FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH301E Korean Christianity in Global Perspective

Lecture 9-3: Peace, Reconciliation and the World Church

Contents 27
CH301E Korean Christianity in Global Perspective
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Why Korea? Reading Korean Christianity as World Christianity
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Korean Anomaly
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Lens of World Christianity
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading the Sources Fairly
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: A Church Without Missionaries - Korean Catholicism, 1784-1886
  1. Lecture 2-1: Books from Beijing
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Ancestral Rites and the Persecutions
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Martyrs and Their Memory
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Bible Before the Missionaries - Protestant Beginnings, 1832-1900
  1. Lecture 3-1: Translation First
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Missionaries Arrive
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Nevius Method
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Revival - Wonsan 1903 and Pyongyang 1907
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Happened
  2. Lecture 4-2: Practices Born of Revival
  3. Lecture 4-3: What Did the Revival Do?
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Faith Under Empire - The Churches and Japanese Rule, 1905-1945
  1. Lecture 5-1: Churches and the Nation
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Shrine Crisis
  3. Lecture 5-3: Remembering Collaboration and Resistance
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Division and War, 1945-1953
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Church of the North
  2. Lecture 6-2: The Korean War
  3. Lecture 6-3: Anticommunism and the Church in North Korea Today
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Growth, Division and Democracy, 1953-2000
  1. Lecture 7-1: Explosive Growth
  2. Lecture 7-2: A Church That Keeps Dividing
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Churches and Democratization
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: From Mission Field to Mission Force - Missions and the Diaspora
  1. Lecture 8-1: Korea as a Sending Church
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Immigrant Church
  3. Lecture 8-3: Korea in Global Christian Networks
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Present Tensions and Possible Futures
  1. Lecture 9-1: Growth Stalls
  2. Lecture 9-2: Women in Korean Christianity
  3. Lecture 9-3: Peace, Reconciliation and the World Church

Jump to the key points ↓

23 min

Chapter 6 of this course ended with a divided peninsula and a southern church that had learned, through war and flight, to see itself as the enemy of communism. For decades that stance was hardly questioned in South Korean Protestantism. In the 1980s some churches began to speak differently: of repentance for hatred, of peace, of reunification as a Christian task. What they said, and the strong reaction it provoked from other Christians, is the first subject of this lecture.

The second subject is what churches have actually done — the humanitarian work in the North since the famine of the 1990s, and Catholic efforts at reconciliation. The third is the widest: what Korean Christianity offers the world church, and what it asks of it.

The lecture ends the course. It does so with open questions, because the story it tells has not ended.

What these 23 minutes give you

  • Describe the 1988 NCCK Declaration on National Reunification and Peace, its background in ecumenical meetings of the 1980s, and the main criticisms evangelical Christians made of it.
  • Describe the main forms of Protestant and Catholic humanitarian and reconciliation work related to North Korea, and the difficulties it faces.
  • Explain how the divide over the North continues older divisions in Korean Protestantism described in earlier chapters of this course.
  • Identify some things Korean Christianity offers the world church and some questions it poses to it, and state them as open questions rather than conclusions.

For he is our peace, who made both one, and broke down the middle wall of partition, — Ephesians 2:14

World English Bible

and might reconcile them both in one body to God through the cross, having killed the hostility thereby. — Ephesians 2:16

WEB

But all things are of God, who reconciled us to himself through Jesus Christ, and gave to us the ministry of reconciliation; — 2 Corinthians 5:18

WEB

namely, that God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself, not reckoning to them their trespasses, and having committed to us the word of reconciliation. — 2 Corinthians 5:19

WEB

Ephesians speaks of Christ breaking down "the middle wall of partition" between Jew and Gentile. Korean Christians who worked for reconciliation often applied the image to the line dividing the peninsula; the fit was obvious in a country with a fortified border. Other Korean Christians objected that Paul's "wall" was about the reconciliation of peoples in Christ, not about political treaties between states, and that using the text for a political programme confused the two. That disagreement is itself part of the history in this lecture. Second Corinthians adds the phrase both sides could agree on — the church has been given "the ministry of reconciliation" — while disagreeing about what that ministry requires.

