FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH301E Korean Christianity in Global Perspective

Lecture 3-3: The Nevius Method

Contents 27
CH301E Korean Christianity in Global Perspective
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Why Korea? Reading Korean Christianity as World Christianity
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Korean Anomaly
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Lens of World Christianity
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading the Sources Fairly
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: A Church Without Missionaries - Korean Catholicism, 1784-1886
  1. Lecture 2-1: Books from Beijing
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Ancestral Rites and the Persecutions
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Martyrs and Their Memory
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Bible Before the Missionaries - Protestant Beginnings, 1832-1900
  1. Lecture 3-1: Translation First
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Missionaries Arrive
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Nevius Method
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Revival - Wonsan 1903 and Pyongyang 1907
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Happened
  2. Lecture 4-2: Practices Born of Revival
  3. Lecture 4-3: What Did the Revival Do?
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Faith Under Empire - The Churches and Japanese Rule, 1905-1945
  1. Lecture 5-1: Churches and the Nation
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Shrine Crisis
  3. Lecture 5-3: Remembering Collaboration and Resistance
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Division and War, 1945-1953
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Church of the North
  2. Lecture 6-2: The Korean War
  3. Lecture 6-3: Anticommunism and the Church in North Korea Today
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Growth, Division and Democracy, 1953-2000
  1. Lecture 7-1: Explosive Growth
  2. Lecture 7-2: A Church That Keeps Dividing
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Churches and Democratization
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: From Mission Field to Mission Force - Missions and the Diaspora
  1. Lecture 8-1: Korea as a Sending Church
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Immigrant Church
  3. Lecture 8-3: Korea in Global Christian Networks
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Present Tensions and Possible Futures
  1. Lecture 9-1: Growth Stalls
  2. Lecture 9-2: Women in Korean Christianity
  3. Lecture 9-3: Peace, Reconciliation and the World Church

Jump to the key points ↓

25 min

In June 1890 an older American missionary from China, John Livingston Nevius, spent about two weeks in Seoul talking with the young Presbyterian missionaries there. The conversations lasted only a fortnight, but the policy that came out of them shaped Korean Protestantism for generations. Its core was a set of three principles now usually called the "three-self" principles — self-support, self-propagation and self-government — together with a system of intensive Bible-study classes for ordinary church members.

This lecture explains what Nevius proposed and where the ideas came from, how the Korean missions (the Northern Presbyterians above all) adopted and adapted them, and what they produced. It then weighs the costs and asks whether the Korean church was really as "self-governing" as its founders claimed. It ends with a brief comparison: the same words, "three-self," came to mean something very different in the People's Republic of China after 1950.

What these 25 minutes give you

  • State the three-self principles, their origins before Nevius, and the particular form Nevius gave them.
  • Describe the Korean Bible-study class (*sagyeonghoe*) and explain why it became the backbone of church life.
  • Assess what the method achieved (a self-funding, lay-led, rapidly spreading church) and what it cost (theological narrowness, missionary control, underinvestment in higher education).
  • Distinguish the Korean Nevius tradition from the Chinese Three-Self Patriotic Movement, fairly and briefly.

The things which you have heard from me among many witnesses, commit the same to faithful men, who will be able to teach others also. — 2 Timothy 2:2

World English Bible

When they had preached the Good News to that city, and had made many disciples, they returned to Lystra, Iconium, and Antioch, confirming the souls of the disciples, exhorting them to continue in the faith, and that through many afflictions we must enter into the Kingdom of God. When they had appointed elders for them in every assembly, and had prayed with fasting, they commended them to the Lord, on whom they had believed. — Acts 14:21-23

WEB

Nevius and those who followed him argued from passages like these. Paul, they said, did not stay for decades in each city; he taught, appointed local elders, and moved on, trusting the local church to the Lord. Second Timothy describes a chain of teaching handed from one faithful person to another — exactly the chain the Korean Bible classes were built to create. Whether Paul's practice in the first century can be made into a method for the nineteenth is a real question, and some of the Nevius method's critics asked it. The passages belong here because the missionaries, and many Korean leaders, believed they were doing what Paul had done.

1. Where the three-self idea came from

The phrase "self-supporting, self-governing, self-propagating" did not originate with Nevius. It goes back to two mid-nineteenth-century mission administrators: Henry Venn (1796-1873), secretary of the Church Missionary Society in London, and Rufus Anderson (1796-1880), secretary of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions in Boston. Working separately, both argued that the goal of mission was not a permanent mission station run by foreigners but an independent local church that would support itself, govern itself and spread the gospel itself; the missionary's job was to make himself unnecessary. Venn spoke of the "euthanasia of the mission."

