FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

BT603E The Letters of Paul

Lecture 12-2: Justification Reconsidered - Luther, Sanders, and the Debate Since

Contents 37
BT603E The Letters of Paul
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Reading Paul
  1. Introduction: Reading Paul
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Paul - Life, Sources, and the Shape of a Career
  1. Lecture 1-1: Who Paul Was — Pharisee, Roman Citizen, Apostle
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Damascus Road — Conversion, Call, or Both
  3. Lecture 1-3: Reading Acts Alongside the Letters
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: Letters, Chronology, and the Pauline Collection
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Ancient Letter, the Secretary, and the Congregation That Heard It
  2. Lecture 2-2: Chronology: Dating the Letters and Why It Is Contested
  3. Lecture 2-3: Thirteen Letters, Seven Undisputed: How the Corpus Was Formed and Divided
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: 1 and 2 Thessalonians
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Earliest Letter: Founding a Church and Leaving It
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Dead in Christ and the Coming of the Lord
  3. Lecture 3-3: 2 Thessalonians and the Authorship Question
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Galatians
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Crisis: Circumcision, Table Fellowship, and Antioch
  2. Lecture 4-2: Justification, Faith, and the Works of the Law
  3. Lecture 4-3: Freedom, the Spirit, and the Life That Follows
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: 1 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Divided Church: Factions, Wisdom, and the Cross
  2. Lecture 5-2: Bodies, Marriage, Food, and Idols: Ethics in a Pagan City
  3. Lecture 5-3: Worship, Gifts, Love, and the Resurrection of the Body
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: 2 Corinthians
  1. Lecture 6-1: A Damaged Relationship and the Letter's Difficult Unity
  2. Lecture 6-2: Ministry in Weakness: Treasure in Clay Jars
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Collection, the Rival Apostles, and Paul's Boasting
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: Romans 1 to 8
  1. Lecture 7-1: Why Romans, and to Whom: Purpose and Audience
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Human Predicament and the Righteousness of God
  3. Lecture 7-3: Baptism, the Law, the Flesh, and Life in the Spirit
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: Romans 9 to 16
  1. Lecture 8-1: Israel, Election, and the Argument of Romans 9 to 11
  2. Lecture 8-2: The Renewed Mind: Worship, Government, and the Weak and the Strong
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Ending of Romans and the People Paul Names
Chapter 9 · Chapter 9: Philippians and Philemon
  1. Lecture 9-1: Philippians: Partnership, Joy, and Imprisonment
  2. Lecture 9-2: The Christ Hymn of Philippians 2
  3. Lecture 9-3: Philemon: One Slave, One Letter, and a Long Aftermath
Chapter 10 · Chapter 10: Colossians and Ephesians
  1. Lecture 10-1: Colossians: The Supremacy of Christ and the Colossian Philosophy
  2. Lecture 10-2: Ephesians: One Body, and the Question of Its Authorship
  3. Lecture 10-3: The Household Codes and How They Have Been Used
Chapter 11 · Chapter 11: The Pastoral Epistles
  1. Lecture 11-1: The Authorship Debate and What Hangs on It
  2. Lecture 11-2: Order, Office, and Sound Teaching in 1 Timothy and Titus
  3. Lecture 11-3: 2 Timothy: A Last Letter and Its Portrait of Paul
Chapter 12 · Chapter 12: Paul's Theology and His Interpreters
  1. Lecture 12-1: Christ, Spirit, and the Shape of Pauline Theology
  2. Lecture 12-2: Justification Reconsidered - Luther, Sanders, and the Debate Since
  3. Lecture 12-3: Paul After Paul - Reception, Misuse, and Reading Him Now

Jump to the key points ↓

40 min

In chapter 7 this course opened the question of justification and deliberately left it open. This lecture completes it, as far as it can be completed, which is not all the way.

