Lecture 6-2: Sharing Decisions, Money and Leadership
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Culture Is Like an Iceberg
- Lecture 1-2: The Glasses You Cannot See
- Lecture 1-3: Maps of Difference, and Their Limits
- Lecture 1-4: Observe Before You Judge
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: One Strange Scene, Three Columns
- Lecture 2-1: Why Learn the Local Language
- Lecture 2-2: How to Learn Sounds and Speech
- Lecture 2-3: Working With Interpreters and Translations
- Lecture 2-4: Speaking as a Guest, Listening as a Learner
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Your First Fifty Sentences
- Lecture 3-1: Arriving as a Guest and a Learner
- Lecture 3-2: Respect, Honour and Authority
- Lecture 3-3: Money, Gifts and Unequal Power
- Lecture 3-4: Friendship, Boundaries and Keeping People Safe
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Relationships
- Lecture 4-1: Culture Shock and the Curve of Adjustment
- Lecture 4-2: Who Am I Here? Identity and Belonging
- Lecture 4-3: Lowering Expectations, Starting Small
- Lecture 4-4: Staying in Touch With Home Without Leaving Here
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Week of Adjustment Notes
- Lecture 5-1: How Misunderstandings Are Made
- Lecture 5-2: Anger, Apology and Forgiveness
- Lecture 5-3: Teams, Criticism and Working Together
- Lecture 5-4: When It Is More Than a Misunderstanding
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Misunderstanding, Three Views
Lecture 6-1 said that the local church belongs to Christ and is led by the people in it. That sentence is easy to agree with. It is much harder to live by when a decision has to be made, a bill has to be paid, or a leader has to be chosen. This lecture goes to those three places, because they are where partnership is either real or only a word.
The central claim of the course applies here with force. Entering as a learner is not only a posture for the first year. It is a way of handling power for as long as you stay. Money and training are real gifts, and they also make an unequal relationship, whether the giver wishes it or not. The task is to be honest about that inequality and to work, patiently, so that it shrinks.
This lecture follows the questions in order: who decides, what money does to a decision, how leaders are raised and responsibility handed over, and how a church becomes able to carry its own life. It also asks what different churches bring to one another, without ranking any of them.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Explain who should decide, and how an outsider can tell when a decision is really being shared.
- Describe how funding and foreign status can buy a decision without anyone intending it.
- Explain, from Titus 1:5 and 2 Timothy 2:2, how leaders are appointed locally and how responsibility is handed on.
- Distinguish a dependence that serves a church for a time from one that keeps it small.
- Say what the same arrangement looks like from the side of a local leader who is offered resources.
I left you in Crete for this reason, that you would set in order the things that were lacking, and appoint elders in every city, as I directed you;" — Titus 1:5
World English Bible
The things which you have heard from me among many witnesses, commit the same to faithful men, who will be able to teach others also." — 2 Timothy 2:2
WEB
For this is not that others may be eased and you distressed, but for equality. Your abundance at this present time supplies their lack, that their abundance also may become a supply for your lack; that there may be equality." — 2 Corinthians 8:13-14
WEB
But Peter said to him, “May your silver perish with you, because you thought you could obtain the gift of God with money!" — Acts 8:20
WEB
Titus and Timothy show leadership being passed along in a line of trust. The text from Corinthians is about churches giving to one another, and it asks for "equality" in both directions. Acts 8:20 is a hard saying about a man who thought that money could buy a spiritual office. It is not about every gift. It is a warning that a gift can be turned into a purchase.
1. Who actually decides
Suppose a worker named Mara and a local board in the town of Kest meet to plan a children's reading project (an invented example). Mara has drawn up a plan. She presents it. The board nods. The chairman, an older man named Tobe Rasel, says, "It is good." Mara goes home glad.
Three months later almost nothing has happened. What went wrong?
Possibly nothing went wrong in the room. A board that has been shown a finished plan by a guest with funding has been given a very narrow choice: accept or refuse. Refusal costs something. It may offend the guest, lose the funding, or look ungrateful. Acceptance costs nothing in that moment. So the board accepted. But accepting a plan in a meeting is not the same as owning it afterwards, and people do not carry out what they do not own.
A decision is shared when four things are true.
- The local side helped form the question, not only the answer. They said what the problem was, in their words.
- More than one plan was on the table, or at least a plan that could have been changed in a real way.
- No one was shamed for objecting, and a "no" was one of the choices that was truly open.
- The people who will carry the work were in the conversation, not only the people with titles.
Notice that these four tests apply to the outsider as well. A local leader who makes every decision alone, without the congregation, has also failed the test. A partnership has to ask questions in both directions.
