FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT603E The Letters of Paul

Lecture 9-2: The Christ Hymn of Philippians 2

Contents 37
BT603E The Letters of Paul
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Reading Paul
  1. Introduction: Reading Paul
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Paul - Life, Sources, and the Shape of a Career
  1. Lecture 1-1: Who Paul Was — Pharisee, Roman Citizen, Apostle
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Damascus Road — Conversion, Call, or Both
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading Acts Alongside the Letters
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Letters, Chronology, and the Pauline Collection
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Ancient Letter, the Secretary, and the Congregation That Heard It
  2. Lecture 2-2: Chronology: Dating the Letters and Why It Is Contested
  3. Lecture 2-3: Thirteen Letters, Seven Undisputed: How the Corpus Was Formed and Divided
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: 1 and 2 Thessalonians
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Earliest Letter: Founding a Church and Leaving It
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Dead in Christ and the Coming of the Lord
  3. Lecture 3-3: 2 Thessalonians and the Authorship Question
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Galatians
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Crisis: Circumcision, Table Fellowship, and Antioch
  2. Lecture 4-2: Justification, Faith, and the Works of the Law
  3. Lecture 4-3: Freedom, the Spirit, and the Life That Follows
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: 1 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Divided Church: Factions, Wisdom, and the Cross
  2. Lecture 5-2: Bodies, Marriage, Food, and Idols: Ethics in a Pagan City
  3. Lecture 5-3: Worship, Gifts, Love, and the Resurrection of the Body
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: 2 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 6-1: A Damaged Relationship and the Letter's Difficult Unity
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ministry in Weakness: Treasure in Clay Jars
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Collection, the Rival Apostles, and Paul's Boasting
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Romans 1 to 8
  1. Lecture 7-1: Why Romans, and to Whom: Purpose and Audience
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Human Predicament and the Righteousness of God
  3. Lecture 7-3: Baptism, the Law, the Flesh, and Life in the Spirit
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Romans 9 to 16
  1. Lecture 8-1: Israel, Election, and the Argument of Romans 9 to 11
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Renewed Mind: Worship, Government, and the Weak and the Strong
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Ending of Romans and the People Paul Names
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Philippians and Philemon
  1. Lecture 9-1: Philippians: Partnership, Joy, and Imprisonment
  2. Lecture 9-2: The Christ Hymn of Philippians 2
  3. Lecture 9-3: Philemon: One Slave, One Letter, and a Long Aftermath
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Colossians and Ephesians
  1. Lecture 10-1: Colossians: The Supremacy of Christ and the Colossian Philosophy
  2. Lecture 10-2: Ephesians: One Body, and the Question of Its Authorship
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Household Codes and How They Have Been Used
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: The Pastoral Epistles
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Authorship Debate and What Hangs on It
  2. Lecture 11-2: Order, Office, and Sound Teaching in 1 Timothy and Titus
  3. Lecture 11-3: 2 Timothy: A Last Letter and Its Portrait of Paul
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: Paul's Theology and His Interpreters
  1. Lecture 12-1: Christ, Spirit, and the Shape of Pauline Theology
  2. Lecture 12-2: Justification Reconsidered - Luther, Sanders, and the Debate Since
  3. Lecture 12-3: Paul After Paul - Reception, Misuse, and Reading Him Now

Jump to the key points ↓

39 min

Six verses in the middle of a short letter have generated a body of scholarship out of all proportion to their length. Philippians 2:6-11 describes someone who was in the form of God, did not treat equality with God as something to be seized or exploited, emptied himself, took the form of a slave, became obedient to the point of death, and was in consequence exalted by God and given the name before which every knee bows. Almost every clause in that summary is disputed, and the disputes are not merely technical: the passage stands behind the classical formulations of the person of Christ, behind a nineteenth-century school of theology that tried to revise them, and behind a good deal of modern writing about self-emptying as a pattern for human life.

