Lecture 6-1: Whose Church Is It?
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Culture Is Like an Iceberg
- Lecture 1-2: The Glasses You Cannot See
- Lecture 1-3: Maps of Difference, and Their Limits
- Lecture 1-4: Observe Before You Judge
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: One Strange Scene, Three Columns
- Lecture 2-1: Why Learn the Local Language
- Lecture 2-2: How to Learn Sounds and Speech
- Lecture 2-3: Working With Interpreters and Translations
- Lecture 2-4: Speaking as a Guest, Listening as a Learner
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Your First Fifty Sentences
- Lecture 3-1: Arriving as a Guest and a Learner
- Lecture 3-2: Respect, Honour and Authority
- Lecture 3-3: Money, Gifts and Unequal Power
- Lecture 3-4: Friendship, Boundaries and Keeping People Safe
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Relationships
- Lecture 4-1: Culture Shock and the Curve of Adjustment
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I Here? Identity and Belonging
- Lecture 4-3: Lowering Expectations, Starting Small
- Lecture 4-4: Staying in Touch With Home Without Leaving Here
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Week of Adjustment Notes
- Lecture 5-1: How Misunderstandings Are Made
- Lecture 5-2: Anger, Apology and Forgiveness
- Lecture 5-3: Teams, Criticism and Working Together
- Lecture 5-4: When It Is More Than a Misunderstanding
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Misunderstanding, Three Views
Five weeks of this course have been about the person who stands at the edge of another people's life: learning to read, to speak, to befriend, to adjust and to repair. This week the question changes. What is the stranger's place when the people already have a church?
That question has two askers. The worker who arrives asks it, often without noticing that it is a question at all. The local pastor, priest, elder or lay leader asks it too, usually in silence, when a visitor with money, training or a famous name walks into the church hall. Both of them need the same first answer, and it is a short one: the local church belongs to Christ, and under him it is led by the people who live in it. The outsider is a guest in that house.
This lecture builds that answer from Scripture, names the roles an outsider can honestly hold, and looks at what to learn before doing anything. One point in it is disputed between honest readers, and it is stated fairly.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain why the local church, and not the visiting worker, holds the authority over the local church's life.
- Describe what a newcomer should find out about the local church before proposing anything.
- Name four roles an outsider can hold and say what each one asks and does not ask.
- State fairly the disagreement over how far an outside body should lead.
- Describe the same arrival from the side of a local leader receiving an outsider.
Then it seemed good to the apostles and the elders, with the whole assembly, to choose men out of their company, and send them to Antioch with Paul and Barnabas: Judas called Barsabbas, and Silas, chief men among the brothers." — Acts 15:22
World English Bible
So then you are no longer strangers and foreigners, but you are fellow citizens with the saints, and of the household of God," — Ephesians 2:19
WEB
in whom you also are built together for a habitation of God in the Spirit." — Ephesians 2:22
WEB
The first passage shows a decision made by many people together, with the local churches on both sides taking part. The second and third say who the church is: not a branch office of any one nation, but a household in which a stranger has become a fellow citizen. In the second passage the word "you" is plural. The building is built together.
1. First, find out what is already there
Imagine a worker named Mara, who has come from the invented country of Veltra to the town of Kest, where the Daran people live (an invented example). Mara has a degree, a sending organisation and a plan: a weekly programme for young people in the church hall. She has not asked whether the young people already meet. They do. Every Thursday a tailor named Orrin gathers them in his shop, teaches them to sing, and walks the younger ones home. Nobody has called it a programme. Nobody wrote it down.
Mara's plan was made in a distant office from a distant picture. The picture said: there is a gap here. The gap was in the picture, not in Kest.
This happens often enough that it deserves a rule. Before you propose anything, learn what the church is already doing, who does it, and who gave them the right to do it. Much of that work is quiet. Much of it is done by people with no title: the woman who visits the sick, the old man who keeps the building, the teenager who translates for the elderly. If you cannot name five things the church does well, you have not yet looked.
Looking has a posture. It is the posture of lecture 1-4, "observe before you judge", applied to a congregation. Attend as a member would. Sit where you are placed. Ask what the church has prayed for in the last year. Ask what it has tried and given up, and why. A story of a failed attempt is often more useful than any report of success, because it shows where the real difficulty lies.
2. The authority of local leaders
Every church has someone whose word counts: a pastor, a priest, a bishop, a board of elders, a council, a respected grandmother who is not on any list. Traditions order this differently, and this course does not choose between them. What it asks is simple: find out who actually decides, and go to them first.