The argument has four movements. The first is the sixteenth century: what Martin Luther actually found in Paul, in what circumstances, and what the Council of Trent said in reply — not the caricature of Trent that circulates in Protestant textbooks, but its actual decree, which affirms grace as the beginning and cause of everything and denies that anyone can merit the grace of justification. The second is the twentieth-century turn, which began not with a doctrine but with a historical observation: Krister Stendahl argued in 1963 that the anxious, guilt-searching conscience through which the West had read Paul was Augustine's and Luther's rather than Paul's, and that Paul says of himself that he was blameless under the law. The third is E. P. Sanders in 1977, whose account of Second Temple Jewish literature — he called the pattern he found covenantal nomism, meaning that Israel's obedience to the law was the response to a covenant already given by grace, not a means of earning entry into it — removed the background against which the traditional reading had made Paul make sense, and the New Perspective on Paul that James Dunn and N. T. Wright built on that foundation. The fourth is the serious criticism of all this, from Stephen Westerholm, Simon Gathercole and Seyoon Kim, which is not a nostalgic defence of the old view but a set of specific historical and exegetical objections that have obliged the New Perspective to sharpen itself.

The lecture closes with the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification signed by the Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church in 1999. It is important to be exact about that document, because it is misdescribed in both directions: it is not a declaration that the Reformation was a misunderstanding, and it is not a piece of diplomatic language that settled nothing. It states a specific consensus and it lists, in its own text, the places where differences remain.

One thing this lecture will not do is tell you which tradition is right. That is not modesty. It is the position this school takes about a question on which its students belong to communions that have thought about it for five centuries and have not converged.

What these 40 minutes give you

  • Describe Luther's reading of the righteousness of God, its personal setting, and what the Council of Trent's sixth session affirmed and denied.
  • State Krister Stendahl's argument about the introspective conscience of the West, identify the Pauline texts he rested it on, and give the strongest reply to it.
  • Define covenantal nomism in your own words, name the evidence E. P. Sanders assembled for it, and explain why the claim mattered for reading Paul.
  • Distinguish James Dunn's reading of "works of the law" from N. T. Wright's account of justification and covenant membership, since the two are often merged under one label.
  • State the specific objections of Westerholm, Gathercole and Kim, and say which of them is a historical claim and which an exegetical one.
  • Give an accurate account of what the 1999 Joint Declaration agreed and of the differences its own text leaves standing.

We maintain therefore that a man is justified by faith apart from the works of the law. — Romans 3:28

World English Bible

yet knowing that a man is not justified by the works of the law but through faith in Jesus Christ, even we believed in Christ Jesus, that we might be justified by faith in Christ, and not by the works of the law, because no flesh will be justified by the works of the law. — Galatians 2:16

WEB

Now to him who works, the reward is not counted as grace, but as something owed. But to him who doesn’t work, but believes in him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is accounted for righteousness. — Romans 4:4-5

WEB

For it isn’t the hearers of the law who are righteous before God, but the doers of the law will be justified — Romans 2:13

WEB

circumcised the eighth day, of the stock of Israel, of the tribe of Benjamin, a Hebrew of Hebrews; concerning the law, a Pharisee; concerning zeal, persecuting the assembly; concerning the righteousness which is in the law, found blameless. — Philippians 3:5-6

WEB

For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision amounts to anything, nor uncircumcision, but faith working through love. — Galatians 5:6

WEB

For I know nothing against myself. Yet I am not justified by this, but he who judges me is the Lord. — 1 Corinthians 4:4

WEB

These are the texts the debate keeps returning to, and they have been chosen so that they do not all point the same way. Romans 3:28 and 4:4-5 are the classical Protestant texts. Romans 2:13 says that the doers of the law will be justified, in the same letter, three chapters earlier, and no reading of Paul is complete until it has said something about that sentence. Philippians 3:6 is Stendahl's evidence. Galatians 5:6 is the verse in which faith and love appear in one clause, and it is quoted by Catholic and Protestant writers alike, with different emphases on which word governs which. 1 Corinthians 4:4 complicates Stendahl in turn: Paul's conscience is clear and he does not treat a clear conscience as a verdict.

1. What Luther found, and where

Martin Luther was an Augustinian friar and a professor of biblical studies at Wittenberg. His difficulty, by his own later account, lay in a single phrase in Romans 1:17, "the righteousness of God." Trained to read it as the attribute by which God is righteous and therefore justly condemns the unrighteous, he found the gospel announcing precisely the thing he most feared. The breakthrough he described was a change in the sense of the genitive: the righteousness of God is not the standard by which God judges but the righteousness God gives, received by faith.

Two things should be said about this before anything is said against it.

First, it was an exegetical argument, not only an experience. Luther was reading a text and asking what kind of possession the righteousness in it is. Whatever one concludes, the question is a real one in Romans, and chapter 7 of this course showed that modern scholars still divide over it — an attribute of God, a status God confers, or God's faithfulness.

