FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH301E Korean Christianity in Global Perspective

Lecture 7-2: A Church That Keeps Dividing

Contents 27
CH301E Korean Christianity in Global Perspective
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Why Korea? Reading Korean Christianity as World Christianity
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Korean Anomaly
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Lens of World Christianity
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading the Sources Fairly
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: A Church Without Missionaries - Korean Catholicism, 1784-1886
  1. Lecture 2-1: Books from Beijing
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Ancestral Rites and the Persecutions
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Martyrs and Their Memory
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Bible Before the Missionaries - Protestant Beginnings, 1832-1900
  1. Lecture 3-1: Translation First
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Missionaries Arrive
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Nevius Method
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Revival - Wonsan 1903 and Pyongyang 1907
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Happened
  2. Lecture 4-2: Practices Born of Revival
  3. Lecture 4-3: What Did the Revival Do?
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Faith Under Empire - The Churches and Japanese Rule, 1905-1945
  1. Lecture 5-1: Churches and the Nation
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Shrine Crisis
  3. Lecture 5-3: Remembering Collaboration and Resistance
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Division and War, 1945-1953
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Church of the North
  2. Lecture 6-2: The Korean War
  3. Lecture 6-3: Anticommunism and the Church in North Korea Today
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Growth, Division and Democracy, 1953-2000
  1. Lecture 7-1: Explosive Growth
  2. Lecture 7-2: A Church That Keeps Dividing
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Churches and Democratization
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: From Mission Field to Mission Force - Missions and the Diaspora
  1. Lecture 8-1: Korea as a Sending Church
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Immigrant Church
  3. Lecture 8-3: Korea in Global Christian Networks
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Present Tensions and Possible Futures
  1. Lecture 9-1: Growth Stalls
  2. Lecture 9-2: Women in Korean Christianity
  3. Lecture 9-3: Peace, Reconciliation and the World Church

Jump to the key points ↓

22 min

Visitors to South Korea often notice that there seem to be Presbyterian churches everywhere — and that they belong to a bewildering number of different denominations, many of which carry nearly the same name. This is not an accident of language. In the decade after 1945 the single Presbyterian Church of Korea split three times, in 1952, 1953 and 1959, and the resulting bodies kept dividing for the rest of the century. Methodists, Holiness churches and Baptists also divided, though less often. The Catholic Church, bound into one hierarchy under Rome, did not divide at all.

This lecture tells the story of the three great Presbyterian splits. It tries to do something that is easy to say and hard to do: to explain the theological stakes of each split in the terms its participants used, before counting what the splits cost. The people who walked out of general assemblies in these years did not think they were being petty. They thought the truth of the gospel, the purity of the church or the authority of the Bible was at stake. Some historians agree with one side or another; others see mainly personal rivalry, regional loyalty and money. Both kinds of cause were usually present at once.

What these 22 minutes give you

  • Name the three major Presbyterian splits of 1952, 1953 and 1959 and the denominations that came from them (Kosin, Gijang, Tonghap and Hapdong).
  • Explain the theological issue at the centre of each split as each side understood it.
  • Identify non-theological factors — regional loyalty, personal leadership, money, and foreign influence — and explain why historians disagree about how much weight they carry.
  • Describe the ecumenical and evangelical councils that emerged and the forms of cooperation that survived division.

Now I beg you, brothers, through the name of our Lord, Jesus Christ, that you all speak the same thing and that there be no divisions among you, but that you be perfected together in the same mind and in the same judgment. For it has been reported to me concerning you, my brothers, by those who are from Chloe’s household, that there are contentions among you. Now I mean this, that each one of you says, “I follow Paul,” “I follow Apollos,” “I follow Cephas,” and, “I follow Christ.” Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you? Or were you baptized into the name of Paul? — 1 Corinthians 1:10-13

World English Bible

that they may all be one; even as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be one in us; that the world may believe that you sent me. — John 17:21

WEB

Every side in the Korean splits knew these passages, and every side quoted them. Paul's complaint about factions named after leaders ("I follow Paul", "I follow Apollos") has an uncomfortable resemblance to Korean denominations that were long known by the names of their leaders, seminaries or meeting places. Jesus' prayer in John 17 was the founding text of the modern — and the ecumenical movement was itself one of the causes of the 1959 split. The same texts also contain a question the dividing parties asked sincerely: unity in what? Paul asks the Corinthians to be of "the same mind"; those who left their assemblies believed they were leaving in order to keep the same mind as the apostles.

