FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH301E Korean Christianity in Global Perspective

Lecture 4-1: What Happened

Contents 27
CH301E Korean Christianity in Global Perspective
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Why Korea? Reading Korean Christianity as World Christianity
  1. Lecture 1-1: The Korean Anomaly
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Lens of World Christianity
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading the Sources Fairly
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: A Church Without Missionaries - Korean Catholicism, 1784-1886
  1. Lecture 2-1: Books from Beijing
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Ancestral Rites and the Persecutions
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Martyrs and Their Memory
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The Bible Before the Missionaries - Protestant Beginnings, 1832-1900
  1. Lecture 3-1: Translation First
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Missionaries Arrive
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Nevius Method
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Revival - Wonsan 1903 and Pyongyang 1907
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Happened
  2. Lecture 4-2: Practices Born of Revival
  3. Lecture 4-3: What Did the Revival Do?
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: Faith Under Empire - The Churches and Japanese Rule, 1905-1945
  1. Lecture 5-1: Churches and the Nation
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Shrine Crisis
  3. Lecture 5-3: Remembering Collaboration and Resistance
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: Division and War, 1945-1953
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Church of the North
  2. Lecture 6-2: The Korean War
  3. Lecture 6-3: Anticommunism and the Church in North Korea Today
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Growth, Division and Democracy, 1953-2000
  1. Lecture 7-1: Explosive Growth
  2. Lecture 7-2: A Church That Keeps Dividing
  3. Lecture 7-3: The Churches and Democratization
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: From Mission Field to Mission Force - Missions and the Diaspora
  1. Lecture 8-1: Korea as a Sending Church
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Immigrant Church
  3. Lecture 8-3: Korea in Global Christian Networks
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Present Tensions and Possible Futures
  1. Lecture 9-1: Growth Stalls
  2. Lecture 9-2: Women in Korean Christianity
  3. Lecture 9-3: Peace, Reconciliation and the World Church

Jump to the key points ↓

24 min

This lecture tells the story of the revival as carefully as the sources allow. It begins in the port town of Wonsan on Korea's east coast in 1903, where a Canadian missionary doctor named Robert Hardie stood before his colleagues, and then before a Korean congregation, and confessed that his work had failed because of his own pride. It follows the spread of prayer meetings to other towns in 1904-06, and then to the winter Bible class for men in Pyongyang in January 1907, where the meetings at the Jangdaehyeon (Changdaehyŏn) Church became the centre of what Korean Protestants call the Great Revival. It introduces Gil Seon-ju (Kil Sŏn-ju), the Korean elder and future pastor whose own confession and leadership made him the revival's best-known Korean figure. And it follows the revival into schools and other cities.

The second half of the lecture places the Korean revival alongside other revivals of the same years — in Wales (1904-05), in the Khasi Hills of northeast India (1905-06), at Pandita Ramabai's Mukti mission in western India (1905), and at Azusa Street in Los Angeles (1906). These movements knew about each other, and news of them reached Korea. But knowing about is not the same as causing, and the lecture explains why historians are cautious.

What these 24 minutes give you

  • Describe Robert Hardie's confession at Wonsan in 1903 and explain why a missionary's confession mattered to Korean hearers.
  • Narrate the main events of the Pyongyang meetings of January 1907, including the practice of public confession and Gil Seon-ju's role.
  • Identify the main eyewitness sources for the revival and their limits.
  • Place the Korean revival among the revivals of 1904-1907 and explain why a simple chain of cause is not supported by the evidence.

Now when they heard this, they were cut to the heart, and said to Peter and the rest of the apostles, “Brothers, what shall we do?” Peter said to them, “Repent, and be baptized, every one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is to you, and to your children, and to all who are far off, even as many as the Lord our God will call to himself.” With many other words he testified, and exhorted them, saying, “Save yourselves from this crooked generation!” Then those who gladly received his word were baptized. There were added that day about three thousand souls. — Acts 2:37-41

World English Bible

Confess your offenses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The insistent prayer of a righteous person is powerfully effective. — James 5:16

WEB

Missionaries and Korean Christians in 1907 described what they saw as "the Korean Pentecost," and Acts 2 was the passage through which they understood it: people "cut to the heart", asking what to do, repenting, and a church growing suddenly. James 5:16 was the text most often cited to justify the most striking feature of the Pyongyang meetings, the confession of sins aloud before others. This lecture does not ask whether the participants' interpretation was right; that is a theological judgement each reader's tradition will make. It asks what they did and why they understood it this way.

