
- Confidence comes in degrees and should be matched to evidence; a feeling of certainty is not the same as a standard of evidence.
- Doubt can be a useful tool or a trap; it is not a sin, and certainty is not a sign of faith.
- The Bible joins knowing and believing and gives no definition of knowledge; the Hebrew and Greek words for knowing are wide.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three kinds of knowing | Knowing how (a skill), knowing someone (acquaintance) and knowing that (a fact). |
| Justified true belief | The traditional account of knowledge: I believe it, it is true and I have good grounds. |
| The stopped clock | A true belief with reasons that fit only by luck; it shows that having reasons and truth together is not always enough. |
| Certainty, two senses | A feeling of being sure, or a standard of evidence; the two can come apart. |
One sentence to remember To say "I know" is to claim a belief that is true and well grounded, and a careful person asks which kind of knowing is meant and how the grounds fit.
This week's action Listen for the word "know" in conversation or in a sermon and ask yourself which of the three kinds is meant.
요약 보기
- Reason clarifies meaning, tests consistency, draws conclusions and weighs evidence, but works on something that is given it.
- General revelation is what God makes known to all through creation and conscience; special revelation is made known in particular events, persons and words, above all in Christ.
- Faith has been described as knowledge, assent and trust together; traditions fill this out in their own ways.
- Four models join reason, revelation and faith differently: harmony, faith-first, mystery and experience, and presuppositions. Each has a strength and a weak point.
- "Faith is believing without thinking" and "only reason is a path" are caricatures that almost every tradition rejects.
- The course requires that you state each model fairly and give reasons for your own view; it does not require a side.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Reason | The power to think: to clarify, test for consistency, draw conclusions and weigh evidence, working on what is given. |
| General and special revelation | What God makes known to all through creation and conscience, and what he makes known in particular events, persons and words, above all in Christ. |
| Faith, three parts | Knowledge, assent and trust; each tradition fills this in its own way. |
| Two caricatures | "Faith is believing without thinking" and "only reason is a path"; almost every tradition rejects both. |
One sentence to remember Christians join reason, revelation and faith in different ways, and each way has a strength and a weak point that a fair reader can state.
This week's action Read a paragraph of a theologian you know and ask what the author thinks reason can reach and what must be received.
요약 보기
- No chain of reasons can go on for ever; it must stop at beliefs that are not proved from others, called basic beliefs.
- Evidentialism says to believe in proportion to evidence; it cares for honesty, and its weak points are what counts as evidence and whether its own rule meets its own test.
- Reformed epistemology holds that belief in God may be properly basic, like memory; it cares for ordinary faith, and the Great Pumpkin objection is a weak point.
- Basic is not a licence: a basic belief can still be challenged and given up.
- A wider approach holds that knowing God involves arguments, experience, the church and grace together, and has its own weak point.
- The course asks you to state each position fairly and to give reasons for your own view, not to take a side.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Basic belief | A belief held without proving it from another belief, such as memory, what I see or the existence of other minds. |
| Evidentialism | Believe in proportion to the evidence; it protects honesty; critics ask what counts as evidence. |
| Reformed epistemology | Belief in God may be properly basic, like memory; it protects ordinary faith; the Great Pumpkin objection is a challenge to it. |
| Why no proof text | Each side reads the same verses, and Scripture was not written to settle a debate in epistemology. |
One sentence to remember Every chain of reasons stops somewhere, and the question is not whether we have basic beliefs but which may be held and how they can still be tested.
This week's action Pick one belief you hold and write down your reasons, then ask which of them is basic.
요약 보기
- Most of what we know rests on the word of others; trusting well asks whether a source was in a position to know, is honest and is agreed with by others who know.
- The church hands on knowing through creed, worship and the shared reading of Scripture, which can guard against private error, though a community can also be wrong.
- Virtue epistemology holds that character shapes knowing; humility, patience, honesty, carefulness, open-mindedness and courage help, and pride, hurry and closed-mindedness harm.
- False certainty claims more than the grounds allow; paralysing doubt refuses ever to settle.