Second, the consequences Luther drew were pastoral and institutional at once. If God's acceptance is received rather than accumulated, then a system of graded satisfactions was not merely inefficient; it was addressing a need that had already been met. That is why the argument moved so fast from a lecture room to a continent.

The formula that came to summarise the Lutheran position is that the believer is simul iustus et peccator, at once righteous and a sinner: righteous in the verdict God pronounces, still a sinner in what can be observed. The righteousness is described as imputed — reckoned to the believer's account, external in its source, complete from the beginning — and this is where the sixteenth-century division actually falls.

2. What Trent said

The 's sixth session, in January 1547, produced a decree on of sixteen chapters and thirty-three canons. It is worth reading rather than summarising, and the following are its load-bearing claims.

Justification is a translation from the state in which a person is born into a state of grace, and it is not merely the remission of sins but also and renewal of the inner person. Nothing that precedes justification — neither faith nor works — merits the grace of justification; the first anathematises anyone who says a person can be justified by their own works without divine grace, and the third does the same to anyone who says grace is given for . Faith is called the beginning of human salvation, the foundation and root of all justification. But the righteousness received is inherent: God does not only account a person righteous, God makes them righteous, and that righteousness can grow and can be lost through grave sin and restored through the of penance. Trent also condemned the proposition that a person can know with the certainty of faith that they are among the predestined, which is the counterpart to the Lutheran emphasis on assurance.

Set side by side, the sixteenth-century disagreement was less about whether grace comes first — both said it does — than about what justification is: a declaration about a person's standing, or a transformation of the person, and whether the two can be distinguished at all. Add to that the question of assurance, and the question of whether works done in grace can be called meritorious, and the shape of the dispute becomes visible.

The Orthodox churches were not party to this argument and it is a mistake to place them on one side of it. The Greek-speaking tradition never went through the Augustine-Pelagius controversy in the form the Latin West did, and its treatment of salvation is generally framed as , the participation of the human person in the divine life, within which the language of a forensic verdict has a much smaller role. Orthodox theologians who have engaged the Western debate — Georges Florovsky and John Meyendorff among them — have usually said that the question as posed contains assumptions they do not share. A student from that tradition should not read this lecture as asking them to choose between Wittenberg and Trent.

Three views of justification

This is a point where readers will not agree. Lutheran and Reformed theology holds that justification is a declarative act in which Christ's righteousness is imputed, distinct from the sanctification that follows. Catholic teaching, as defined at Trent, holds that justification includes renewal and that the righteousness given is inherent in the justified. Orthodox theology generally declines the framing, treating salvation as participation in the divine life rather than as a verdict to be analysed. Each of these is a considered position with texts behind it; readers who find one obviously right usually have not read the others in their own words.

3. Stendahl and the introspective conscience

The modern phase of the debate began with a historical claim rather than a doctrinal one. In an essay first delivered in 1961 and published in English in 1963 as "The Apostle Paul and the Introspective Conscience of the West," Krister Stendahl argued that Western readers had been finding in Paul an experience Paul does not describe.

His evidence was mostly negative and mostly simple. Paul, describing his life under the law, says he was blameless (Philippians 3:6). He nowhere describes a struggling conscience before his encounter with Christ; the passage usually cited for it, Romans 7, is describing something else, and Stendahl argued that reading it as autobiography is precisely the mistake. When Paul does speak about his own conscience, at 1 Corinthians 4:4, he says he is aware of nothing against himself — and then, importantly, refuses to treat that as a verdict. And the questions the letters actually address, Stendahl argued, are not "how may I find a gracious God?" but "on what terms do Gentiles belong to the people of God?" and "what has become of the promises to Israel?" Romans 9 to 11, on this reading, is not an appendix but the destination.

Stendahl's further claim was that Augustine, reading Paul through his own long interior struggle, and Luther, reading Paul through the penitential system of the late medieval church, installed a psychology in the text that the text does not contain — and that this is why Western Christianity read Romans as being about the individual before God rather than about Jews and Gentiles in one community.