These were Protestant ideas framed for Protestant missions, but the underlying concern was not only Protestant. Catholic mission thinkers of the same era argued about how quickly to form local clergy, and papal documents in the twentieth century (notably Benedict XV's Maximum Illud, 1919) urged the formation of native clergy and warned missionaries against serving national interests. The question "when will this be a church of its own people?" was being asked across the traditions.

2. John Nevius and his "plan"

John Livingston Nevius (1829-1893) was an American Presbyterian who had worked in China since 1854, mostly in Shandong province. Over the years he became critical of the usual method in China, in which missionaries hired Chinese preachers and paid them with foreign money. In Nevius's view this produced dependent churches, attracted people for the wrong reasons (a salary or mission favour), and made Christianity look foreign. He set out his alternative in a series of articles in the Chinese Recorder (1885-86), published as a book, Methods of Mission Work (1886); a later expanded version appeared as The Planting and Development of Missionary Churches.

His plan, in simplified form, had these elements:

  1. Each convert stays where he or she is — in the same village, work and family — and witnesses there, rather than being taken into mission employment.
  2. Church life is organized around what local believers can manage and pay for. Worship takes place in homes or in buildings the believers build themselves in local style; leaders are unpaid local believers at first.
  3. Paid workers are few, and where possible paid by the local church rather than the mission.
  4. Systematic Bible study for all believers, with the missionary's main work being to train local leaders through regular classes.
  5. Strict discipline and careful examination before baptism.
  6. Missionary itineration: missionaries travel a circuit of local churches, supervising and teaching rather than settling as pastors.

Nevius's plan had a mixed record in China itself; he was not particularly successful there by his own measures. In Korea it found better ground.

3. Seoul, June 1890

In 1890 the Northern Presbyterian missionaries in Korea were a handful of men and women in their twenties and thirties — Underwood, Samuel Austin Moffett (who arrived in January 1890), and others. They had read Nevius's articles and invited him to visit on his way through. He spent about two weeks with them in June 1890. In 1891 the Northern Presbyterian mission adopted rules for its work that were based on his plan, and the other Presbyterian missions in Korea broadly followed. The Methodist missions did not adopt "the Nevius method" by name, but their practice in the countryside came to resemble it in many ways, especially in the use of Bible classes and lay leaders.

The Korean version is usually summarized in the classic study by the missionary Charles Allen Clark, The Korean Church and the Nevius Methods (1930). Clark stressed features that were, if anything, stronger in Korea than in Nevius's own China work: the centrality of Bible study, the expectation that every believer would evangelize, and the insistence that Korean congregations build their own churches.

4. The Bible-study class: sagyeonghoe

The most distinctive Korean development was the sagyeonghoe ("Bible study gathering"), usually called in English the Bible class or Bible conference. It deserves attention, because many Korean churches abroad still hold something that descends from it, often under the same name.

A sagyeonghoe was a period of concentrated study, usually several days to two weeks, held above all in the winter months after the harvest when farmers had time. Participants came from surrounding villages, often walking long distances and bringing their own rice. The day typically began with early-morning prayer, followed by hours of study of a book of the Bible, taught by missionaries and trained Korean leaders; the afternoons might be given to practical evangelism in the town, and the evenings to preaching. There were classes at the local level, the district level and, for leaders, at the mission centres. Separate classes for women were organized and increasingly taught by Korean women.

Missionary reports speak of such classes with attendance in the hundreds and, at the largest centres, over a thousand. The exact figures should be treated with some caution — missionaries were reporting to boards that funded them — but there is no doubt that the classes were large, regular and central. Chapter 4 of this course will show that the great revival of 1907 broke out in exactly such a class, the winter Bible class for men at Pyongyang.

The sagyeonghoe connected directly to the Hangeul Bible described in lecture 3-1. People who had learned to read in a few weeks could now spend days at a time reading and discussing Scripture. The classes also trained the lay "helpers" (josa) and leaders who ran the local congregations while missionaries itinerated.

5. What the method produced

By the early twentieth century the Korean Protestant churches, especially the Presbyterian churches of the northwest, had several features that impressed visiting missionaries from other countries:

  • They largely paid their own way. Local congregations built their own church buildings and supported many of their own workers. Missionary reports claimed that a large majority of church buildings had been built without mission money; the claim was repeated often enough to become a mission slogan, and a historian would want to check how "church building" and "mission money" were defined. Still, the general pattern is not seriously disputed.
  • They spread through lay people. Believers were expected to witness to neighbours, and the practice of pledging "days of preaching" (volunteer days given to evangelism) became common (see lecture 4-2).
  • They were biblically literate. Ordinary members knew the Bible well by the standards of most churches anywhere.
  • They grew fast. Protestant numbers rose steeply in the years after 1895, particularly in the northwest. The Nevius method was only one reason (lecture 3-2's schools and hospitals, the collapse of the old order and the search for national renewal described in Chapter 4 of this course were others), but most historians count it among them.