- A settled but open confidence is held according to the grounds, ready to give reasons and to be corrected.
- A student can notice whose word they rely on, read with others, practise one virtue and let a question stay open.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Testimony | Knowing from the word of another; not a poor kind of knowing, but it must be trusted well. |
| Three ways a church hands on knowing | The creed, worship and the shared reading of Scripture. |
| Virtue epistemology | The idea that character, such as humility, patience and honesty, shapes how well a person knows. |
| Two dangers | False certainty, which claims more than the grounds allow, and paralysing doubt, which refuses to settle. |
One sentence to remember We know in company, by the word of others and the life of a community, and the character of the knower helps or hinders.
This week's action For one belief you hold, write down who told you, and whether they were in a position to know.
요약 보기
- The lab asks you to look at the assumptions behind a general claim that you say you know.
- It never asks you to write about a crisis of faith, a bereavement, an illness or any personal pain, and nothing of that should be written.
- Name the kind of knowing, the grounds, how sure you feel and how sure the grounds allow.
- Write what would change your mind, one virtue and one danger, the weak point of your claim, one question and one step.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Looking at the grounds of a general "I know", how sure you feel against how sure the grounds allow, and choosing one step. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What the lab never asks | A crisis of faith, a bereavement, an illness or other personal pain; a real name or confidential matter. |
One sentence to remember Look honestly at what you rest on when you say "I know", and take one small step.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, on a general claim, and keep it where only you will find it.
제 3 장 Week 3: Being: Metaphysics
요약 보기
- Metaphysics asks the most general questions about what exists: what a thing is, what stays when it changes, what depends on what.
- Substance, in the older sense, is the thing that has properties; an accident can change while the thing remains.
- An essence is what makes a thing the kind of thing it is, though some thinkers dispute that things have essences.
- Realism holds that general things are real; nominalism holds that only individuals exist and general words are names; Scripture does not settle it.
- Theology borrowed metaphysical words in speaking of creation and the incarnation, and reshaped them.
- A borrowed word may be a tool or a framework; traditions weigh this differently.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Metaphysics | The study of the most general features of what exists: things, properties, change, dependence. |
| Essence and accident | An essence makes a thing the kind of thing it is; an accident is a property it could lose and stay itself. |
| Realism and nominalism | Realism: general things are real in some way. Nominalism: only individuals exist; general words are names. |
| Tool or framework | A tool is used for a purpose and put down; a framework shapes the room in which you work. |
One sentence to remember Know what a borrowed word meant before you decide what it is doing in a text.
This week's action Take one word from a creed or textbook (nature, substance, being) and write what it meant in its older use and what you think it adds.
요약 보기
- A cause brings something about; ordinary speech uses the word for many kinds of reasons, so ask which is meant.
- Aristotle listed four kinds: material, formal, efficient and final; modern speech mostly means the efficient one.
- Hume asked what we really see when we say one thing causes another; philosophers have answered in several ways.
- A contingent thing exists but could have been otherwise; a necessary thing could not have been otherwise.
- A starting cause comes first in time; a sustaining cause keeps something in being now. The two are different questions.
- These words clarify what Christians mean by creation; they do not prove it.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four causes | Material (what it is made of), formal (its pattern), efficient (what makes it), final (what it is for). |
| Contingent and necessary | Contingent: exists but might not have. Necessary: could not have been otherwise. |
| Starting and sustaining cause | A starting cause begins a series in time; a sustaining cause keeps a thing in being now. |
| Hume's question | What do we actually see when we say one thing causes another, beyond one event following another? |
One sentence to remember When you hear the word cause, ask which kind is meant, and whether it is about the beginning or about what holds things in being now.
This week's action Pick a statement about creation you have heard, and ask whether it speaks of a starting cause, a sustaining cause, or something else.
요약 보기
- Time may be pictured as flowing, with only the present real, or as laid out like a map; the picture shapes the question of what God can know.
- Some Christians hold that God is outside time, others that he is within time; each view has a strength and a weak point.
- Determinism holds that all is fixed; libertarian freedom that I could have chosen otherwise; compatibilism that a choice is free if it comes from my own wants, unforced.