The strongest reply is that Stendahl proved less than he claimed. Blamelessness in Philippians 3:6 is a claim about observable performance within a covenant that made provision for sin through sacrifice; it is not a claim to have felt no guilt, and the two are not the same measurement. Paul's language elsewhere about being the least of the apostles and unfit to be called an apostle (1 Corinthians 15:9) shows something other than serenity. And a further reply, made from a different direction, is that even if Stendahl is right about Paul's psychology, that settles nothing about the theological question: whether a person is accepted by God on the basis of an alien righteousness is not answered by determining how anxious Paul felt.

4. Sanders and covenantal nomism

E. P. Sanders's Paul and Palestinian Judaism (1977) is the most consequential book on Paul written in the twentieth century, and most of it is not about Paul. Roughly two-thirds of it is a survey of Jewish literature from about 200 BC to AD 200 — the Dead Sea Scrolls, the Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha, the Tannaitic rabbinic material — asking one question of each body of text: what is the pattern of religion here? How does a person get in, and how does a person stay in?

His answer was that these texts share a pattern he named covenantal nomism, from nomos, the Greek word for law. God chose Israel and gave the covenant by grace; the law was given within that covenant as the way of remaining in it; obedience is the response to , not the means of achieving it; and the covenant provides means of atonement for transgression. On this account, Judaism of Paul's period was not a religion in which people tried to earn salvation by accumulating obedience, and the picture of it as such — long standard in Christian scholarship, and given wide currency by Ferdinand Weber and after him Wilhelm Bousset — was constructed from selected texts read through a Reformation lens.

Two implications follow, and they should be kept separate.

The historical implication is the more secure. If the picture of Jewish legalism was wrong, then a great deal of Christian writing about Paul was arguing against an opponent that had been invented — and the history of what that invention was used for, in a Europe that produced the twentieth century's worst crime against Jews, is not a small matter. It is worth saying plainly that this correction has been broadly accepted, including by scholars who reject almost everything else in Sanders.

The exegetical implication is more contested. Sanders concluded that Paul's problem with Judaism was not that it was legalistic but, in his famous formulation, that it was not Christianity: Paul reasoned backwards from the solution (Christ) to the plight, rather than forwards from a felt problem to its answer. Many readers have found this the weakest part of the book, since it makes Paul's argument in Romans 1 to 3 a piece of retrospective rationalisation.

5. Dunn, Wright, and what "New Perspective" names

The phrase "the New Perspective on Paul" was coined by James D. G. Dunn in a lecture of that title in 1982, published in 1983. It is a label for a family of readings that accept Sanders's historical picture and then ask what Paul was arguing against, if not legalism. It is not a single position, and treating Dunn and Wright as interchangeable produces confusion.

Dunn's proposal concerns the phrase erga nomou, "works of the law," which chapter 4 of this course examined in Galatians. Dunn argued that in context the phrase does not mean human achievement in general but those observances that functioned as boundary markers between Jew and Gentile — circumcision, food laws, sabbath — the practices that ancient non-Jewish writers themselves noticed as the visible marks of Jewish identity. Paul's objection is then not to effort but to a condition of belonging that would keep the people of God ethnically bounded. Dunn found support in the Qumran document 4QMMT, a letter listing particular legal rulings and using a phrase best translated "works of the law" for them, which suggests the expression had a concrete referent rather than an abstract one.

Wright's proposal is larger and different in kind. For Wright, justification is God's declaration about who belongs to the covenant family, made in the present on the basis of faith and anticipating the verdict of the last day; the doctrine is therefore about ecclesiology as well as soteriology, about who sits at the table as well as about how a person is saved. Wright places this inside the covenantal narrative described in lecture 12-1 and insists that his position affirms grace throughout — a claim his critics dispute at the point where he speaks of a future justification in accordance with the whole life lived.

A third figure belongs here. Douglas Campbell's apocalyptic reading, mentioned in the previous lecture, is not a New Perspective position; it argues that the traditional reading of Romans 1:18 to 3:20 attributes to Paul a contractual account of salvation that Paul is in fact quoting from an opponent in order to destroy. It is a minority view and a strenuously argued one, and it shows that the field is not divided into two camps.

6. The criticism

The New Perspective has been criticised in detail, and the criticism is not a reflex. Three names matter most.