This lecture makes three arguments. The first is that the questions of literary form and of authorship — is this a pre-existing hymn that Paul quotes, or did he compose it? — are not preliminaries to interpretation but a part of it, because a quoted text and a composed text stand in different relations to the argument surrounding them. The second is that the two most contested words, harpagmos and kenosis, are contested in different ways: one is a lexical problem with a partial solution, and the other is a translation whose plain sense has been read as a doctrine it may not support. The third, and the one most often lost, is that Paul introduces this passage as the ground of a moral appeal. Verse 5 comes before verse 6, and whatever the passage is about, it is deployed to persuade a congregation with a unity problem to stop looking to their own interests.

The lecture also treats the reception of the passage in Christian doctrine with more care than a New Testament course usually does, because this is one of the places where readers from different traditions arrive with settled positions. The Chalcedonian definition of 451, the Orthodox understanding of the communication of properties, the nineteenth-century kenotic christologies and the objections to them, and the twentieth-century recovery of kenosis as a category for talking about God are set out in their own terms. The lecture does not adjudicate among them. It does insist that they be distinguished from the exegetical question, because a reading of six Greek verses cannot by itself settle a doctrinal question that took four centuries to formulate.

What these 39 minutes give you

  • State the case that Philippians 2:6-11 is a pre-Pauline hymn, name Ernst Lohmeyer and describe his strophic analysis, and set out the recent arguments against calling the passage a hymn at all.
  • Explain the lexical problem in `harpagmos` at 2:6, describe Roy Hoover's proposal and N. T. Wright's development of it, and state what each of the main renderings implies.
  • Give an accurate account of the debate between James Dunn's Adam christology reading of `morphe theou` and the pre-existence reading, with the strongest argument on each side.
  • Describe nineteenth-century kenotic christology with at least two named representatives, state the principal objections to it, and explain how it stands in relation to the Chalcedonian definition.
  • Explain how 2:5 and 2:12-13 frame the passage as an argument about conduct, and identify the main interpretive options for the phrase translated "have this in your mind, which was also in Christ Jesus."

Have this in your mind, which was also in Christ Jesus, who, existing in the form of God, didn’t consider equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, being made in the likeness of men. And being found in human form, he humbled himself, becoming obedient to death, yes, the death of the cross. — Philippians 2:5-8

World English Bible

Therefore God also highly exalted him, and gave to him the name which is above every name; that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, of those in heaven, those on earth, and those under the earth, and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father. — Philippians 2:9-11

WEB

If there is therefore any exhortation in Christ, if any consolation of love, if any fellowship of the Spirit, if any tender mercies and compassion, make my joy full, by being like-minded, having the same love, being of one accord, of one mind; doing nothing through rivalry or through conceit, but in humility, each counting others better than himself; each of you not just looking to his own things, but each of you also to the things of others. — Philippians 2:1-4

WEB

So then, my beloved, even as you have always obeyed, not only in my presence, but now much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling. For it is God who works in you both to will and to work, for his good pleasure. — Philippians 2:12-13

WEB

Look to me, and be saved, all the ends of the earth; for I am God, and there is no other. I have sworn by myself, the word has gone out of my mouth in righteousness, and will not return, that to me every knee shall bow, every tongue shall take an oath. — Isaiah 45:22-23

WEB

The last of these is included because 2:10-11 is not an allusion but a citation. Isaiah 45:23 stands in a passage whose whole point is that there is no god besides the God of Israel, and the words that Isaiah says will be addressed to God are, in Philippians, addressed to Jesus. Any account of what this passage claims has to reckon with that transfer, and with the fact that it ends "to the glory of God the Father" rather than in a competition between two objects of worship.

1. Is it a hymn, and is it Paul's?

In 1928 Ernst Lohmeyer published Kyrios Jesus, a study of Philippians 2:5-11 which proposed that the passage was a pre-existing liturgical composition that Paul had taken over. He set it out in six strophes of three lines each and argued that its vocabulary, its rhythm, and its independence from the surrounding argument marked it as a unit with a life before this letter. He further argued that four words at the end of verse 8 — "yes, the death of the cross" — broke the pattern and were Paul's own addition to the inherited text. Lohmeyer thought the underlying composition Semitic in background, possibly Aramaic.

