Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Two Commentary Extracts
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Exegesis Is, and in What Order We Work
- Lecture 1-2: Choosing the Passage and Marking Its Edges
- Lecture 1-3: Translations Side by Side
- Lecture 1-4: Reading the Footnotes: Where Manuscripts and Translators Differ
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The First Reading Note
- Lecture 2-1: The Literary Context and the Flow of the Book
- Lecture 2-2: Drawing the Structure
- Lecture 2-3: Genre: Questions to Ask
- Lecture 2-4: Signals Inside a Passage: Repetition, Contrast, Turning Points
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Structure
- Lecture 3-1: How Far to Go with a Word
- Lecture 3-2: Grammar and the Sentence
- Lecture 3-3: Where Translations Divide, Where Readings Divide
- Lecture 3-4: Figures of Speech and Idiom
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Word and One Translation Difference
- Lecture 4-1: Using Historical, Cultural and Geographic Background
- Lecture 4-2: Reading Within the Canon
- Lecture 4-3: Other Traditions' Readings
- Lecture 4-4: Choosing and Comparing Commentaries
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Two Commentary Extracts
- Lecture 5-1: Writing the Main Point in One Sentence
- Lecture 5-2: The Theological Check
- Lecture 5-3: From Exegesis to a Bridge to Today
- Lecture 5-4: Writing a One-Page Exegetical Summary
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Page
This is the fourth Practice Lab of the course. Like the others, it asks you to do something rather than agree with something.
The task is small. Read two short commentary extracts on Isaiah 40:1-11 that read the passage differently, and set them side by side in a table: what is the same, what is different, where the evidence divides, and what you judge. You will not be asked to name a real author, a real book or a real person, and you will not be asked to judge anyone.
Lectures 4-1 to 4-4 gave you three kinds of background, a way of rating links between passages, a way of listening to other traditions and a way of choosing and comparing commentaries. Knowing these is not the same as using them. Today you use them once, slowly, on two extracts, so that when a real commentary is in your hands you have already compared two once.
이 19분으로 얻는 것
- Fill in the four-part comparison table for two commentary extracts.
- Find the place where the evidence divides between two readings of one passage.
- Spot a conjecture that has been written as if it were a fact, and say what would be needed to support it.
- Write a short judgement that gives your reason and states the disagreement openly.
- Explain the four promises of privacy that govern every lab, and keep them in a group.
Comfort, comfort my people,” says your God. “Speak comfortably to Jerusalem; and call out to her that her warfare is accomplished, that her iniquity is pardoned, that she has received of Yahweh’s hand double for all her sins.” — Isaiah 40:1-2
World English Bible
Where there is no wise guidance, the nation falls, but in the multitude of counselors there is victory. — Proverbs 11:14
WEB
The first passage is the opening of the practice text, on which both extracts comment. The second is a reminder that there is safety in many advisers, which is the habit this lab practises. The full text of Isaiah 40:1-11 is printed in lecture 4-1.
1. What this lab is for
A lab is not an examination. It is a place to try something with nothing at stake. A musician plays scales; a surgeon works on a model. You are practising a way of reading other people's reading, so that on the day when two real commentaries disagree you do not have to learn the method at the same time.
2. Four promises of privacy
Before any lab begins, whether you are alone or in a group, hold these four promises. If you are leading a group, say them aloud.
- Nobody reads what you write. The sheet is yours. It is not collected, copied or shown.
- Nothing is marked or graded. There is no right answer to be found. There is only an honest one.
- You may pass on any part. If a question feels too close, skip it. Passing is not failing.
- The leader fills in a sheet too. A leader who watches while others write turns the room into an examination.
If you record yourself speaking, only you watch the recording.
And one more rule, which concerns the form itself: never write the name of a real person, congregation or organisation on it. Write "Commentary A" and "Commentary B", and describe each by kind, not by author or publisher. The purpose of the sheet is to look at how two readings differ, not to collect judgements about anyone.
If the lab brings a harm to light. If, while you work, you find that something you remember or have read is really about abuse, violence, a threat or danger to someone, stop the lab. It was never meant to hold that. Speak this week to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person. If there is danger now, call the local emergency number. A lab can wait; a person cannot.