- Reformed, Lutheran, Arminian, Catholic and Orthodox writers all hold that God is sovereign and people are responsible, and differ in how they join the two.
- The puzzle of God's knowledge and freedom turns on whether knowing is the same as causing, and on a picture of time.
- Scripture's verses on these questions do not settle one theory.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Two pictures of time | Flowing (only the present is fully real) and laid out (all moments equally there, like places on a map). |
| God and time | Outside time (all present to him at once) or within time (everlasting, living through time); each has a strength and a weak point. |
| Three words on freedom | Determinism: all fixed. Libertarian freedom: I could have chosen otherwise. Compatibilism: free if from my own wants, unforced. |
| Knowing and causing | One family of replies says God's knowing a choice does not cause it, as seeing the time on a clock does not make it noon. |
One sentence to remember Christians of every tradition hold that God is sovereign and people are responsible, and they differ in how they join the two.
This week's action Write the strongest form of a view on providence and freedom that you do not hold, as someone who holds it would say it.
요약 보기
- The four families are ontological (from the idea of God), cosmological (from the world's existence), design (from order and purpose) and moral (from right and wrong).
- Each can be set out as premises and a conclusion, and each has a strength, an objection and a reply.
- Aquinas's five ways are brief arguments, named by idea; they are not the whole of his thought.
- A sound argument might show that a first cause or designer exists, not that he is the Father of Jesus Christ.
- A believer may use an argument as a ground, as a map or as a help to others, or not at all.
- Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox writers have judged natural theology differently; this lecture reads the arguments and does not train apologetics.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four families | Ontological, cosmological, design, moral; each starts from a different point and has its own objections. |
| What a sound argument shows | At most that something fitting the description exists; revelation, not argument, says that he is the Father of Jesus Christ. |
| What an argument may be for | A ground of belief, a map of the question, or a help to others; for some, nothing at all. |
| Different judgements | Catholic writers value natural theology; some Protestants criticise it; some Orthodox writers stress that God is known in worship and life. |
One sentence to remember Read each argument as premises and a conclusion, give it its strongest form and its weak point, and keep clear what it could show.
This week's action Take one argument for God that you have heard and write it as numbered premises and a conclusion, then mark the premise you think a critic would attack first.
요약 보기
- The lab asks you to look at what you take for granted about what exists, cause, time, God and freedom, on a general question.
- It never asks you to disclose a crisis of faith, a bereavement or any other personal pain, and nothing of that should be written.
- Sort each assumption: I can give reasons, I inherited it, or I have never examined it.
- Write the strongest objection to one assumption, one question you hold and one step you will take.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Finding and sorting the assumptions you use on a general question, and choosing one step. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What the lab never asks | A crisis of faith, a bereavement or other personal pain; a real name or confidential matter. |
One sentence to remember Notice what you take for granted, say which of it you can defend, and take one small step to test it.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, on a general question, and keep it where only you will find it.
제 4 장 Week 4: Language: How We Speak of God
요약 보기
- A word gets its meaning from its use; stretched uses are guided by a resemblance that hearers can follow.
- God is not one thing among others, so every word used of God is carried a long way from its first home.
- Scripture speaks of God in many pictures: rock, shepherd, fortress, father, without fitting them into one drawing.
- A metaphor is a way of knowing: it says "is" and "is not", and carries over part of the picture.
- Flat literalism makes God small; over-spiritualising leaves nothing that could be true.
- Readers differ on how much of God-speech is metaphor; the question of gendered language is named, not argued here.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Where a word gets its meaning | From its use: who says it, about what, in what setting, against which other words. |
| Metaphor | A way of speaking of one thing in terms of another; it says "is" and "is not", and carries over only part of the picture. |
| Two opposite mistakes | Flat literalism (every part of the picture is true of God) and over-spiritualising (the picture becomes only a mood). |
| Why Psalm 18:2 uses many pictures | Each says something different about what God is for the one who trusts; none is the whole. |
One sentence to remember A picture of God tells the truth when you ask what it carries over and what it leaves behind.