The comparison with Catholic growth in the same years is instructive, and should not be drawn unfairly. Korean Catholicism had its own tradition of lay leadership, forged when there were no priests (Chapter 2 of this course). After 1886 the Catholic church in Korea was organized under French missionary bishops, and it grew more steadily and less spectacularly, with a strong base in villages where Catholic families had survived the persecutions. It was not less "Korean"; it had a different structure of authority, in which the sacraments and an ordained priesthood were essential in a way they were not for the Protestant Bible class.

6. The costs

The Nevius method also had costs, and Korean historians have debated them for decades. Four are commonly raised.

1. A theology that stayed missionary-shaped. The missionaries who taught the Bible classes were, for the most part, theologically conservative. Many of the Northern Presbyterians, including Samuel Moffett, had studied at seminaries that defended a strict view of biblical and were wary of the new critical scholarship. What the classes taught was their reading of the Bible. Because Bible study was the backbone of church life, and because the missions controlled theological education, that reading shaped Korean Protestantism deeply. Critics argue that the method produced a church that knew the text well but was trained to distrust other ways of reading it — a pattern that fed the later conflicts over biblical criticism described in lecture 7-2 of this course. Defenders reply that the missionaries taught what they believed to be true, that many Korean Christians embraced that theology freely and still hold it, and that the conservatism was as much Korean as missionary.

Pace of Korean leadership

2. How "self-governing" was it? The rhetoric was independence; the reality was slower. The first Korean Presbyterian ministers — seven graduates of the Pyongyang theological seminary, among them Gil Seon-ju — were ordained only in 1907, twenty-two years after the missionaries arrived, when an independent Presbytery of Korea was formed. The General Assembly followed in 1912. Even after that, missionaries held great influence in the seminaries, the schools, the hospitals and the property, and in many church bodies. Some historians argue that "self-support" in practice meant Koreans paid for the churches while missionaries kept control of the institutions that mattered most. Others reply that the pace of ordination was normal for the period, that it was faster than in many mission fields, and that Korean leaders did in fact lead the congregations from very early on.

3. Underinvestment in higher education. The Nevius approach concentrated resources on evangelism and elementary Bible training. Some missionaries worried that advanced education would produce a Korean elite that would drift from the church or demand salaries the churches could not pay. A dispute among the missions in the 1910s over whether to support a Christian college in Seoul (as opposed to Pyongyang) reflected these different priorities. Critics argue that this held back an educated Korean Christian leadership; defenders point out that mission schools and colleges were, for their time, a very large educational investment.

4. Keeping out of politics. Nevius's emphasis on the spiritual independence of the church fitted well with the missionaries' wish to keep the church out of Korean politics — a wish that became urgent as Japan took control of Korea after 1905. Whether that was wise, and what it did to the church, is one of the disputed questions of Chapter 4 of this course, and this lecture does not settle it.

7. A caution: was it the method at all?

It is easy to give the Nevius method too much credit. Some historians, including Sung-Deuk Oak, have argued that Korean believers were practising self-support and self-propagation before the method was adopted — Sorae built its own church (lecture 3-1), colporteurs spread the Gospels without direction — and that the missionaries, to some extent, formalized what they found. Others note that the same method had modest results in Shandong, which suggests that the conditions in Korea mattered more than the method. A fair judgement is probably that the method fitted Korean conditions unusually well: a people with a newly accessible Bible in their own script, a social order in collapse, a tradition of voluntary scholarly associations, and a court too weak to suppress the churches. Method and ground worked together. The elegance of the story "a missionary visited for two weeks and a great church grew" is itself a warning sign.

8. The same words in China: the Three-Self Patriotic Movement

In 1950, after the Communist victory in China, a group of Chinese Protestant leaders led by Wu Yaozong (Y. T. Wu) issued a document usually called the "Christian Manifesto," which pledged Chinese Protestants to support the new government and to break their ties with foreign missions. From this came the Three-Self Patriotic Movement, formally organized in 1954, which remains the officially registered Protestant body in the People's Republic of China.

The words were the same as Venn's and Nevius's: self-government, self-support, self-propagation. The meaning had changed. In the missionary tradition, "three-self" was a goal the mission set for the church it had planted, meaning independence from the mission. In the Chinese movement, it meant independence from all foreign ties, under the supervision of a state that was ideologically committed to atheism and that controlled religious bodies through its Religious Affairs Bureau. Chinese Christians have disagreed sharply among themselves about the movement. Some regard it as a necessary way for the church to survive and serve in a socialist society, and many sincere believers worship in its churches. Others, especially in the unregistered "house churches," regard it as a compromise of the church's freedom and refuse to join it. The Catholic church in China went through a parallel division, between the state-sponsored Catholic Patriotic Association and communities loyal to Rome, with a provisional agreement between the Holy See and China on the appointment of bishops signed in 2018.