There is a practical habit that serves all four tests. Come to the meeting with less than a finished plan: a list of what you have seen, a few questions, and one or two rough ideas you are happy to drop. It feels less professional. It is more honest, and it gives the room something to do.
2. What money does to a decision
Money is not evil, and a church that refuses all help may suffer for it. The Bible has no shyness about one church supporting another. Paul gathered an offering from several churches for believers in need, and in 2 Corinthians 8 he asks for a mutual flow, "that there may be equality", with each side supplying the other's lack at different times.
But the same money can do three things nobody intended.
It can buy a decision. If a church needs a roof and an outside body offers the money for the roof together with a new programme, the church may agree to the programme in order to get the roof. Nobody was forced. The pressure was real, and it came from the shape of the situation.
It can change who is listened to. The person who writes the funding report becomes more important than the person who sits with the dying. Leaders who are good at forms and at English may rise above leaders who are good at people.
It can change what the church wants. A congregation that has never thought of employing a full-time youth worker may start to want one because the foreigner arrived with a model that has one. It is not wrong to want a youth worker. It is a question of whether the want arose from the local church's own life or from the funder's picture.
Acts 8 shows the old, blunt form of this: a man offered money for a spiritual office, and Peter refused him in the strongest words. The lesson is not that gifts to the church are suspect. It is that money cannot buy what belongs to God and to the body: standing, authority, a decision. Where a funder's money starts to behave as though it could buy these, something is wrong, however polite the language is.
What can an outside partner do? Say aloud, in the first meetings, how the money may shape things. Write down what the money is for and what it is not for. Separate gifts that come with legal or safety conditions from gifts that come with preferences, and call the second kind by their true name. Do not hide the budget from the local leaders whose church it affects. Keep accounts that a local treasurer can read. Follow the written rules of your own organisation and the law of the place, and accept that a local church has the right to say, "We would rather not take it on those terms." Nothing in this lecture gives a sum, a tax rule or a legal instruction. Those depend on place and on your organisation, and you should ask a qualified person.
What can a local leader do? Say what the money would change, not only what it would add. Ask what happens when it ends. Ask who would report to whom. A leader who asks these questions politely is not being ungrateful. She is protecting the church's future.
3. Raising up leaders
Titus 1:5 is short and important. Paul left Titus in Crete "to set in order the things that were lacking, and appoint elders in every city." Notice the shape of this. Titus is the outsider, the delegate, the trained worker. His task is not to rule Crete for ever. It is to help set things in order and to see that elders are appointed in each town from the people who live there. The same pattern appears in Acts 14:23, where Paul and Barnabas appointed elders in every assembly, with prayer and fasting, and then commended them to the Lord.
2 Timothy 2:2 describes a chain: Paul to Timothy, Timothy to "faithful men", and those to "others also." That is four links in a single sentence. Each link is meant to be able to teach the next. The measure of success is not what the first link did. It is whether the fourth link exists.
From these two texts several habits follow.
Look for faithful people, not impressive ones. The text says "faithful men who will be able to teach". It does not say famous, educated, rich or fluent in the visitor's language. A church can lose years by promoting the person who speaks best to foreigners.
Let the church choose. An outsider may offer observations and may say, honestly, what worries them. The appointment belongs to the church, in whatever way its tradition appoints. Catholic and Orthodox readers will think of bishops and ordination; others of elders and congregations. The principle is the same: the choice is made inside the body.
Teach in a way that can be passed on. Do you teach with a tool, a building or a language that the next teacher will not have? If so, you are teaching a chain that breaks at the second link. Ask of each thing you do: Could a local person do this next year with what is here?
Hand over early, and in steps. Do not wait until you are leaving. A local person who has carried a small task well for a year can carry a larger one next year. Stay nearby while they do it. Praise in public what is done well and say what could be improved in private, with the courtesy that lecture 3-2 described.
Plan for the day you are not needed. A good sign in a partnership is that the outsider is slowly being asked to do less.
4. Self-support and dependence
A church that depends entirely on outside money is in a fragile position, and a church that refuses all outside help may be proud or may simply be poor. Neither extreme is a rule. The useful question is not "Is this church dependent?" but "Is the dependence moving, or fixed?"
Some dependence is healthy and temporary: a church recovering from a flood, a young church without a trained teacher, a church in a region where almost nobody has paid work. Support given in these conditions, openly and with an agreed way of reducing it, helps a church stand.
Dependence becomes harmful when it is permanent without anyone having decided so, when the church cannot say no to the giver, or when the congregation has stopped giving because "the foreigners pay." A congregation that gives its own small offering, even of food, time or labour, keeps its own dignity and its own say. It also learns what its church costs, and that knowledge is part of owning it. A gift from the poor is not a smaller gift. The widow's two coins in the Gospels are noticed because of what they cost her.
