FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT603E The Letters of Paul

Lecture 9-3: Philemon: One Slave, One Letter, and a Long Aftermath

Contents 37
BT603E The Letters of Paul
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Reading Paul
  1. Introduction: Reading Paul
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Paul - Life, Sources, and the Shape of a Career
  1. Lecture 1-1: Who Paul Was — Pharisee, Roman Citizen, Apostle
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Damascus Road — Conversion, Call, or Both
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading Acts Alongside the Letters
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Letters, Chronology, and the Pauline Collection
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Ancient Letter, the Secretary, and the Congregation That Heard It
  2. Lecture 2-2: Chronology: Dating the Letters and Why It Is Contested
  3. Lecture 2-3: Thirteen Letters, Seven Undisputed: How the Corpus Was Formed and Divided
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: 1 and 2 Thessalonians
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Earliest Letter: Founding a Church and Leaving It
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Dead in Christ and the Coming of the Lord
  3. Lecture 3-3: 2 Thessalonians and the Authorship Question
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Galatians
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Crisis: Circumcision, Table Fellowship, and Antioch
  2. Lecture 4-2: Justification, Faith, and the Works of the Law
  3. Lecture 4-3: Freedom, the Spirit, and the Life That Follows
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: 1 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Divided Church: Factions, Wisdom, and the Cross
  2. Lecture 5-2: Bodies, Marriage, Food, and Idols: Ethics in a Pagan City
  3. Lecture 5-3: Worship, Gifts, Love, and the Resurrection of the Body
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: 2 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 6-1: A Damaged Relationship and the Letter's Difficult Unity
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ministry in Weakness: Treasure in Clay Jars
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Collection, the Rival Apostles, and Paul's Boasting
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Romans 1 to 8
  1. Lecture 7-1: Why Romans, and to Whom: Purpose and Audience
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Human Predicament and the Righteousness of God
  3. Lecture 7-3: Baptism, the Law, the Flesh, and Life in the Spirit
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Romans 9 to 16
  1. Lecture 8-1: Israel, Election, and the Argument of Romans 9 to 11
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Renewed Mind: Worship, Government, and the Weak and the Strong
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Ending of Romans and the People Paul Names
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Philippians and Philemon
  1. Lecture 9-1: Philippians: Partnership, Joy, and Imprisonment
  2. Lecture 9-2: The Christ Hymn of Philippians 2
  3. Lecture 9-3: Philemon: One Slave, One Letter, and a Long Aftermath
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Colossians and Ephesians
  1. Lecture 10-1: Colossians: The Supremacy of Christ and the Colossian Philosophy
  2. Lecture 10-2: Ephesians: One Body, and the Question of Its Authorship
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Household Codes and How They Have Been Used
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: The Pastoral Epistles
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Authorship Debate and What Hangs on It
  2. Lecture 11-2: Order, Office, and Sound Teaching in 1 Timothy and Titus
  3. Lecture 11-3: 2 Timothy: A Last Letter and Its Portrait of Paul
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: Paul's Theology and His Interpreters
  1. Lecture 12-1: Christ, Spirit, and the Shape of Pauline Theology
  2. Lecture 12-2: Justification Reconsidered - Luther, Sanders, and the Debate Since
  3. Lecture 12-3: Paul After Paul - Reception, Misuse, and Reading Him Now

Jump to the key points ↓

39 min

Philemon is the shortest of Paul's letters — twenty-five verses, one chapter, a single request about a single person — and it has had consequences out of all proportion to its size. It is the only letter in the collection addressed primarily to an individual about a private matter. It is the only one whose subject is a named enslaved man. And it is the New Testament text that was quoted most often, and most confidently, in defence of slavery in the United States in the decades before the Civil War, while also being quoted against slavery by the people arguing on the other side.

This lecture has three tasks, and it is important that they be kept in the right order. The first is to establish what can and cannot be reconstructed about the situation. The traditional account — Onesimus ran away, possibly after stealing, encountered Paul in prison, was converted, and is now being sent back — is a reconstruction, not a report, and every element of it has been challenged. The second is to determine what Paul actually asks for, which is harder than it looks, because the central request in verse 16 is expressed in a comparison rather than an instruction, and verse 21 says explicitly that Paul expects more than he has asked. The third is the history of the letter's use.

