Lecture 3-4: Councils and Fathers: Deciding or Confirming?
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Word "Canon" and the Question It Answers
- Lecture 1-2: Before There Was a Canon
- Lecture 1-3: What "Criteria" Can and Cannot Explain
- Lecture 1-4: Who Decides? Church and Scripture
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Reading the Front and Back of My Bible
- Lecture 2-1: Law, Prophets and Writings
- Lecture 2-2: The Greek Old Testament
- Lecture 2-3: The Scrolls from the Desert and the Shape of Scripture
- Lecture 2-4: Three Old Testaments
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Three Lists Side by Side
- Lecture 3-1: The Gospels and Paul's Letters Are Gathered
- Lecture 3-2: Reading the Early Lists
- Lecture 3-3: The Books Still Discussed
- Lecture 3-4: Councils and Fathers: Deciding or Confirming?
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Following One Book Through the Lists
- Lecture 4-1: Scribes, Papyrus and the Codex
- Lecture 4-2: Great Uncials and Many Minuscules
- Lecture 4-3: The Hebrew Text and Its Witnesses
- Lecture 4-4: What Careful Copying Looks Like, and Where It Fails
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Copy a Sentence
- Lecture 5-1: Kinds of Variants and Why They Arose
- Lecture 5-2: How Scholars Weigh Readings
- Lecture 5-3: Three Hard Cases
- Lecture 5-4: Ancient Translations as Witnesses
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Reading a Footnote
A story is often told in a few lines. "In the year so-and-so, a council of bishops met, voted on which books belonged in the Bible, and that is how the New Testament was made." Some tell it to praise the church. Some tell it to say that the Bible is a human product chosen by the powerful. Both versions share the same picture: one meeting, one vote, one day.
The first three lectures of this week have made that picture hard to keep. The Gospels and Paul's letters were read in worship long before any list (lecture 3-1). Writers sorted the books, reported doubts and taught with authority (lecture 3-2). The edge books were discussed for centuries (lecture 3-3). So where do church meetings fit?
This lecture looks at what church meetings actually did, as far as the sources let us say. It meets one Father in depth, Augustine of Hippo, who took part in the North African meetings and also wrote about how to weigh the books. Then it states the question that divides readers: did the councils decide the canon, or did they confirm a canon that was already received? Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant readers give different answers, and each has reasons worth hearing in its strongest form.
The doctrine of Scripture (inspiration, inerrancy, authority) belongs to the systematic theology courses. This lecture says only how each tradition understands the relationship between the church's meetings and the books.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Describe what regional church meetings of the late fourth and early fifth centuries did about the books, and what they did not do.
- Explain how Augustine weighed the books, and what that shows about the role of the churches.
- State fairly the reading that councils *decided* the canon and the reading that they *confirmed* it, and say how each tradition holds them.
- Explain why "one vote on one day" and "no human history at all" are both wrong pictures.
The apostles and the elders were gathered together to see about this matter. When there had been much discussion, Peter rose up and said to them, “Brothers, you know that a good while ago God made a choice among you, that by my mouth the nations should hear the word of the Good News, and believe. God, who knows the heart, testified about them, giving them the Holy Spirit, just like he did to us. He made no distinction between us and them, cleansing their hearts by faith. Now therefore why do you tempt God, that you should put a yoke on the neck of the disciples which neither our fathers nor we were able to bear? But we believe that we are saved through the grace of the Lord Jesus, just as they are.”" — Acts 15:6-11
World English Bible
For it seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us, to lay no greater burden on you than these necessary things:" — Acts 15:28
WEB
Acts 15 is not about the . It is about whether Gentile believers must keep the law of Moses. But it is the first church meeting in the New Testament, and Christians of every tradition have looked to it when they think about later meetings. Notice its shape. There was a real question and "much discussion". Peter appealed to what God had already done: giving the Holy Spirit to the Gentiles. And the letter that followed said that the decision "seemed good to the Holy Spirit, and to us". Was the meeting deciding something new, or recognising what God had already shown? Readers of Acts 15 answer that question differently, and their answers often match how they read the later councils.
1. Two wrong pictures
Before looking at the meetings, set aside two pictures that trap 6 of this course warns against.
The first wrong picture: one vote on one day. This is the story of a single council that chose the books. It is wrong because the books were in use long before any meeting, because the lists differ from region to region, and because no single meeting of the whole church in the early centuries issued a list that everyone then followed.
The second wrong picture: no human history at all. This is the story in which the twenty-seven books simply were there from the start, with no lists, no doubts and no meetings. It is wrong because the sources show people reading, sorting, doubting, teaching and meeting.
The real history is slower and more human than the first picture, and more involved than the second. Hold that in mind as we look at the meetings.
2. What we know church meetings did
Here we must be careful. Much that is said about councils and the canon is repeated from book to book without being checked. This lecture keeps to what is reasonably certain and says "church meetings of the late fourth century" where details are uncertain.