1. Wonsan, 1903: a missionary's confession

Robert Alexander Hardie (1865-1949) was a Canadian physician who had come to Korea in 1890 as an independent medical missionary supported by students in Toronto, and who later joined the Southern Methodist mission. By 1903 he had worked for years in Wonsan and the surrounding Gangwon region with little visible result. In August 1903 a small group of missionaries gathered at Wonsan for a week of prayer and Bible study. Two women missionaries visiting from China, Mary Culler White and Louise McCully, are usually named among those who asked for the meeting, and Hardie was asked to lead studies on prayer and the Holy Spirit.

As he prepared, by his own later account, Hardie became convinced that his failure lay in himself: that he had relied on his own ability, that he had been proud, and that he had looked down on the Koreans he served. He confessed this first to the missionaries, and then — which was far more unusual — to the Korean congregation at Wonsan. Korean hearers had not seen a missionary, a man of status, standing before them admitting his own failure and humiliation. Accounts from the time report that Korean believers began to confess their own sins in turn, and that prayer meetings of a new intensity followed.

It is worth pausing on why this mattered. In the social world of late Joseon Korea, rank and face were closely guarded. Missionaries were foreigners of high status — often with servants, larger houses and connections to the court. A missionary publicly confessing his own pride and his contempt for Koreans reversed the usual order. Whatever one makes of it theologically, it was socially startling, and it gave Korean believers permission to do something similar.

Over the next three years similar meetings were reported in several places, including Gaeseong, Seoul and Pyongyang, often led by Hardie or by missionaries who had heard him. They were significant but local. What changed their scale was what happened in Pyongyang.

2. News from Wales and India, 1906

In the autumn of 1906 an American Presbyterian, Howard Agnew Johnston, visited Korea and spoke to missionaries and Korean Christians in Seoul and Pyongyang about the revivals in Wales and in the Khasi Hills of India, where Welsh Presbyterian missionaries worked. Missionary accounts say this news deepened the missionaries' desire for revival in Korea and that the Pyongyang missionaries began meeting daily at noon to pray for it through the late autumn of 1906. Korean church leaders, including Gil Seon-ju, are reported to have been stirred by the same news. The sources for this are chiefly missionary sources, written after the revival, and they naturally stress the missionaries' preparation.

3. Pyongyang, January 1907

By 1907 Pyongyang was the strongest centre of Protestantism in Korea. The Northern Presbyterian mission had its main station there; Samuel Moffett, Graham Lee, William Blair and others lived and worked there; and the city's churches had grown fast. The largest was the Jangdaehyeon Church (often called the Central Church in missionary English), a large building that could hold, by various reports, well over a thousand people.

Each winter the mission held a Bible class for men from across the province — the kind of sagyeonghoe described in lecture 3-3 of this course. In January 1907 the class began in the first days of the month and lasted about two weeks. Men came from the surrounding districts for daytime study; in the evenings there were meetings at Jangdaehyeon open to the city's Christians, attended by hundreds of men (the women met separately).

The eyewitness accounts agree on the main events, though not on every detail. For several nights the meetings seemed ordinary, even heavy. Then, on the evening of about 14 January, after a short sermon, Graham Lee invited people to pray. So many began to pray at once that Lee — according to the accounts — told them that if they wanted to pray, they should all pray, and the whole congregation began praying aloud together. Then individuals began to stand and confess sins publicly. The confessions were of ordinary and extraordinary things: hatred, jealousy, lying, theft, drunkenness, adultery, cruelty to wives. Some confessors wept loudly, some fell to the floor, some beat the floor with their fists; the meeting went on into the early hours. It resumed the next night, 15 January, with even greater intensity.

Among the confessions the missionaries remembered most sharply were those that crossed the line between Koreans and missionaries. William Blair recorded that a Korean church leader confessed to hating Blair himself, and that the missionary and the Korean were reconciled before the congregation. Such confessions exposed tensions that the official reports of the mission usually passed over: resentment of missionary authority, missionary impatience with Koreans. The revival made them public and, for a time at least, dissolved them.

4. Gil Seon-ju

Gil Seon-ju (1869-1935) was one of the most important Korean Protestant leaders of the first half of the twentieth century, and the figure most associated with the revival in Korean memory. Before his conversion he had been a seeker in several religious traditions, including practices associated with Daoist-influenced mountain devotion, and had spent long periods in prayer and discipline. He converted in the late 1890s, became an at Jangdaehyeon, and was studying at the new Presbyterian theological seminary in Pyongyang in 1907.