The lecture takes a position on how that third task should be done. It would be easy to write about Philemon in a way that defends Paul, and equally easy to write about it in a way that convicts him by the standards of the nineteenth century or the twenty-first. Both are ways of avoiding the letter. Paul did not attack the institution of slavery, and no ancient author of any school did; that is a historical fact about the ancient world and it does not excuse anything, because the enslaved people of the first century were not less harmed for their harm being universal. What can be examined is what this letter does to the relation between an owner and a person he owns, what it leaves untouched, and what happened when it was later put to work.

What these 39 minutes give you

  • Set out at least three reconstructions of the situation behind Philemon — the fugitive reading, Peter Lampe's `amicus domini` proposal, and one further alternative — with the evidence each depends on.
  • Describe the rhetorical strategy of the letter, including the effect of addressing it to a household assembly, the withholding of a command in verses 8-9, the wordplay on the name Onesimus, and the announcement of a visit in verse 22.
  • State precisely what verses 15-16, 17, and 21 request, and explain why scholars disagree about whether manumission is being asked for.
  • Give an accurate account of how Philemon was used in the American slavery debate, naming at least one writer on each side and identifying the specific argument each made from the text.
  • Explain what the realities of ancient slavery, as described by historians such as Jennifer Glancy and Keith Bradley, add to the reading of this letter that a purely exegetical treatment misses.

For perhaps he was therefore separated from you for a while, that you would have him forever, no longer as a slave, but more than a slave, a beloved brother, especially to me, but how much rather to you, both in the flesh and in the Lord. — Philemon 1:15-16

World English Bible

Therefore though I have all boldness in Christ to command you that which is appropriate, yet for love’s sake I rather beg, being such a one as Paul, the aged, but also a prisoner of Jesus Christ. I beg you for my child, whom I have become the father of in my chains, Onesimus, who once was useless to you, but now is useful to you and to me. I am sending him back. Therefore receive him, that is, my own heart, whom I desired to keep with me, that on your behalf he might serve me in my chains for the Good News. But I was willing to do nothing without your consent, that your goodness would not be as of necessity, but of free will. — Philemon 1:8-14

WEB

If then you count me a partner, receive him as you would receive me. But if he has wronged you at all, or owes you anything, put that to my account. I, Paul, write this with my own hand: I will repay it (not to mention to you that you owe to me even your own self besides). — Philemon 1:17-19

WEB

Having confidence in your obedience, I write to you, knowing that you will do even beyond what I say. Also, prepare a guest room for me, for I hope that through your prayers I will be restored to you. — Philemon 1:21-22

WEB

Were you called being a bondservant? Don’t let that bother you, but if you get an opportunity to become free, use it. For he who was called in the Lord being a bondservant is the Lord’s free man. Likewise he who was called being free is Christ’s bondservant. You were bought with a price. Don’t become bondservants of men. — 1 Corinthians 7:21-23

WEB

The last passage is included because Philemon cannot be read in isolation from it, and because it is itself unclear at exactly the point where clarity would help. The Greek of the middle clause of 1 Corinthians 7:21 is elliptical: it says, literally, "but if indeed you are able to become free, rather use." What is to be used — the opportunity of freedom, or the condition of slavery — is not stated, and translations divide. The World English Bible renders it one way, as most modern versions do; older versions and some modern scholars render it the other. A student should know that the ambiguity is in the Greek and not in the translators.

1. What the letter says

Twenty-five verses. Paul, a prisoner, and Timothy, write to Philemon, to Apphia, to Archippus, and to the assembly that meets in Philemon's house. Paul thanks God for Philemon's love and faith and for the refreshment he has brought to the hearts of the saints. He then says that although he could command, he prefers to appeal, and appeals for Onesimus, whom he calls his child, fathered in his chains — a man who was once useless and is now useful to both of them. He is sending him back. He would have liked to keep him, so that Onesimus might serve Paul on Philemon's behalf, but he would do nothing without Philemon's consent. Perhaps, he says, Onesimus was separated for a while so that Philemon might have him back for ever, no longer as a slave but more than a slave, a beloved brother. If Philemon counts Paul a partner, he should receive Onesimus as he would receive Paul. Any debt should be charged to Paul's account, and Paul writes the promissory sentence in his own hand — adding, parenthetically, that Philemon owes Paul his own self. He asks for refreshment, says he is confident that Philemon will do even beyond what he says, and asks him to prepare a guest room.

