Lecture 1-3: What "Criteria" Can and Cannot Explain
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Word "Canon" and the Question It Answers
- Lecture 1-2: Before There Was a Canon
- Lecture 1-3: What "Criteria" Can and Cannot Explain
- Lecture 1-4: Who Decides? Church and Scripture
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading the Front and Back of My Bible
- Lecture 2-1: Law, Prophets and Writings
- Lecture 2-2: The Greek Old Testament
- Lecture 2-3: The Scrolls from the Desert and the Shape of Scripture
- Lecture 2-4: Three Old Testaments
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Three Lists Side by Side
- Lecture 3-1: The Gospels and Paul's Letters Are Gathered
- Lecture 3-2: Reading the Early Lists
- Lecture 3-3: The Books Still Discussed
- Lecture 3-4: Councils and Fathers: Deciding or Confirming?
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Following One Book Through the Lists
- Lecture 4-1: Scribes, Papyrus and the Codex
- Lecture 4-2: Great Uncials and Many Minuscules
- Lecture 4-3: The Hebrew Text and Its Witnesses
- Lecture 4-4: What Careful Copying Looks Like, and Where It Fails
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Copy a Sentence
- Lecture 5-1: Kinds of Variants and Why They Arose
- Lecture 5-2: How Scholars Weigh Readings
- Lecture 5-3: Three Hard Cases
- Lecture 5-4: Ancient Translations as Witnesses
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Footnote
If you open a textbook on the canon, you will often find a short list of criteria: tests that a book had to pass to be received as Scripture. The list usually has four or five items. Was the book connected with an apostle? Was it accepted widely? Did it agree with the faith the churches had received? Was it read in worship? The list is useful. It is also tidy, and lecture 1-1 warned that a tidy account is a reason to look again at the sources.
This lecture does both things. It sets out the criteria that early Christian writers seem to have used, one by one, with a source or a case for each. And it asks honestly what the criteria can explain and what they cannot. Two questions run underneath. Did the criteria make the list, or did they describe how books were already being used? And does any single criterion fit every case? The first question is debated among readers of every tradition. The answer to the second is, as far as the sources show, no.
This lecture does not walk through the full history of each disputed book; that is week 3. It gives just enough cases to test the criteria.
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Name four reasons early Christians gave for receiving a book, and give an example of each.
- Describe the case of Serapion and the Gospel of Peter, and say which criterion it shows at work.
- Show, with one case for each, that no single criterion fits every book.
- State fairly the debate over whether criteria made the list or described how books were already used.
So then, brothers, stand firm, and hold the traditions which you were taught by us, whether by word, or by letter." — 2 Thessalonians 2:15
World English Bible
Beloved, don’t believe every spirit, but test the spirits, whether they are of God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world. By this you know the Spirit of God: every spirit who confesses that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is of God, and every spirit who doesn’t confess that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is not of God, and this is the spirit of the Antichrist, of whom you have heard that it comes. Now it is in the world already." — 1 John 4:1-3
WEB
The first passage speaks of what the church received from the apostles, "whether by word, or by letter". The second gives a test: what does a voice confess about Jesus? Neither passage is about a list of books. But both show a church that already knew it had to hold what it had received and test what it heard. The criteria of later centuries grew in that soil.
1. Where the word "criteria" comes from
Start with a small but important point. No early Christian writer, as far as we know, published a numbered list of tests and then ran every book through them. The word criteria belongs to modern study. Scholars read the early writers, noticed the reasons they gave when they spoke about a book, and gathered those reasons under a few headings.
That is a fair thing to do. But it means the criteria are partly our summary of the sources, not the sources themselves. When you read a neat list, remember that the writers behind it gave their reasons one case at a time, often in the middle of an argument, and not always the same reasons.
With that warning, here are the four reasons that appear most often.
2. Apostolic connection
The first reason is a link with the apostles. A book was valued if it came from an apostle, or from someone close to an apostle, or from the time when the apostles' teaching was being handed on directly.
This reason fits much of what we see. Paul's letters carry his name and speak with his authority. The Gospel of Matthew and the Gospel of John were associated early with apostles. The Gospel of Mark and the Gospel of Luke were not written by apostles, but early writers connected Mark with Peter and Luke with Paul. The link mattered because the apostles were the witnesses of Jesus, and the church understood itself as holding to what they handed on: "the traditions which you were taught by us" (2 Thessalonians 2:15).
