Lecture 6-3: Anticommunism and the Church in North Korea Today
Contents 27
- Lecture 1-1: The Korean Anomaly
- Lecture 1-2: The Lens of World Christianity
- Lecture 1-3: Reading the Sources Fairly
- Lecture 2-1: Books from Beijing
- Lecture 2-2: The Ancestral Rites and the Persecutions
- Lecture 2-3: The Martyrs and Their Memory
- Lecture 4-1: What Happened
- Lecture 4-2: Practices Born of Revival
- Lecture 4-3: What Did the Revival Do?
- Lecture 5-1: Churches and the Nation
- Lecture 5-2: The Shrine Crisis
- Lecture 5-3: Remembering Collaboration and Resistance
- Lecture 6-1: The Church of the North
- Lecture 6-2: The Korean War
- Lecture 6-3: Anticommunism and the Church in North Korea Today
- Lecture 7-1: Explosive Growth
- Lecture 7-2: A Church That Keeps Dividing
- Lecture 7-3: The Churches and Democratization
- Lecture 8-1: Korea as a Sending Church
- Lecture 8-2: The Immigrant Church
- Lecture 8-3: Korea in Global Christian Networks
This lecture looks at the long shadow of the division and the war on both sides of the line.
In the south, the war did something to Protestant identity that is still visible today. For many southern Protestants, especially those whose families had come from the north, opposition to communism became not just a political opinion but a part of what it meant to be a Christian. That fusion shaped the churches' relationship with the southern state under Syngman Rhee and the military governments that followed, and it continues to shape debates over North Korea policy and over the churches' place in public life. The lecture traces that fusion and its consequences, and it also notes the voices — Catholic and Protestant — that did not fit it.
In the north, the story is harder to tell because so little can be known with certainty. There are official churches in Pyongyang, a state-sponsored Christian federation, and repeated reports of secret believers and of severe persecution. The lecture describes what is known and, just as important, who the sources are and what each of them can and cannot see.
What these 25 minutes give you
- Explain how the experience of the north and of the war fused Protestant identity with anticommunism in the south, with examples from the 1950s onward.
- Identify some of the political consequences of that fusion, and some Christians and churches who took a different view.
- Describe the official churches of Pyongyang — Bongsu, Chilgol, Changchung Cathedral and the Orthodox church — and the Korean Christian Federation.
- Evaluate the main sources for Christianity in North Korea today (defector testimony, NGO reports, the UN Commission of Inquiry of 2014, visitors' accounts, official statements), stating the limits of each.
for I was hungry, and you gave me food to eat. I was thirsty, and you gave me drink. I was a stranger, and you took me in. I was naked, and you clothed me. I was sick, and you visited me. I was in prison, and you came to me.’ “Then the righteous will answer him, saying, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry, and feed you; or thirsty, and give you a drink? When did we see you as a stranger, and take you in; or naked, and clothe you? When did we see you sick, or in prison, and come to you?’ “The King will answer them, ‘Most certainly I tell you, because you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.’ — Matthew 25:35-40
World English Bible
Isn’t this the fast that I have chosen: to release the bonds of wickedness, to undo the bands of the yoke, and to let the oppressed go free, and that you break every yoke? Isn’t it to distribute your bread to the hungry, and that you bring the poor who are cast out to your house? When you see the naked, that you cover him; and that you not hide yourself from your own flesh? — Isaiah 58:6-7
WEB
Remember those who are in bonds, as bound with them; and those who are ill-treated, since you are also in the body. — Hebrews 13:3
WEB
These passages have been read in very different ways by Korean Christians thinking about the north. Some read Matthew 25 and Isaiah 58 as a call to feed North Koreans whatever their government — the basis for humanitarian aid through the famine of the 1990s and after. Others read the same passages, and Hebrews 13:3, as a call to stand first with those "in prison", including Christians in North Korean camps, and to refuse anything that props up the regime that holds them. Isaiah's phrase "your own flesh" has a particular force in a divided nation, where the hungry and the imprisoned are, for many families, literally kin. The texts do not settle the policy question; they explain why Christians on both sides of it feel bound by conscience.