That summary contains almost everything the letter states. Notice what it does not contain: any statement that Onesimus ran away, any statement that he stole anything, any statement of what he had done wrong, and any explicit instruction about his legal status.

2. Reconstructing the situation

This is a point where readers will not agree.

The fugitive reading. From the patristic commentators onward the standard account has been that Onesimus was a runaway. This reading takes "he was separated from you for a while" (v. 15) as a euphemism for flight, "once useless" (v. 11) as a reference to his desertion or to loss caused by it, and verse 18's conditional about wrong done and debt owed as covering theft or the value of lost labour. The classical parallel is a letter of the younger Pliny (Epistles 9.21) interceding with a friend, Sabinianus, on behalf of a freedman who had offended him — a letter whose tone is remarkably close to Philemon's, and which is cited in nearly every commentary. On this reading, Paul is doing something legally delicate: Roman law penalised harbouring a fugitive slave, and returning him with a letter of intercession was the correct and safe procedure.

The difficulty is coincidence. A runaway slave from Colossae, or wherever Philemon lived, would have to arrive at the very prison where his master's friend and spiritual father was held. Defenders answer that this is less improbable than it sounds if Paul's location was a large city that a fugitive would head for, and if Onesimus went there deliberately because he knew of Paul. But that second answer concedes most of the case to the next reading.

The intercession reading. Peter Lampe, in a 1985 article in Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft, argued that Onesimus was not a fugitive at all in the legal sense. Roman jurists recognised a distinction: a slave who left in order to seek out a friend of his master and ask him to intercede in a dispute was not classed as fugitivus. The jurist Proculus is cited in the Digest (21.1.17.4) to this effect. On Lampe's reading, Onesimus had fallen out with Philemon over something, went deliberately to Paul as an amicus domini, a friend of the master, to obtain his mediation, and Paul's letter is exactly the mediation requested. This explains the coincidence, explains why Paul sends him back without apology, and explains why the letter has the shape of a formal intercession rather than of a confession.

Lampe's proposal has been widely adopted — by Brian Rapske, by S. Scott Bartchy, and by many recent commentators — and it is probably now the most common view among specialists. Its weakness is that it explains the evidence well without being demonstrated by it: nothing in the letter says that Onesimus went to Paul deliberately, and "he was separated from you" is as compatible with flight as with a journey.

Other reconstructions. Sara Winter argued in 1987 that Onesimus had been sent to Paul by the Colossian assembly to assist him, and that the letter's request is for his permanent release into Paul's service — a reading that takes verse 13 as the real point and verse 16 as its ground. Allen Dwight Callahan, in an article of 1993 and then in Embassy of Onesimus (1997), argued a more radical case: that Onesimus was not enslaved at all but was Philemon's estranged biological brother, that the letter is about a family reconciliation, and that the slave reading was imposed by patristic interpreters, above all John Chrysostom, and thereafter became unquestionable. Callahan's proposal rests heavily on reading "no longer as a slave but more than a slave" (v. 16) as a comparison rather than a description of status. It has been criticised in detail, notably by Margaret Mitchell, on the grounds that the letter's language of receiving, of debt, and of usefulness fits the situation of an enslaved person and that the comparative reading of verse 16 is strained. The proposal is a minority position, and it should be reported as one; but it should be reported, because it identified something true, namely that generations of readers took the slave reading as self-evident when it is in fact an inference.

Any responsible reading operates under a constraint that should be stated once and remembered: we have one side of a correspondence, we do not know the outcome, and we do not have a single word from Onesimus.

3. How the letter works

Whatever the situation was, the rhetoric of the letter is recoverable, and it is unusually well made.

It is not private. Verse 2 addresses the assembly that meets in Philemon's house. A letter read aloud to the congregation makes Philemon's answer a matter of public knowledge. Paul does not say this, and he does not have to.