But apostolic connection does not explain everything.
- Hebrews names no author. Early writers did not agree on who wrote it. Some connected it with Paul; others doubted that. Yet it was read and treasured, especially in the East, and was in the end received everywhere. If apostolic authorship were the only test, Hebrews would be hard to explain.
- Names could be borrowed. In the second and later centuries, writings appeared under the names of apostles (gospels, acts and letters "of Peter", "of Thomas" and so on) that were not received. A name alone did not settle anything.
So apostolic connection was a strong reason, but it was weighed together with others.
3. Wide acceptance
The second reason is that a book was received widely, by many churches in many regions, and not only in one place. The early writers who sorted books often asked, in effect: is this book read and accepted by the churches generally, or only by some?
This reason matters because the church understood itself as one body across many cities. A book read only in one corner, or only by one group, raised a question. A book read in Rome, in Alexandria, in Antioch and elsewhere carried weight.
But wide acceptance also has limits.
- Some books were widely read and still not received. The Shepherd of Hermas, a long book of visions and moral teaching from the second century, was read and loved in many churches. Some early writers quoted it with great respect. Yet in the end it was not received into the New Testament, even though it was not thought to teach anything false. Week 3 looks at the reasons given.
- Some books were accepted in one region long before another. Revelation, for example, was read early in some regions and long questioned in others. "Wide acceptance" was not one moment; it was a slow process that happened at different speeds in different places.
4. Agreement with the faith received
The third reason is that a book agreed with the faith the churches had received. Lecture 1-1 described Irenaeus's rule of truth: an outline of the faith handed down in the churches, against which any teaching could be measured. A book that taught another God, or another Christ, or denied that Jesus came in the flesh, was not received, whatever name it carried. 1 John 4:1-3 shows that same instinct at work within the New Testament itself: test what you hear by what it confesses about Jesus.
A clear early case of this reason at work comes from Serapion, bishop of Antioch around the end of the second century. The story is told by the church historian Eusebius in the fourth century, who had Serapion's own letter before him.
As Eusebius reports it, the Christians of a small town called Rhossus, not far from Antioch, had been reading a writing called the Gospel of Peter. When Serapion first visited them, he allowed it, assuming from its name and from the church's peace that it was harmless, though he had not read it himself. Later he heard that the book was being used to support a teaching he thought false. So he obtained a copy and read it. He found that most of it agreed with the true teaching about the Saviour, but that some things had been added. He wrote to the church to correct his earlier permission and to explain why.
This scene is valuable for four reasons.
- A book with an apostle's name was tested by its content. The name "Peter" did not protect it.
- The bishop changed his mind after reading it. The judgement was not made in advance by a council; it was made by a pastor who read and then wrote.
- The question arose because of use. The church at Rhossus was already reading it. Serapion's letter responded to a practice; it did not create one.
- We know the case only through a later historian. Eusebius chose to preserve it, and he had his own purposes in writing history. The broad outline is generally accepted, but it reaches us at second hand.
Agreement with the faith received was perhaps the most important reason of all. But it too has a limit. It works well to exclude a book that teaches something clearly against the received faith. It works less well to decide between two books that both teach nothing false, such as 2 Peter (which was long discussed) and the Shepherd of Hermas (which was not received). Both passed the test of agreement; that test alone did not decide them.
5. Use in worship
The fourth reason is that a book was read in the public worship of the churches. Lecture 1-2 described Justin's account of the memoirs of the apostles and the writings of the prophets read in the Sunday assembly. A book that the churches had long read aloud as Scripture had, in a sense, already been received.
This reason is close to the heart of the matter. In many traditions, to say that a book is Scripture is to say that it is read in the as the word of God. Orthodox Christians, in particular, often stress that the was received through the worship of the church before it was listed by anyone.
The limits are by now familiar.
- Use varied from place to place. A book read in worship in one region might not be read in another.
- Use and status could differ. Some early writers distinguished between books read in church as Scripture and books that could be read for instruction, privately or to new believers, but not as Scripture. The line between "read in church" and "read by the church" was not always sharp.