1. How anticommunism became part of Protestant identity
Several strands came together in the 1950s to fuse southern Protestantism with anticommunism.
Experience. Many of the south's most influential Protestants were refugees from the north who had personally seen their churches closed, their pastors arrested and their land taken (lecture 6-1 of this course). The war then added the killings of 1950 (lecture 6-2 of this course). For these Christians anticommunism was not an abstract theory; it was memory.
Theology. Communism was officially atheist and hostile to religion. For conservative Protestants, and for Catholics following the teaching of Popes Pius XI and Pius XII, it was not only a political rival but a false faith. The language of spiritual warfare — Christ against Antichrist — was easily applied to the north.
The state. The first president of the Republic of Korea, Syngman Rhee (in office 1948-1960), was a Methodist who had lived for decades in the United States, and Protestants were over-represented in his government and among its supporters. The state made anticommunism its founding principle, and churches that shared it found themselves favoured. Christmas became a public holiday; military and prison chaplaincies were established; foreign mission and relief agencies worked freely. Historians such as Timothy S. Lee have argued that in these years Korean evangelicalism came to see the defence of the southern state against communism as close to a religious duty.
The United States. The churches' links to American churches and relief agencies, and the American military presence, tied the southern church to the United States' side of the Cold War. For many Korean Christians, the United States was both the source of their faith and the protector of their freedom.
Put together, these strands made it easy for many southern Protestants to regard a good Christian and a firm anticommunist as the same thing. The chapter's principle names this: the war taught the southern church to see itself as the enemy of communism.
2. What the fusion meant politically
The fusion had consequences that historians still debate.
- Support for authoritarian governments. Many church leaders supported Rhee and later the military governments of Park Chung-hee (1961-1979) and Chun Doo-hwan (1980-1988), which justified their restrictions on freedom in the name of anticommunism. Chapter 7 of this course examines both the churches that supported these governments and those that opposed them, and presents the dispute over that period on its own terms.
- A narrow space for dissent. Christians who criticized the southern government could be accused of helping the north. When some Protestant and Catholic leaders did take up democracy and workers' rights in the 1970s and 1980s, they were often attacked in exactly these terms.
- Divided responses to reconciliation. When the National Council of Churches in Korea issued its 1988 declaration on reunification and peace (discussed in Chapter 9 of this course), it was sharply criticized by other Protestant bodies, partly because it spoke of repentance for hatred of the north. From the 1990s onward, debates over engagement with the north — including the "Sunshine Policy" of the South Korean governments of 1998-2008 — divided the churches. Large conservative Protestant rallies in Seoul in the early 2000s expressed opposition to engagement and support for the alliance with the United States; other Christians took part in aid and exchange.
It would be misleading to say that all southern Christians took the same path. Three qualifications matter:
- Anticommunism did not always mean support for the government. The Catholic Church's daily newspaper, the Kyunghyang Shinmun, was a leading critic of Rhee's increasingly authoritarian rule and was closed by his government in 1959. The Catholic politician Chang Myon (John M. Chang), Rhee's political rival, briefly led the government after Rhee's fall in 1960. Anticommunism was shared across the political divide; support for Rhee was not.
- Anticommunism was not only Protestant. Catholics and Protestants alike opposed communism, and many non-Christians shared the same outlook. What distinguished Protestantism was the degree to which anticommunism became part of its religious self-understanding, especially among northern refugees.
- Memory changed with generations. Younger Korean Christians who did not experience the north or the war have often been less attached to the fusion than their grandparents. Chapter 9 of this course takes up the present debates.
A too simple story
It is also worth guarding against an elegant but misleading conclusion: that the refugee experience caused southern Protestant anticommunism in a simple way. The Cold War, American influence, the South Korean state's own ideology and Catholic teaching all pushed in the same direction, and the refugees' experience is one strand among several. Its importance is that it gave the others a human face and a claim of first-hand truth.
3. The church in North Korea: what is officially visible
After 1953 the churches in the north disappeared from public view. For decades there were no open churches at all. The regime's official line was that religion had died out naturally as people became free of superstition, and the Korean Christian Federation existed mostly for use in international contacts.