The proposal was enormously influential. For roughly half a century the pre-Pauline hymn was the default position in scholarship, and it was extended: comparable analyses were offered of Colossians 1:15-20, 1 Timothy 3:16, John 1:1-18, and other passages, and a general picture emerged of early Christian worship producing christological hymns which the letter-writers then quoted. Ralph P. Martin's Carmen Christi (1967) surveyed the whole discussion and became the standard reference; Martin himself, following Ernst Käsemann, read the passage as a drama of salvation rather than as a moral example.

Two lines of criticism have since made the consensus much less secure.

The first concerns the strophic analysis. Lohmeyer's six strophes are not the only possible arrangement, and other scholars produced different ones — two stanzas, three, four — each defensible and each incompatible with the others. When a text can be divided into a poetic structure in several mutually exclusive ways, the divisions are doing less work than they appear to. The removal of "the death of the cross" as an intrusion is a particularly clear case: it is removed because it does not fit the reconstructed metre, and the metre is reconstructed from the text with that phrase removed. Gordon Fee pressed this objection hard, arguing that the passage is exalted prose, that Paul was quite capable of writing it, and that the vocabulary said to be un-Pauline is a small sample from a passage of unusual subject matter.

The second concerns the category "hymn" itself. Benjamin Edsall and Jennifer Strawbridge, in "The Songs We Used to Sing?" (Journal for the Study of the New Testament, 2015), examined how these passages were actually used by early Christian writers and found that they were not treated as songs; the early evidence for singing them is absent. Matthew Gordley has argued that the passage is better classified against ancient encomium — a formal composition in praise of a subject — than against hymnody. Michael Wade Martin and Bryan Nash have proposed a metrical analysis on Greco-Roman rather than Semitic principles. The effect of this work is not to prove Pauline authorship, but to show that the confident label "the Christ hymn" carries assumptions that have not been demonstrated.

Who wrote the passage

This is a point where readers will not agree. Ernst Lohmeyer, followed by Ralph Martin and a long tradition, held that Paul is quoting a pre-existing composition. Gordon Fee, Stephen Fowl, and Markus Bockmuehl hold that Paul composed the passage for this letter, in an elevated style suited to its subject. Edsall and Strawbridge, and Gordley from a different angle, argue that the genre classification on which the old consensus rested is itself insecure. It is worth being clear about what the disagreement changes and what it does not. It does not change what the words say. It changes two things: how much weight the passage can bear as evidence for what Christians believed before Paul wrote, and how tightly its content can be tied to the argument of chapter 2. A student should also notice a temptation in this area. If the passage is pre-Pauline, it becomes very early evidence for a high christology, which is a conclusion many readers want; that is a reason to examine the argument for it more carefully, not less.

2. morphe theou, and whether it implies pre-existence

Verse 6 begins with a participle: "existing in the form of God." Morphe is the ordinary Greek word for form or shape, and the question is what "the form of God" means when a person is said to be in it.

The traditional reading takes it as a statement about the pre-existent Son: the one described was in the divine mode of being before becoming human, and verses 7 and 8 describe the . This is how the passage was read from the patristic period onward, and it is presupposed by the creeds.

James Dunn, in Christology in the Making (1980), challenged it. His proposal was that the passage draws its structure from Adam. Adam was made in the ; Adam grasped at equality with God and was told he would be like God; Adam's disobedience brought death. The figure in Philippians 2 is in the form of God and does not grasp; he is obedient instead of disobedient; his obedience goes to death and is reversed by exaltation. On this reading morphe theou corresponds to the image of God in which every human being is made, and the passage contrasts two human histories rather than describing a descent from heaven. Verse 7's "being made in the likeness of men" then describes not incarnation but the condition of fallen humanity that Christ shared.

The objections are substantial and come from several directions. Larry Hurtado, N. T. Wright, Gordon Fee, and Charles Gieschen have all argued against Dunn on overlapping grounds. First, the Adam parallel requires that morphe and eikon (image) be effectively synonymous here, which is arguable but not obvious, and Paul elsewhere uses eikon when he means image, including of Christ. Second, the sequence in verse 7 — taking the form of a slave, being made in the likeness of men, being found in human form — reads more naturally as a description of becoming human than as a description of what a human being does. Third, the exaltation in verses 9-11 confers the divine name, and it is not clear what would be conferred on a merely human figure in Adam's position. Dunn's answer to the third point is that exaltation is precisely the reversal of Adam's fate and needs no pre-existence; his answer to the second is that "likeness of men" would be an odd way to describe incarnation if the subject were already understood to be divine.