This week's action Write down three pictures of God that you use in prayer or teaching, and next to each write one thing it carries over and one thing it leaves behind.
요약 보기
- A word said of God may mean the same as of creatures, something wholly different, or something related by analogy.
- The same meaning makes God a larger creature; a wholly different meaning makes "God is good" tell us nothing.
- Analogy says a likeness is real and the difference is greater; the speaker asks what is carried over and what is left behind.
- Barth is known for criticising one form of analogy; Catholic defenders reply that the likeness is God's gift.
- Analogy protects both the truth of speech about God and the difference between God and creatures.
- Neither John 1:18 nor Colossians 1:15 settles the matter; the course asks you to state each side fairly.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three answers to "what does good mean of God?" | The same meaning, a wholly different meaning, or a related meaning (analogy). |
| The everyday example of analogy | "Healthy" said of a person, a meal and a complexion: one centre, related uses. |
| Barth's concern, and the reply | Do not start from the creature and climb; true speech rests on revelation. Reply: the likeness is God's gift, and the difference is always greater. |
| What analogy tries to protect | The truth of speech about God and the difference between God and creatures. |
One sentence to remember Analogy says that our words about God are neither the same as nor wholly unlike our words about creatures, and it asks us in each case what carries over.
This week's action Take one word you often use of God, such as good, wise or near, and write two sentences: what carries over, and what must be left behind.
요약 보기
- The negative way speaks of God by saying what God is not: invisible, infinite, unchanging.
- Eastern writers and Western mystics have both used it; many Christians use some of it without naming it.
- Affirmation, negation and eminence work together: say it, deny the creaturely sense, and praise beyond.
- Humility without speech can become silence as an excuse; confidence without humility can make God an exhibit.
- The Reformed emphasis on God's revealed name and the Orthodox emphasis on the icon are described here in their own terms, each with a weak point.
- These verses suggest speaking "in part"; they do not prove a single theory.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The negative way | Speaking of God by saying what God is not, to clear the mind of small pictures. |
| Affirmation, negation, eminence | Say what is true; deny the creaturely sense; praise beyond what we know. They work together. |
| Danger of negation alone / confidence alone | Silence as an excuse for not thinking; treating God as an exhibit that has been mapped. |
| Two emphases on the incarnation | Reformed: God's revealed name and Word. Orthodox: the icon. Each has a weak point critics name. |
One sentence to remember Good speech about God says what it can, says what it must not mean, and keeps a place for silence.
This week's action Before your next prayer or lesson, say aloud one thing you will affirm of God, one thing you will deny, and then stay silent for a minute.
요약 보기
- Scripture speaks of God in story, poem, law and letter, and each kind does it differently.
- A good reader asks what kind of sentence this is before asking what it says about God.
- The creeds borrowed words from outside Scripture and set limits around them, as with a warning label.
- Chalcedon's four negatives show a creed saying what must not be said, as well as what is held.
- A doctrinal term is both a fence that marks a boundary and a signpost that points; using only one distorts it.
- Across languages, ask what carries over and what is left behind in each place, and listen before judging.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four literary kinds | Story, poem and song, law, letter; each speaks of God in its own way. |
| A word with a warning label | A borrowed word that the creed uses for one purpose and limits, to rule out mistakes, not to map God. |
| Fence and signpost | A fence marks what we do not hold; a signpost points to who God is. Both are needed. |
| Speaking of God across cultures | Words for father, lord or spirit carry different weight; ask what carries over, explain the picture and listen. |
One sentence to remember Read each kind of Scripture as what it is, treat a creed's words as a fence and a signpost, and carry words across languages with care.
This week's action Choose one passage you will teach or read soon and write down what kind of writing it is and what that tells you about how it speaks of God.
요약 보기
- The lab asks you to look at the words you use for God and at which way of speaking you lean on.
- For each word, name what it carries over and what it leaves behind.
- Most people lean on one way, and the lab asks you to notice what you may neglect.