It withholds the command it says it could give. Verses 8-9 state that Paul has boldness in Christ to command what is appropriate, and then decline to. This is a recognised rhetorical move — the ancient handbooks discuss the technique of mentioning what one will not say — and it leaves the command standing in the room while formally removing it. Verse 14 does the same thing from the other side: Paul wants Philemon's goodness to be "not as of necessity, but of free will," a sentence that both creates the freedom and specifies what should be done with it.

It uses the name. Onesimus means "useful" or "profitable," and it is a common slave name. Verse 11 plays on it: once achrestos, useless, now euchrestos, useful. There is a further resonance in that chrestos, useful or good, was frequently confused in pronunciation and in spelling with Christos, and ancient readers noticed the overlap. The wordplay is affectionate; it is also an argument, since a slave's value was precisely his usefulness, and Paul is redescribing what that usefulness now consists in.

It creates a debt and cancels it in one sentence. Verses 18-19 offer to pay whatever Onesimus owes, in Paul's own handwriting, in the form of a legal promise — and then add, in a parenthesis, that Philemon owes Paul his own self. The parenthesis makes the promise unenforceable in practice while leaving it formally intact.

It announces a visit. Verse 22 asks Philemon to prepare a guest room. Paul will be coming to see what happened.

It calls Onesimus a brother, in the flesh and in the Lord. Verse 16 states the relation Paul wants established and does so in a phrase — "both in the flesh and in the Lord" — that resists being confined to a spiritual realm. Whatever Paul is asking for, he is not asking merely for a change of inner attitude.

4. What is actually being requested

The exegetical question on which everything turns is whether Paul asks for manumission.

The case that he does: verse 16 says "no longer as a slave"; verse 17 asks Philemon to receive Onesimus as he would receive Paul, and Paul is not a slave; verse 21 says Paul expects Philemon to do "even beyond what I say," which implies something beyond what has been named; and verse 13 shows that Paul wants Onesimus with him, which would in practice require his release.

The case that he does not, or does not say so: the letter never uses the vocabulary of manumission, which existed and was familiar; verse 16's "no longer as a slave, but more than a slave" is a comparison of how Onesimus is to be received, not a legal instruction; verse 16 goes on to say "both in the flesh and in the Lord," which some read as presupposing a continuing household relationship; and Paul's stated request in verse 17 is about reception. Verse 21's "beyond what I say" is genuinely open, and this openness is not an accident of our distance from the text — it is the letter's method, since a request that named its object could be refused precisely.

Was Onesimus to be freed

This is a point where readers will not agree. John Knox and Sara Winter read the letter as asking for Onesimus's release into Paul's service. F. F. Bruce wrote that the letter brings slavery into an atmosphere in which the institution could only wilt and die — a formulation often quoted and worth examining, since an atmosphere is not an argument, and the institution did not in fact wilt for eighteen centuries in Christian societies. Joseph Fitzmyer and Markus Barth, in their commentaries, reach cautious and different conclusions about manumission. Jennifer Glancy and Katherine Shaner have argued that the question of manumission is less central than it appears, because the change Paul requests leaves the structure of the household — and the master's power to decide — entirely intact, and because a single enslaved person's release changes nothing about the position of enslaved people as such. That last argument is a challenge to the terms of the debate rather than a position within it, and it is worth taking seriously.

5. What ancient slavery was

A discussion of this letter that treats slavery as an economic arrangement will misread it, and this needs saying because a certain kind of textbook presentation — ancient slavery was not race-based, slaves could be educated, manumission was common — has the effect of softening the subject while stating true things.

The true things are true. Roman slavery was not organised by race; enslaved people worked as physicians, teachers, and estate managers as well as in mines and fields; manumission was more frequent than in the modern Atlantic system, and freedmen could hold property and their children could be citizens. But Keith Bradley's work on Roman slavery, and Jennifer Glancy's Slavery in Early Christianity (2002), establish the other half of the picture with equal documentation. Enslaved bodies were legally available for corporal punishment and for sexual use, and the second of these was so ordinary that it barely required comment in ancient sources. Testimony from enslaved people was taken under torture as a matter of legal routine. Families were divided at the owner's convenience. Orlando Patterson's category of "social death" — the condition of a person with no recognised standing of their own, existing only through the master — describes something real about the institution across cultures, and it applies here.