1. The starting point: one church, many pressures

In 1945 there was one Presbyterian Church in Korea, formed in 1907-1912 from the work of four missions (American Northern and Southern Presbyterians, Australian Presbyterians and Canadian Presbyterians). Its heartland was in the north, around Pyongyang. After liberation and division, northern pastors and congregations streamed south (Chapter 6 of this course), bringing strong opinions and strong leaders into southern presbyteries that had their own. The church carried three unresolved questions into the new era:

  1. What should be done about the leaders who had approved attending Shinto shrines in 1938 (Chapter 5 of this course)?
  2. How should the church understand the Bible's authority, now that some Korean theologians had studied modern biblical criticism abroad?
  3. Should the church belong to the new World Council of Churches (WCC), founded in Amsterdam in 1948?

Each question produced a split.

2. 1952: Kosin — the purity of a repentant church

The first split is treated at length in lecture 5-3 of this course; a short summary is enough here. Pastors who had refused the shrine rites and been imprisoned, notably Han Sang-dong and Ju Nam-seon, were released in 1945 and called for the church's leaders to repent publicly and step aside for a time before resuming their ministry. In 1946 they founded Goryeo Theological Seminary in Busan. The majority of the church's leadership, many of whom had complied under pressure, resisted what they saw as an impossible demand on pastors who had tried to keep their congregations alive. After several years of conflict the General Assembly refused to recognize the seminary's graduates and its supporting presbytery, and in 1952 the group formed its own body, known as the Goryeo or Kosin Presbyterian Church.

Two views of repentance

The stakes as Kosin saw them: a church that had bowed to another god could not be restored without repentance. Discipline was not vengeance; it was the mark of a true church.

The stakes as the majority saw them: nearly every pastor had complied; to demand that they all withdraw would have left the church without leaders just as it faced communism in the north and chaos in the south. Forgiveness and rebuilding mattered more than a purge.

3. 1953: Gijang — the authority of the Bible

The second split was about how to read Scripture.

Kim Jae-jun (Kim Chae-jun, 1901-1987) had studied at Princeton Theological Seminary and Western Theological Seminary in the United States in the late 1920s and early 1930s. He taught at the Chosun Theological Seminary, founded in Seoul in 1940 (the forerunner of today's Hanshin University). He accepted a moderate form of historical criticism — the view that the Bible, while the word of God, was written by human authors in history, and that questions of authorship, dating and scientific detail could be studied freely without threatening faith. He held that the doctrine of verbal (that the Bible is without error in every statement, including matters of history and science) was not required by the Reformed confessions.

The majority tradition in Korean , shaped by the missionaries and by the theology of Old Princeton, held that it was. Its most influential theologian, Park Hyung-ryong (Pak Hyŏng-nyong, 1897-1978), also Princeton-trained, taught that the verbal and inerrancy of Scripture were the foundation of the whole Christian faith.

The conflict became public in 1947, when a group of Chosun seminary students — the number usually given is fifty-one — petitioned the General Assembly against Kim's teaching. Over the next years the Assembly investigated, created a rival seminary, and in 1952 voted to remove Kim from the ministry. Kim and his supporters did not accept the decision. In 1953 they formed a separate General Assembly, which became the Presbyterian Church in the Republic of Korea (PROK), known in Korean as Gijang (short for its Korean name).

Two views of Scripture

The stakes as Gijang saw them: the freedom of theological scholarship, and a Reformed faith that trusts the Spirit to speak through a fully human text rather than resting on a theory of inerrancy. Kim also argued that the church must engage society and culture, not only save souls — a conviction that would carry the PROK into the democratization struggle (Lecture 7-3).

The stakes as the majority saw them: if the Bible could err in its history, its account of salvation could not be trusted either. Protecting the students and churches from "new theology" was a pastor's duty, not an attack on scholarship.