Stephen Westerholm, in Perspectives Old and New on Paul (2004), performs the useful service of reading the Reformation authors accurately before disagreeing with anyone. His central argument is that when Paul says a person is justified apart from works of the law, the argument he gives is not that boundary markers are divisive but that no flesh will be justified by the law because all have sinned (Romans 3:20, 3:23). The reason offered in the text is universal human failure, not ethnic exclusivity. Westerholm accepts a great deal of Sanders's historical picture and still concludes that Paul's own reasoning is closer to Luther's than the New Perspective allows.

Simon Gathercole, in Where Is Boasting? (2002), attacks the historical foundation directly. Examining Jewish texts from the period, he argues that while covenantal nomism describes much of the material, it does not describe all of it: there are texts in which final vindication is expected on the basis of obedience, and in which the righteous are confident of their deeds at the judgment. If so, Sanders's pattern was drawn too tightly, and Paul's polemic may have a real target after all — not a caricature of Judaism, but a strand within it.

Seyoon Kim, in Paul and the New Perspective (2002), argues from the Damascus event. In The Origin of Paul's Gospel (1981) he had contended that Paul's gospel, including his justification language, derives from the christophany itself rather than from later controversy; the later book presses the case that Dunn and Wright have made a doctrine that pervades Paul's thought into a by-product of a dispute about Gentile admission. Kim also objects, as a matter of history, that on the New Perspective it becomes hard to explain why Paul was persecuted.

Each of these criticisms is worth weighing on its own terms. Gathercole's is a historical claim, testable against the Jewish texts, and the most likely to shift the debate. Westerholm's and Kim's are exegetical, about which reading fits the argument Paul actually makes. And it should be said that the criticisms have had effect: Dunn and Wright have both restated their positions to say more clearly that they do not deny universal human sinfulness, and few now hold the New Perspective in the simple form in which it was first advertised.

Where the debate stands

This is a point where readers will not agree. Krister Stendahl held that the West read its own conscience into Paul. E. P. Sanders held that Second Temple Judaism was covenantal, not merit-based, and that justification language is not the centre of Paul's thought. James Dunn holds that "works of the law" means the identity markers of Jewish covenant membership. N. T. Wright holds that justification is a declaration of covenant membership with a present and a future aspect. Stephen Westerholm holds that the reason Paul himself gives is universal sin, and that the Reformers read him substantially correctly. Simon Gathercole holds that some Jewish texts do expect vindication on the basis of deeds, which weakens the historical premise. Seyoon Kim holds that the doctrine originates in the Damascus event rather than in the Gentile controversy. There is no consensus, and a student who tells you there is has read one side.

7. 1999: what the Joint Declaration did and did not do

On 31 October 1999, in Augsburg, representatives of the Lutheran World Federation and the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity signed the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. The World Methodist Council associated itself with it in 2006, and the Anglican Consultative Council and the World Communion of Reformed Churches later did so as well.

What it states. Its central affirmation, in paragraph 15, is that by , in faith in Christ's saving work and not because of any merit on our part, we are accepted by God and receive the Holy Spirit, who renews our hearts and equips and calls us to good works. It then works through seven disputed topics — human powerlessness, justification as forgiveness and as making righteous, faith and grace, the sinfulness of the justified, law and gospel, assurance, and the good works of the justified — and in each it states a common conviction followed by the distinct emphases each side continues to make. Its formal claim, in paragraph 41, is narrow and precise: in the light of this consensus, the condemnations of the sixteenth century do not apply to the teaching of the other party as presented in the Declaration.

What it does not state. It does not say the Reformation was unnecessary or that the sixteenth-century condemnations were baseless when issued. It does not resolve the disputed questions; it locates them within a consensus on fundamentals and says the remaining differences are of emphasis rather than church-dividing. Whether that judgment is correct is itself contested. A large group of German university theologians publicly opposed the Declaration in 1998 on the ground that it obscured real differences, and Eberhard Jüngel's criticism from the Lutheran side is the most substantial. From the Catholic side, the Official Common Statement and its annex were needed to address concerns raised by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, particularly about simul iustus et peccator. It also does not address the questions of church authority, ministry and the sacraments in which the justification dispute was embedded, and the Declaration says so. And it is a Lutheran-Catholic document; the Orthodox churches are not party to it, and neither are most of the world's evangelical bodies.

The right conclusion is neither that the argument is over nor that nothing happened. Something specific happened: two communions that anathematised each other over this doctrine stated in a signed text what they now hold in common, and listed what they do not.