Two mistakes are common. The first is to go straight to the people whose English is good, or who are young, or who are friendly to foreigners, because they are easy to talk to. They may be gifted people. They may also be people with little standing in the congregation, and a plan that begins with them may meet quiet resistance later. The second mistake is to treat the senior leader as an obstacle to be managed, rather than as the person who carries responsibility before God and the congregation for this flock.
Scripture is clear that leadership in the church is a form of service and not a form of ownership. Peter writes to elders that they should shepherd the flock "not under compulsion, but voluntarily, not for dishonest gain, but willingly" and not "lording it over those entrusted to you." That is said to local leaders about their own people. It is no less true of the outside worker, who has an even smaller claim to rule a flock that is not his. Yet the same text tells the local leader something: the flock is entrusted to you. Responsibility is real, and it is yours.
3. What Acts 15 shows
Acts 15 is a good passage to hold in mind, as long as we read it without adding to it. Some men came down from Judea to Antioch and taught that the non-Jewish believers could not be saved unless they were circumcised. Paul and Barnabas disagreed, strongly. The Antioch church did not settle it alone, and the visitors did not settle it for them. The church appointed Paul, Barnabas and others to go to Jerusalem, where "the apostles and the elders were gathered together to see about this matter."
After "much discussion", Barnabas and Paul reported what God had done among the nations, and the council reached a judgment. Then comes the line that matters for this lecture: the decision "seemed good to the apostles and the elders, with the whole assembly." The letter that went out was sent with chosen men, so that the Antioch believers would hear the decision from people they could trust, and not only read it. And when it was read, "they rejoiced over the encouragement."
Notice what the story does not show. It does not show a distant centre issuing orders to a passive field. It does not show a field church doing as it likes with no one to answer to. It shows two communities, each with its own standing, who needed one another, who spoke plainly, and who reached a conclusion together under the guidance of the Spirit. We should be careful not to make the passage into a full theory of church government. It does not give us that. It does show a pattern of shared judgement that outside workers and local leaders can both learn from.
4. The household, and what an outsider is in it
Ephesians 2:19-22 describes the church as a household and a building. Strangers and foreigners have become fellow citizens. This is a strong statement, and it cuts two ways.
It cuts for the outsider: you are not a permanent visitor in the household of God. You are a member of the same body, and your gifts are welcome. Do not be shy about what you can bring.
It cuts against the outsider's claim to be the owner: the household was there before you came, and it will be there after you leave. You do not hold the title deed. In Ephesians the building is "built together", and the foundation is the apostles and prophets with Christ as the cornerstone. No nation owns that foundation.
5. Four names for the outsider's role
Because the outsider is neither an owner nor a stranger, it helps to choose a name for the role and to say it aloud. Four names are common. Each one asks something different.
Adviser. Someone who gives an opinion when asked. An adviser is honest, and also accepts that advice may be declined without offence. The danger is an adviser who gives opinions nobody asked for, or who grows quietly angry when advice is not followed.
Partner. Someone who shares a task as an equal in dignity, though not always in resources. A partner has something to give and something to receive. The danger is that "partner" becomes a polite word for a relationship in which one side pays and the other side obeys. If you call yourself a partner, ask whether the local side can say no, and whether they ever have.
Supporter. Someone who gives money, prayer, materials or presence for a work that belongs to others. A supporter stays in the background by design. The danger is a supporter who attaches strings, or who requires reports that the local church finds heavy and unfamiliar.
Worker. Someone who does a defined job inside a work the church leads: teaching, building, translating, caring for the sick. A worker comes under the direction of those who lead the work. The danger is a worker who continues to take direction from a distant office more than from the local leaders they live among.
None of these names is superior. A single person may hold two of them at once. What matters is that the local leaders know which name you are using and agree that it fits, and that you use the same name in your reports home.
6. Where the local side stands
Now the same arrival from the other side. A local leader has seen outsiders come before. Some stayed and became friends. Some stayed a year, started a project, left, and the project quietly stopped. Some brought gifts the church could not return. Some asked the leader to sign a form in a language he read slowly. Some were kind and clumsy; some were kind and wise.
A local leader often cannot say no. A guest is a guest, and a guest with resources is a delicate matter. Because of this, an outsider cannot take a polite "yes" as a final answer. A yes given from courtesy, from hope of help, or from the wish not to offend may carry no promise at all. This is not dishonesty. It is the same courtesy a good host shows. The outsider's task is to make it easy to say "not yet", and to notice when it has been said without words.