In the revival, Gil played two roles. As a preacher and leader, he gave many of the Korean-language addresses and led prayer. As a confessor, he made one of the confessions most often retold: that he had been entrusted with managing money on behalf of a dying friend's widow and had kept part of it for himself. By the usual account he compared himself to Achan, the Israelite who hid stolen goods in Joshua 7, and returned the money. The exact details of this confession vary in the retellings, and the version most often told is from later sources. The core — a respected leader publicly confessing a real wrong — is well attested and helped make confession normal for others.

In September 1907 Gil was among the seven men ordained as the first Korean Presbyterian ministers (lecture 3-3). He became pastor of Jangdaehyeon and remained one of the most influential preachers in Korea for decades. He was one of the signers of the Declaration of Independence in 1919 and was imprisoned for it (Chapter 5 of this course). That fact alone should make readers careful about any simple claim that the revival made its leaders apolitical, a question taken up in lecture 4-3.

5. The spread

From the men's class the revival moved into the city and beyond. Meetings followed in the women's gatherings, in the boys' and girls' mission schools of Pyongyang, and in the Christian college (the institution later called Union Christian College, or Soongsil). Students left the city for home and took the meetings with them. Korean leaders, including Gil, travelled to preach in other cities. Missionary reports through 1907 describe similar scenes in Seoul, in the southern cities, and in rural churches, though often less intense than in Pyongyang. By the end of 1907 the revival had touched most regions where Protestant churches existed, Presbyterian and Methodist alike.

Historians and the numbers

It is difficult to give reliable numbers for the revival's effect on membership. Missionary reports claim steep growth in the years around 1905-1907, but that growth had begun before the revival and had several causes, including the political crisis described in the chapter overview. Historians differ on how much of the growth to credit to the revival itself. This course gives no figure because the available figures do not isolate the revival's effect.

6. The sources and their limits

Almost everything we know about the Pyongyang meetings in detail comes from missionary accounts. The most important are:

  • Articles by missionaries in the Korea Mission Field, the missionaries' own magazine, in early 1907, including Graham Lee's account of the meetings.
  • William Newton Blair's booklet The Korean Pentecost (1910), later expanded as William Blair and Bruce Hunt, The Korean Pentecost and the Sufferings Which Followed (1977).
  • Mission annual reports and letters to mission boards.
  • Later memoirs, such as Jonathan Goforth's (see the chapter overview).

Korean sources from the time are fewer: church minutes, some articles in Korean-language church newspapers, and later recollections, including Gil Seon-ju's own writings and memories preserved by his family and students. This imbalance matters. The missionaries describe the revival in the vocabulary of Anglo-American evangelical revivalism — "conviction of sin", "the Spirit fell", "Pentecost" — because it was their vocabulary. How Korean participants understood what they were doing, in their own words and categories, is harder to recover. Lecture 4-3 will return to this.

7. Wales, the Khasi Hills, Azusa Street — and Korea

The first decade of the twentieth century saw revivals in many parts of the world, and participants were aware of each other:

  • Wales, 1904-05. Associated with the young preacher Evan Roberts, marked by spontaneous prayer, singing and public confession, widely reported in the Christian press of the English-speaking world.
  • The Khasi Hills, northeast India, 1905-06. Among the churches of the Welsh Presbyterian mission, with news carried directly from Wales.
  • Mukti, western India, 1905. At the mission for widows and orphaned girls led by Pandita Ramabai, an Indian Christian woman reformer; accounts describe prayer, confession and ecstatic experience.
  • Azusa Street, Los Angeles, 1906. Meetings led by William J. Seymour, an African American preacher, usually counted as a birth of the modern Pentecostal movement, marked by speaking in tongues.

It is tempting to draw a line through these — Wales to India to Los Angeles to Korea — as if one revival lit the next. News did travel along such lines: Johnston's visit in 1906 carried stories from Wales and India to Korea, and Goforth carried Korea to China. But there are good reasons to resist a simple chain.

First, the Korean revival began in 1903, before the Welsh revival. Hardie's confession did not depend on news from Wales.

Second, the Korean meetings differed in important ways from the others. They grew out of a disciplined Bible-class system; they did not feature speaking in tongues, which was central at Azusa Street; and they took place within mission churches with an established structure.

Third, Korean religious practice was already rich in prayer, fasting, mountain retreats and intense devotion, in Buddhist, Daoist-influenced and popular religious forms. Gil Seon-ju's own background is one example. Some historians argue that the revival's intensity drew on these Korean forms as much as on Welsh or American models.