The comparison should not be forced. Korea in 1890 and China in 1950 were utterly different situations. The comparison is useful for one lesson only: the same principle — "the church should be its own" — can mean freedom from a foreign mission or subjection to one's own state, depending on who is saying it and why.


The three-self principles in Korea: gains and costs Adopted by the Northern Presbyterian mission in 1891, after Nevius's visit in 1890 Self-support Congregations build their own churches, pay their own helpers Self-propagation Every believer witnesses; Bible classes train lay leaders (sagyeonghoe) Self-government Local leaders run congregations; first Korean ministers ordained 1907 Costs historians debate 1. Theology stayed close to the conservative missionaries who taught the classes 2. Missionaries kept seminaries, schools, hospitals and property for decades 3. Less investment in higher education for Korean leaders 4. "Spiritual" independence fitted a policy of staying out of politics (Chapter 4 of this course) Same words, different meanings Venn, Anderson, Nevius (19th c.) Who sets the goal: the foreign mission Independent from: the mission Supervised by: the church's own bodies Aim: the mission makes itself unnecessary Three-Self Patriotic Movement (1950s) Who sets the goal: Chinese leaders with the new state's backing Independent from: all foreign ties Supervised by: state religious affairs bodies; contested by house churches

5. Going to the Sources

Source: John L. Nevius, Methods of Mission Work (Shanghai: Presbyterian Mission Press, 1886), first published as articles in the Chinese Recorder in 1885. It is in the public domain, and later editions (retitled The Planting and Development of Missionary Churches) are available in digitized form. What follows is a paraphrase of the argument of the opening chapters, not a quotation.

Nevius contrasts two systems. In the first — the "old system," as he calls it — the mission employs a large number of paid native preachers and assistants, supported by foreign money, and the growth of the church depends on how many such workers the mission can afford. In the second, which he recommends, new believers remain in their ordinary occupations and homes and are expected to spread the faith there; the church grows by voluntary, unpaid work; paid agents are few and are introduced only as the local church can support them. He argues that the first system tempts people to profess Christianity for the sake of employment, stirs the suspicion of non-Christians who see converts as hirelings of foreigners, and leaves churches unable to stand without the mission. The second, he admits, is slower at first, but he believes it produces churches that are sturdier and more truly native.

  1. Nevius is writing from experience in China. What in the Korean situation of the 1890s — described in lectures 3-1 and 3-2 — made his second system easier to apply there than in Shandong?
  2. Nevius argues that paid native workers attract insincere converts. Is that fair to the Korean colporteurs and Bible women, many of whom were paid? What would they have said?
  3. Nevius's plan gives the local church independence in money and in evangelism. Does it say who will control the theological teaching? Why might that silence matter?

In short

  • The three-self ideas (self-support, self-propagation, self-government) came from Henry Venn and Rufus Anderson. John Nevius added a plan: converts stay in place, few paid workers, systematic Bible study and missionary itineration.
  • Northern Presbyterians adopted his approach after his 1890 visit to Seoul. Its centre was the sagyeonghoe, a winter Bible class of days or weeks, and it trained lay leaders.
  • The churches largely built their own buildings, spread through lay witness, knew the Bible well and grew fast. The lecture counts the method as one cause among several.
  • Costs were debated: a missionary-shaped conservative theology, slow ordination (first ministers in 1907), little higher education, and distance from politics. Defenders answer each point.
  • Some historians say Korean believers practised self-support before the method. In China the same words came to mean loyalty to the state in the Three-Self Patriotic Movement.

Topic: This lecture explains the Nevius method, the Bible-study classes it produced, and its results, costs and limits.

Remember: The goal was a church that supports, governs and spreads itself, built on lay Bible study. The method fitted Korean conditions, so method and ground worked together.

Caution: Do not credit the method alone. Self-government was slower than the rhetoric, and the same "three-self" words meant something different in China after 1950.

One line to carry into ministry: Train others so well that your own role becomes unnecessary, and be honest about who still holds control.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Does your church hold anything like a sagyeonghoe — a revival week, a Bible conference, a retreat? What does it keep from the old winter Bible classes, and what has changed?
  • "The missionary's job is to make himself unnecessary." Is that a good principle for any leader — a pastor, a parent, a teacher? What makes it hard to practise?
  • The Korean church paid for its own buildings but the missionaries kept the seminaries. If you had been a Korean church leader in 1910, what would you have wanted to control first, and why?
  • Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant traditions answer differently the question of what makes a local church "its own" — its bishop, its communion with other churches, its self-support. How does your own tradition answer?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.