That changed, in a limited way, in the late 1980s, as North Korea sought contacts with foreign churches and governments:
- Bongsu Church, a Protestant church in Pyongyang, was opened in 1988.
- Changchung Cathedral, a Catholic church in Pyongyang, was also opened in 1988. It has no resident priest recognized by the Holy See, and North Korea's Catholic body, the Korean Catholic Association, is a state organization with no formal link to Rome; visiting priests have occasionally celebrated Mass there.
- Chilgol Church, a second Protestant church in Pyongyang, opened a few years later. It is presented as standing on the site associated with Kim Il-sung's mother, Kang Pan-sok, and her family's church.
- The Church of the Life-Giving , a Russian Orthodox church, was consecrated in Pyongyang in 2006, served by North Korean clergy who had trained in Russia.
The Korean Christian Federation also says that thousands of believers meet in "house churches" or worship points across the country. Its membership figures, which have been reported at various times as ranging from a few thousand to more than ten thousand, cannot be independently checked.
Foreign visitors who have attended services at Bongsu or Chilgol have given different accounts. Some have concluded that the congregations are staged for foreigners and that the worshippers are officials or selected people; others have reported that at least some of the worshippers appeared to be genuine believers, perhaps from families that kept their faith quietly since before the war. Both kinds of report come from sincere observers, and neither can be confirmed. The churches are clearly used by the state for its purposes; whether anything else happens there is not something outsiders can know with confidence.
4. The church in North Korea: what is reported
Beyond the official churches, the evidence comes from people who have left the country and from organizations that collect their testimony.
Defector testimony. Tens of thousands of North Koreans have reached South Korea since the 1990s, most of them by way of China. Many describe the possession of a Bible, contact with Christians in China, or religious activity as grounds for severe punishment, including imprisonment in political prison camps. Some describe secret believers — families who kept a faith from before the war, or people who became Christians while in China and returned.
NGO reports. Organizations such as the Database Center for North Korean Human Rights in Seoul, and international Christian advocacy groups, have compiled defector testimony into reports. Open Doors, an international Christian organization that ranks countries by the persecution of Christians, has placed North Korea at or near the top of its annual World Watch List for many years, and it has estimated the number of Christians in North Korea in the hundreds of thousands, with tens of thousands in prison camps. These estimates are widely quoted; their methods are not fully public, and they are best treated as estimates by an advocacy organization.
The UN Commission of Inquiry, 2014. In 2013 the UN Human Rights Council established a Commission of Inquiry on Human Rights in the Democratic People's Republic of Korea, chaired by the Australian judge Michael Kirby. Its report, published in February 2014, drew on public hearings with defectors in Seoul, Tokyo, London and Washington and on confidential interviews. It found that the North Korean state regards the spread of Christianity as a particularly serious threat, that Christians are prohibited from practising their faith and are severely punished if discovered, and that such persecution forms part of a wider pattern of violations that the Commission considered to amount to crimes against humanity. North Korea rejected the report and refused the Commission access to the country.
5. The limits of what can be known
Every one of these sources has limits, and a fair history has to name them:
- Defectors are a self-selected group. People who leave are more likely to have suffered or to have been in contact with outsiders; those who are content, or who are too closely watched to leave, are not heard from. Many defectors pass through networks in China run by Christian missionaries, which may make them more likely to have encountered Christianity and to report on it.
- Testimony can be shaped by its audience. Defectors who settle in the south may speak to advocacy groups, churches, journalists and governments whose interests can shape what is asked and emphasized. This does not make testimony unreliable; the UN Commission found it strongly consistent across many witnesses. It does mean that details, especially numbers, should be handled with care, and some prominent individual testimonies have later been revised.
- Advocacy organizations have missions. Their purpose is to draw attention and support to persecuted Christians. Their figures may be sound, but they are not neutral.
- The state is the least reliable source of all on this question. Its official statements are designed for its own purposes, and it denies outsiders the access that would allow them to be checked.
- No one can count. There is no census of religion in North Korea that outsiders can trust, and no way to survey believers who would face punishment if identified.