From the local side, there is a matter of pride and of honesty. A church that has learned to give in kind, in labour and in hospitality should say so, and outsiders should count it. It may not appear in a budget, but it is part of the church's real wealth.
5. What churches bring to one another
Paul's phrase in 2 Corinthians 8:14 is that an abundance in one place supplies a lack in another, "that their abundance also may become a supply for your lack." It runs both ways, in time and in kind.
Here we must be careful. It is easy to say "churches in the West are wealthy but spiritually dry, and churches in the South are poor but alive." Or the reverse. Both sentences are the kind of ranking this course refuses. Churches vary within every region. A rich church may have a deep life of prayer. A poor church may be torn by quarrels. A city church and a village church in the same country may differ more than two churches that are a continent apart.
What can be said honestly, in the form of examples (invented): a church in the town of Kest has a long habit of sitting with the bereaved for a week, and a visiting worker learns how to grieve with others. A church in the worker's home country has a good system for training teachers and shares it, if asked. A church in a third place has been through persecution or poverty and knows things about waiting that the other two do not. None of these is a ranking. Each is a particular strength in a particular church, held with thanks.
The practical question is: what can they bring to us, and what can we bring to them? If the second question is the only one asked, the relationship is a one-way pipe. If the first is asked and received with respect, it becomes a partnership in the sense of Philippians 1:5, shared work "from the first day until now."
6. The same story from the local leader's side
A local pastor, whom we may call Ansel Dorrow in the invented valley of Sunmere, is offered a large gift by a visiting organisation. He knows the gift would bring a new roof, a bus and a training programme. He also knows that the programme is not what his people had asked for, and that the organisation will want reports in a language his treasurer finds hard.
He has four honest choices. He can accept it all and manage the cost. He can accept some and decline the rest, explaining why. He can ask for time. Or he can say no. What makes the situation hard is not the choice but the sense that any answer other than yes will be heard as ingratitude.
So the burden falls on the donor to make the other answers safe. A donor who says, "If you choose the roof only, we will be glad", has changed the conversation. A donor who has already printed the programme leaflets has not.
The burden also falls on the leader to say, kindly and early, what he needs. A leader who accepts what he does not want, hoping to renegotiate later, builds a misunderstanding that can last for years.
Diagram 1. Where the pressure comes from, and where a decision can be shared
Diagram 2. Questions to ask before a gift is accepted or offered
| The one who offers asks | The one who receives asks |
|---|---|
| What is this for, and what is it not for? | What would this change, not only add? |
| What conditions come from law and safety, and what are only preferences? | What happens when it ends? |
| Is the budget open to the local leaders? | Who would report to whom, and in what language? |
| Can they say no, or part, or not yet, without cost? | Can we say what we truly need, early and kindly? |
| Could a local person do this next year with what is here? | Do our own people give something, even small, to this work? |
In short
- A decision is shared when the local side named the problem, a no was truly open, and the people who carry the work were present.
- Money can buy a decision, change who is listened to, and shape what a church wants, even when no one intends it.
- Titus 1:5 and 2 Timothy 2:2 show elders appointed locally and teaching handed on in links; the fourth link is the measure.
- Dependence is harmful when it is fixed, when a church cannot say no, or when its own people stop giving.
- Churches vary inside every region; speak of particular strengths in particular churches, never of one region as more alive.
- A donor must make "no" and "not yet" safe to say; a local leader should say early and kindly what the church needs.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A shared decision | Local side names the problem, more than one plan, a real no, carriers present. |
| What money can do | Buy a decision, change who is heard, shape what a church wants. |
| Titus 1:5, 2 Timothy 2:2 | Elders appointed in each town; teaching committed to faithful people who teach others. |
| Healthy dependence | Open, temporary, with an agreed way of reducing it; the church still gives something. |
One sentence to remember Money and training are real gifts, and they build an unequal relationship, so say so, and work for the day you are asked to do less.
This week's action Write down one decision in your own community or ministry and mark which of the four tests of a shared decision it passed.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a meeting where a plan was presented and approved. How could you tell whether the decision was shared or only accepted?
- How can money change who is listened to in a church, even when nobody means it to?
- Read Titus 1:5 and 2 Timothy 2:2 together. What do they ask of the outsider, and what do they leave to the local church?
- What is the difference between dependence that is moving and dependence that is fixed? Can you give an example from any community you know?
- Why is it a mistake to say that churches of one region are more alive than churches of another? What can be said instead?
- If you were a local pastor offered a gift that did not fit your people's needs, how would you say so? What would make it easier?