6. No single criterion fits every case
Put the four reasons side by side, and a pattern appears. Each one explains a lot. None explains everything.
| Case | Apostolic connection | Wide acceptance | Agreement with the faith | Use in worship |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hebrews | Author unknown; disputed | Earlier in East than West | Yes | Yes, in many places |
| Gospel of Peter (at Rhossus) | Claimed by its title | Local only | Questioned on reading | Read locally |
| Shepherd of Hermas | Not claimed | Read in many places | Yes | In some places |
| 2 Peter | Claimed by its text | Long discussed | Yes | Slowly |
(This table simplifies; week 3 gives the sources behind each row.)
What the table shows is that the early church weighed reasons together. A book that had one strong reason and lacked another could go either way. The decision, where there was one, came from many readers over a long time, not from a single test.
7. Did criteria make the list, or describe it?
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is whether the criteria were tests that produced the list, or explanations given afterwards for a list that use had already formed.
Some readers hold that the criteria were real tests. In this view, early church leaders, faced with many writings and some false teaching, consciously asked whether a book was apostolic, orthodox, widely received and read in worship, and accepted or rejected it on those grounds. They point to cases like Serapion's, where a pastor clearly applied a test, and to the early lists, which sometimes give reasons for placing a book in or out.
Other readers hold that the criteria mostly described a process that had already happened. In this view, churches had been reading certain books for generations because they found in them the voice of the apostles and of the Lord. When challenged, leaders gave reasons; the reasons were real, but the books were not first admitted because of them. They point out that the criteria fit some cases poorly, which is what one would expect if they were explanations rather than rules.
A third emphasis, found among many Protestant readers and in some Orthodox and Pentecostal reflection as well, adds that the books commended themselves: God's people heard God's voice in them, and the criteria put that hearing into words. Catholic readers often add that the church's discernment over time, guided by the Spirit, is itself the setting in which these reasons were weighed. Lecture 1-4 takes up that question of who decides.
What this course requires is less than any of these positions. It requires that you do not treat the criteria as a machine that produced the canon automatically, and that you do not treat them as mere excuses invented after the fact. They were real reasons, given by real people, weighed together over time, and they fit some cases better than others. You may hold, with your own tradition, a fuller account of why the books were received; the course asks only that you can state the other accounts fairly.
Criteria are a summary, not a source
When you meet a list of criteria, ask three questions: Which early writer gave this reason? For which book? And does the reason fit the hard cases as well as the easy ones?
Diagram 1. Four reasons: what each explains, where each struggles
핵심 요약
- "Criteria" is a modern summary of reasons that early writers gave one case at a time, often in the middle of an argument.
- Four reasons appear most often: apostolic connection, wide acceptance, agreement with the faith received, and use in worship.
- Serapion of Antioch read the Gospel of Peter and judged it by its content, not its name, after a church was already using it.
- No single reason fits every case; Hebrews, the Shepherd of Hermas and 2 Peter each strain at least one of them.
- Readers differ on whether the reasons produced the list or described a use already formed; the course asks that they be treated as real reasons, weighed together.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four reasons | Apostolic connection; wide acceptance; agreement with the faith received; use in worship. |
| Serapion and the Gospel of Peter | A bishop allowed a book unread, then read it, found additions, and corrected his permission. |
| Hebrews as a test case | Author unknown, yet received: apostolic authorship alone cannot explain the canon. |
| The open question | Did criteria produce the list, or describe a use already formed? Readers differ. |
One sentence to remember The criteria were real reasons, weighed together over time, not a machine that produced the canon.
This week's action Choose one book of the New Testament and ask of it the four questions of this lecture: whose, where, what it teaches, and whether it is read aloud.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Before this lecture, had you met a list of "criteria for the canon"? Did it seem to you like a set of rules or a description?
- Why might Hebrews, whose author is unknown, be a useful test case for the criteria?
- In the story of Serapion, what do you make of the fact that he first allowed a book he had not read, then changed his mind? What does that tell you about how decisions were made?
- The Shepherd of Hermas was widely read and taught nothing considered false, yet it was not received. What does this suggest about the limits of the criteria?
- Of the three views on whether criteria made or described the list, which is closest to what you were taught? Can you state one of the others fairly?
- 1 John 4:1-3 asks believers to test what they hear. How do you test teaching you hear today, and is that similar to or different from what the early church did with books?