1. Before 1988: anticommunism as common sense

Chapter 6 of this course described how the Korean War fused Protestant identity in the South with anticommunism. Many southern church leaders were themselves refugees from the North; many had lost family members, churches and property to the northern regime. For them anticommunism was not an abstract position but the memory of persecution. Chung-shin Park, in Protestantism and Politics in Korea (2003), shows how this experience placed most of the Protestant mainstream firmly on the side of successive southern governments for decades.

Under the military governments, public advocacy of contact with the North was legally dangerous, since South Korea's National Security Law made unauthorised contact with the North a crime. Discussion of reunification was largely controlled by the state.

2. The ecumenical meetings of the 1980s

The change began outside Korea. In 1984 the World Council of Churches (WCC) held a consultation at Tozanso, near Tokyo in Japan, on peace and justice in Northeast Asia, at which Korean reunification was a main topic. In 1986, at Glion in Switzerland, Christians from the South met delegates of the Korean Christian Federation from the North, under WCC sponsorship. It was the first such meeting since the war. Further meetings followed.

These meetings were controversial from the beginning. Supporters saw them as the first step toward reconciliation among divided Christians. Critics pointed out that the Korean Christian Federation operated with the permission of the northern state, and asked whether its delegates could speak freely. Chapter 6 of this course discussed how little is known with certainty about Christian life in the North; that uncertainty ran through every one of these encounters.

3. The 1988 Declaration

On 29 February 1988 the General Assembly of the National Council of Churches in Korea (NCCK) — the of several Protestant denominations, including Methodist, Tonghap Presbyterian, PROK and Anglican churches — adopted the Declaration of the Churches of Korea on National Reunification and Peace.

The declaration's content can be summarised as follows. (This is a summary, not a quotation.)

  • A confession. It confessed that the churches had sinned by hating their fellow Koreans in the North, by treating anticommunism almost as a creed, and by failing to work for reconciliation.
  • Principles. It adopted principles for reunification that had first been agreed between the two Korean governments in a joint communiqué of 1972 — independence (reunification to be achieved by Koreans themselves), peaceful means, and the great unity of the Korean people — and added principles of its own: humanitarian concern, and the participation of ordinary people rather than only governments.
  • Proposals. It called for a peace treaty to replace the 1953 armistice, for mutual reduction of armed forces, and for the eventual withdrawal of foreign (United States) troops and nuclear weapons once peace was secured. It also proposed that the churches treat 1995, the fiftieth anniversary of liberation from Japan, as a year of Jubilee for reunification.

The declaration was a turning point in how part of the Korean Protestant world spoke about the North. It drew on the social theology of the 1970s and 1980s (Chapter 7 of this course) and on the 's language of peace and justice.

4. The criticism

The declaration was sharply criticised by many Korean Protestants, especially evangelical and conservative leaders. Their objections deserve to be stated in their strongest form.

  1. Confession on others' behalf. Critics asked what right the NCCK had to confess the sin of anticommunism on behalf of churches whose members had been imprisoned, tortured or killed by the northern regime. To such Christians, resisting that regime was not hatred but faithfulness.
  2. Moral equivalence. Critics argued that the declaration treated the two Korean states as though they were equally responsible for division and hostility, when one of them persecuted churches and the other did not.
  3. Political proposals. The call for the withdrawal of United States troops was, critics said, a political and military judgement that no church body was qualified to make, and one that coincided with the North's own demands.
  4. Who speaks for the church. The NCCK represented only part of Korean Protestantism. Many of the largest conservative denominations were not members. Critics objected that the declaration was received abroad as "the Korean churches' position" when many Korean churches rejected it.

In 1989 the Christian Council of Korea (CCK) was founded as a council of mainly evangelical and conservative churches. Historians often connect its founding partly with dissatisfaction with the NCCK, including over the reunification question, though it had other causes too. From then on Korean Protestantism had two major councils speaking in different voices on the North — a division that continued older splits over the WCC described in Chapter 7 of this course.

It would be too neat to say that one council stood for peace and the other for war. Evangelical and conservative churches have also prayed for reunification, supported North Korean refugees, and sent large amounts of aid; many of the defector ministries described in Chapter 8 of this course come from these churches. The disagreement has been less about whether to seek peace than about how: through engagement with the northern state and its recognised church bodies, or through pressure on that state and support for those who flee it.

5. Humanitarian work

In the mid-1990s North Korea suffered a severe famine; estimates of the number of deaths vary very widely, and sources differ. The northern government appealed for international aid, and churches in the South and abroad responded.