3. Three ways into the lab
Choose the one that fits you. Any one is enough.
1. In your own place. If you have two commentaries, notes or study-Bible entries on a passage, take them and fill in the table from them. Use any passage you wish; Isaiah 40:1-11 will do. Mark each by kind and date, never by author. If you have only one, ask someone whose reading differs from yours what they would say, and treat their answer as the second.
2. The observer's way. If you do not have two commentaries to hand, use the two invented extracts below. They are printed so that you can fill in the form from them without drawing on any real book. Do not decide who is right.
(An invented example.) Extract A, from an expository commentary of the older kind:
"Isaiah 40:1-11 was spoken to the exiles in Babylon. The first word, 'comfort', answers their grief. 'Her warfare is accomplished' announces that the time of punishment is over. The highway of verse 3 is the great processional road of the city of Babylon, along which the statues of the gods were carried each year. The prophet takes the road the exiles have watched and tells them that Yahweh will make a better one through the desert to bring them home. The herald of verse 9 is told to go up a high mountain and to say to the cities of Judah, 'Behold, your God!' The chapter is therefore a clear message of release for a people who had begun to doubt that their God could act in a foreign land."
(An invented example.) Extract B, from a technical commentary of recent date:
"The chapter opens in a scene we are not shown. A plural command goes out, 'Comfort, comfort', and the speaker is God; the text does not say who is commanded. Voices follow one another. The setting on earth is left open: no king, no date and no place of writing is named. This reading takes the chapter as a word for any time when God's people stand among the ruins of their hopes. The movement matters most: comfort is announced (verses 1 and 2); a way is prepared (3 to 5); human frailty is set against the word that stands (6 to 8); the news is sent out (9); God arrives as ruler and as shepherd (10 and 11). The phrase 'double for all her sins' is taken by some to mean a full measure; the text does not say how much is meant, and the question remains open."
3. The partner's way. Find a trusted partner. Take turns. One of you says which kind of commentary you most trust (devotional, expository, technical, tradition-based, history of reading, or a study note) and why, in two or three sentences, without naming any author, book or publisher. The other listens without commenting, then asks one question: "What would make you trust a different kind?" Then swap. Nobody has to say anything painful. If you have nothing to say, use the two extracts above and tell your partner which of them you would read first, and why.
4. How to fill in the form
Use the form printed under Diagrams. Copy it by hand onto a sheet of paper, or open a blank page and write the same headings. Take about twenty-five minutes.
Six steps
Step 1. Record each commentary's kind, date, stance and audience in box A, as far as you can tell. For the invented extracts, use what the printed description gives you.
Step 2. Column one: what is the same. Write what both say about the passage. Include things they assume without saying. Agreement between readers who differ is a good sign.
Step 3. Column two: what is different. Write each difference in a few words. Look at the setting, the road, the herald, the phrase "double for all her sins", and what each does with the structure.
Step 4. Column three: where the evidence divides. For each difference, write what a reader would need to know to decide. Often the answer is "the text does not say" or "we would need an independent source". Also label each background claim: text, certain history or conjecture (lecture 4-1).
Step 5. Column four: my judgement. Write which reading you would work with and why, in "I would work with..., because ...". Then add one sentence for what the other reading gives that you would keep.
Step 6. One small thing. Write one habit you will change in how you read commentaries this month. Not to fix everything.
5. What usually goes wrong
"I want to say which one is right." Notice the wish. Write it in column four, with your reason. The aim is not to find the winner; it is to know what your choice rests on.
"I cannot see where the evidence divides." Ask of each claim: what is this resting on? A claim that rests on the text can be checked in the passage. A claim that rests on "history" should name its source. A claim that names no source is a place to look.
"Both extracts sound sure of themselves." That is true of many commentaries. Sound confidence is not evidence. Look at each sentence and ask whether the author says "perhaps" where a guess begins.
"I only read the one I already agree with." Read the other one aloud. Then write one sentence saying what it sees that your own reading has not.