- It never asks about a crisis of faith, a bereavement or personal pain, and a word that hurts may be skipped without a reason.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Looking at the words you use for God, what each carries over and leaves behind, and choosing one step. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What the lab never asks | A crisis of faith, a bereavement or personal pain; real names or confidential matters; why a word was skipped. |
One sentence to remember Look honestly at the words you use for God, say what each carries over and leaves behind, and take one small step.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, using ordinary words, and keep it where only you will find it.
제 5 장 Week 5: Reading and Writing Arguments
요약 보기
- An argument offers premises as reasons for a conclusion; words such as "because" and "so" often mark them.
- An argument is valid if the conclusion would have to be true when the premises are; it is sound if it is valid and the premises are in fact true.
- Most arguments leave a premise unsaid; naming that hidden assumption is often where real disagreement is found.
- Drawing an argument as boxes and arrows shows what is claimed and what supports what.
- Argument, persuasion and witness are different kinds of speech, and argument is not the whole of theology.
- Readers differ on how large a part argument plays in theology, and on how to read Romans 5:12-21.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Premise and conclusion | A premise is a reason offered; the conclusion is the claim it is supposed to support. |
| Valid and sound | Valid: the conclusion must be true if the premises are. Sound: valid, and the premises are in fact true. |
| Hidden assumption | An unstated premise the argument leans on; say it aloud and look at it. |
| Argument, persuasion, witness | Reasons to weigh; anything that moves a person; what someone has seen, received or lived. |
One sentence to remember An argument is a map of reasons: draw it, ask "does it follow?" and "is it so?", and remember that argument is a tool of theology and not all of it.
This week's action Take one paragraph you read this week, underline its conclusion, and write down its premises and one hidden assumption.
요약 보기
- Deduction gives certainty if its premises are true; induction gives a degree of support from cases seen; best-explanation reasoning picks the story that fits the facts best.
- Support for a claim comes in degrees; "I cannot prove it" is not "I have no reason".
- Scripture, tradition, reason and experience are a map of the sources of theological reasons.
- Traditions weigh the four differently, and each has a weak point it must answer.
- Proof-texting lifts a verse out of its setting to settle a question; it is poor because one verse rarely carries a whole contested question.
- A better way states what the text says, what a tradition reads and what I judge, and says how strong the case is.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Deduction, induction | Deduction: certain if the premises are true. Induction: from cases seen to cases unseen, with a degree of support. |
| Best explanation | Choose the story that accounts for the most facts with the fewest strained extras; it is not a proof. |
| The four sources | Scripture, tradition, reason and experience; traditions weigh them differently. |
| Proof-texting | Using a verse out of its setting as if it settled a question; a poor argument. |
One sentence to remember Most of our reasoning gives degrees of support and not proof, so say how strong a case is and do not claim more than the reasons carry.
This week's action Next time you hear a verse used to settle a question, read the verses around it and ask what kind of writing it is.
요약 보기
- A fallacy is a common pattern of poor reasoning that looks better than it is; nine are described: attacking the person, straw man, false dilemma, circular argument, appeal to authority, slippery slope, genetic fallacy, hasty generalisation and loaded question.
- Some patterns are not always faults (authority, slopes, origins), and the fault lies in using them without the needed steps.
- A fallacy is a fault in the argument; the conclusion may still be true.
- Fallacy names should examine reasoning, beginning with our own, and should not be used as weapons.
- The principle of charity states another's view in its strongest form before replying; it is not agreement.
- A good reader of a hard objection listens, restates, finds the premises, notices the strongest point and says what is not yet known.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Straw man | Answering a weaker or sillier version of someone's view than the one they hold. |
| False dilemma | Offering two choices as if there were no others. |
| Fallacy and truth | A fallacy shows a fault in the argument; the conclusion may still be true. |
| Principle of charity | State the other view in its strongest form, until its holder says "yes, that is what I mean", then reply. |
One sentence to remember Use the names of fallacies to examine reasoning, yours first, and answer another person's view only after you have stated it at its strongest.
This week's action In your next disagreement, restate the other person's view and ask "Is that right?" before you reply.