Protestant, Catholic and interreligious organisations sent food, medicine and agricultural help. The Korean Sharing Movement, an interreligious and civic organisation founded in 1996, was one channel. Some aid went through international bodies such as the World Food Programme and Caritas; some through church organisations directly. The Eugene Bell Foundation, founded in the mid-1990s by Stephen Linton, a descendant of early Presbyterian missionaries to Korea, became known for long-term work against tuberculosis in the North. The Pyongyang University of Science and Technology, founded with the backing of Korean-American and South Korean evangelical Christians, opened in 2010 and taught North Korean students with foreign faculty.

This work has always raised hard questions. How can donors be sure aid reaches those in need rather than the military or the elite? Does cooperation with the northern state strengthen a government that persecutes Christians? Does refusing to cooperate leave ordinary people to suffer for their government's actions? Christians who agree on the command to feed the hungry (Matthew 25) have answered these questions differently, and the answers have changed with each political season — expanding during periods of engagement, shrinking during periods of tension and international sanctions.

6. Catholic reconciliation

Catholic efforts took a different institutional shape. The Catholic Church in Korea has a particular reason to care about the North: the Diocese of Pyongyang still exists in Church law, and its bishop, Francis Hong Yong-ho, disappeared after his arrest in 1949. Since then, the Archbishop of Seoul has served as apostolic administrator of the Pyongyang diocese, and Catholic prayers for the "Church of silence" in the North have continued for decades.

In 1995 the Archdiocese of Seoul established a Committee for the Reconciliation of the Korean People, which organised prayer, education and aid. The Catholic Bishops' Conference also has a committee for reconciliation. The Catholic Church's approach has generally combined prayer for the persecuted with support for dialogue and humanitarian aid, a combination that has been criticised both by those who want more pressure on the North and by those who want more engagement. On 18 August 2014, at the end of his visit to Korea, Pope Francis celebrated a Mass for Peace and Reconciliation at Myeongdong Cathedral in Seoul, in which he spoke of forgiveness as the path to reconciliation.

The Catholic Changchung cathedral in Pyongyang, mentioned in Chapter 6 of this course, has no resident priest recognised by Rome. What that congregation's life is actually like remains hard to know.

7. What Korean Christianity offers the world church

What does this history offer to Christians elsewhere? Here, more than anywhere in the course, it is wise to speak modestly: these are observations offered for discussion, not settled conclusions.

  • Lay initiative. Both the Catholic and the Protestant churches in Korea began with lay people reading their way into faith before clergy arrived (Chapters 2 and 3 of this course). That history challenges any assumption that churches must be founded by missionaries or clergy.
  • The Bible in the vernacular. Korean Protestantism is one of the clearest cases of Lamin Sanneh's and Andrew Walls's argument (Chapter 1 of this course) that translation into a people's own language renews faith rather than diluting it.
  • Prayer and discipline. Dawn prayer, unison prayer and intensive Bible study (Chapter 4 of this course) have travelled with Korean churches around the world and have been adopted by some non-Korean churches.
  • Martyrs of two traditions. Korea has Catholic martyrs of the nineteenth century and Protestant and Catholic martyrs of the twentieth. A church whose memory holds both has something to say about what Christians share.
  • A divided nation. Korean Christians have lived for three generations with the question of how to love a neighbour across a fortified line — and have disagreed about it. That experience speaks to churches in other divided places.

8. What Korean Christianity asks of the world church

It also asks questions, some uncomfortable:

  • Is rapid growth a blessing without cost? Lecture 9-1 showed how a church shaped for growth has had to face scandal, distrust and decline. Churches now growing fast in Africa, Latin America and elsewhere may be asking how to avoid the same path.
  • Who speaks for the church? Korean Protestantism's many denominations and councils have spoken with many voices on politics and the North. Is that a weakness, or a faithful form of Christian freedom?
  • How do outside churches relate to a divided people? Western churches, the WCC and the Vatican have all acted in Korean affairs, sometimes in ways Korean Christians welcomed and sometimes in ways they resented. How should the world church support a local church without speaking over it?
  • What does it mean to be a sending church in decline at home? Korea sends tens of thousands of missionaries abroad (Chapter 8 of this course) while its home churches shrink. What is the relation between the two?