This bears directly on Philemon in two ways. First, Onesimus was returning to a man with legal power to have him flogged, and Paul's letter was the only protection he carried. Whatever else the letter is, it is a document written for someone in danger. Second, the appeal to receive Onesimus as a beloved brother "in the flesh" is being addressed to a household in which the ordinary relations between owner and owned included things that the word "brother" cannot coexist with. That is a sharper claim than a request for kinder treatment, and reading the letter without knowing what it was addressed to blunts it.

6. Afterwards

The early church. The letter's usefulness was questioned early; some ancient readers thought a note about one slave unworthy of a place in scripture, and Jerome and others defended it. John Chrysostom preached three homilies on it, and his reading became standard: the letter shows that Christianity does not overturn social orders but transforms conduct within them, and slaves should be all the better slaves for being Christians. Chrysostom's homilies also, and in the same breath, denounce the mistreatment of slaves and describe masters as accountable to God. Both halves belong to the reading, and later users of the letter selected between them.

John Knox's hypothesis. Ignatius of Antioch, writing to the Ephesians early in the second century, greets their bishop, whose name is Onesimus. In Philemon among the Letters of Paul (1935), John Knox argued that this was the same man, that the letter was addressed principally to Archippus rather than Philemon, and that Onesimus, as bishop, was instrumental in assembling the Pauline collection and ensuring that the little letter about himself was preserved in it. The hypothesis is elegant, which by the standards of this course is a reason for suspicion, and it has been rejected by most scholars — Onesimus was a very common slave name, the identification requires an implausible lifespan, and the argument about the addressee is weak. It is worth knowing because it is frequently repeated as though established, and because the question it tries to answer is a good one: why was a private note about one person kept at all?

The American slavery debate. In the antebellum United States, Philemon became a proof text on both sides.

The proslavery use was direct. Paul, it was argued, met a fugitive slave, converted him, and sent him back to his master rather than assisting his escape; therefore the apostolic precedent supports the return of fugitives and, by extension, the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850, and condemns those who helped runaways. Thornton Stringfellow's A Brief Examination of Scripture Testimony on the Institution of Slavery, first published in 1841 and much reprinted, made this argument as part of a systematic biblical defence of slavery. Richard Fuller argued a version of it in his published exchange with Francis Wayland (1845), and it appears throughout the sermons and pamphlets of the period, including in the work of James Henley Thornwell, who held that slavery was a civil institution on which scripture pronounced no condemnation.

The abolitionist reply took several forms, and they were not equally strong. Albert Barnes, in An Inquiry into the Scriptural Views of Slavery (1846), argued from verse 16: whatever Paul had done with the man, he required that he be received "no longer as a slave, but more than a slave, a beloved brother," which is not a request that could be honoured while continuing to own him. Theodore Dwight Weld, in The Bible Against Slavery (1837), attacked the underlying assumption that the biblical vocabulary of servitude denotes chattel slavery of the American kind. Others pointed out that the letter nowhere says Onesimus was a fugitive, and that the entire proslavery argument rested on an inference. Frederick Douglass, in the appendix to his Narrative (1845), did not argue at all; he distinguished between the Christianity of Christ and the slaveholding religion of the land, and refused the latter the name. His refusal is a different kind of response, and it identifies the thing the exegetical debate could not reach: that the people quoting the letter owned people.

A further observation belongs here. Howard Thurman, in Jesus and the Disinherited (1949), recorded that his grandmother, who had been enslaved, would not allow the Pauline letters to be read to her, because the passages instructing slaves to obey their masters had been preached to her as scripture by white ministers. That is a piece of reception history as significant as any commentary, and it registers a cost that arguments about verse 16 do not remove.