A meeting at Laodicea. A gathering of bishops at Laodicea in Asia Minor, in the fourth century, issued a set of short rulings about church life. One of them said that only the canonical books should be read in church, not private psalms or books outside the canon. A list of books follows the rulings in some copies, but many readers think the list was added later, because it is missing from some early witnesses. So Laodicea shows a meeting saying which kind of book may be read in worship. Whether it gave a list is uncertain.
Meetings in North Africa. In the 390s and early 400s, bishops of North Africa met several times, at Hippo and at Carthage. The records of these meetings include a ruling that nothing except the canonical Scriptures should be read in church under the name of divine Scriptures, followed by a list of books. The New Testament part of that list names the twenty-seven books most churches read today. The Old Testament part includes the books that Catholic readers call deuterocanonical (week 2). These were regional meetings: bishops of one part of the Latin-speaking church, making rules for their own churches.
A bishop of Rome answers a question. In the early fifth century, a bishop of Rome replied to a bishop in Gaul who had asked which books were to be received, and included a list much like the North African one. This, too, was a letter for a particular need.
Much later meetings. In the East, a council held in Constantinople near the end of the seventh century confirmed a large body of earlier church rulings, including some of the older lists; those lists do not all agree with each other in every detail. In the West, the , meeting in the sixteenth century during the controversies of the Reformation, gave the Catholic Church a defined list of the books, Old and New Testament, and declared it binding. Protestant churches in the same century set out their lists in their own confessions of faith. Several Orthodox gatherings of the following century also spoke about the books, especially the Old Testament.
Notice four things about this list of meetings.
- The early meetings were regional. None of the great councils of the whole church in the early centuries (the ones that spoke about Christ and the ) issued a list of the books of Scripture.
- They came late in the process. By the time the North African bishops met, the four Gospels and Paul's letters had been read for some two centuries.
- Their main concern was worship. The rulings are about what may be read in church. That is a practical question about the gathered community.
- They wrote down a list that matched what many churches already used. The North African list and Athanasius's New Testament (lecture 3-2) agree. The meetings did not invent new books.
3. Augustine: weighing the books
Augustine was bishop of Hippo, a port town in North Africa, from the 390s until his death in the early fifth century. He is honoured as a Father and teacher by Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant Christians, though each draws on him differently. He took part in the life of the North African church when its meetings spoke about the books.
The scene: Augustine writing a handbook for Christian teachers and preachers, usually called On Christian Teaching. In one part of it he explains how a reader should know which books are canonical. In paraphrase, he advises this: follow the judgement of the greater number of churches; among them, give special weight to the churches that were founded by apostles or received letters from them. Books received by all the churches come first. Among books not received by all, prefer those received by more churches, and by churches of greater weight. If some books are held by more churches and others by weightier ones, he thinks the two should be held as of equal authority, though he adds that such a case is unlikely to arise. He then gives a list of the books.
What does this scene show?
First, Augustine describes a process of reception. His test is not "what a council voted" but "what the churches, especially the apostolic churches, have received". The individual reader is to look at the whole church's practice.
Second, he admits degrees. Some books are received by all, some by fewer. Augustine does not pretend that every book was received in the same way.
Third, he gives the churches a real role. He does not say that each reader decides for themselves. He says the reader should follow the churches' judgement.
Readers from different traditions draw different lessons from Augustine. Some see him as showing that the church's judgement is essential to knowing the canon. Others see him as describing the churches' recognition of books that had their own authority. Both draw on the same passage. Augustine also wrote elsewhere a famous remark about how the authority of the church moved him to believe the Gospel; it too is read in more than one way, and it should be checked in his text rather than repeated from memory.
4. What the Fathers did, taken together
Put Augustine beside the others of this week: Irenaeus, Tatian, Origen, Eusebius, Dionysius, Athanasius and Jerome. What did the Fathers do about the books?
- They used them, in preaching, teaching and argument.
- They reported what churches received and what they doubted (Origen, Eusebius, Jerome).
- They defended the collection against those who wanted fewer or more (Irenaeus).
- They taught with authority, naming the books for their own churches (Athanasius).
- They gave guidance on how to weigh the books (Augustine).
- They studied questions of authorship honestly (Dionysius).
None of them presents himself as inventing the canon. Each, in his own way, is handing on and clarifying what the churches received. That much is common ground. The disagreement begins with what to call this.
Did the councils decide the canon or confirm it?
This is a point where readers will not agree. There are two broad readings, and each tradition holds them with its own emphasis.
The reading that the church decided. Catholic readers hold that the church, guided by the Holy Spirit, has the authority to define which books belong to Scripture, and that it did so with growing clarity: in regional meetings, in the teaching of bishops of Rome, and finally, for the Catholic Church, at the Council of Trent. On this reading, without the church's judgement no reader could know with certainty which books are Scripture; the books and the church that received them belong together. Catholic teaching also insists that the church does not make the books inspired; it recognises and declares what they are. So "decide" here means "judge with authority", not "invent".