The most defensible statement is that the Korean revival was part of a worldwide pattern of revival in these years, that news of other revivals encouraged it, and that it had its own local roots and its own character. A diagram of arrows from Wales to Pyongyang would be tidier than the evidence.


From Wonsan to Pyongyang, 1903-1907 Main stages as the eyewitness sources describe them (dates approximate where marked) Aug 1903 Wonsan: Hardie confesses to missionaries, then to Koreans 1904-1906 Meetings in Gaeseong, Seoul, Pyongyang; news of Wales and India (1906) Jan 1907 (c. 14-15) Jangdaehyeon Church: unison prayer, public confession, Gil Seon-ju 1907 Schools, women's meetings, other cities; Sept: 7 ordained Other revivals of the same years: connected, but not a chain of cause Wales 1904-05 (Evan Roberts): news carried to Korea in 1906 - but Wonsan (1903) came first Khasi Hills 1905-06 and Mukti 1905 (Pandita Ramabai), India: reported alongside Wales Azusa Street 1906 (William J. Seymour): tongues central there, not a feature of Pyongyang Korea to China: Goforth carries the Korean accounts to Manchuria, 1907-08

5. Going to the Sources

Source: William Newton Blair, The Korean Pentecost (1910), a booklet by a Northern Presbyterian missionary who was present at the Pyongyang meetings, later incorporated in William Blair and Bruce Hunt, The Korean Pentecost and the Sufferings Which Followed (Banner of Truth, 1977). The 1910 text is in the public domain; the 1977 edition is widely available. What follows is a paraphrase of Blair's account of the evening of about 14 January 1907.

Blair writes that after a short sermon, Graham Lee took charge and called for prayers. So many began to pray that Lee told the congregation that if they wished to pray like that, they should all pray, and at once the whole room was filled with the sound of hundreds of men praying aloud — not confusion, Blair says, but a harmony of voices like the sound of many waters. He describes how men then rose one after another to confess their sins, many weeping, some falling to the floor; how he and the other missionaries were themselves overwhelmed; and how a Korean leader who had been at odds with him confessed his hatred of him, so that the two were reconciled in front of the congregation. Blair writes that the meeting lasted until two in the morning, and that he had never experienced anything like it. He interprets the whole as the work of the Holy Spirit poured out on the Korean church.

  1. Blair was a participant, and he interpreted the events theologically as he wrote. What in this account is description, and what is interpretation? Could a historian who does not share Blair's faith still use his description?
  2. The confession Blair remembered most was one directed at himself. Why might that be? What does it tell you about relations between missionaries and Korean church leaders before the revival?
  3. Blair's booklet was published in 1910, the year Korea was annexed. Does his account mention the political situation at all? What might explain that silence?

In short

  • In 1903 at Wonsan, missionary Robert Hardie confessed his pride, first to missionaries and then to a Korean congregation. This reversed the usual order of rank and led Korean believers to confess in turn.
  • In January 1907, during the winter Bible class in Pyongyang, Graham Lee led the congregation in prayer at Jangdaehyeon Church. Public confession of sins followed, including confession between Koreans and missionaries.
  • Gil Seon-ju became the best-known Korean figure. His confession of keeping money entrusted to him was widely retold, though its details vary. He was later ordained and signed the 1919 Declaration of Independence.
  • Most detailed sources are missionary accounts, so how Korean participants understood events is harder to recover. The lecture gives no growth figure.
  • The revival began in 1903, before Wales, and differed from other revivals. It was part of a worldwide pattern but with local roots, not a simple chain.

Topic: This lecture tells what happened in the Korean revival from Wonsan in 1903 to Pyongyang in 1907, and how it relates to other revivals.

Remember: The revival began with a powerful person confessing fault first, and it grew inside the Bible-class system with public confession.

Caution: Sources are mostly missionary and describe events in their own vocabulary. News of Wales and India encouraged the revival, but it did not simply cause it.

One line to carry into ministry: When trust is broken, leaders who confess first make it safe for others to do the same.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • The revival began, in Korean memory, with a missionary confessing his pride. What happens in a community when the person with the most power admits fault first?
  • Public confession of sins before a congregation was central in Pyongyang. What are its benefits and dangers? How does your own tradition handle the confession of sin — privately to a priest, in a general confession in worship, in small groups, or publicly?
  • If you have taken part in a revival meeting, a retreat or a charismatic gathering, how would you describe it to a historian a hundred years from now? What would be lost in the description?
  • Why do you think Christians have so often wanted to see their revival as part of a single worldwide movement? What is gained and what is lost by that way of telling it?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.