9. Open questions

The course ends here, with questions its author cannot answer and does not wish to answer for you.

Will the decline described in lecture 9-1 continue, level off, or reverse? Will Korean churches abroad, especially the English-speaking second generation, develop a form of Christianity that is neither simply Korean nor simply American, Australian or Brazilian? Will reunification ever come, and if it does, what will the churches of the South and the believers of the North have to say to each other — and to ask forgiveness for? Will Korean Catholics and Protestants, who share so much history and have told it so separately, learn to tell it together?

The history in this course gives no certain answer to any of these. It does show that Korean Christians have faced hard questions before — under the Joseon state, under Japan, in war and dictatorship — and that they have answered them in more than one way, faithfully and unfaithfully, sometimes both at once.


The churches and the North, 1984-2014 Selected events; two Protestant councils, and a Catholic path of its own 1984 Tozanso (WCC) 1986 Glion: South meets North 1988 NCCK Declaration 1989 CCK founded 1995-96 Famine; aid begins; Catholic committee 2010 PUST opens 2014 Pope Francis: Mass for Reconciliation NCCK (ecumenical) Engagement with the North and its church bodies; confession of hatred; peace treaty proposals CCK and evangelicals Memory of persecution; support for defectors; aid, with doubts about engaging the state Catholic Church Pyongyang diocese kept; prayer for the persecuted; dialogue and aid through reconciliation committees

The three panels summarise emphases, not complete positions. Individual churches and Christians in each group have acted across these lines.


5. Going to the Sources

The Declaration of the Churches of Korea on National Reunification and Peace was adopted by the 37th General Assembly of the National Council of Churches in Korea on 29 February 1988. The Korean text is published by the NCCK, and English translations circulated through the World Council of Churches and are reproduced in several collections on Korean Christianity and reunification.

Paraphrased, not a quotation: In its confession of sin, the declaration says that the Korean churches, while living in a divided nation, came to hate their fellow Koreans in the North as enemies, turned anticommunism into something close to an article of faith, and so disobeyed the command to love one's neighbour. It asks forgiveness of God and of the Korean people for this, and commits the churches to work for reconciliation.

  1. Who is included in the "we" of this confession, and who might have felt they were being confessed for without being asked?
  2. Compare this confession with the demands for repentance after 1945 over the Shinto shrine rites (Chapter 5 of this course). In both cases, who asked whom to repent, and on what authority?
  3. A northern Christian refugee of 1950 and a young South Korean pastor of 1988 might have read this paragraph very differently. Write two or three sentences in the voice of each.

In short

  • For decades most Korean Protestants held anticommunism as common sense, shaped by war, refugees and persecution. Ecumenical meetings in the 1980s, at Tozanso and Glion, began to change this and were controversial.
  • In 1988 the NCCK declaration confessed hatred of the North and proposed a peace treaty and Jubilee. Evangelical critics objected on four grounds: confession for others, moral equivalence, political proposals and who speaks for the church.
  • The CCK was founded in 1989, so two councils spoke differently on the North. The lecture says the dispute is more about how to seek peace than whether to.
  • Humanitarian aid after the 1990s famine raised hard questions about reaching the needy. Catholic work combined prayer for the persecuted, dialogue and aid.
  • The lecture ends with open questions about what Korean Christianity offers and asks of the world church.

Topic: This lecture covers Korean church efforts at peace and reconciliation with the North, the strong disagreement they caused, and open questions for the world church.

Remember: Korean Christians agree on the ministry of reconciliation but disagree about what it requires, engagement with the northern state or pressure on it.

Caution: Do not say one council stood for peace and the other for war. Both prayed and gave aid, and the lecture gives open questions, not conclusions.

One line to carry into ministry: Feed the hungry and seek reconciliation, but weigh honestly who is helped and who may be harmed.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Is working for peace between two states a proper task of the church, or should the church limit itself to reconciling people with God and with each other? Can the two be separated?
  • If you were responsible for a church's aid to North Korea, how would you weigh the risk that aid supports the government against the certainty that people are hungry?
  • Of the things this lecture suggests Korean Christianity offers the world church, which seems most valuable to you? Which would you add or remove?
  • Look back at the question you wrote down at the start of this course about why Christianity grew in Korea. How would you answer it now — and what would you add about why the growth stopped?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.