The Gijang church remained small, but its seminary produced a large share of the theologians of the 1970s and 1980s, including leading minjung theologians.

4. 1959: Tonghap and Hapdong — the World Council of Churches

The third and largest split cut the remaining majority almost in half.

The Presbyterian Church of Korea had joined the WCC as a founding member in 1948. In the 1950s the WCC was attacked worldwide by conservative Protestants, above all by the American fundamentalist Carl McIntire and his International Council of Christian Churches (ICCC), who accused it of , of aiming at a single world church that would swallow Protestantism, and of softness towards communism. For Korean Christians who had fled communism, the last charge carried great weight. The more moderate National Association of Evangelicals (NAE), which also had a Korean branch, shared some of the theological concerns but not McIntire's methods.

Other tensions ran alongside. There were rivalries between groups of pastors from different regions — notably between some northern refugee leaders and some southern ones — and a public dispute in the late 1950s over the handling of a large sum of money raised for the General Assembly's seminary, in which Park Hyung-ryong, the seminary's head, was involved and after which he resigned.

At the 44th General Assembly, meeting in Daejeon in September 1959, a dispute over which delegates from the Gyeonggi presbytery should be seated — a dispute that everyone understood to be about the balance of votes on the WCC — broke the meeting apart. The two parties then held separate assemblies in Seoul. The group that favoured ecumenical cooperation became known as Tonghap ("united"); the group opposing the WCC as Hapdong ("joint"). The two names became the names of the two largest Presbyterian denominations in Korea. Attempts at reconciliation in the following year, including concessions on WCC participation, failed. In 1960 Hapdong united with Kosin, but the union broke apart again within a few years.

Hapdong and Tonghap views

The stakes as Hapdong saw them: faithfulness to the historic Reformed faith and to Scripture, and the refusal to join a movement that, they believed, compromised both and was naïve about communism.

The stakes as Tonghap saw them: the unity Jesus prayed for in John 17, the Korean church's place in the world church, and the conviction that one could be ecumenical without being liberal. Tonghap remained theologically conservative by most international standards.

5. After 1959: multiplication

After the three great splits the process did not stop. Disputes over seminaries, property, leadership succession and doctrine produced more and more Presbyterian bodies. By the 1990s the number of denominations using the Presbyterian name in Korea was commonly counted at well over a hundred — counts differ, depending on how small and how independent a group must be to count. Methodists divided in the 1950s and later reunited; the Holiness Church (a body descended from the Oriental Missionary Society) divided in 1961 along a line very similar to the 1959 Presbyterian one.

Councils. The splits reshaped cooperation as well. The National Council of Churches in Korea (NCCK), whose roots go back to a Protestant council of 1924, gathered the ecumenical churches — among them Tonghap, the PROK, the Korean Methodist Church and the Anglican Church. Many conservative bodies stayed outside it. In 1989 the Christian Council of Korea was formed as a broad council of conservative churches, and it soon rivalled the NCCK in the number of churches it represented.

Cooperation across the lines. Division did not end cooperation. The great evangelistic rallies of Lecture 7-1 were organized by committees that crossed denominational lines. In 1977 Catholic and Protestant scholars together published a Common Translation of the Bible (Gongdong beonyeok) — a notable ecumenical achievement, even though most Protestant churches continued to use their older translation in worship.

6. Counting the costs — and a counter-argument

The costs of division are easy to list: lawsuits over church buildings; rival seminaries producing more pastors than churches could support; congregations and families split; energy spent on internal politics; and a public impression, frequently noted by Korean commentators, that Protestants could not agree among themselves. The contrast with the visibly united Catholic Church in the 1980s (Lecture 7-1) was noticed.

Some historians and church leaders have made a counter-argument: in a period of rapid urbanization, division worked like . Each new denomination founded new congregations, trained new pastors and competed for new members, and growth was fastest in the decades of most division. This argument deserves to be heard, but it should be held loosely. Correlation is not cause: both division and growth may have come from the same energetic, entrepreneurial style of Korean Protestantism, and Catholic growth shows that growth did not require division.