요약 보기
- A contradiction says something both is and is not so in the same sense and respect, and cannot be true; a paradox only seems to, and the respects can be separated; a mystery is a truth deeper than we can take in.
- The first test for any apparent contradiction is whether the words are used in the same sense and respect.
- The charge that the Trinity and the incarnation are contradictory, and the reply by distinguishing respects, can be set out as a structure without setting out the doctrines.
- Readers disagree whether the replies succeed, and each side has a weak point.
- Mystery must not be used to stop reasoning, and argument cannot dissolve every mystery.
- Teaching and preaching on these questions calls for plain definitions and kindness; a one-page tool helps in reading a text.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Contradiction, paradox, mystery | Contradiction: is and is not in the same respect. Paradox: seems so, but the respects differ. Mystery: truth deeper than we can take in. |
| The first test | Are the words used in the same sense and the same respect? |
| Two rules about mystery | It is no licence to contradict or to refuse a fair question; and argument cannot dissolve every mystery. |
| The shape of the debate | The charge: the same thing is and is not. The reply: said in different respects. Each side has a weak point. |
One sentence to remember Ask whether the words are used in one sense; do the reasoning you can, and be honest where reason stops.
This week's action Use the one-page tool on one paragraph of a theological text this week.
요약 보기
- The lab asks you to draw the bones of a short, general text: its claim, reasons and hidden assumptions.
- You notice a trap in plain words and state a differing view in a form its holder would accept.
- You then name one assumption you tend to make, one question you hold and one step you will take.
- It never asks for a personal crisis of faith, a bereavement, health matters or personal pain, and never for real names.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed passage, the partner's way.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Drawing the claim, reasons and hidden assumptions of a short text, and stating a differing view fairly. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What the lab never asks | A personal crisis of faith, a bereavement, health or other pain; a real name or confidential matter. |
One sentence to remember Read slowly, draw the bones, say what is assumed, and state the other view so well that its holder says "yes".
This week's action Fill in the form on paper for one general paragraph, and keep it where only you will find it.
제 6 장 Week 6: Evil, and the Place of Philosophy
요약 보기
- This chapter treats the problem of evil as an argument; a suffering person needs presence and other words before any argument.
- The problem asks how a good and all-powerful God can allow real evil; it can be set out as premises and a conclusion.
- Moral evil comes from human choices; natural evil does not, though the two blur at the edges.
- The logical form asks whether the claims can both be true; the evidential form asks how likely a good God is, given the evil we see.
- Job and the lament psalms meet evil as appeal and struggle, in prayer, and do not offer a philosophical solution.
- A defence shows that no contradiction is proven; a theodicy tries to say what God's reasons actually are.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The problem of evil | How real evil and suffering can be understood if God is good and all-powerful; set out as premises and a conclusion. |
| Moral and natural evil | Moral evil comes from what people do or allow; natural evil from the way the world works; the two blur at the edges. |
| Logical and evidential forms | Logical: can the claims both be true? Evidential: given the evil we see, how likely is a good, powerful God? |
| Defence and theodicy | A defence shows that a good reason is possible; a theodicy tries to say what God's reasons are. |
One sentence to remember The problem of evil can be studied as an argument, but the Bible meets it first as a cry to God, and a person in pain needs a companion before an argument.
This week's action Write the five steps of the argument on one sheet in your own words, and mark the premise you would question first.
요약 보기
- Each answer to evil questions a premise of the argument; ask what good it aims at, which evil it speaks to, whether it is a defence, and its weak point.
- The free-will defence says that free love makes evil possible; it speaks best to moral evil and finds natural evil harder.
- Soul-making, in the Irenaean tradition, pictures the world as a place where persons grow; it faces the objection that much pain crushes.
- Evil as a lack of good keeps creation good, but says what evil is, not why God allows it.
- Catholic and Orthodox writers have used these ideas with their own emphases, and often stress mystery; readers differ on whether any argument answers the problem.