Since. The letter continues to be read differently depending on who is reading. African American interpretation of Philemon, examined by Demetrius Williams, Clarice Martin, and Mitzi Smith among others, has generally been more attentive than the mainstream tradition to the silence of Onesimus and to what the letter does not say. Katherine Shaner's Enslaved Leadership in Early Christianity (2018) argues that enslaved people were more visible and more active in early Christian communities than the surviving texts, written by and for the free, allow us to see, and that reading those texts requires attention to their gaps. These are not fringe readings; they are the current state of a discussion that for most of its history was conducted by people with no stake in the outcome.

7. How to hold it

Two errors are available and the lecture recommends neither.

The first is the apology: Paul was ahead of his time, slavery was different then, the seeds of abolition are in verse 16, the institution could not have been attacked directly. Some of these statements are true and none of them is a conclusion. The seeds of abolition were also, on the same reading, in the hands of Christians for eighteen centuries during which Christian societies conducted the largest slave trade in history, using this letter among others in its defence. A reading that ends with Paul vindicated has not accounted for that.

The second is the anachronistic verdict: Paul failed to condemn slavery and is therefore complicit. This is true as a description and useless as history. No ancient writer proposed abolition; the Stoics who wrote about the equality of souls owned slaves; the great slave revolts sought freedom for their participants, not the end of the institution. To convict Paul of not holding a position that had not been formulated is to convict him of living in the first century, which explains nothing about the letter.

What is left when both are set aside is more interesting than either. Paul asks a slave-owner to receive a man he owns as he would receive Paul himself, calls that man his own child and his own heart, describes him as a brother in the flesh as well as in the Lord, makes the request in front of the congregation, offers to pay his debts, declines to command, and says he expects more than he has asked. He does not say what the more is. That combination — a request that reaches further than the words and stops short of naming its object — is what has made the letter usable by everyone since, and a student's task is to describe it accurately rather than to resolve it.

The diagram sets the three main reconstructions of the situation beside the evidence each depends on, and then tracks the letter's use in the nineteenth-century debate. The two halves are placed on one page deliberately: the proslavery argument depended entirely on the fugitive reconstruction being treated as a fact about the letter rather than as an inference from it.

Philemon: what is reconstructed, and what was built on the reconstruction The letter never states that Onesimus fled. Every account of the situation is an inference. Three reconstructions Fugitive Onesimus ran, perhaps after loss or theft, and met Paul in prison. Rests on: v. 15 “separated”, v. 11 “useless”, v. 18 debt; Pliny, Ep. 9.21. Problem: a runaway arriving at the prison of his master’s friend. Amicus domini (Lampe, 1985) He went to Paul deliberately to ask a friend of his master to mediate. Rests on: Roman jurists (Digest 21.1.17.4) — such a slave is not legally a fugitivus. Problem: it fits the evidence but is not demonstrated by it. Other proposals Winter (1987): sent by the assembly to serve Paul; the request is release. Callahan (1993): Onesimus is not enslaved but an estranged brother. A minority position, criticised by Mitchell; report it as one. What was built on it: the American debate Proslavery use Paul met a fugitive and sent him back; therefore returning fugitives is apostolic, and the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 has scriptural warrant. Thornton Stringfellow (1841); Richard Fuller, in debate with Francis Wayland (1845); James Henley Thornwell. Abolitionist reply v. 16 requires reception as a beloved brother, which cannot be honoured while still owning him; and the letter nowhere says Onesimus was a fugitive. Albert Barnes (1846); Theodore Dwight Weld (1837). Frederick Douglass (1845) answered on other ground entirely. The load-bearing point: the proslavery reading needed “fugitive” to be a fact of the letter. It is an inference — and one that the most widely held modern reconstruction rejects.