Four ways to read it

This is a point where readers will not agree. James Dunn reads an Adam christology without pre-existence. Larry Hurtado, in Lord Jesus Christ (2003), reads the passage within a pattern of devotion to Jesus that he argues was already established within the first two decades and that presupposes more than an exalted human. N. T. Wright reads pre-existence but insists that the passage is about the redefinition of what divinity looks like rather than about a divine being taking a holiday from divinity. Richard Bauckham, in God Crucified (1998), argued that the categories of "high" and "low" christology are unhelpful here, and that the passage places Jesus within the unique identity of the one God of Israel by the citation of Isaiah 45 — which is a different kind of claim from a statement about natures. A student who can state these four positions in their own terms is in a better position than one who has learned only the conclusion of whichever one their tradition holds.

3. harpagmos

Verse 6 says that he did not consider equality with God harpagmon. The noun is extremely rare. It is built from a verb meaning to seize or snatch, and the difficulty is whether it denotes the act of seizing, the thing seized, or something else.

Three renderings have been standard:

Something to be seized (res rapienda). He did not have equality with God and did not grab at it. This fits an Adam reading well, since Adam did grab.

Something to be held on to (res rapta). He had equality with God and did not cling to it. This is the reading behind many older English translations and behind the popular picture of Christ setting divinity aside.

Something to exploit for advantage. Roy Hoover, in a 1971 article in the Harvard Theological Review, examined the parallel constructions in which the word or its cognates appear with a verb of considering and argued that the phrase functions as a set idiom meaning "regard as something to take advantage of." On this reading the question of whether the subject already possessed equality is not raised by the word at all; what is denied is that he treated it as a thing to use for himself.

Hoover's study is widely regarded as the most careful lexical work done on the phrase, and N. T. Wright developed its implications in an article in the Journal of Theological Studies (1986), arguing that the passage does not say Christ gave up equality with God but that he understood equality with God as consisting in self-giving rather than in self-advantage. That reading has been influential and it has also been criticised for producing a conclusion of considerable theological convenience from a slender lexical base; the number of surviving parallel constructions is small, and Hoover's category rests on their being read together.

The practical upshot for a student is worth stating plainly. If the third reading is right, then a great deal of popular preaching on this verse — that Christ "gave up" or "laid aside" his divinity — is not merely a paraphrase but a claim the verse does not make. That is a significant result, and it should be held with the reservation that the lexical basis is thin.

4. kenosis

"But emptied himself." The verb is kenoo, to empty, and the noun formed from it, kenosis, has become the name for a whole family of theological positions.

The first thing to establish is what the sentence itself supplies. Paul says that he emptied himself, and then, in the same sentence, says how: "taking the form of a servant, being made in the likeness of men." Grammatically the participles explain the emptying. Nothing in the clause names a content that was removed. Whether the emptying consists in the taking, or whether the taking is a consequence of some prior subtraction, is not stated, and every substantive theological position on is an attempt to fill a gap that the verse leaves.

Nineteenth-century kenotic christology. In the middle of the nineteenth century, a group of largely Lutheran theologians in Germany, of whom Gottfried Thomasius is the best known, proposed that in becoming incarnate the Son laid aside certain divine attributes — the so-called relative attributes of , , and — while retaining the essential attributes of holiness, love, and truth. The motive was serious and not merely speculative: the Gospels show Jesus growing in wisdom, being ignorant of the day and hour, being surprised, being tired, and the traditional doctrine of two natures was thought by these writers to have handled such texts by attributing them to the human nature in a way that made the incarnation less than real. British versions followed, notably in Charles Gore's contribution to Lux Mundi (1889), P. T. Forsyth's The Person and Place of Jesus Christ (1909), and H. R. Mackintosh's work.