The reading that the councils confirmed. Protestant readers generally hold that the books carried their own authority as the apostolic witness, and that the churches recognised that authority over time. On this reading, the councils confirmed and wrote down what the churches had already received; their lists have weight as a witness to that reception, but the books' authority does not rest on them. Several Protestant confessions of faith say that believers receive the books not mainly because a church approves them, but because of their own character and the witness of the Holy Spirit.
Orthodox readers often stand in a different place from both. They stress that the canon was received in the life of the church as a whole, above all in its worship, and that no single council in the early centuries fixed it for everyone. Meetings and Fathers bear witness to a consensus that grew under the Holy Spirit. On this view, the very question "decided or confirmed?" can be too sharp, since church and Scripture are not two powers set against each other. This is also why Orthodox churches have tolerated some differences in the edges of the Old Testament.
A historian working without any church commitment will note simply that the early meetings were regional, came late, matched existing practice, and helped settle it.
What this course requires is less than any of these. It requires you to state the facts that all can see: use came first; lists reported and taught; regional meetings ruled for worship and matched what was received; later meetings defined the lists for particular communions. And it requires you to be able to state both readings, decide and confirm, in a form that a person who holds each would recognise as fair. Which reading you hold is a matter for your tradition and your own study.
5. Why the question matters, and why it need not divide
Why does this question stir feeling? Because it touches the deeper question of authority that lecture 1-4 introduced. If the church decided, then the church's authority seems to stand above the books. If the books carried their own authority, then the church's role seems smaller. Each side fears the other's answer will weaken something precious: the church's unity and teaching office, or the freedom of Scripture to judge the church.
Two observations may lower the temperature.
First, every tradition gives both the church and the books a role. Catholic teaching says the church does not create the books' . Protestant confessions accept that the churches' long reception is a real witness. Orthodox teaching refuses to set the two against each other. The traditions differ in emphasis and in where they place final authority, but none of them says "only the church" or "only the books" in the crudest sense.
Second, the history fits more than one reading. The sources show communities using, testing, reporting, teaching and finally ruling. A reader who says "the church decided" and a reader who says "the councils confirmed" are often looking at the same facts with different questions in mind. This is why the course asks first for honest history.
What this week has shown
The New Testament canon was used before it was listed, tested at its edges for centuries, and listed by teachers and regional meetings that mostly wrote down what churches already read. Later meetings defined it for particular communions. How to describe the authority of those meetings is a real disagreement between traditions.
Diagram 1. Not one day: the road from use to definition
Diagram 2. What the meetings did and did not do
| They did | They did not |
|---|---|
| Rule which books may be read in church as Scripture | Meet as one council of the whole early church to vote on a list |
| Write down lists that matched what many churches already read | Invent books or add new writings to the collection |
| Bind the churches of their own region | Settle the question for every region at once |
| Later, define the list for a particular communion (Trent; confessions; synods) | Remove the debate between traditions about what such definitions mean |
핵심 요약
- Both "one vote on one day" and "no human history at all" are wrong pictures of how the New Testament canon formed.
- The early meetings that named the books were regional, came late, ruled on what may be read in church, and matched existing use.
- Augustine advised weighing the books by their reception in the churches, giving more weight to the apostolic churches.
- Catholic readers stress that the church judged with authority; Protestant readers stress that councils confirmed books already received.
- Orthodox readers stress a consensus grown in worship; the course asks for honest history and a fair statement of each reading.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The early meetings | Regional gatherings, such as those in North Africa, that ruled which books may be read in church and listed them. |
| Augustine's guidance | Weigh the books by how widely the churches received them, giving more weight to apostolic churches. |
| "Decided" | The church, guided by the Spirit, judged with authority which books are Scripture (stressed by Catholic readers). |
| "Confirmed" | Meetings recognised and wrote down books already received for their own authority (stressed by Protestant readers). |
One sentence to remember The councils came late in a long road of use and testing; how to name what they did is a real and honest disagreement.
This week's action Write one paragraph stating the "decided" reading and one stating the "confirmed" reading, each as its holders would put it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Before this lecture, which of the two wrong pictures ("one vote on one day" or "no human history at all") was closer to what you had heard? Where did you hear it?
- Augustine advised readers to follow the churches, especially the apostolic ones. How would a Catholic reader and a Protestant reader each explain what he meant?
- Why does it matter that the early meetings were concerned mainly with what may be *read in church*?
- State the reading that councils decided the canon in a way that a Catholic would accept as fair. Then state the reading that they confirmed it in a way that a Protestant would accept as fair.
- Why might an Orthodox reader say the question "decided or confirmed?" is too sharp?
- In Acts 15, the meeting appealed to what God had already done. Does that help you think about later meetings, or does it make the question harder?