Finally, it is important not to reduce these events to a morality tale. The people on every side of these splits were mostly pastors and elders who had survived colonial persecution, war and flight. They believed that truth mattered enough to divide over. A reader may judge that they were wrong about what was worth dividing over — but should first understand why they believed it.


One Presbyterian church becomes four, 1952-1959 Each branch with the question its founders believed was at stake Presbyterian Church of Korea one body in 1945 1952 Kosin Must a church that bowed at shrines repent first? 1953 Gijang (PROK) How is the Bible's authority understood? 1959: the WCC Hapdong against WCC membership Tonghap for WCC membership

The diagram shows only the theological question named in each split. The lecture explains the other factors — region, leadership, money and foreign influence — that were also present and that no simple diagram can show.


5. Going to the Sources

Source: the petition of Chosun Theological Seminary students to the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church of Korea, 1947, against the teaching of Kim Jae-jun; and Kim Jae-jun's written replies in the following years. The petition and the Assembly's responses are recorded in the minutes of the General Assembly (in Korean) and are summarized in the major Korean church histories and in Kirsteen Kim and Sebastian Kim, A History of Korean Christianity (2015). What follows is a paraphrase of both sides as historians have summarized them, not a quotation.

The students' complaint (paraphrased): the students stated that they had been taught at the seminary that parts of the Bible contained errors, that the traditional authorship of some books could not be held, and that the historical accounts of Scripture were to be read critically. They asked the Assembly to protect the church from this "new theology" and to ensure that its seminary taught the faith received from the missionaries: that the whole Bible is the inspired and infallible word of God.

Kim Jae-jun's position (paraphrased): Kim replied that he held the Bible to be the word of God and the only rule of faith and life, as the church's confession said; that the confession did not require a theory of verbal inerrancy in matters of history and science; and that honest study of how the Bible came to be written served faith rather than destroying it. He argued that forbidding such study would leave Korean Christians unable to answer educated critics.

  1. Both sides claimed to hold that the Bible is the word of God. Where exactly did they disagree?
  2. Students petitioned against their teacher to the highest court of the church. What does this tell you about authority in the Korean church in 1947 — about who was expected to guard doctrine?
  3. You have read a paraphrase made by later historians, not the original documents. What might be lost in that process? What would you look for in the originals?

In short

  • The one Presbyterian church of 1945 carried three unresolved questions: what to do about leaders who approved shrine attendance, how to understand the Bible's authority, and whether to belong to the World Council of Churches.
  • In 1952 the Kosin church formed. Kosin held that a church that bowed to another god needed repentance first. The majority feared leaving the church without leaders.
  • In 1953 the Gijang church (PROK) formed around Kim Jae-jun, who accepted moderate historical criticism. The majority, with Park Hyung-ryong, held that verbal inerrancy (no error in any statement) is the foundation of faith.
  • In 1959 the Assembly split into Tonghap (for WCC cooperation) and Hapdong (against). Regional rivalry and a money dispute were also present.
  • Division continued, but cooperation survived in rallies, councils and the 1977 Common Translation. Costs include lawsuits and split families. The "division as church planting" argument should be held loosely.
  • Participants believed the truth was at stake. A reader may judge them wrong but should first understand them.

Topic: This lecture explains the three great Presbyterian splits of 1952, 1953 and 1959, each in the terms its participants used.

Remember: Each split began with a sincere theological question. Non-theological causes such as region, leadership and money were usually present at the same time.

Caution: The lecture does not treat the splits as a morality tale, and it does not prove that division caused growth. Correlation is not cause.

One line to carry into ministry: Before dividing over a disagreement, state the other side's concern in words it would accept, and count the cost to families and neighbours.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Choose one of the three splits. Write the strongest one-paragraph case for the side you are less inclined to agree with.
  • Is there anything a church should divide over? If so, what? If not, how should a church deal with serious disagreement about doctrine or discipline?
  • Catholics in Korea did not divide in this period; Protestants did, repeatedly. What does each tradition's structure make easier and harder?
  • If you know the denomination of a Korean church you have attended, can you trace it back to one of the branches in the diagram above? Did you know the story before?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.