What can be said with reasonable confidence is this: the North Korean state has, since the late 1940s, systematically suppressed independent religious life, including Christianity; it maintains official churches for its own purposes; and there are people in the country who hold Christian faith privately at great personal risk. Beyond that, most numbers are estimates, and every statement should name its source.
6. Two churches, one history
The north and the south began this chapter as one church. By its end they had become, in a sense, each other's opposite: a southern church that grew and understood itself partly in opposition to the northern state, and a northern church that survived, if at all, in the shadow of that state. Both are heirs of the Pyongyang congregations of 1907 and of the shrine prisoners of 1945. How the churches of the south, and of the diaspora, should relate to the north — through prayer, aid, advocacy, pressure, engagement or all of these — is one of the questions Chapter 9 of this course takes up. It will not be answered there either, but it will be asked with this history in view.
Every arrow in the diagram points at a subject that none of the sources can see whole. That is the honest shape of the evidence, and any account — including this lecture — that sounds more certain than the diagram allows should be read with suspicion.
5. Going to the Sources
Source: the Report of the UN Commission of Inquiry on Human Rights in the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (UN document A/HRC/25/63, February 2014), with its longer companion report of detailed findings. Both are public documents, available on the website of the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. On religion, the Commission's findings are here paraphrased:
The state considers the spread of Christianity a particularly serious threat, because it challenges the official ideology and provides a basis for organization and interaction outside the state's control. Apart from a few state-controlled churches, Christians are prohibited from practising their religion. Those caught practising Christianity, possessing religious material, or in contact with Christians in China are subject to severe punishment, including imprisonment in political prison camps. The Commission based these findings on the testimony of witnesses, since it was not permitted to enter the country.
- The Commission explains the state's hostility to Christianity by its threat to the official ideology and its independent organization. Compare that explanation with the reasons lecture 6-1 of this course gave for the regime's pressure on the churches in 1945-1950. What has changed, and what has not?
- The Commission openly states that it could not enter the country. How does that limit the report, and what did the Commission do to compensate? Is its evidence stronger or weaker than the other sources described in this lecture?
- Suppose you had to write one paragraph about Christians in North Korea for a church newsletter. Using only what this source and this lecture support, what would you say, and what would you refuse to say?
In short
- In the south, experience, theology, the Rhee government and ties to the United States fused Protestant identity with anticommunism. The lecture says the refugees' experience was one strand among several.
- The fusion led many church leaders to support authoritarian governments and narrowed space for dissent. It later divided the churches over the 1988 declaration and the Sunshine Policy.
- Not all southern Christians followed this path. The Catholic Kyunghyang Shinmun criticized Rhee, anticommunism was not only Protestant, and younger Christians are often less attached to it.
- North Korea has official churches: Bongsu, Chilgol, Changchung Cathedral and the Orthodox church. Visitors disagree on whether the worship is staged, and membership figures cannot be checked.
- Evidence on Christians in the north comes from defectors, NGOs, the 2014 UN Commission of Inquiry, visitors and the state. Each has limits, and no one can count.
- What can be said with confidence: the state has suppressed independent religion since the late 1940s, keeps official churches for its own purposes, and some people hold faith privately at great risk.
Topic: This lecture explains how the war tied southern Protestant identity to anticommunism, and what can and cannot be known about Christianity in North Korea today.
Remember: Name the source of every claim about Christians in North Korea, because each source sees only part of the picture.
Caution: The lecture does not say all southern Christians were anticommunist in the same way, or that refugee memory alone caused the fusion. Advocacy figures are estimates, not neutral counts.
One line to carry into ministry: Before repeating a statistic about persecuted Christians, ask who counted, how, and why.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Is it possible for a church to oppose a political system firmly without coming to see the people who live under it as enemies? What have Korean churches done well or badly here?
- If you grew up in a Korean church, what did you hear there about North Korea? Where did that picture come from, and how does it compare with what this lecture says can be known?
- Matthew 25 and Hebrews 13:3 have been used to support both humanitarian aid to the north and a refusal to deal with its government. How would you decide between them in a specific case?
- When you hear a statistic about persecuted Christians anywhere in the world, what questions should you ask about it before repeating it?