- None of these answers explains why a particular person suffers, and used on a sufferer they can wound.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Free-will defence | Love must be free, so evil is possible; strong for moral evil, weaker for natural evil. |
| Soul-making | The world is a place for growth of persons (Irenaean tradition); objection: much pain crushes. |
| Evil as a lack of good | Evil is a loss of good, like blindness; it keeps creation good but does not say why evil is allowed. |
| Questions to ask of an answer | What good? Which evil? Defence or theodicy? What weak point? |
One sentence to remember Each answer to evil sees something real and has a weak point; none explains why one person suffers.
This week's action Choose one answer, write it fairly in four sentences, and add its weak point in one sentence.
요약 보기
- Some thinkers say that attempting a theodicy is itself morally troubling, because it can find a use for evil and claim to know God's reasons.
- Others say that careful defences are needed, since claims about God must face evidence, and that a study is not a bedside.
- Christians do not offer the cross as an explanation of evil; they point to God in Christ going into suffering and death to overcome them.
- Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox writers speak differently of God and suffering, but all say that God is not distant from it.
- Saying that God suffers with us does not remove the question why evil is allowed; it changes how the believer stands in it.
- The arguments of this chapter are not words for a person in pain; in danger, turn to a pastor or priest and local emergency help.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Anti-theodicy view | Attempting to explain why God allows evil can wrong victims and claim knowledge we lack; evil is to be resisted and mourned. |
| Reply to it | Claims about God must face the evidence, and a study is not a bedside; weak point: the line blurs. |
| The cross and evil | Not an explanation, but God in Christ entering suffering and death to overcome them. |
| Three voices on the suffering God | Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox differ on how to speak of what happens in God; all say God is not distant. |
One sentence to remember Whether or not we explain evil, the Christian story points to a God who has gone into suffering, and a person in pain needs company more than an argument.
This week's action Write down, for yourself, one thing you would not say to a person in pain, and one thing you could do instead.
요약 보기
- Philosophy gives theology distinctions, definitions, arguments and honest questions; it cannot give revelation, salvation or trust, and it does not settle theology's conclusions.
- Theology asks philosophy to be honest about its own starting assumptions, as philosophers ask the same of theologians.
- Two dangers are distrust, treating philosophy as an enemy, and trust, treating it as a master; each has an honest fear in it.
- Readers differ on how much philosophy may shape theology; each side must be stated in its strongest form.
- Doubt is not a sin and faith does not forbid questions; the Gospels have room for the honest doubter, and the mind is part of loving God.
- The six tools of the course are asking who is in the conversation, knowing and believing, necessary and contingent, how words work, the map of an argument, and holding evil as a question.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What philosophy gives | Distinctions, definitions, arguments and honest questions. |
| What it cannot give | Revelation, salvation and trust; it does not settle theology's conclusions. |
| The two dangers | Distrust (philosophy as enemy) and trust (philosophy as master); each has an honest fear. |
| Doubt and faith | Doubt is not sin and faith does not forbid questions; Mark 9:24 and John 20 leave room for the honest doubter. |
One sentence to remember Theology cannot speak without philosophy, but philosophy does not settle theology's conclusions; Christians borrow its tools, know their limits and ask honestly.
This week's action Write the six tools on one card and keep it in your Bible or notebook.
요약 보기
- The lab asks you to put your philosophy and your theology on one page: the assumptions you use, your questions and one step.
- It never asks about a crisis of faith, a bereavement or other personal pain, and nothing of that should be written.
- Name two assumptions, the tool of the course that helps you see each, and whether you lean toward distrust or trust.
- Separate what Scripture says, what a tradition reads and what you judge, and write the weak point of your own view.
- Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
- There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed talk, the partner's way.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What the lab practises | Putting on one page the assumptions you use, the tools that help you see them, your questions and one step. |
| The four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too. |
| Three ways in | Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way. |
| What the lab never asks | A crisis of faith, a bereavement or other personal pain; a real name or confidential matter. |
One sentence to remember Look honestly at the assumptions you use, name the tool that helps you test each, and take one small step.
This week's action Fill in the form on paper, on a general topic, and keep it where only you will find it.
← Philosophy for Theology: Knowing, Being, Language, Argument and Evil