6. Further Reading

  • Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Letter to Philemon (Anchor Bible, 2000). Careful, technical, and thorough on the legal and social background.
  • Markus Barth and Helmut Blanke, The Letter to Philemon (Eerdmans Critical Commentary, 2000). Long, argumentative, and unusually attentive to the history of interpretation.
  • Peter Lampe, "Keine 'Sklavenflucht' des Onesimus," Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft 76 (1985). The article that changed the standard reconstruction; its argument is summarised in most later commentaries.
  • Allen Dwight Callahan, Embassy of Onesimus: The Letter of Paul to Philemon (1997). The minority reading, with the history of interpretation that it takes issue with.
  • Jennifer A. Glancy, Slavery in Early Christianity (2002). The standard account of what enslavement involved in the world of the New Testament, including what the texts do not say.
  • Keith Bradley, Slavery and Society at Rome (1994). The general historical background, independent of any New Testament interest.
  • John Knox, Philemon among the Letters of Paul (1935; revised 1959). The Onesimus-as-bishop hypothesis in its own form.
  • Katherine A. Shaner, Enslaved Leadership in Early Christianity (2018). On reading early Christian texts for the enslaved people who are present in them without speaking.
  • Demetrius K. Williams, "'No Longer as a Slave': Reading the Interpretation History of Paul's Epistle to Philemon," in Onesimus Our Brother, ed. Matthew V. Johnson, James A. Noel, and Demetrius K. Williams (2012). African American interpretation of the letter and its history.

In short

  • The letter never states that Onesimus ran away, stole anything, or did anything wrong — the traditional "fugitive" reading is an inference from euphemisms like "separated from you for a while" (v. 15), and Peter Lampe's 1985 amicus domini proposal, citing the jurist Proculus in the Digest (21.1.17.4), argues Onesimus deliberately sought Paul's mediation and was never legally a fugitive at all.
  • Paul withholds the command he says he could give (vv. 8-9) and calls his request unnamed even at the end — verse 21's "even beyond what I say" — a rhetorical strategy that makes the letter usable by everyone since precisely because it never states its object.
  • The wordplay on Onesimus's name ("useless," achrestos, now "useful," euchrestos, v. 11) works alongside the near-homophone chrestos/Christos, and the letter is addressed not privately but to "the assembly that meets in Philemon's house" (v. 2), making Philemon's response a matter of public record.
  • Historians Keith Bradley and Jennifer Glancy establish that Roman slavery, while not race-based, legally permitted corporal punishment and sexual use of enslaved people and took their testimony under torture — Orlando Patterson's category of "social death" describes the real danger Onesimus was returning into, which Paul's letter was his only protection against.
  • Philemon was quoted on both sides of the American slavery debate — Thornton Stringfellow (1841) argued Paul's return of a "fugitive" gave apostolic warrant for the Fugitive Slave Act, while Albert Barnes (1846) argued verse 16's "no longer as a slave, but... a beloved brother" could not be honored while still owning him; Frederick Douglass instead simply refused the "slaveholding religion" the name of Christianity.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Philemon is twenty-five verses about one enslaved man, and nearly everything commonly assumed about it — that Onesimus ran away, that he stole something — is inference, not statement; Peter Lampe's now-widely-held amicus domini reading holds he went to Paul deliberately to seek intercession, which was a recognized legal category distinct from flight. Paul's rhetoric withholds the command he says he could give and never names what he is actually asking for, even after saying he expects Philemon to do "even beyond what I say" (v. 21) — a deliberate openness that let the letter be claimed by both defenders and opponents of American slavery, with Thornton Stringfellow citing it for the Fugitive Slave Act and Albert Barnes citing verse 16 against him. What should not be forgotten is what the letter was written into: Roman slavery permitted flogging and sexual use of the enslaved as a matter of routine, so Paul's letter was the only protection Onesimus carried back into his master's house, and Howard Thurman's own grandmother, once enslaved, refused to let Paul's letters be read to her because of how they had been preached to justify exactly that.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • The fugitive reading of Philemon was treated as obvious for eighteen centuries and is now a minority position among specialists. What made it seem obvious, and what does that tell you about how background assumptions enter exegesis?
  • Verse 21 says Paul is confident Philemon will do "even beyond what I say." Why might a request be more effective for not naming its object, and what are the costs of that strategy — for Philemon, and, more importantly, for Onesimus?
  • Both sides of the American slavery debate quoted this letter with confidence. Is there a way of reading it that could have settled the question, or was the disagreement about something the text could not reach?
  • Howard Thurman's grandmother would not have the Pauline letters read to her. What obligation, if any, does that place on someone teaching those letters now?
  • Historians describe what ancient slavery involved for the body of the enslaved person. How should that information function in the reading of Philemon: as background, as a check on the interpretation, or as something else?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.