8. Where this leaves a reader of Paul

Three observations, offered as the residue of the debate rather than as its resolution.

First, the texts resist every tidy scheme, and Romans 2:13 is the standing proof. Any reading of Paul must account for a sentence in which the doers of the law will be justified, standing three chapters before the sentence that a person is justified apart from works of the law. Proposed accounts include a hypothetical statement of a principle never met, a description of Gentile Christians who fulfil the law by the Spirit (looking ahead to Romans 8:4), and a genuine expectation of a final judgment according to works that Paul never abandoned. Each has serious defenders.

Second, no participant in this debate holds that human effort earns God's favour. That is worth saying because the debate is often reported as though someone did. Trent denies it, Luther denies it, Sanders says Second Temple Judaism denied it, and Dunn and Wright deny it. The disagreements are about the nature of the divine act, the referent of a Greek phrase, the shape of first-century Judaism, and the relation between the verdict now and the judgment at the end.

Third, and this is the reason the course places this lecture at the end rather than the beginning: the way each tradition reads justification is bound up with how it understands the church, the sacraments, and what a human being is. That is why five centuries of argument have not been settled by a better lexicon. Anyone who thinks the dispute can be closed by a word study has not yet found the actual question.

The Justification Debate: Five Centuries, Four Moves Each move answers the one before it. None of them cancels the one before it. 1517-46 Luther The righteousness of God is given, not demanded. Received by faith; imputed, not earned. Simul iustus et peccator. Read from Romans 1:17 in a penitential system of graded satisfactions. 1547 Trent, session 6 Grace precedes and merits nothing; faith is the root. But justification renews as well as remits, and the righteousness given is inherent, can grow, and can be lost. Assurance of election is denied. 1963 Stendahl The guilt-searching conscience is Augustine's and Luther's, not Paul's: Philippians 3:6 says blameless. Paul's question is how Gentiles belong, so Romans 9-11 is the destination, not an appendix. 1977 Sanders: covenantal nomism Second Temple Judaism: election by grace, law as the way of staying in, atonement provided. Not a religion of earning salvation. The opponent Christian scholarship had assumed was not there. 1983- New Perspective Dunn: works of the law = boundary markers (circumcision, food, sabbath); 4QMMT. Wright: covenant membership, present and future. The criticism Westerholm: Paul's stated reason is universal sin. Gathercole: some Jewish texts do expect vindication by deeds. Kim: the doctrine begins at Damascus. 1999 Joint Declaration (Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church, Augsburg) A stated consensus on grace and faith; the sixteenth-century condemnations declared not to apply to the other party's teaching as here presented. It lists the remaining differences rather than settling them. Not party to it: the Orthodox churches, which frame salvation as theosis, and most evangelical bodies. Nobody on this timeline holds that human effort earns God's favour. That is not what the five centuries were about.

The timeline is drawn as a sequence of replies rather than as a progress. Each move was made because the previous one had left something unaccounted for, and none of them removed what the earlier ones had seen. The shaded box on the right is placed level with the New Perspective rather than after it, because the criticism was contemporaneous and the two have developed in conversation.

6. Further Reading

  • Martin Luther, preface to the Latin writings (1545), in Luther's Works, vol. 34 (Philadelphia: Muhlenberg, 1960). His own account of the Romans 1:17 breakthrough, written near the end of his life and therefore to be read as recollection.
  • Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent, session 6, in H. J. Schroeder, trans., Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent (St. Louis: Herder, 1941). Short, and repeatedly misdescribed by people who have not read it.
  • Krister Stendahl, "The Apostle Paul and the Introspective Conscience of the West," Harvard Theological Review 56 (1963), reprinted in Paul among Jews and Gentiles (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1976). The essay that began the modern phase.
  • E. P. Sanders, Paul and Palestinian Judaism (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1977). Long; read the concluding sections on covenantal nomism first, then sample the surveys.
  • James D. G. Dunn, The New Perspective on Paul, rev. ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008). Collects the 1983 lecture with later restatements and replies to critics.
  • N. T. Wright, Justification: God's Plan and Paul's Vision (Downers Grove: IVP Academic, 2009). Wright's own summary, written in reply to John Piper's criticism, so both sides are visible in it.
  • Stephen Westerholm, Perspectives Old and New on Paul: The "Lutheran" Paul and His Critics (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004). The fairest survey of the whole argument by a participant in it.
  • Simon J. Gathercole, Where Is Boasting? Early Jewish Soteriology and Paul's Response in Romans 1-5 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2002). The historical challenge to covenantal nomism.
  • Seyoon Kim, Paul and the New Perspective: Second Thoughts on the Origin of Paul's Gospel (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2002). The case that the doctrine originates in the Damascus christophany.
  • Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000), with the Official Common Statement and Annex. Short enough to read in one sitting, and it should be read rather than summarised.
  • Joseph A. Fitzmyer, Romans, Anchor Bible 33 (New York: Doubleday, 1993). A major Catholic commentary that treats the Pauline righteousness language at length.