The objections. Critics argued that the position is incoherent in principle: if a being can cease to be omnipotent and remain God, then omnipotence was not essential to God, and the doctrine of God has been revised in order to solve a christological problem. A second objection concerns the : if the Son suspended omnipresence during the incarnation, what became of the Son's relation to the Father and the Spirit and to the sustaining of the world? A third is exegetical, and is the one this lecture has already given: the verse does not say that anything was subtracted. Charles Hodge in the nineteenth century and Donald Baillie in the twentieth pressed versions of these objections, and kenoticism in its strong form has few defenders now, though modified versions continue to be argued in philosophical theology, for instance in the work of Stephen Davis and C. Stephen Evans.

Chalcedon. The definition agreed at Chalcedon in 451 states that Christ is acknowledged in two natures, without confusion, without change, without division, without separation, the distinction of natures being in no way removed by the union. The phrase "without change" is the point of contact: on the standard reading, Chalcedon rules out a divine nature that alters in the incarnation, and strong kenoticism therefore stands outside it. Kenotic theologians replied in different ways — that Chalcedon addressed a different question, or that a voluntary self-limitation is not a change imposed from outside — and the argument continues at that level. What a student should take from it is the structure: the exegetical question, the doctrinal question, and the question of whether a later definition governs the reading of an earlier text are three questions, and confusing them produces bad arguments in every direction.

The Eastern reading. In Greek patristic and later Orthodox interpretation, kenosis is usually read through the communication of properties — the principle, developed above all by Cyril of Alexandria, that what is said of either nature is said of the one person — so that the Word truly suffers, in the flesh, without the divine nature being diminished. Kenosis in this tradition names a mode of the incarnation and not a subtraction from divinity, and it is often connected to the wider account of God's self-giving descent that makes human participation in the divine life possible. Sergius Bulgakov, in the twentieth century, developed a much more far-reaching kenotic theology within an Orthodox framework, and it was controversial in his own church, which is itself a useful indication of where the boundaries lie.

Twentieth-century recovery. Kenosis returned as a major theological category in the twentieth century in forms quite different from the nineteenth-century one: in Hans Urs von Balthasar's account of the descent into the depths of human abandonment, in Jürgen Moltmann's The Crucified God (1972), and in a large body of writing about self-emptying as the form of Christian life. This last development raises a question that is properly ethical rather than exegetical, and it has been raised most sharply by feminist theologians — Daphne Hampson and others have asked whether self-emptying, preached to those who have already been emptied by others, functions as an instruction to remain there. The question is a good one and this course does not answer it, but a student should notice that it arises from the passage's ethical framing, not despite it.

5. The name above every name

Verses 9-11 are the second movement and are grammatically dependent on the first: "Therefore God also highly exalted him." The exaltation is God's act, and it is a response.

The name given is not stated directly, but the citation identifies it. Isaiah 45:23, in the Greek version Paul used, says that to God every knee will bow and every tongue confess, in a chapter that insists there is no other God. Philippians applies this to Jesus and closes the confession with the title kyrios, Lord, which in that Greek version renders the divine name. What the passage does, then, is not to add a new figure alongside God but to place Jesus inside a text that excludes any such addition — and then to say that the whole thing is "to the glory of God the Father."

Richard Bauckham built an account of early christology on this observation, arguing that the earliest Christian writers included Jesus in the unique identity of the God of Israel while retaining Jewish monotheism, and that this happened much earlier than the developmental models of the older scholarship allowed. Larry Hurtado reached a compatible conclusion by a different route, through the practice of devotion. Both positions are contested in detail, and both are compatible with more than one view of the passage's authorship. What is not seriously contested is that the citation of Isaiah 45 is deliberate, and any reading that treats the passage as being about a merely exalted human being has to explain it.

6. The reason the passage is in the letter

Return to verse 5. The passage does not begin at verse 6; it begins with an instruction, and the instruction follows an appeal in verses 1-4 that a congregation with a disagreement stop acting from rivalry and conceit and count others better than themselves. It is followed at verse 12 by "So then, my beloved... work out your own salvation with fear and trembling."

The Greek of verse 5 is compressed and can be construed in two main ways.