6. Doing it from the leader's side
If you are leading a group or teaching a class, the same table works as a way to prepare. Take two commentaries on the passage you will teach and fill in the form. In box E, add the question that the disagreement raises for your hearers. It is no less your lab than theirs.
7. The lab does not remove the disagreement
Do not expect the table to give you an answer. Often it leaves you with a clearer account of where two careful readers divide and why. That is the aim. A reader who can say "these two differ here, for these reasons, and the text does not decide" has done the honest work of .
8. Leader's note, for running this in a small group
Privacy comes first
State the four promises aloud, before anyone picks up a pen. Say them even if you said them last time. People write honestly only if they are certain that nobody will read what they write.
Fill in your own sheet. Sit down and write alongside the group. A leader who walks around and looks over shoulders turns a lab into a test.
Let people choose the way. Some will use their own commentaries, some the printed extracts, some will work with a partner. All three are the lab. Do not prefer one.
Give twenty-five quiet minutes, then ask about the experience, not the contents. Ask: "What was it like to put two readings side by side?" and "What did you notice about the way you wanted to choose?" Do not ask: "What did you write?" or "Which author did you use?"
Do not ask: "So which commentary did you agree with?" Ask instead: "What did you notice when you tried to write down what each reading rests on?"
Allow anyone to pass. Say it aloud, and move on cleanly.
If the printed extracts are used, handle them gently. Some groups will want to decide whether A or B is right. Steer them to the columns. A group that can find one claim in A that is stated more firmly than its support allows has done the lab. It is fine to help them see which claim it is, but let them find it first.
If a member begins to describe harm. If someone starts to describe abuse, violence or danger, whether to themselves or to someone else, stop the lab kindly. Do not press for details and do not promise to keep it secret. Make sure they know whom to speak to (a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person) and, if there is danger now, the local emergency number. Follow your organisation's written safeguarding rules and local law.
Diagram 1. The form: Two Commentary Extracts
Diagram 2. Leader's checklist for this lab
| Item | Done |
|---|---|
| Said the four promises aloud before anyone wrote | [ ] |
| Filled in my own sheet alongside the group | [ ] |
| Let each person choose: own commentaries, printed extracts or partner | [ ] |
| Gave twenty-five quiet minutes | [ ] |
| Did not ask "what did you write?" or "which author did you use?" | [ ] |
| Did ask "what was it like to put two readings side by side?" | [ ] |
| Offered a genuine option to pass, and moved on cleanly | [ ] |
| Steered the group from "which is right" to "where does the evidence divide" | [ ] |
| Knew whom to send a person to if a harm came to light | [ ] |
핵심 요약
- The lab applies background, links, other traditions and the choosing of commentaries to two short extracts.
- Four promises of privacy: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader fills in a sheet too.
- Three ways in: your own commentaries, the printed extracts, or a partner. Any one is enough.
- Fill in: what is the same, what is different, where the evidence divides, and my judgement.
- Label each background claim as the text's own, certain history or conjecture, and notice a guess written as a fact.
- If the lab brings a harm to light, stop, speak to a trusted person, and call the local emergency number if there is danger.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The form | Kinds and dates; what is the same; what is different; where the evidence divides; my judgement; one habit to change. |
| Four promises | Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader fills in a sheet too. |
| Three ways in | Your own commentaries; the observer's way with the printed extracts; the partner's way. |
| If harm appears | Stop the lab, speak to a trusted pastor, priest or safeguarding person, and call the local emergency number if in danger. |
One sentence to remember When two careful readers differ, the useful question is what each rests on and where the evidence runs out.
This week's action Fill in the form for two readings of one passage (your own, or Extracts A and B), and keep the sheet where only you will find it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What was it like to put two readings side by side? Answer with a feeling, not with the contents.
- What did you notice about the way you wanted to choose between them?
- Which difference was hardest to label as text, certain history or conjecture? What helped?
- What did the reading you did not choose give you that you would keep?
- In column four, what did you learn about how you use commentaries that you did not expect? Say it only if you wish; you may pass.
- If you teach or lead: what question does the disagreement raise for the people you teach, and how would you put it to them?