In short

  • Luther's breakthrough on Romans 1:17 reinterpreted "the righteousness of God" from the standard by which God condemns to the righteousness God gives and receives by faith, producing the formula simul iustus et peccator — righteous in God's verdict, still a sinner in observable fact.
  • The Council of Trent's sixth session (1547) denied that anyone can merit the grace of justification (canons 1 and 3) while also holding that justification is not only remission of sins but a real, inherent renewal that can grow or be lost — the actual point of division from Luther's imputed, external righteousness.
  • E. P. Sanders's Paul and Palestinian Judaism (1977) surveyed Second Temple Jewish texts and named the pattern "covenantal nomism": obedience to the law as the response to a covenant already given by grace, not the means of earning entry into it — overturning the older caricature of first-century Judaism as legalistic.
  • James Dunn's New Perspective reading of "works of the law" (supported by the Qumran document 4QMMT) takes the phrase to mean boundary markers like circumcision, food laws, and sabbath rather than human effort generally; Stephen Westerholm countered that Paul's own stated reason in Romans 3:20 and 3:23 is universal human sin, not ethnic exclusivity.
  • The 1999 Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church, Augsburg) states that the sixteenth-century condemnations do not apply to the other party's teaching as presented in the document, but explicitly does not resolve seven listed disputed topics, and the Orthodox churches and most evangelical bodies are not party to it at all.

If you remember nothing else from this lecture: Luther read Romans 1:17's "righteousness of God" as a gift received by faith rather than a standard of judgment, producing simul iustus et peccator; the Council of Trent answered in 1547 that grace precedes and merits nothing, but that justification is a real, inherent renewal rather than only an external declaration. Krister Stendahl's 1963 essay argued the West's guilt-searching reading of Paul was Augustine's and Luther's, not Paul's own (Philippians 3:6: "blameless"), and E. P. Sanders's 1977 covenantal nomism overturned the picture of Second Temple Judaism as legalistic, launching the New Perspective of James Dunn ("works of the law" as boundary markers, supported by 4QMMT) and N. T. Wright (justification as covenant membership) — met by serious criticism from Westerholm, Gathercole, and Kim. The 1999 Joint Declaration between Lutherans and Catholics states a real, specific consensus on grace while explicitly listing what remains unresolved, and Romans 2:13's "the doers of the law will be justified" remains, three chapters before Romans 3:28, the standing proof that no scheme fits every verse.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Read the sixth session of the Council of Trent and identify three statements in it that a Lutheran could sign without qualification. Then identify the sentence at which the agreement stops, and say precisely what it turns on.
  • Stendahl argued from Philippians 3:6 that Paul had no troubled conscience. Blamelessness there is a claim about performance within a covenant that provided sacrifice for sin. Does that distinction rescue Stendahl's argument, weaken it, or leave it untouched?
  • Explain covenantal nomism to someone who has never heard the term, in five sentences, without using the words "legalism" or "grace."
  • Gathercole's objection is that Sanders's pattern does not cover all the Jewish evidence. Suppose he is right about a minority of texts. What exactly would follow for the New Perspective, and what would not follow?
  • Romans 2:13 says the doers of the law will be justified. Set out the three main ways of reading it described in the lecture, and say which one you find least strained and why.
  • The Joint Declaration says the remaining differences are differences of emphasis rather than church-dividing. What would it take to show that a difference of emphasis has become a difference of substance? Answer in general terms first, then apply your answer to the question of assurance.
  • Why does this lecture insist that the shape of the justification dispute is tied to the doctrine of the church and the sacraments? Test the claim: pick one of the seven topics the Declaration treats and show whether it can be settled without reference to either.

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.