The example reading. "Have this mind among yourselves which was also in Christ Jesus" — Christ is the pattern, and the congregation is to reproduce the disposition the passage describes. This is the natural reading of the English translations, it fits the context of verses 1-4 exactly, and it is defended by Larry Hurtado in an essay titled "Jesus as Lordly Example" and by Stephen Fowl in The Story of Christ in the Ethics of Paul (1990).

The incorporation reading. "Have this mind among yourselves which is yours in Christ Jesus" — the phrase en Christo Iesou is Paul's usual formula for being incorporated into Christ, and on this reading Paul is not offering an example to copy but describing the sphere in which the congregation already stands. Ernst Käsemann argued this, and Ralph Martin followed him. Käsemann's motive was theological as well as grammatical: he objected that the example reading turns a soteriological drama into moral instruction and makes Christ into a model of humility, a role Käsemann thought foreign to Paul.

The two readings are not as far apart as the polemic between them suggested. Verse 12's "work out your own salvation" is immediately qualified by verse 13's "for it is God who works in you both to will and to work" — a pairing that holds together an imperative addressed to the congregation and a statement that the capacity is God's. That pairing is one of the places where the traditions have historically divided, and it is worth stating each side accurately: Catholic theology reads it as cooperation with grace, grace being prior and enabling; the Orthodox tradition speaks of synergy in a comparable sense within its own framework of participation in the divine life; classical Protestant readings emphasise that the working out is the outworking of a salvation already given and not a contribution to it. The Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of of 1999, treated in Lecture 12-2, addressed the underlying question and did not dissolve it. What should be said here is only that Philippians 2:12-13 is a text all three traditions can and do use, and that whoever finds it easy has probably read only half of it.

The lecture's own conclusion is a modest one. Whatever else this passage is — a quoted hymn, an encomium, Paul's own composition; a statement about pre-existence or a contrast with Adam — Paul put it where he put it in order to change how a small congregation in a Roman colony treated one another. That is not a reduction of its content. It is a statement about the level at which Paul thought this content operates.

The diagram sets out the shape of 2:6-11 as the two-movement descent and exaltation that nearly all readings recognise, and marks the four points at which interpretation divides. The strophe boundaries are not shown, because the competing strophic analyses are one of the things in dispute.

Philippians 2:6-11: two movements, four disputed points Descent is the subject’s own act; exaltation is God’s. The frame at 2:5 and 2:12 is part of the passage. 2:5 Have this in your mind, which was also in Christ Jesus — the frame 2:6 existing in the form of God did not consider equality with God a thing to be grasped 2:7 but emptied himself taking the form of a servant, made in the likeness of men 2:8 he humbled himself, obedient to death — yes, the death of the cross 2:9 Therefore God also highly exalted him and gave him the name above every name 2:10-11 every knee bows, every tongue confesses citing Isaiah 45:23 · ending to the glory of God the Father 2:12-13 So then … work out your own salvation — the frame closes 1. morphe theou Pre-existence (Hurtado, Wright, Fee) or Adam christology without it (Dunn)? 2. harpagmos Seized, clung to, or exploited for advantage (Hoover, Wright)? 3. kenosis The text names no content removed. Kenotic christology fills that gap. 4. Quoted or composed? Pre-Pauline hymn (Lohmeyer, Martin), Pauline prose (Fee), or encomium rather than hymn (Gordley)? Lohmeyer treated “yes, the death of the cross” as Paul’s addition to an inherited text, because it breaks the metre. The metre, however, is reconstructed from the text after that phrase is removed. Notice the shape of the argument.

6. Further Reading

  • Ralph P. Martin, Carmen Christi: Philippians ii.5-11 in Recent Interpretation and in the Setting of Early Christian Worship (1967; revised 1983). The standard history of the discussion; its own position follows Käsemann.
  • Ralph P. Martin and Brian J. Dodd, eds., Where Christology Began: Essays on Philippians 2 (1998). A collection covering most of the positions described here, including contributions by scholars who disagree with the editors.
  • James D. G. Dunn, Christology in the Making (1980; 2nd ed. 1989). The Adam christology reading, with a preface to the second edition responding to critics.
  • Larry W. Hurtado, Lord Jesus Christ: Devotion to Jesus in Earliest Christianity (2003). The case that devotion to Jesus of a kind requiring more than an exalted human is very early.
  • Richard Bauckham, God Crucified: Monotheism and Christology in the New Testament (1998). The divine-identity argument, built substantially on the use of Isaiah 45 here.
  • N. T. Wright, "harpagmos and the Meaning of Philippians 2:5-11," Journal of Theological Studies 37 (1986). Hoover's lexical result developed into a christological reading.
  • Stephen E. Fowl, The Story of Christ in the Ethics of Paul (1990). The strongest recent defence of reading the passage as without reducing its content.
  • Sarah Coakley, Powers and Submissions: Spirituality, Philosophy and Gender (2002). Includes a sustained treatment of kenosis and of the feminist objection to it, arguing a position that neither dismisses the objection nor abandons the category.