A good local leader also has duties here. Hospitality is not the same as saying yes to everything. A leader who welcomes every offer, because it brings money or recognition, may carry the congregation into debts of obligation it cannot meet. And a leader who is open about what the church wants and does not want gives the visitor the most helpful gift available: a clear answer. Some outsiders have been quietly grateful for a local pastor who said, in the first month, "We do not need that, but we do need this."
History belongs in the room too. In many places, the arrival of foreign workers has been tied up with periods of political or economic power that were not equal, and those memories still shape how a guest is received and what is expected of one. That history is real. It is no reason for suspicion of any particular person, and it is no reason to pretend that it did not happen. It is a reason to be slow, to listen, and to let trust be earned.
7. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: how far an outside body should lead. Some outside organisations hold that when they fund and staff a work, they carry responsibility to their donors, to the law and to the people served, and that this responsibility gives them a real part in how the work is run. They fear waste, abuse of funds and harm to vulnerable people, and they have seen all of these happen when oversight was thin. Some local churches hold, with equal force, that the work belongs to them, that it is their neighbours who are served, and that a body which is not present in the town every day cannot see what is needed. They have seen outside plans that failed because the planners were absent, and they have felt the weight of being treated as a field rather than a church. Both positions come from care, and neither side is acting in bad faith.
This course does not settle the matter by naming one side right. It asks for less than either position demands, and for more than either position often gives. Local leaders decide the life of the local church: its worship, its teaching, its and who serves in it. Outside partners offer, and ask, and name plainly what they can give and cannot give, and which conditions are matters of law, safety and honest accounting. Conditions of that last kind are legitimate when they are open, written, agreed in advance and applied in a way the local side can understand. What is not legitimate is an unwritten wish that arrives later as a quiet pressure.
8. What to carry away
If you are the one who has come: look first, ask who decides, choose your name, say it aloud, and let a "not yet" be easy to give.
If you are the one who receives: say what the church is already doing, say plainly what it needs and does not need, and accept that an honest "no" to an offer is a gift to both sides.
For both: the church is Christ's household, and nobody present is its owner.
Diagram 1. Four names for the outsider's role
Diagram 2. Two arrivals, side by side
| The one who arrives | The one who receives |
|---|---|
| Asks: what is already being done here, and by whom? | Says: here is what we do, and here is what we do not yet do. |
| Asks: who decides, in practice? | Says plainly who decides, and who does not. |
| Chooses a name for the role and says it aloud | Says whether the name fits |
| Makes "not yet" easy to give | Gives an honest "no" or "not yet", even when a yes would bring help |
| Names what can and cannot be given | Names what is needed and what is not |
In short
- Before proposing anything, learn what the local church already does, who does it, and who gave them the right.
- Find out who actually decides in the local church and go to them first, not only to the most friendly or fluent.
- Acts 15 shows two communities deciding together with the whole assembly; it does not give a full theory of church government.
- Four honest names for the outsider's role are adviser, partner, supporter and worker; the local leaders should know which one is meant.
- A polite yes may not be a yes. Make "not yet" easy to give, and give it honestly when you are the host.
- Local leaders decide the life of the local church; outside partners offer, ask, and name what they can and cannot give.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| First task for a newcomer | Learn what the church already does, who does it, and who decides. |
| Acts 15, in one line | Two communities, much discussion, one judgment reached with the whole assembly. |
| Four names for an outsider | Adviser, partner, supporter, worker; say which, and ask if it fits. |
| Who decides the church's life | The local leaders; outside partners offer, ask and say what they can give. |
One sentence to remember The church is Christ's household, and the stranger is a guest in it, welcome and not the owner.
This week's action Write down five things a local church near you already does well, and who does them, before you suggest a sixth.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- If you were to arrive tomorrow in a church that is not your own, what five good things would you look for before suggesting anything?
- Which of the four names for the outsider's role is closest to the role you hold, or are likely to hold? Would the local leaders choose the same name?
- Why might a polite "yes" from a host mean less than it seems to? Have you ever given one yourself?
- State the disagreement over how far an outside body should lead in the way each side would be glad to hear it stated. What would you add?
- Acts 15 does not give a full theory of church government. What does it still teach about how two communities decide together?
- From the local side: what would you want to say to a visiting worker in the first month, and what makes it hard to say it?