In short

  • Ernst Lohmeyer's 1928 Kyrios Jesus proposed Philippians 2:6-11 as a pre-existing hymn in six strophes, treating "yes, the death of the cross" as Paul's own addition because it breaks the reconstructed metre — but that metre is itself reconstructed only after removing the phrase, a circularity Gordon Fee and others have pressed hard.
  • James Dunn's Adam-christology reading of morphe theou (Adam was made in God's image, grasped at equality with God, and fell; Christ, in the form of God, did not grasp, and was obedient instead) denies pre-existence, but critics including Hurtado, Wright, and Fee argue the sequence in verse 7 reads more naturally as a description of becoming human than of a human's conduct.
  • Roy Hoover's 1971 lexical study of harpagmos (2:6) argued the phrase is an idiom meaning "regard as something to exploit for advantage" rather than "something to be seized" or "clung to" — a reading N. T. Wright developed to argue the verse never says Christ gave up divine equality, only that he did not treat it as self-advantage.
  • Nineteenth-century kenotic christology (Gottfried Thomasius; in Britain, Charles Gore and P. T. Forsyth) proposed the Son laid aside "relative" attributes like omniscience in the incarnation, but critics note the Greek verb kenoo in 2:7 is immediately explained by the following participles ("taking the form of a servant") with no content named as removed — the doctrine fills a gap the verse itself leaves open.
  • Philippians 2:10-11 directly cites Isaiah 45:23, where every knee bowing to God is a claim made in a passage insisting "there is no other" god — Paul applies this to Jesus and closes it "to the glory of God the Father," which Richard Bauckham reads as including Jesus within the unique identity of Israel's God rather than adding a second object of worship.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Philippians 2:6-11 is framed by verse 5's appeal to conduct and verse 12's "work out your own salvation," so whatever else it is, Paul deployed it to persuade a divided congregation to stop looking to their own interests. The passage's status as a quoted hymn (Lohmeyer, Martin) versus Paul's own composition (Fee, Bockmuehl) is disputed, and its two hardest words carry real theological weight: harpagmos (2:6), which Roy Hoover argued means "something to exploit," not "something to seize or cling to," and kenosis (2:7), where the text names no content removed even though nineteenth-century kenotic theologians built whole christologies on filling that gap. The passage closes by citing Isaiah 45:23 — a text about the God of Israel to whom every knee bows — and applying it to Jesus while still ending "to the glory of God the Father," which is exactly the kind of claim that took the church four centuries to formulate carefully at Chalcedon in 451.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • State, as precisely as you can, what changes in the interpretation of Philippians 2:6-11 if Paul is quoting rather than composing, and what does not change. Then say which of those changes matters most, and why.
  • Roy Hoover's reading of `harpagmos` produces a theologically attractive result from a small body of parallel texts. What standard should a student apply when a lexical argument and a desirable conclusion point the same way?
  • Nineteenth-century kenotic theologians were trying to take the Gospel portrait of Jesus seriously. Set out their problem in the strongest form you can, and then state what you think the best answer to it is, whether or not that answer is theirs.
  • Käsemann objected that reading this passage as an ethical example makes Christ into a model of humility and loses the drama of salvation. Is that objection fair to Philippians 2:1-5? What would be lost if he were right?
  • The question has been asked whether preaching self-emptying to people who have already been emptied by others functions as an instruction to stay there. How should a reader of Philippians 2 answer that question without either dismissing it or abandoning the text?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.